Pulled into a hotel late and was hoping for a quick decent dinner for myself, wife and kids ages 16 and 20. After reading through reviews we settled on this place. Ordering on the phone was difficult, but we got it done! Food arrived in about 30 min so not bad. Not I must preface this with I am from NYC, and as such a pizza snob. If something claims to be NYC pizza it must be not only style, but taste. This pizza was there in style (10/10), and for NYC taste I give is a 6/10, which is actually not bad. I liked it much better than the rest of my family. If it was just the pizza this would have been a 3.5 review. Unfortunately, the mozzarella sticks were very floury, telling me they weren't fresh or cooked well, and the salad was, well, inedible. It was suppose to be a garden salad. It was mostly tomatoes and onions and the little lettuce there was in the order was very soggy. Ugh. If you order from here stick to the pizza. Ugh. read more

When you walk in you know that it's going to be good New York pizza. The smell of the pizza and the ovens.. it was a piece of my hometown. Staff were friendly and welcoming. The pizza is authentic nyc. All the ingredients were quality. read more

See all

Let me tell yall something this place here was amazing. I was visiting Chattanooga and I love pizza so I had to try. First let me say the ambience was great to me there was nice worship/Christian music playing. I'm sure of the employees name but he was really nice and patient. He was even willing and able to talk about Jesus! I enjoyed my experience there and the pizza with cheesy with nice thin foldable crust. Overall great experience will come back to try some more options. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Top pizzas in Chattanooga for me, will definitely be going back to get another pie. The crust was thin and crispy, the pizza was extra cheesy, plenty of toppings, the sauce was exactly too read more

The pizza is fresh, tastes fantastic. The staff are courteous and friendly. The service is excellent. It's a casual, easy family friendly atmosphere. read more

New York Pizza - Two delicious crispy pepperoni slices with a side of fresh tomato sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

This is the closest to the real Nee York pizza in the area. Being from Manhattan and missing the pizza this is my absolute go to when I get that craving! The place is small but it does not take away from the flavors. Makes me wonder if the owners are from NY themselves or nearby. 10/10! read more

This is our FAVORITE pizza restaurant in Chattanooga. The pizza crust is perfectly crispy every time! The workers are always kind, and we're on a first name basis with all of them. The building is small but it's never cramp or busy enough to get super loud. I love the art they have on their walls. It's right next to AMC too, so perfect for date night. Make sure you have plenty of time before your movie though- The food takes some time to cook. read more

Visited NY Pizza recently, and I was left quite underwhelmed. While the establishment had a unique ambiance and friendly staff, the quality of the pizza fell short of expectations. Granted I did order 2 slices of the premade pizza and had toppings added. Not a whole pie made fresh. I ordered hoping for a delightful meal. Sadly, the pizza was just fair. The toppings, which were generous in quantity, arrived cold and seemed to be haphazardly thrown on. Many of them were falling off as I tried to eat, making for a less-than-enjoyable dining experience. Since it was not baked with the cheese on top the toppings were just loose The crust was decent, though it could have been less done for me. A little more care in preparation and ensuring toppings are evenly distributed and properly heated would go a long way in improving the overall quality. In summary, NY Pizza has potential but needs to refine its pizza-making process to provide a more satisfying dining experience. Hoping for improvements in the future. read more

Yes it is NY Pizza. Great and surprising find in Chattanooga Tennessee. Good crust! read more

I called in an order and was told "we are very busy today so it will be about 30-35 minutes." I said it was no problem and showed up early but waited patiently in the parking lot. At the quoted time I went in to pick up the pizza and was then told "my pizza guy isn't even at work yet so we can't even start the pizza." Why didn't you just say that on the phone??? Why even open the doors or accept phone calls if you can't serve food? Wild. read more

Cravable. It's dinner every Sunday night for us. It's consistently hot and crispy. You can also just get a slice for lunch. One slice will do it! They are huge. read more

