We usually grab some Nick's about once a month, we always order online and pick up the order, so there's not too much to review. The order is always ready. The staff at the counter is friendly. The prices seem fair for the portions. And the food always tastes great. So far we have tried several types of pizza, the rustics, the mega fries, and mozzarella sticks. May have also had some of the wraps and sandwiches, all were great. read more

Best Gyro I have ever had in this area!!! I know how to eat and drink so believe me and my Bluenose Bella Loves Meatballs!!! read more

The raviolis and meatball special Tuesday nights are so delicious.. plus we've had their beef gyros...wow! Sensational! The tsaiztiki sauce and thick juicy pieces of meat it is truly mouth watering experience! Totally recommend both items! Wonderful friendly service as well! read more

Took over an hour for delivery. Food was cold. I'll take my business elsewhere. Absolutely horrendous.

Ordered a cheesesteak and a pepperoni Panzarotti. The Panzarotti, while an official Tarantini, was overcooked and looked pitiful (sorry, forgot to get a pic). The cheesesteak was ok, but nothing special. Only made a pickup, so I cannot comment on the ambience. I haven't tried the pizza here yet. That'll be next time. read more

We love Nick's. It's our go-to place for great food when we feel like bringing home takeout. However tonight we ordered a Stromboli (of which we had many in the past and we always loved) but tonight we're disappointed that they're now half the size they used to be. With inflation being like it is now, its not surprising that restaurants need to watch their costs. But you really shouldn't skimp on the things that make your restaurant so great. I'd be willing to pay a little more for the great food we've always had from you. Your food is that good that I don't think you need to worry about your pricing. I really feel as though I'm not alone in that sentiment. Or maybe you can offer 2 sizes - the smaller one you have now at the regular price and one that's the former larger size at a slightly higher price. read more

Great staff. The food is good and the service is fast. A clean environment and comfortable.

Great food. Reasonable prices. Plus free pizzas and coupons when you join the vip club.

The pizza is amazing. 2 pies for $20.00 and I drove them to Pleasantville. They were still smoking hot. read more

Nick's Pizza - The pizza is amazing. 2 of these pies were $20.00 and I drove back to Pleasantville and they were still smoking hot. - Pizza Near Me - Northfield, New Jersey

Solid pizza choice, reminds my brother of "Little Caesars". Special automatically applied to my online order - 2 large pies for 20 dollars - was much appreciated. The website even has a pizza tracker which is a great feature. Note that a family member who has an allergy to some unknown preservative had a reaction with this pizza. If you like pizza thats a little processed, but quick and delicious, I recommend. Will order again. read more

This is a very nice place to eat they have a very good menu and the prices are very reasonable for a family of five it wasn't bad at all for us to go out and the food is very good. They have a big selection of food everything is cooked very well staff is very friendly and they have free refills on drinks . Would definitely recommend this place. read more

Nick's Pizza - Ate it and it was good - Pizza Near Me - Northfield, New Jersey

See all

Good food normally. Today was not what we're used to and did not use gloves when preparing my food. Don't normally complain but I'm a culinary manager and not using gloves is so gross. read more

Service matters! With so many different options around the area, it's hard to give any shop 5 stars, but Nick's has figured it out. Good food, awesome service at a good price is the winning combo. The pizza, stromboli, wings, cheese steaks and pastas have all been good. I'm sure you can find a place(s) that does 1 of the items better then Nick's, but it's hard to find consistently good food across the menu with excellent friendly service anywhere around. Service example: before I was ever a customer here, I stopped in to just buy a sub roll for the dinner we made at home. Not only were they willing, but they gave it to me for free. That was memorable, especially when Rose's next door charges you $2 for the same thing or Gaspares charges you $6 to put cheese on some bread. This is now our go to for bi-weekly delivery. Thanks! read more

5 stars for excellent value. The shrimp parm dinner is a steal for the quality of the meal versus the price. A nice salad, pasta, and 6 good size shrimp for 12 bucks. Nice. The margarita pizza was good for the price. I'd go back again. read more

Nick's Pizza - Margharita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northfield, New Jersey

Awesome place to eat! Great customer service from front of the house to the back! Very friendly and personable. Food is amazing and very reasonably priced. Their dinners are huge and very good. Great place to stop in after a busy day to take your family their dinners are amazing. You will thank me! The dinners come with salad and garlic bread. Portions are very large. You can also byob as long as it's done tastefully. The pizza looks so good. Lots of locals eating there. Get the veal parmigiana or shrimp parmigiana! Huge menu even has crab cake sandwiches. The restaurant is beautiful! read more

See all

18 mild wings. They were amazing! I went home craving them. The pizza was also delicious. The dough is nice and soft is feels like bitting into a cloud. I love saucy pizza, and this pizza that they serve here was great, maybe more cheese but highly recommended coming here. read more

Nick's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northfield, New Jersey

