I love the new pastas that New York Pizza now carries. The Pesto and Chicken pasta is so good with lots of yummy tender chicken.

We order pizza from New York Pizza at least once a week. Yes, it's my husband's favorite pizza place. So, it's time for me to let them know that we enjoy their pizza. Our order: large vegetarian pizza with Alfredo - White creamy garlic sauce. Original hand tossed crust. They never skimp on the toppings. And the order always comes out hot and speedy. read more

New York Pizza - Delicious vegetarian pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

Chicken Bacon pizza was overloaded with cheese, the chicken and bacon was applied sparingly and when I called to complain, I was informed that he, the cashier made the pizza and he told me that he put the bacon on it... let's see how much bacon, tastes okay but horribly made and bad customer service...I'm not going to return. read more

New York Pizza - Claimed that he added bacon... two dollars for less than a half slice crumbled... outrageous. - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

Craving 'za (aka pizza)? You can never go wrong with a NY style 'za! I like that they are literallt 5 mins away and I can grab a quick slice or get a whole pie when the craving hits. The crust is crispy and a good balance of dough per toppings ratio. My usual fave is a combo w/o bell peppers. Any leftovers are even better - as I can eat leftover pizza at any time of day! read more

New York Pizza - 2 slices of medium pizza. Good crispy crust! - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

Decent pizza that was quick and fairly priced. Sauce had good tang, the crust was crispier than I thought it was going to be. Good amount of toppings. Would come back for a quick pie read more

The pizza is on par with round table. They have a very affordable party packages which equates to 5 XL (16") 1-toppings for $82. We tried the pizza and the dough was tough and chewy but the sauce and toppings were good. We hope the pizza is better next time but it's not terrible for Elk Grove, just not amazing either. Great deals though! read more

New York Pizza - Menu 5/1/25 - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

In short: -Best for take out since they only have 2 tables and no ambiance lol. - Good pizza for a quick meal but they don't offer slices. - Great service - the two guys there were really nice. We got a small so the crust was a bit thicker than I was expecting for NY style but the combo flavors were good, just could have used a bit more cheese to crust ratio for me, but it was still enjoyed with some red pepper flakes and oregano on top Thanks guys for your help! read more

Ordered delivery so I have not seen the store . Delivery was quick and the pizza was still hot! As someone who tried and loved pizza in NYC I would say this place was pretty close! Prices was reasonable and the pizza was delicious! read more

This pizza was delicious!! Perfect amount of sauce, cheese and pepperoni. The crust was perfectly made too! Can't wait to come back and try other dishes. read more

New York Pizza - Large Pizza with Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

I was in the mood for NY style pizza so I came by for dinner takeout. The place is a bit hole in the wall and outfitted primarily for takeout service. The service was friendly. I had called ahead and ordered a medium sized combination pizza and added a Greek salad. The salad was wonderful with fresh vegetables, feta cheese, and ranch dressing. The pizza crust was not the usual thin NY style I prefer but nonetheless was hand tossed and tasted great. I look forward to coming back. read more

See all

So close to being a NY slice. But honestly living out here for the last 10 years I realize it's close enough. Right chew to the crust. Fresh toppings. Good service. 1000000% better than any round table or other crap place. I'll be back. Also they sell slices. read more

The pizza is a great size and the flavors are always tasty. The service is quick and the workers are friendly. Ive never eaten in because we always get delivery or pick up but they have a lot of customers. read more

This is our new go-to pizza joint! Obsessed! We pretty much always get one of their family meals (large 2-topping pizza, cheesy garlic bread, and a 2 liter). Their pizza and garlic bread are both ALWAYS fantastic! Seasoned and topped perfectly, and the crust is so delicious!!! Today, I ordered the gyro for my mom and she loved it. My husband is a HUGE fan of gyros, but he was sick today so he didn't eat anything, but I will be ordering him one next time. It smelled and looked super fresh and tasty! Honestly, you can't go wrong with this place. Great ingredients and they're very consistent. read more

See all

Honestly this place makes the best pizza!! I literally live on the other side of town and will drive over here to get it. People are always nice and service is good. Not much room to eat there but the quality highly outweighs that one minor inconvenience. Have never had a bad pizza from here and they have family deals that are great! read more

