Went here for a nice sunset dinner scheduled for 7pm and was seated right away. They seated us at the front of the restaurant where we saw a lovely sunset over the ocean. The pool cabanas blocked some of the view, but it was still lovely. We shared the strawberry and beets salad. It was the perfect portion for two and it was delicious. Not one to normally care for beets, the arugula and goat cheese coupled with the sweet strawberries made this a nice treat to begin our meal. My wife picked the catch of the day special which was Mong Chong fish. We never had it before, and it was absolutely delicious. I had the pecan crusted mahi-mahi and it was really good. Both meals were stunningly displayed and were 5-star for taste. We then got the crème brûlée and the macadamia nut brownie. Both were very good. Overall a great view, dinner, and ambience. Devin was our server and he was very friendly and attentive. We highly recommend this place. Someone mentioned about having to valet your car. There is no charge to valet other than whatever you tip the attendant, so give them a decent tip considering. We'll be back! read more

See all

From beginning to end this was a great dining experience. We started with Manhattans and crab cakes with a great view of the water. The lemon added to the crab cakes made them light and refreshing. I had the Seared Diver Scallops with Goat Cheese Tortellini and my husband got the Mahi-mahi. Both dishes were incredible. The flavor profiles were perfect. We were going to order dessert but our waiter offered us a surprise dessert since we were celebrating our honeymoon! It was a custard with fresh fruit. Amazing. What a great place. read more

See all

Fun place nice white table cloth that has a busy clientele. You will need a reservation. Local seafood and turf food. I had the spiny lobster and my friend had the rib eye. We shared each other's plate and she had the Caesar and I had this amazing salad. Service was great. Zero complaints about the staff. The lobster was a bit overdone. Everything else was good the prices I felt for what you received was a little steep at $300 for dinner for two. read more

Had a great experience here and delicious meal. Our waiter was very upbeat and informational, the view was incredible and food delicious. Was not sure since it was a hotel restaurant, but really enjoyed it. The Octopus ap was so flavorful and both fish dishes were tasty and cooked to perfection. Highly recommend read more

This upscale eatery in the upscale part of Maui should have been better. Food wax good and service was good but we were mismatched with drinks from the waiter - long story. I suggest you stay in your Kane with alcohol and don't mix it up too much! read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - a group of men sitting around a table - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

OMG! Best meal on Maui (and we had some other great ones too - kimo's, merrimans, etc)! We went for my dad's 70th birthday and the fish blew our minds. My dad and I both started "writing" Yelp reviews in our minds before the meal was even over. Ahi with mushroom risotto - phenomenal Special picatata style - super creative and clever Desserts- panna cotta & macadamia chocolate brownie! Service - best on Maui Cocktails - meh, kind of boring and corporate/sponsored drink list. Mai thai was great though!! A+!!! read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - 70th birthday dinner! - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Some of the best views in Maui, great food attentive service and amazing experience. Always the first call when I'm in Maui is Nicks

Always Amazing!! The food, spirits, and service are top shelf! Oh, did I mention the view at sunset....SPECTACULAR! Never had a bad experience or meal here. See you again soon and thank you for the kindness and service every time we dine with you. Mahalo Nicks Staff! Keep up the great work! It not just the food and view that brings us back it's the special people on staff that take care of us while there! read more

Wish we had a better experience since we were celebrating our honeymoon and especially because we are staying at the resort the restaurant is in. The waiter seemed to barely pay any attention to us, and strangely spent all of his time with the table next to us. It was odd. We felt like we were a bother or did something wrong? Took awhile to get food ordered, and even longer to get our check well after table was cleared, but table next to us had long conversations and extra treats taken to them. Food was good but not worth the experience and price tag, we preferred Ko's unique menu and service more. read more

One of the Fairmont Resort's restaurants. Excellent quality seafood and 'Maui-affordable" prices. Still pricey, but worth it. The bar is lovely and the bartenders and friendly and knowledgable. Casual atmosphere but high end options. A lovely dinner for those staying at the resort! read more

