I really love this place! It was recommended and I drove down from Roseville to try. I have passed the area a few times during backroad drives from Loomis and Lincoln. It's fairly close off of I80. A historic part of town with plenty of charm. The Newcastle Cheese Shop appears to be very popular. People come from all over to try. I love the photos and woodworking all around. The staff were very friendly and personable. A recommendation was to try the hot pastrami sandwich with a Dutch Crunch roll. It was super delicious. There's plenty of seating or you can take it to go. They package your sandwich nicely. Out of the three places I reviewed, this was my fav. I'll be out again to try out another sandwich plus the clam chowder. read more

See all

After reading reviews, I had to visit after a few hours of gold panning the American River. I like the location and outdoor seating. No complaints about the service as they come out looking for you when you sit outside. Now about the sandwich. I ordered a hot pastrami on dutch crunch. The meat was piled high and delicious but for me it's about the bread. The dutch crunch lacked any crunch. It was very soft on the outside which for me was a bummer. read more

Visited some family out in Newcastle and right off the bat seemed like an amazing spot in the area for a fresh sandwich. My family often goes here a lot too so I was excited. Got their infamous Rat Trap Sandwich and it was delicious. It was packed with so much meat and condiments, filled me up fast. Got the sandwich with Dutch Crunch bread it was okay, it wasn't that crunchy like your normal Dutch Crunch but I think I got a wrong slice of it. Planning on coming to this area each year to visit during the holidays so I'm excited to come back and get it again. For parking, there's plentiful in front and also inside seating. read more

See all

Arrived 30 minutes before closing and was greeted with a smile. Ordered the infamous Rat Trap on a Dutch crunch with all the fixings Dirty Sea Salt chips. Mrs ordered the Veggie Sandwich on a soft roll & pasta salad. Used the restroom & the water station & the sandos were delivered quickly. Pretty tasty combo of meats and cheese on a slightly dry fluffy Dutch crunch. Vegi Sandwich offered a medley of green including avocado. Pasta salad was delicious but plain consisting of,pasta,onions, light cheese crumbles. Maybe not the best sandwich I've ever had, but pretty decent with super friendly service. read more

See all

Had a sandwich and it was amazing. The service was also great as well as a comfortable, clean and charming sitting area. Really satisfying experience. read more

Best deli sandwiches I've ever had. Always hits. Great service, everyone is kind. Cozy and comfortable floor/deck space. The kinda small business deli shop that would be on "Diners, Drive-Ins-and Dives". Cash discount read more

This place has the best sandwiches! I don't care what kind you get you can't go wrong! Potato salad, everything is delicious! Friendly service! It is definitely the best sandwich shop I've ever been too!! read more

Excellent deli with the best salads and Rat Trap special sandwich. The staff is amazing always so friendly. Super fun crew that works there! read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Rat Trap Sammy - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

See all

The best sandwich shop in Placer County. Been going here for decades. Love it! Get the pastrami . read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Pastrami with Swiss and everything on it. Best pastrami sandwich I've had in a very long time. sandwich was 11$ and some change. - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

See all

I'll drive 20-25 minutes for their sandwiches. The rat trap without pastrami and their mac salad are amazing. Wish it was closer

This is the perfect sandwich shop and it's a real gem for the city of Newcastle . The rat trap sandwich is fantastic and priced just right . Staff are great and always fast! I love the location and its great charm inside . One of the best in placer county. You won't regret coming here read more

I bought and paid for a pastrami sandwich today Dec 18th and when I got home no sandwich. Just soup and potato salad. For $36. I even tipped them. I'll never go here again. They also will not answer the phone so I'm posting this everywhere! read more

The friendliest most welcoming spot! My husband and I ordered and snagged a table outside with our pup. The staff brought us out a bowl with cold ice water and some cold cuts for our dog to enjoy. It was such a thoughtful gesture! Totally recommend this spot! read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - 1/2 sandwich & potato salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

I've been going to this place since I was a little kid. Got a rat trap today and it had freezer burned Dutch crunch bread. Absolutely ridiculous, I will take my business to the deli in downtown Auburn. read more

Best sandwich shop EVER. How is this not a killer deal. This so called "half-sandwich " which is the size of a fat whole sandwich and a side of potato salad for $12 out the door. Absolutely the best sandwiches anywhere around. read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Half pastrami cold with smoked cheddar and potato salad side. - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