I got this pizza for pick up so I didn't check out the environment just gotta say that first. This is for sure a NY pizza slice, great undercarriage as well as a crispy crunchy crust. The flop is minimal, not too floppy not too stiff. Cheese to sauce ratio seemed on point. The chicken felt a bit bland but it did the job well. Beef is great as well lots of savory flavor. The pepperoni was greasy and absolutely punchy with its flavor which complimented the slice quite well. The mozzarella tastes really good. Tomato sauce does its job to complement the mozz. Definitely going to this spot when I need some good NY style pizza in the area. This probably beats downtown community pie right now but is very slightly below prime downtown community pie if ykyk. 8.3 out of 10 will eat again! read more

See all

This place is absolutely amazing, we went here right after a movie at AMC and got this pizza, it was crunchy but not burnt( I have no idea how they did that) 10/10 recommend read more

This place is legit. Someone with a deep love for pizza plopped this gem down in the place you'd least expect to find authentic pie. My dining companion and I sought refuge for a late Wednesday lunch during a minor family emergency and this place revealed itself as the best option. 1. The pizza is honest-to-Pete New York style. Expansive slices, crisp crust with the right amount of chew, perfectly proportioned toppings. No notes. 2. Calzone was on point. Delicious, generously sized, heated up perfectly in an air fryer the next day. 3. Meatball sub was well-enjoyed by my table mate. I can't comment further, other than to say that this kid is partial to meatball subs and deemed it "good" with a thumb high up. 4. The restaurant itself is newly remodeled and very pleasant, on the dark and moody side. Which TBH I prefer. 5. Pricing was fair and ordering was easy and modern. You wanna talk to a person? Done. You wanna order from your table with a QR code? Done. A solid pizzeria. Don't pass it up. read more

I was in the pizza business for a decade, and this is my go-to pizza. I stumbled across you by accident a couple of years or so ago - I'm thrilled that I did! read more

It was great and very much like NY pizza. Crispy and foldable crust with delicious sauce and cheese.

I love pizza, had it all over, from South Florida to California, and this is a small place but big flavor, pizza has a nice crunch with homemade flavor on the sauce and cheese, definitely will be back. Stop by if ur in the area, you won't be disappointed. read more

New York Pizza - Cheese pizza, calzone, garden salad - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Best authentic pizza in East Tennessee. If you like large thin slice pizza and have wondered what "New York" pizza was like look no further. We drive 30 mins to eat here and it's worth it every time! read more

I'm going to have to be biased here considering I'm from up north, but this is the BEST pizza place I've been to around here in a long time. This is very authentic New York Pizza! The crust, the sauce, the CHEESE and the toppings. Even the way it folds Just seeing the cheese slices alone I knew immediately I was in the right place. The staff was amazing, and he told me about the owners. He really made us feel at home. Then the pizza came out. This is exactly what a pizza should look and taste like. And I'm so happy we stopped in after the movie. We will be back, and thank you sooooo much for giving me that taste of home I've been missing so much, it seriously brought a tear to my eye read more

New York Pizza - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Omg this place is so delicious! The pizza is so crunchy, my favorite kind!!! This was our first time trying it and we got the 18inch pizza and had left overs! It even better warmed up at home. Next time we ware getting a bigger size so we have more!! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Finally a place in TN that makes great Pizza. I have had the opportunity to try this place 2x now. First I had their combo pie. Great crust, crisp bottom thin crust with chewy top. Good amount of meat topping, and quality mozzarella. Today I had there Margarita pie with razor thin sliced fresh tomatoes, basil, mozzarella and spices. Excellent. read more

New York Pizza - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Been jonesing for pizza and decided on this place a mile from my daughter's house. Boy what a great find! Crispy thin crust, served hot with a drink for $10. Can't be beat...try it out!! read more

New York Pizza - Now that's a great $10 lunch!! - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Pizza was amazing. We got two cheese pizzas , and they were excellent. Price was reasonable too. read more

Tiny pizza place with all the flavor. We went to grab a quick dinner before seeing a movie. This calzone was the best I've had in awhile! The ladies let me have the brisket special as an addition. Perfectly cooked, tender brisket and all the cheese in this perfect calzone! Koodos to the staff. read more