Best pizza in Elk Grove hands down Great prices I'll never got to another pizza spot lunch time slices fire fire After eating it mountain Mike's, Little Caesars round table lamppost all the other pizza restaurants in elk Grove is nasty compared to this place read more

Julian is a amazing employee and I love the scenery the service was 10 stars but I only see Five. I liked the paper plates very environment safe. read more

The food here is amazing. The employees are friendly and always ready to help. The restaurant itself is a small pick up and go type establishment which helps keep the overhead low and pizza delicious. Check out there deals online! read more

New York Pizza - Extra Large 2 Topping Pizza Half Pepperoni & Sausage / Half Pineapple & Canadian Bacon - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

Ehhhh I wasn't too impressed with this place. We decided to try them since we were closer to here than our normal pizza place. We got the Super Hot Deal which is 2 large 2 topping pizzas and liter of soda plus an order of buffalo wings, total came to a little over $50 which honestly isn't that bad for pizza nowadays. When we tried to pay, we were informed they couldn't take a $100 bill and that's all we had. Since the surrounding shops were all closed, we had to drive down the street to the gas station to break the bill which was a pain. Also worth mentioning, this is a grab and go pizza spot. No sit down seating at all. My kids devoured half the double pepperoni pizza on the car ride home so it's safe to say they like the pizza. I, on the other hand did not. My pepperoni and black olive pizza had a weird aftertaste and lacked flavor in the sauce. The crust though was pretty good. Chicken wings were a huge disappointment. In an order of 10 wings I only got one flat. And the wings aren't saucy at all so they were super dry and have absolutely zero flavor, 10/10 do not recommend. I also asked for extra ranch and only got the one tiny cup that came with the wings. Their ranch is house made but it tasted very dill flavor forward. Overall, for me it was a miss, but my kids seemed to enjoy it. While it won't be on my radar for pizza next time, should the kiddos ask for it I have no issue giving them another shot. read more

New York Pizza - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all

Wife saw a coupon for pizza wings and soda combo and I was hesitant because our last experience ordering a Malick Monk pizza from a competitor was a total bust. When we got it home the pizza and wings looked meh but they were both surprisingly good. I was actually impressed on taste. The crust is light and a little chewy in a good way and the buffalo wings were tasty too but could've a little more spicy and I'm not a spicy kinda guy except in the bedroom....Hehehehe I would definitely order from NYP again. read more

First time here, didn't have high expectations. But it was surprisingly really good, definitely way better than lamppost and other chain restaurants. The pizza was great, my kids loved it. And my wife ate the salad so fast I didn't even have time to take a picture! The workers were really nice and helpful too. Diego(I think that was his name?) hooked it up and made sure everything was spot on. I'll be back for sure. read more

New York Pizza - All meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

Julien is the best worker. Amazing customer service and great food. Great environment as well.

I just don't believe a pizza joint stops serv8ng pepperoni pizza 2 hours before closing. They just don't want my business And yes, I do have to ask if the prw judged me somehow. Open for another two hours..... that's bullcrap. Edut: I mean this passed ke off. I called and asked about hours and availability. They told me I must have called the other location. Which was actually accurate.BUT WHO CARES. I AM STANDING RIGHT THERE TWO HOURA BEFORE CLOSING. TWO HOURS. MAKE ANOTHER PIZZA FOR GOD SAKE. OR EXPLAIN WHY YOU DENY RANDOM ORDERS. YOU SIMPLY DID NOT WANT TO SERVE ME. WHY? Place that behave like that should not be in business. read more

I wanted to try something different from all the big chains and this place did not disappoint. It is a little bit pricier than the bigger names but well worth it! My family and I really enjoyed everything I got. We got two different types of pizzas and garlic cheese bread. You can really taste the freshness. This is our new go to place for pizza. read more

I ordered this on a whim when I wanted a quick pizza. This was absolutely worth it. The flavors are strong and they're generous with their toppings. The dough itself is a bit thicker than most would like but tastes sooo good when you air fry it for a couple of minutes. I know that you can choose the type of dough that you want, so I'll definitely try the thin-crust version for a thinner pizza! I'll definitely be a returning customer. read more

New York Pizza - thick garlic chicken pizza (10" small) + pineapple. soooo good! - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all

I have never tried New York Pizza on Bruceville Rd, so I went online and placed an order for a gourmet pizza Meat Lovers. I added mushrooms and olives. I paid for a gourmet pizza and the additional items. To my surprise, when I got home to enjoy my pizza, the MEAT was missing!! No meat, just mushrooms and olives. So I paid for a Meat lovers pizza with 2 extra toppings and got only mushroom and olives on the pizza. Check your orders as it seems the employees don't care about quality of their product. I won't be ordering from this place again. read more

I'm from New York and I enjoy this pizza very much. Although it is very difficult to reproduce an authentic New York pizza. They do a very good job. Give them a try. read more

Pizza delivery came. When pizza received bottom of box was soaked. Pizza was in carry case on top of soda which made the pizza soggy.