This is a tradition meal when we come to Maui. Nick's is great for sunset dining, good service, and great food. We try to get the same table every time and this time was no exception. The hostess accommodated our request. Service was good as the wait staff continually ensured we had filled glasses of water, our server went over the menu options, and checked in at the right moments. We started with the ahi sashimi which was delish as always. I tried the seafood chowder which had a crab cake in the middle and then the chowder was poured around it. My daughter who is not a seafood lover said it tasted great. My wife had the escargot and it was very cheesy but delish according to her. For main dishes, my daughter went with crab cakes. I had the filet mignon which came with mac & cheese and asparagus. It was cooked to my liking and tasted great. My wife ended up getting the mongchong special which she enjoyed. We normally go for the strawberry panzini, but given we've cut back on the dietary endulgences for weight and health sake, we passed. No one was ordering it either. It's now $27 and it's meant for 3-4 people even though they say 2. My daughter however, got their coconut dessert as a treat for celebrating straight A's in school. Thank you Nick's! read more

See all

Delicious pupus, wonderful service and beautiful views. Thank you Cyrus and Renaldo for the wonderful aloha. read more

See all

So could be our luck, but we were seated in a booth that had a very musky smell, not only we could smell it the entire time, but it's also overpowered the aroma of food. To make matters worse, when we ordered appetizer with seafood chowder, we found paper inside of it. Waiter said that it must have been a receipt. They took it off the bill, but still isn't the nicer experience to chew paper. Lamb chops were suppose to be medium, but were deff more on the med rare side. Stake with potatoes was good but potatoes and veggies were pretty undercooked. Service was good. I think the kitchen is rushing too much... read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Soup with paper ... - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Great service, food is alright but not great especially for the price. We dined on the patio which was nice. The steaks are okay, Brussels sprouts weren't great. Chocolate macadamia but brownie was excellent. Overall nothing impressive. read more

See all

Dinner was great at Nick's. Gorgeous setting and very friendly staff. I had the macadamia crusted mahi mahi and really enjoyed it. Others in my party had the ahi, heads up that if you want it rare you have to specifically ask for rare. read more

We decided to do a late dinner and the hostess informed us of the wait which we understood because it was about 8:30 and by reservation. But she did indicate the bar seating was open. So we sat at the bar and actually had a great view of the patio. Our bartender Eric took care of us providing outstanding services. He provided recommendations for both entrées and drinks and they did not disappoint! We ordered the half shell oysters with tuna and truffle oil (omg the best I've ever had!!) escargot for appetizers and for the main course the seared ahi tuna. Seared just perfectly!! Highly recommend for couples who don't have reservations to sit at the bar you are able to access the full menu and Eric provides top notch services! read more

See all

The absolute best service ive ever had in my life. Ask for Aundre he was outstanding . They went absolutely way above and beyond for my family we were celebrating my brothers wedding and came here for dinner and i was absolutely stunned from how amazing they were we had my daughter and my sisters daughter fall asleep while we were trying to eat and they made our daughters basically a bassinet out of chairs i honestly wanted to cry ive never had anyone anywhere do something so generous for us i wanted to cry this place is the absolute best restaurant ever read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Our experience began with our seasoned server who grew up in Kona, Chris Lanis. He made some really awesome recommendations and we ordered different entrees and we shared samples with each other in our party of six. I ordered the Opakapaka which was great. Chris recommended the rack of lamb and that was outstanding as well. My wife ordered the filet mignon and it was tender and cooked to perfection. The restaurant wasn't busy due to the sharp reduction in visitors due to the Lahaina fire and the situation is having a negative impact on the businesses on the other side of the island such as Nick's. I encourage people to visit and support this wonderful restaurant. Chris Lanis will take good care of you! We were extremely happy with the ambience, food, and especially the service. read more

See all

I took my extended family to Nick's for a family dinner while on Maui for a work trip. Fantastic service, amazing food, relaxing resort ambiance all made for a memorable family meal. Highly recommend if you're looking to treat your family. read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Surprisingly good dinner at nick's! We were staying at the fairmont this week and had a long day after exploring the road to Hana so decided to grab dinner at the hotel. I typically hate hotel restaurants but we really enjoyed our time here. The oysters with tuna and passion fruit were AMAZING. The tuna sashimi melted in your mouth. We got the mahi mahi and shrimp for mainS - good not great. The bananas foster dessert was incredible. Our server Cyrus was a delight! So friendly and knowledgeable. The views here are great and nice to watch the sunset. Would come back for a low key but nice dinner. Great wine selection too! read more