See all

I have been going to the newcastle cheese shop for many many many years. They are my favorite sandwich shop. We even used to drive two hours when we moved away to go there. . My the rat trap on the Dutch crunch. read more

Best hidden gem in the Sierra Nevada! If you are lucky enough to visit on a Wednesday you can try their French dip. Although they are known for their rat trap sandwich. They are all delicious. They also sell different cheese. read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

Unimpressed. The Rat trap was bland. They ran out of Dutch crunch and French roll bread early in the day. The bread they had on hand was stale and hard. The hype had me very excited to eat here. But was sadly disappointed. Staff was polite and quick. Location was small and packed but clean. read more

Stopped at this rustic cafe after checking out a small nursery in the area. The counter service was fast, friendly and put together some amazing sandwiches that hit the spot. The bread and fillings were very fresh and of high quality. Would definitely recommend if you're looking for a quick, satisfying and delicious bite. read more

Second time here have not been disappointed yet for five sandwiches two bags of chips and five drinks. It was $77 worth the price will be back read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Salami with pepper jack cheese no tomato on a white roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

The rat hole ? sandwich they are known for was unusual and delicious. There were quite a few officers dining there that day which gave me the impression it's a favorite place for many of them. read more

Walked in, and immediately loved the atmosphere and vibes inside this small town sandwich Shop. The decor, historical pieces, family vibes, just loved it all. They were quick to acknowledge and greet me warmly, took my order (I'm a 1st timer), and had my rat trap sandwich to my table relatively quickly! The sandwich was really good and great value spent. Tasted like a quality sandwich with quality ingredients. Dutch crunch bread could have been a bit crunchier (maybe just preference), but I can also appreciate that it wasn't *too hard* where it breaks a tooth or collapses the entire sandwich just trying to take a bite, lol. I'll note that for next time I come in! And might ask for some extra mustard and veggies (preference). All in all, excited to come back, and try it again! read more

See all

Rode from Rancho Cordova to get out of the house & a mini road trip. WELL WORTH the drive!! Excellent sandwich-the half was enough!! read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Waiting for Sammies - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

See all

Cute little spot! Got half sandwich half salad combo! I had turkey ham & cheese on dutch crunch & macaroni salad - delish! Friend got rat trap sandwich & potato salad and enjoyed both! Was a perfect little midway point from the bay to tahoe for a good bite! read more

I don't know what I expected but this wasn't it. Yes they have cheese as the name suggests but the draw is the made to order deli sandwiches and the huge variety of drinks. I had the famous "rat trap" sandwich - 4 meats, cheese, and the works on a Dutch roll - and it's really good. You can customize any sandwich and they'll heat it up if you'd like. They also have some snacks you can buy to round out your meal. The service is really friendly. I commented that the chili smelled good so they slipped a little sample with my order. They know people's names, everyone was smiling even when it got busy. It's pretty small so you might have a hard time finding a seat if it's around the lunch hour. There are also a few tables outside but not a lot. Go! read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

Great sandos! Great people! Great place! Love the small town and generous portions they give. Killer rolls and everything else. Our go to place for lunch! read more

I got a pepper turkey sandwich with smoked cheddar. It was SO GOOD!!! The price is reasonable for the portions you get, and I love supporting a local shop. The owner is always there and he is the nicest guy ever. If you are in Newcastle this is a great find. The area it's in feels nostalgic, like I'm going back in time to visit a cute little town from the 50s (in a good way). I love coming here. They also have a ton of different cheeses so you can buy some and take some home with you. I love cheese and they had plenty of kinds that I've never heard of before. read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Pepper turkey sandwich with smoked cheddar - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

Great casual place to shop for cheeses and sandwiches. We just moved to Placer County from Sac and on the lookout for a new quick and grab sandwich spot. This place hit the spot. The sandwiches were very large portion for the price and the service was welcoming. Will be back when we are in the area. They also have cool root beers to try in the refrigerated section! read more

I had a rat trap sandwich and the macaroni salad. I asked for it to be on a Dutch crunch roll but it came on a regular roll. It happens. It was a great meal read more