Service was ok and server was not liking his day maybe. Pizza was not bad and filling. Good for last minute meal. Location was a little hard to find parking space. Clean store and neat indoor. read more

Love the pizza here. The cheeseburger pizza, supreme pizza, and Greek pizza are awesome!

I had never used Laguna New York Pizza but it went well. I ordered thru DoorDash and it was exactly what I thought it would be. I don't know whether it's a virtual kitchen because there are three with the same listing as New York Pizza. You get your money's worth. Try them read more

Ok the pizza not bad on price and it was good customer service also was good so yes I will be back

New York Pizza in Elk Grove! That something you wouldn't think about at first, but it is a place that is definitely worth trying! I honestly did not have high expectations since I came back from some work and was exhausted. I was way too tired to cook myself dinner, so I figured I would try this place out. I gave them a quick call, and the manager picked up the phone, it wasn't the most customer friendly call, but it was straight to the point. I was already ready with my order and I made some minor adjustments, and they accomplished it right on the dot. I ordered a half and half pizza, basically a combo pizza and a pineapple pizza (I know what you are thinking! Pineapple doesn't belong on pizza!), I disagree, it provides a sweet and savory taste to the pizza! Anyways, along with the pizza I ordered some salad with no onions, and some chicken wings. I picked up about an 40 minutes later, not issue besides the small amount of pepper provided, I had to request the clerk some more as the manager didn't hear me, he must have been in a rush for his break or something. Anyway, I went home with my stack of napkins and pepper with obviously my half and half pizza, so I was happy! Food review: Overall, good pizza, not exactly NY pizza, but good pizza. For the price, its better than pizza hut! Good experience, I think they could definitely elevate their experience if they had better customer friendly service and some prepared pick up processes! Some great incentives for customers! Steve read more

Delicious solid pizza, good deals, and staff are friendly and not stressed out when we go in. They always check in if our order online seems off, and overall are caring and attentive. Crust is perfect and thoroughly cooked. Also, they are hiring delivery drivers. LGBT friendly staff, and staff say they enjoy their job. Owner seems very friendly and kind. read more

See all

New York Pizza is a small business located near a busy street. The Pizzas are made fresh according to customers requests. The pizzas are full of fresh ingredients and flavor. Service is fairly quick even on a busy night. read more

To my surprise this pizza taste VERY good! In all fairness I ate the NY Combo and the Calzone. Taking a break until I eat the NY Super Chicken. Lots of topping at a fair price. The price online differs from the restaurant price. I would recommend! read more

Fast service, excellent presentation and most importantly delicious. 5 stars from me. read more

New York Pizza - X-Large 3 combo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

The pizza was bomb.com the sauce/crest everything about our pizza was great taste. We also go cheeses garlic bread bomb . We found a new place to get our pizza now. read more

New York Pizza - NY Super Chicken Pizza/Combination and Cheesy bread bomb.com. This place was delicious , we found a new pizza place - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all

We started getting New York pizza from this location in 09/2023. The employees here are wonderful. We usually get veggie pizza with white sauce and breadsticks. Love the consistency in food and service. Definitely my favorite pizza place. read more

New York Pizza - Extra large veggie pizza with white sauce and all the toppings including jalapeños. - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

I ordered a large combo to go. The pizza was the average size of a large pizza and had good flavor. The crust is thick and that's exactly what I was craving for. A thick pizza with a combination of everything. I give 4 stars only because the girl at the front wasn't very friendly. read more

I have had their pizza before which is really good This time I tried there calzone Friendly owner and staff I had a chicken feta with mushroom calzone Portion was large White garlic sauce tasted good with the chicken an mushroom Service was quick read more

New York Pizza - Calzone cut to make easier to eat - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all