New York Pizza - Calzone- veggie on the left and bbq brisket on the right - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Such a great restaurant! We were going to see a movie in the same parking lot and we wanted to grab a quick bite to eat and not eat movie theater food! We both got individual slices. The service was top quality. My slice was a little broken at the end and I was offered a new slice but declined. Ambiance is great casual dining. Highly recommend and I cannot wait to return! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

I LIVED lived in New York, up in Washington Heights when it was on the 1/9 Red line. I know when a two-slice-and-a-soda-lunch-time combo is right. The pie at New York Pizza nails it. Real deal. Slice size and sauce, spot on. Crunchy crust, even on the reheat. Come get you a slice. read more

Always on the lookout for good NY pizza, we thought we'd give this new place a try. Called in an order for pickup, plain cheese pizza, and they asked if we wanted 18" or 24"! Well, it was the 24" of course! It was so big my wife had to slide her seat all the way back to have room to hold it while we drove home! People working were very nice and talkative, too. Ambience was cute...definitely newly remodeled. Went back a second time and got the same pizza but with extra sauce. Even better! Huge floppy pieces you can fold in half just like you want to. We'll be going back any time we're close! read more

New York Pizza - 24" pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

Just relocated here from Memphis and this place was only 1 mile from my house. I've been 3 times in a month. Very good, and i'm normally not a NY style pizza guy. read more

Tried this place for the first time. New York style pizza and sausage and peppers sandwich was ordered. Take it from someone who has been to New York many times the food is delicious and authentic. Gid bless the owners I pray they have much success! Grab a slice y'all! read more

New York Pizza - Sausage and Peppers Sandwich! - Pizza Near Me - Chattanooga, Tennessee

See all

THE PIZZA WAS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!! If you're sitting in the parking lot after leaving the movie theater debating whether or not you should go because there are only 24 reviews... now 25. Just go. No questions just go. My #1 pizza place now. Too bad I'm from far South Georgia. I would have added a picture but it was just to dang good read more

This place is phenomenal. This is authentic New York style pizza. Super thin crust, greasy, huge slices. Outstanding breadsticks. Very friendly staff as well. Quick service. Until somebody tops them, this is THE pizza place in Chatty. read more

I grew up on Long Island and this is the best NY pizza in Chattanooga. A regular cheese slice is great and a "grandma" slice is amazing. Fluffy crust and delicious sauce. A reheated slice will give you a little crispy which I prefer. If sandwiches are your thing try the Italian sub. It's awesome. read more

For pizza by the slice m, I'm giving them a 8.5. Really greats place to eat. The food is good and warm. The staff is super friendly and it's like a hidden gem. There was no one there when we went, which is sometimes the best. read more

We stopped in after being told about this place. This place should be way busier than it is!! The pizza was huge and tasted excellent. Dough had a great chew, sauce on point, and just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. Definitely recommend. read more

100% don't pass this place by! They have pizza by the slice deals, crispy and chewy crust. The sauce is nothing like you find at the chain pizza places. Hot fresh and delicious. The owners are so kind. I can't wait to come back! read more

Excellent NY style pizza in East Ridge! Family owned with fantastic customer service. Eat-in or take out, the food is always excellent! Check them out, you won't be disappointed! read more

Great pizza and subs. A word of caution: the 27" pizza is huge but certainly delicious. Bought 2 for a family of 5. Not able to finish one for dinner...but still delicious as leftovers. read more

Thoroughly the best calzone I've ever had in three states. Welcoming manager with nice dark lighting made this one of the best places I've been. You have to understand though I straight up used my bare hands while pouring marinara over it. Fresh made late at night it was the best I've ever had. Only thing I had was an empty box unfortunately when I typed this. read more

There are some really good NY style pizza places in Chatt but this is my personal favorite. And the meatball sandwich may be the best I've ever had. read more

I live up the block and I've been dying for some new haven style coal oven pizza but there is none of that around here so I've been trying to see what's good in the area and to my surprise here was a place where I could get a slice and was close. I took a slice out to my car to eat it and that's when I realized that the good Lord had blessed me once again. I had to go back in for another slice to take with me. I plan on going back again tonight. The inside is great, a place that's cozy to sit alone and eat in and the reg slice of cheese was greater than the sum of its parts. So yea I'll give it 5 because it's going to be a regular place for me. read more