Dare I say the best sandwich ever? First, let's discuss the term sandwich. It should be served on a bread that is supple, supportive, tasty, but not at all the centerpiece. Next, the sandwich shouldn't be the "safe" option, it should be the specialty of the business. While this is a "cheese" shop they serve sandwiches. Great ones. The meats should be fresh, and shouldn't all taste the same. They should stand out but not be obtrusive. And the combination should be akin to a professional sommelier pairing a fine wine with dinner. The assembly should be unexpected when suggested but obvious after the fact. The cheese needs to be real. Not something individually wrapped or pre-sliced. And like the pairing of meats, it too should be designed. Do I sound crazy? Like perhaps covid has melted my brain to mush? Why in the world would a sandwich shop be so exacting? So careful and purposeful? I can think of only one reason. To make the best sandwich ever. And they accomplish this despite the burden of covid. I sincerely hope they endure and I would recommend going and experiencing a sandwich as soon as possible in the event they some how do not make it through covid. It would be a shame. I came from Roseville. We wanted to go on a drive and yelp suggested the spot. Honestly I wasn't in favor of trying a new spot in the midst of covid, but thankfully my wife convinced me to stop. I had the rat trap. It was delightful. It was a variety of meats along with lettuce tomato and some other condiments. It was perfection. My wife had a veggie sandwich and it too was incredible, despite her poor choice (who orders a vegetable sandwich at a cheese shop that basically has three sandwich options to begin with and one is called the "rat trap"? You are obligated to go with the rat trap. Anyways, absolutely worth the detour off I80 if you are going to or from Tahoe/Reno, and totally worth the drive from Roseville. read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Yummy cookies! - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

See all

LET'S TALK ABOUT THIS PLACE. Oh my gosh this place is so very good. The meat and cheese is fresh and you can taste the perfect bread. I walked in and it was small and busy inside. There are a ton of locals that know about this shop, but that makes it very special. I made my own sandwich and I used dutch crunch for the bread. The staff are very friendly and ask tons of questions for clarifications. There are tons of choices of chips and soda to choose from and spaces to sit down inside and outside. THIS IS A MUST STOP LOCATION. Make sure to check the hours before coming out and tip the staff because they are amazing! I will continue to come back often. read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Turkey on sourdough - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California

See all

One word...rat trap...ok two words. Great deli and just get the rat trap. The vibe is great. Not a high end restaurant...but that makes it great. Nothing to change, it is what it is! Get sandwich and you'll understand. read more

Best sandwich I've ever had. I always stop in here when I'm passing through. I only wish they had longer hours but that's part of the allure. read more

Hole in the wall sandwich shop in Newcastle. Was passing through the area and saw very good reviews of this place. Tried the rat trap, as that was the most recommended item, and it was AMAZING. The sandwich is packed with toppings and meat, and the bread was very moist and crunchy :) service was extraordinary. Even though it was rush hour, they acknowledged everyone and worked efficiently with each other. read more

The sandwiches were so good the service was so good they came out so fast. The best sandwich shop around, love a mom and pop shop

Great sandwhichs, chilli and soups. Friendly and fast service. Definitely worth the trip up to Newcastle.

Great food!! Love the availability of 1/2 sandwiches too!! My favorite one is the veggie on Dutch crunch bread! Lots of cheeses and veggies and balsamic dressing !!! Yum!!! read more

Nice historic setting, Excellent sandwich and friendly service. During these times of shrinkflation and our dollars not stretching as far as they used to I felt I got my monies worth at the Newcastle cheese shop. The only thing I regret is I noticed they sell pickle juice in to go cups as if it is meant to be a drink and I DIDNT BUY ONE!!! I kept thinking about it after I left. Next time I'll try! read more

Such a cute and homey place!! I love the veggie sandwich!! It is good and even better after a few hours when all the bread absorbs all the sauce! Yum! They have a little shop too along with sides and just a great feel! A classic and well known to the area! read more

This place is such a cute and local gem. Felt very homey when I walked in. I had the the veggie sandwich on lite rye bread and it was the best sandwich I've ever had! I usually get sourdough at deli's but was told the Rye was good so I gave it a shot. It was delicious and soft! I also had the macaroni salad which was the best macaroni salad in the whole wide world! I'm just in town passing through on a road trip. I wish we had this place back home! Also, the staff was so so sweet and helpful. This place is a must go if you are in town or nearby!!! read more

Newcastle Cheese Shop - Veggie sandwich on Rye bread and macaroni salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Newcastle, California