This is one of those situations when I go to a place & don't order what they're known for. With this situation, I came for a smoothie & didn't have much of an appetite for a bagel (which I always enjoy from the Brookside location). Their Mixed Berry Fruit Smoothie was really good. You can choose from that, Strawberry + Banana , Mango Mania & Peach. I got the 12 oz & it did the job (you can also get it in a 16 oz). The smoothie had the perfect amount of sweetness. I didn't catch what all berries were involved, just know that it's good. For everyone else who was eating at the time, all of the bagels that came out looked extremely good to the point I almost ordered one without having much of said appetite! read more

Typically, me and my family go to the other New York Bagel in Tulsa but we'll occasionally come to this one. This New York bagel is pretty good. For starters, their food is great. I love to get the pizza bagels here. Also, their cookies are really good. The service here for the most part is pretty good. The only problem is we always tell them just to heat up our bagels, not toast them. But, they always toast them. That's why we always go to the other NY bagel in Tulsa because they actually listen to us. The inside here is pretty clean. Good ambiance to it. Overall? This is a good NY bagel but I recommend going to the other one in Tulsa. read more

See all

The menu here is such a great price. You get really good food. The service was quick. The staff was friendly. I really enjoyed the bagel sandwiches here and I had the smoked salmon spread. As always they give you more than enough on your bagel and for less than five dollars this was an amazing meal. read more

See all

Veggie scramble Healthy bagel BLT on multi grain I love a NY Bagel any day. I love this place, there is a nice assortment of bagels and other treats like cookies, muffins, croissants, and cragels(?) We were needing lunch so we ordered BLT on multi grain, veggie scramble without cheese on plain, and healthy egg on sesame. All 3 bagels were well stuffed. Delicious and easy to eat, wrapped in parchment. Definitely will be back when I'm in town and going to come here for breakfast! read more

New York Bagel Cafe - BLT - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Bagels are good. I got a breakfast bagel with ham, egg, cheese. I think McDonald's has better eggs on their sandwiches than here. Lots of space inside. So even if the parking lot looks full you will still likely find a place to sit. Especially if it's nice outside and you can enjoy the balcony. Service left much to be desired. Everyone I saw working here looks like they hate their job. Not one smile. The girl who took my order didn't even speak. Just stood there looking at me until I said "hi, how are you?" Even then there was no "what can I get you?" Just nothing. read more

Their bagels are really good, but don't get their mixed drink drinks like the frappes, because they're horrible! It's like drinking straight up cream, so spend the $.50 extra and go get one at Dutch Bros! read more

Favorite spot to chill with great food at reasonable prices. The indoor is cozy enough to work from. There's an outside terrace to chill on when the weather is nice. Bagels are as close to traditional NYC bagels that I've found in the state. The salads, soups and cookies are all delicious as well! My go to is the half and half order. For less than $9 this is a deal for amazing food in a great spot! read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

The place isn't perfect, but it's definitely good! Our server was nice, and the food was quick to come out. The cheese on the bagel was a little cold, but this place has a great ambiance! I definitely recommend coming here! read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Yummy Bagels, Yummy Spreads! Cinnamon Raisin mmmmm That's all I have ever tried because it is amazing! The service has been always been very good. The inside is pretty chill if you wanted to eat there and relax for a bit but I have always gone to the drive thru. read more

The food here is great. I wish they'd put their cinnamon cragel on their app so I could earn rewards, but whatever. My only complaint is that there's a complete breakdown of communication between the register and the kitchen. I order a cinnamon cragel every week. And every time the person at the register asks, "would you like that sliced or anything?" and I say, "no, thank you." It doesn't come up with "sliced" or anything on the register screen. But 50% of the time I get a sliced cragel. Not the end of the world, but the bottom half is just a plain piece of bread because all the cinnamon sugar is on the top. I don't know how else to order the thing. I've answered their "do you want it sliced?" question with: "no," "no thank you," "no, NOT sliced or anything," and "no, just how it comes" to no avail. It's just frustrating because the food here is so good, I'll keep coming back, but I'm rarely leaving in a good mood. read more

New York Bagel Cafe - "Not sliced" cinnamon cragel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

As a lox connoisseur I'm very excited to have e this place in Tulsa. Goes to show how diverse Tulsa food is for a smaller city. Amazing decor and the place is huuuuuuge! Great place to work from or have a casual business meeting. Plenty of seating for large groups as well. Now onto the : The bagel itself was great, fresh and had that outside bite. I got a customized lox bagel with cucumbers for crunch, toasted on garlic with onion and chives. My only small complain was how little lox they put and if you've had a bagel on you already know how much lox they add. Either way it hits the spot and the place has an awesome atmosphere. read more

