We've enjoyed the Florentine pizza best. The rest is so-so but Florentine is white with ricotta, olive oil, spinach, garlic, cheeses. I'd say 7 out of 10 times was excellent! The other few times were lousy bc bread was stale. The florentine is $20 a large pizza, which isn't cheap but worth it if that's what your craving. read more

Newtown Pizza is a nice little shop across the street from the Green Parrot on Sycamore. They have been around for quite awhile too. I like that they are across the street from the Green Parrot because I just don't think the quality of food justifies the prices. Anyway, Newtown Pizza is your pretty basic pizza shop offering just about everything you might expect. A wide variety of pizza toppings, hoagies, ect... When I was here the other day, the food wasn't as good as I remember. My steak sandwich was fine, and the pizza we ordered was just over oily and way too soggy. The staff was very friendly though. I think Newtown Pizza would benefit from a menu overhaul that is smaller and carries fresher (i.e. not frozen) proteins and other ingredients. read more

Outstanding Trenton pizza (and regular pizza as well). They also have a good mediterranean menu if you're into that. I would stick to those two items...the other Italian offerings do not measure up. read more

THE OWNER IS RUDE AND WILL HANG UP ON YOU. They made a mistake with our order and it was never delivered. When I called to ask about where our food was after 2 hours of WAITING they would do NOTHING to compensate when I had a house full of hungry PEOPLE. When then owner hangs up on you that is a PROBLEM!!! read more

Tried their pizza tonight. Three of us had an everything pizza, slices of mushroom, Marguerite and white with garlic. Margurita was the best. All very tasty. The owner, server is friendly. Nice Italian ambience. They have a great menu, we just went for pizza. read more

Love Newtown Pizza! They have good mediterranean dishes too. The lamb gyro is my fav. When we first moved to the area we couldn't find a good pizza place, finally we found newtown pizza. They are nice in there too. When I go in there with my 18m old son, they help me take the food out. There food is very good but the little things make them better than the others in newtown. read more

My husband and I really like Newtown Pizza. Their pizza and pasta are very good, and they make excellent cheese steaks. Gabe, the owner, is very friendly. Sometimes, he'll come and sit with us at our table and chat for a while. We decided to order out and have chicken parm and eggplant parm delivered. After I placed the order, I read some of the reviews. Most of them were very good. One person commented that the eggplant parm was chewy. Well, he was right. It was too thick and chewy. I actually didn't eat it. The taste was good, but just too chewy. That's my only recommendation for Newtown Pizza. Gabe, if you are reading this, the eggplant would be delicious if it were sliced very thin read more

We moved into the 'burbs from the NYC area, we were all like ugh where are we gonna find good pizza? But now we're ordering a pie (or two) from Newtown Pizza on a weekly basis. Sometimes we'll even get crazy and order an appetizer of calamari or garlic knots (both very yum). Gotta tell them to go light on the cheese though otherwise it gets soggy (in my opinion). Top notch service and also a cute place to go sit although sometimes frequented by those scary things that refer to themselves as teenagers. read more

Well if I lived any closer to this place I'd be 300 lbs. Solid cheesesteaks, fries were great and then there's their Trenton pie. Oh it was good. I took zero pics of our food because it was inhaled. read more

Amazing pizza! Such unique selections in a great setting, right in the center of Newtown. Quaint and lovely.

I live in VA and come to Newtown for business, when I'm here I try to always get the gluten free, no cheese tomato pizza. I know it sounds boring, but has a lot of flavor. Whne we get delivery the food is always hot and ready to eat. Their salads are quite good as well. read more

I wouldn't recommend this place to a dog.. The only thing good was the delivery driver!!! First they messed my order up, I ordered Chicken Cheesesteak Hoagies and they sent plain chicken cheesesteaks which happens so I'm not being a jerk but when I called them they tried to tell me that is what I must've ordered so I asked him why did they charge me for the hoagie and he said they were the same price and the online prices are outdated. Now I would've been satisfied with a great sandwich but the chicken was the dry obviously frozen cardboard crap that you buy from the market and the sandwich was cold. The 1 star is for the driver. read more

Pizza was good but could have a bit crispier crust. Plus one star for the cleanest bathrooms ever.

We requested delivery. They said it would be 45 mins, which was fine. An hour and fifteen minutes later it arrived. The delivery guy wasn't very friendly and had zero personality which I would'nt mind if the food was good, but it wasn't. We ordered a burger with fries, (both ice cold). The burger was cooked as requested but the fries were actually raw and had no flavor whatsoever. I don't think there was a drop of seasoning on them. The pizza looked gorgeous, but the crust was tough and as flavorless as cardboard. All in all this was both the first and last time I get food here. There are too many other pizza places in Newtown to bother with them again. Very disappointed. read more

Yum! We love to sit outside and enjoy a slice here. Always a winner. Buffalo chicken pizza is my favorite.