Incredible location and incredible food! My husband and I got the Mahi Mahi and Maui Wowie salad! *chef's kiss* So fresh and so delicious. Service was great and not rushed. Highly recommend this place! read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Complimentary for our honeymoon. Absolutely delicious! - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Amazing dinners and amazing view. Highly recommend!! Awesome service, good wine and excellent food. read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - View from our table - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I went here for an early dinner with the kids while we stayed at the Fairmont Kei Lani. It was definitely fancier than any other place we went to and the food was the best we had in Maui. Mahi Mahi was really good and kids absolutely inhaled the the pork potstickers with pineapple curry. Service was top notch and the outdoor seating was beautiful overlooking the Fairmont garden. read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Settled on Nick's after searching a lot of places for our last night. I'm from Oregon and eat a lot of quality salmon. I noticed they had salmon on their menu which no one else really offers other than sushi in Maui. I Had to try it. I savored every single bite. It was probably the best salmon plate I've ever had. Combine that with the sunset, the beautiful hotel, excellent service, and it was definitely a meal I'll remember. I will absolutely be back and I'll be thinking about that dish for a long time. read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Beautiful delicious Moroccan Spiced Salmon. Amazing! - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

My family and I had the most fantastic dining experience here last night. The service was outstanding thanks to Justin and the gentleman who always made sure to refill our waters. The lobster was juicy and sweet. I loved the Mac n Cheese side! The Maui Cosmo was very strong, but in an excellent way. We also ordered the NY Ribeye which isn't pictured, but was extremely tender and tasty. Our reservations were for around 6 which was perfect to catch the most incredible sunset. Everyone working at Nick's and in the hotel were extremely kind/hospitable. We will be recommending this spot to everyone. Make your sunset dinner reservations here - you will not be disappointed. FYI - Be sure to drop your car off at valet if you aren't staying at the hotel. They are having construction done at the front entrance, so parking and the walk is a bit far. The valet are incredibly kind and helpful too. read more

See all

Had an outstanding dinner at Nick's Fish Market at the Fairmont Kea Lani. Seating was nice but not great ocean and sunset views- mostly obstructed Food was terrific We had the strawberry beet salad which was small but very tasty The poke bowl had large chunks of tender ahi tuna The mahi-mahi was encrusted with macadamia nuts and served with a coconut sauce that was out of this world The hidden shrimp was very good with 6 very large shrimp that actually tasted like shrimp The macadamia nut brownie with vanilla bean ice cream and caramel sauce was just perfect to top off the evening A nice experience with excellent food read more

Great spot for fancy but unpretentious dinner. Delicious seafood - so fresh. Terrific service. Pricey. Dessert presentation is amazing and not to be missed. However, restrooms are not in the restaurant but rather up a flight of stairs and down a hallway. Not ideal if anyone in your party has mobility issues (or really needs to go!). read more

While staying at the Fairmont in December we decided we'd like to host a dinner for some family and decided on Nicks. We had a party of 9, subject to automatic gratuities and we were treated just that way. Our server was a large gruff character that treated us like an automatic meal ticket and dismissed our family and my kids as if our $1000+ was not the same money as his other tables. We didn't receive the same care or attention as those around us, no pre bus, no proper check backs, no sharing of the menu properly. My eleven year old had to ask for oyster source, proper explanation on dishes and prompt for empty dishes to be pulled. The food was ok, maybe even good, but not great enough to offset the lack of care we received. It wasn't until the bill came that I realized why we were probably treated this way- automatic gratuity. Why provide something you don't have to. I originally thought it was because we were local and maybe didn't appear to have the same money the tourist next to us did, but I really think it was just because we were an automatic $200+ without the work. I love tipping and I love tipping for great service, it's how I made my living and paved my way through my early years but I also am very aware that TIPS are To Insure Proper Service. It is the first time in my life that I didn't add additional money to the gratuity and honestly it was enough of a let down to make me want to speak to management of the hotel. (I didn't because it wasn't appropriate for why I was there -too unwind after a very strenuous community reach out) but I look back on my time in Maui for that visit and the only black spot is Nicks Fish Market. Thank god for the good company, beautiful ambiance, acceptable plating, nice wine and cocktail options or I would've blew my lid. Celebrating a grueling 3 month long venture would've been completely lost if not for the space and the kitchen. read more

By far the best element of this meal was the server, followed by the table (given Covid, it was great to be seated outside and a bit off on the side). The worst part, and it wasn't that bad, was unfortunately the food. The seafood chowder was very meh and lukewarm. The beet salad was good. The tuna crudo was good. The lobster tail was not very good, dry and flavorless. The abalone was a big disappointment. The pasta entree was good. Overall, given the price and the setting we were hoping for an exceptional meal and got an average one in terms of food quality. I'd go again, but stay in the center of the menu (if you get the metaphor), take no risks, and expect a pretty good meal with great service. read more