Listen, I gotta give you five stars for your food, but, your phone service girl seems to be very dry and forward. While she's taking my order, I feel like she's rushing me off the phone. She has no customer service phone etiquette, this makes me feel like I don't want to call and place an order to your business anymore. read more

This place was so good. Menu gives a great variety to choose from . Prices are great and everyone was friendly . Clean and very nice ! read more

Nick's Pizza - Greek salad with grilled chicken. This was a small ! And I couldn't even eat it all . - Pizza Near Me - Northfield, New Jersey

One of the worst pizza's I've had in a long time ordered it crisspy and the bottom was white in the center liked it was cooked with a plate underneath and the top was almost over cooked plus there was so much cheese I could not pick it up very poor balance between cheese and sauce would not go back read more

Passing by for a soccer game with my family and the Pizza, wings & salad was incredible. Inside was very clean and employees were very nice and warm welcoming. I definitely recommed Nicks Pizza! Great Job guys. read more

Would definitely suggest a re-do of customer service. On average, we place lunch/dinner orders 3 to 5 times weekly. Was so surprised when an already paid for delivery in advance (with receipt marked paid and deferred delivery time) was not only an argument about payment, but was refused to be left after being brought to our front door! Demanded we return the $25 order - seriously? But wait, then returned it with a cold order of Stromboli, because you finally figured it out! Sorry, doesn't work for me! Great delivery person, but counter or manager making these decisions- step up your game.. 5 on your salads 3 on the cold stromboli 0 on customer service read more

I usually get the antipasto salad for lunch ! Made fresh and tastes great! Friendly staff!

Today was the 1st time I ate at Nicks. I picked up hours at my companies nursing home in Linwood. Im from Cape May, NJ and I ordered the Alpine Burger from Nicks and it was so good and the portion size was huge! I couldn't even finish it all. Great job and I will definetly be eating here again if I'm sent back up. I now know why all my co-workers, all nurses btw, told me to go eat here! read more

I ordered a rustic meatball sandwich. The meatballs were pre-made frozen ones. You can always spot those. Very disappointing coming from an Italian restaurant. read more

We love Nicks Pizza. We've been regulars since they opened. We love the pizza and the prices are just right. The staff is very nice and friendly. They also have a reward program which entitles you to free food once your points add up. Can't be that. read more

This food is good but the absolute worst with delivery!!! I can't believe how long it takes I live 8 min away and it takes over a hour for them to deliver a sandwich!!!! I call and they say any minute but still no food! Completely ridiculous read more

Worst pizza ever!!! I'm from South New Jersey, lived near NYC, and in Chicago...I know styles of pizza. First, Nick's pizza had a bad odor out of the box (it stunk). Was it the Sauce? Cheese? Mushrooms? Don't know...something seemed spoiled. Second, dough is a thick blob with little flavor and could not possibly been hand spun; not likely semolina based; and no hint of bubbly Tuscan crust. Lastly, Onions (on half) were either spoiled or were the outer peel and seemed uncooked...they could not be chewed!!! Yuk. NJ is the home of the best pizza. Nick's is a disgrace. Hide your face, Nick. Lazy culinary technique. Yo! Go away!!. read more

Update 7/29/17: Nick's is still great and after trying multiple other items they get all 5 stars. Not only is their pizza great but so are their appetizers and dinners. The square pizza is great and you can't beat the daily specials. I've yet to have a bad meal or experience. read more

Had a great lunch at Nick's pizza. Service was good and the food was great! We had the pepperoni Stromboli and it was very tasty! Will definitely come back. read more

This place is the best!!! Evan and his team are always on top of things. The food is great and so is the service. Excellent food at affordable prices. You must try it here when in town. You will not be disappointed. read more

Been a Nick's Pizza customer for the past few months. Their pizza is excellent. Our family used to own Pizza shops in western Pennsylvania and we are really picky about pizza. Nicks is the best in this area. You have to try it. read more

Decided to eat here after attempting to eat at Little Italy on Tilton Rd. Read that review and you'll find out why we wound up here. We used a coupon we got from Local Flavor app and had a pretty decent dinner for the price. Not too much to choose from on the dinner side but had a lot of pizzas, calzones and subs. Ambience is nice and we got to sit where we wanted. You order at the counter and staff brings your good. It's self serve soda and salt, pepper, cheese etc. my husband ordered the chicken parm and I ordered spaghetti with meatballs. Both dinners came with a salad and garlic bread. All for $20. Food came out piping hot and was pretty average. Next time we will order pizza/subs/calzones because that is what they are known for. read more

Welcome to the neighborhood!!! I was hesitant to try out yet another pizza place but this place did not disappoint. The Rustic Italian sandwich is heavenly. Bacon pizza is delicious. Also their pizza freezes and re-heats well. We had a lot extra and I was surprised how well it re-heated. read more