The very best white pizza and calzones within 100 miles. Family owned and friendly. Great place with fresh ingredients.

Only gave them one star because I couldn't give zero stars!!!! Will never order from here again and suggest highly that nobody else does

This is the best Pizza in Newtown! The service is attentive and the staff is friendly, they greet you as you walk in the door. The Garlic rolls are perfect, delicous sauces, Pizza crust is just the right thickness, crisp and chewy at the same time, great combo's too. Try theCheesteak Pizza. On Friday they serve chocolate pizza! Give it a try! read more

Great hoagies and steaks. Recently was turned back on to this place. My wife was not a fan of the pizza. But a good friend reminded me you don't get all your favorite foods from one place. That's why he prefers take out or delivery. So far had a great generous sized turkey hoagie, cheese steak, and some fries. Very good. She sandwiches come in a nice cardboard to go box. Reminds me of a good hoagie that is tightly wrapped. Something about that says a lot about how a place cares for their food. 5 starts when I give the pizza a try. read more

The rude bitches working at the counter don't deserve your business. Stay away. If I could give 0 stars on yelp I would! They screw up an order and give the customer attitude. read more

It's sad that the owner told me the customer that I was wrong when I ordered my food also when i started to eat it anyway it sucked never again !!!!!!!!! read more

This pizza would have been ok if it wasn't COLD -super late on the delivery & the greasy garlic knots yikes & how about the not so buffalo hard wings ‍‍ Do better newtown pizza read more

Great night! My family & I stopped in for a late dinner, while our clothes were drying at the laundromat, as the dryer broke. A man, who seemed to be the owner/manager, was so great! My youngest wanted to watch Hairspray on their tv. This gentleman turned on the correct channel & raised the volume for my kids. The waitress is friendly & efficient. We ordered cheesesteak pizza, which was delicious! Also ordered a pepperoni pizza, which was very good. This will be our new pizza place. Further from our house, but wonderful service, warm staff, & great food!! Ty!! read more

Horribleour first time there we had pizza and salad. Pizza bread was hard and sauce was too salty. Went there again to give it another try maybe Ill get lucky and get a good meal. Being here from the same town, we like supporting local businesses. I ordered chicken gyro ( pizza was not a good experience for me). The worst gyro I've ever had. Chicken was was cold and it was not fresh. It looked like frozen pre sliced that came out of the box. Get it? read more

Their pizza is good but they have some of the best cheesesteaks in the area!!! Both their regular and buffalo chicken cheesesteaks are to die for.. read more

Be careful. They do not always adhere to their posted hours. They sometimes close 15 minutes early. It happened to us tonight.

Best pizza in Newtown. Consistent, good balance between cheese and sauce and always delivered hot. Keep up the good work.

Great pizza with not the usual toppings, salads are very fresh and the baba gnash and hummus and other middles eastern dishes are tasty and authentic! We love eating outside in the summer and we love the back room in the winter. The food is hearty and has a home cooked look and taste. The service is attentive and quick and they have very thoughtful packaging of the food for take out so there are no spills or smashed sandwiches. Yummy, warm, tasty and friendly! Ivy, Newtown, PA read more

We picked up 10 pies for our son's birthday party from Newtown Pizza. For such a large order I was surprised when they were ready on time and still hot when I picked them up. The food tasted great and the kids enjoyed eating it. I will defnitely continue to get take-out from Newtown Pizza! Thanks! read more

I would normally rate the food here higher but the customer service was APPALLING!! My kids ordered a pizza, and it was delivered 2 hours late only after my oldest called to ask why it never arrived. Turns out, the delivery driver had an incorrect address across town. When I called to ask WHY, after 2 hours, they would still charge for the pizza, the owner got on the phone and did not apologize even once & kept asking me why my son waited so long to call them, even calling me cheap for wanting some type of compensation. I am not sure how they got the wrong address, or phone number, but it was a huge mistake that could have been handled so much more professionally & not to mention, even nicely. Due to this fiasco I would NEVER recommend Newtown Pizza to anyone, especially since there are so many awesome pizza restaurants in this area who are so much more professional. read more

Awful pizza, only good for their ranch pizza. 2/10 would not recommend. I even saw a cockroach walk right past my waiter; absolutely disgusting. read more