Right from the start of the evening Chivas (sp?) Was ON point and 5 star. His casual, yet elegant, manner complimented his excellent ability as an ambassador and a server/friend throughout the lovely evening we spent with him. We were staying at the Relais y Chateau Hotel Wailea up the hill, and this young man was equal to THAT lofty level of hospitality. We learned it was a family affair with his big sis as the Maître d'....What a beautiful resort! The torch lighting ceremony with wide-eyed children following the Conch-bearer!!! And the food and beverage were all outstanding! We congratulated ourselves on making such a great dinner selection with a shared XO. Makes me want to stay at the Fairmont for our next Maui getaway! read more

We had the most amazing experience here. I have never tasted such a juicy steak before, and my wife had some lobster that was done to perfection. The service was perfect. The staff attended to us as if we were their most important guests, but I got the feeling that every diner feels that way here. And the sunset in the background was epic! Will come again on our next trip- read more

I will recommend this restaurant to all my friends when they visit Maui! The food is delicious- the seafood tower was perfect to share- and I'm still thinking about the Greek Maui wowie salad...! The gorgeous setting and amazing service are also a standout! Highly recommend!!! read more

I don't know why I'm writing this so late. The last time I ate here was in 2008 and will be back Sept of this year. Can't wait until July so I can make my reservations. I have nothing but the best memories of this restaurant. From ambience, to service and of course the food. I can still taste the amazing steak and root vegetables I has that night. I also tried duplicating the strawberry dessert when we got home but I almost caught my kitchen on fire. We need to leave that to the professionals. HA!!! I'm excited to bring my friends in September! See you soon!!! read more

Perfect evening from the Classic of all classic restaurants. Super staff, great appetizers (Crab cakes and the escargot) were fabulous. Seared scallops cooked to perfection. Great wine by the glass selection too. Mindy had a special prepared vegetarian dish, and we saved room for our 47th anniversary desert... Lived on Oahu for 27 years with many visits to Nicks on Kalakaua Avenue, but so happy to have Nick's here on Maui . You want an awesome sunset on Maui at the infamous Maui Kea Lani hotel... you get both when you dine at Nick's Fish Market..... see you soon. Chef Maka is as good as it gets.... read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - 5-star dining experience at Nick's Fish Market Maui. Happy 47th anniversary Mindy... - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Don't waste your time or money. Terrible service, tasteless food. Ambiance and view is probably the only thing this restaurant has going for it, but you can get that for free from the resort grounds. read more

Nicks has an outstanding view within the fairmont hotel. The service was great and food was well prepared. I took the chance on the scallops being fresh and they were decent. The bananas foster stole the show. Be advised this is still a family hotel so the crowd is loud and obnoxious. read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Pool View - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

I'm not a fish person, but the fam wanted to go so I obliged. I got the filet mignon and it was pretty darn good. The roasted potatoes were good, but a little dry/overcooked Pricing is a little high, but comparable for the locale. Service was good, but honestly a little intrusive. Sometimes checking in to make sure everything is okay can become too much - it felt like every 5 minutes or so the waiter came by. Obviously that's something dumb to complain about, but I'm noting it anyway. I mean, I like god service and the wait staff checking in is great, but every 15 mins is probably better! read more

NICKS FISHMARKET - Filet Mignon - Seafood Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

So glad Nick's reopened in time for my niece's birthday! It's been forever and a day to return, but glad we did! We loved our private table outside! The view, and the setting was awesome! Our entrees were picture perfect and cocktails and wine generously poured everyone savored ever last bite - save for me! I was devastated that I forgot my lobster and fish that I had wrapped! I was so looking forward to a lobster omelette the next morning. It was not the end to a near perfect evening that I would've preferred-no worries-my fault for being senile! Mahalos for a great time!! read more

See all

Highly recommended indeed. Every entree on this menu is just damn right good and different. read more

See all

Always had great food and service in the past, but this time it was off. The Macadamia crusted Mahi was swimming in an overpoweringly sweet sauce with way too much on the plate and it gave everything that sweet flavor (fish, potato and asparagus). When I told the waiter I wasn't happy (Devin), he didn't offer any solution and said it just must be my personal taste. Then, we were celebrating my birthday, which was noted on the original reservation, as well as confirmed at the host stand at check in. Our waiter didn't acknowledge my birthday in any way, which was very disappointing. read more