See all

I love your staff. Don't get me wrong. You guys are very friendly very respectful. But when it comes to a New York style bagel, I'm from New York. I've been in Oklahoma for four years and I'm just tired of people saying New York style food when it taste nothing like New York style food. I gave this restaurant multiple chances to improve and the bagel still does not add up to a New York style bagel. Just my opinion on food that I actually love, but it just keeps missing the taste. The fact that a New York style bagel is toasted on the outside And soft in the middle, but it keeps missing that taste and the authentic New York style bagel. read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Cinnamon raisin bagel, plain cream cheese - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Here's your taste of NYC... Yes these are authentic NYC boiled bagels!!! Fantastic breakfast, excellent lunch, everything in here is house / home made... cream cheese spreads, sandwiches made to order, keto and veggie options, soups, salads, fresh fruit sides, muffins, cookies, and cinnamon rolls... all your coffee and espresso options ...and fruit smoothies. Quick drive thru or order inside with quick turnaround... inside and outside seating... great service on getting orders taken and when your food is delivered...the only thing missing is the dicey attitude from the NYC delis!!! Enjoy your trip for a taste of NY. read more

As a New Yorker visiting Oklahoma had to give it a try.... Very pleased. Bagels were wonderful. Service was fantastic in a wonderfully comfortable space. So glad to have stopped and would recommend to everyone. read more

This is such a wonderful place to grab a delicious bagel and sit around to just take it easy! I brought my book and my fiancé had some work to do, and so many people even on a Saturday morning were in here on their computers and with their families. There's a ton of seating, and the staff is super friendly. More than anything, the food is very reasonably priced and it's a great atmosphere! read more

See all

Forget the bagel. This may sound like bad advice considering the name has "bagel" in it. For me, this cafe gets a 5 solely for the spinach salad which I can sum up in one word, AMAZING. The spinach salad has chicken, sliced green apples, strawberries, tomatoes, blue cheese, and candied pecans on a bed of spinach. Love everything about it, but if there's something I could change, it would be replacing the tomato dices with cherry tomatoes. The best feature of the salad is the raspberry vinaigrette dressing which tastes so good that I could just drink it. New York cafe is a nice decent size cafe, operating at full capacity during lunchtime. However, orders are processed quickly. If you're looking for some peace and quiet, you won't be able to find it here as it is really noisy during this time of the day. Just put on your headphones and enjoy the food. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious. Great atmosphere,the restaurant is more contemporary look. I had gone 9 months ago and now the service was a lot better than the last time. Had Huevos Rancheros with Asiago Bagel ( the bagel has toasted cheese on top) cream cheese it looks like has salsa mixed to die for with ham . Then, had another one same thing but with Jalapeno Bagel with bacon and still put more salsa ,Lol. read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Asiago Bagel , salsa cream cheese with egg and ham - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

One of our favorite Sunday after Church destinations. I ordered a 1/2 Chef salad. It was quite large and very fresh, very filling. It's a nice bright atmosphere with outside seating. read more

See all

Always a great time at old school bagel! The workers are always nice and the restaurant is always clean. read more

See all

Bagel was good. Took 15 minutes to get it, and the staff were incredibly unfriendly. 3 stars for nailing the New York experience.

Great stop for a breakfast sandwich! First time trying the Five Boroughs sandwich. It has your choice of bagel, they suggest having it scooped (no extra charge on this sandwich,) chive and onion cream cheese, egg, cheddar, hashbrown, and choice of meat(the suggest bacon.) This is not a sandwich you want to grab on your way to work unless you have a bib and wet wipes! It's delicious but messy I have also tried the meat lovers bagel in the past in jalapeno cheddar bagel which is also one that stacks up. Try the jalapeno cheese sausage rolls, too, if they have any left when you visit. read more

See all

Large and modern cafe with coastal approved bagels! Their cream cheese is generously slathered for a shmeer but surprisingly runny as well so i felt i needed a bib to eat it. Lattes were lovely and service is excellent. read more

Pros: The atmosphere inside is amazing very friendly staff and plenty of coffee for anyone. The bagels are amazing dense chewy bagels that taste amazing. 10/10 recommendation on the cubano bagel. Cons: I got a breakfast sandwich bagel that had more tomatoes on it than ham. Was good but more meat would've been appreciated Overall great place with a great atmosphere read more

See all

Ordered a Lox and cream cheese bagel with no tomatoes and a whole piece of Romaine lettuce. There were tomatoes on my sandwich and when I opened the wrapping the sandwich fell apart. Lettuce was shredded and so wet it made the sandwich hard to eat. Barely any cream cheese. Almost all lettuce and with two slices of tomato. Oat bran Muffin was dry and stale. Very disappointed read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Bagel with lox and cream cheese. Should have no tomatoes and leaf of lettuce. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great ambiance! Good breakfast items. All bakery items looks freshly made, they also have a small selection of parfaits and "crabagel" (mix between a bagel and croissant). read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Outside patio - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Very disappointed with both the cinnamon rolls and pecan sticky buns, both times I have ordered online from the Yale location they were dry and old. I don't know how you wouldn't know when you pack them to go. read more

I got a bagel here and took a bite and pulled a hair out of my mouth, then I opened the bagel and is was covered in hair...I counted more than 10 strands. I haven't eaten there since. read more

Had the Sausage roll and healthy breakfast start with the Almond flavored Latte. All was very good. Nice place to hangout and chill for a bit. read more

Wow, has this place gone downhill! Did management change? Because it felt that way. They didn't even have their signature Old School Bagel/Cafe 7 basket liner papers... One thing that really gets under my skin in the service industry is when you are placing your order or checking out and the worker is too busy goofing off, laughing, not giving you their attention. They did just that this trip, and so I shouldn't be surprised that our orders came out wrong, missing food, giving us the wrong food, etc...and the place wasn't even busy. There were mabye 4 people eating here. Most people just looked like they were squatting for the free wi-fi and coffee refills. They were supposed to be open until 4 pm, but they pulled all of the bagels and basically started shutting down at 2pm. This was really interesting, because they were so busy doing closing procedures nobody bothered to clean the booths. I had to clean off my seat, and we passed up tables we wanted, because they were dirty. When my sad "veggie sunrise" came out, it was cold, missing avocado and just completely devoid of any flavor, pride, etc...I tracked down my missing avocado which ended up being very under ripe and tough. I tried dousing my sandwich with hot sauces to give it some sort of flavor, but even that wasn't helping. I really don't know what happened here, but if this had been my first experience I would never come back. It has been quite some time since we've been here, but they used to have great service, packed bagels with flavor that were served actually hot if you asked for it. It used to be clean and busy, all of the time, not just wi-fi users, actual customers. If it's still here in a few years we might try it again, but we definitely will avoid at all costs. I will leave you with this sad, parting thought...I would have rather had a McDonald's bagel than a bagel from this location. read more

Okay... Unfortunately this place didn't deliver today. I've actually had it maybe once or twice before and it wasn't bad? Not sure if they went downhill or what... So sad about it! I ordered the veggie bagel sandwich on an everything bagel. I ordered this exact same sandwich at Einsteins bagels and it was just better. Here the bagel was very tough (not like a good bagel chewyness like it should be) and the egg was a little off... They also got my order wrong and I had to switch around bagel halves with my friend who I ordered take out with. Just overall not the best. It's a shame because this pace is so cute and they have so many items on their menu! Sorry to give a low star review but this is just how I felt about their food.... read more

Came here for breakfast after driving by yesterday. Very cute on the outside and even nicer inside! There are so many things to choose from. We got a healthy start bagel on everything and meat lovers on Asiago. To drink I got an iced vanilla latte and he got a cafe mocha over ice. For dessert I got the M&M cookie and he got sedark chocolate. Everything was really good. read more

Nice ambiance, nice music selection. Friendly service. Patio is nice but small. I arrived at 1pm my bagel seemed a little hard but no big deal. They were out of avocado but made up for it by offering guacamole. Breakfast all day! read more

Ok, so i think the cookies are not as good as brookside. Muffins usually are, but the Chocolate muffin is the moistest and best tasting. Used to love the orange/ cranberry, but feel like it's a little dry these days (likewise the lemon poppyseed- no thanks). With those grievances aired ;-) the bagels are on point. My favorite bagel sandwich is the wall street (turkey, cream cheese + chives on everything bagel). there is something magical about a good, toasted bagel. cannot replicate it from the store!! Service is capable at the drive thru. they've stayed busy during COVID. I appreciate you Old School! read more

No dairy free items and no gluten free options Although food looks good my friends nor I could eat any of it read more

Great variety, good service, fair prices, friendly people, nice ambiance, interesting decor.

Quick service bagel stop that's good for breakfast and lunch. Came here with my friend on a Sunday around noon. There was a small line but it moved quickly. We got our to-go, and they just call out your name from the left hand side counter. Otherwise they give you a number and they'll just find you wherever you're sitting. The wasabi bomb on the everything bagel (toasted of course) was the bomb. It came with lox, cucumber, red onion, and a very generous amount of cream cheese. I also got a small hot chocolate which was too milky for my taste, but was still warm and comforting. Really good thing to have for brunch or when you want a heavy meal. We are ours right before going on a hike on turkey mountain so we were energized for the hike (yay for carboloading!). read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Hot chocolate - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

options for bagel and breakfast were amazing, this location has a good vibe for great food and exceptional attention to customers by people who work there read more

This place used to be awesome. Here's the ham and egg bagel my friend got this morning. It used to have a ton of ham on it. They've been going downhill for a long while, but I'm done now. It's sad when a place that was good goes downhill. read more

YUM! Great breakfast spot. It was raining so we didn't get to sit on their beautiful upper-level patio... overall great bagels for a good price! read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

They are now "New York Bagel" the quality has dropped. I just picked up a breakfast bagel this morning and the bagel is overcooked and has little everything seasoning. Miss the old school bagel. Sad to see it gone and most likely won't be coming back. read more

New York Bagel Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma