Family stopped here before we went to Six Flags so we didn't have to pay absurd prices for food in the park and we were not disappointed at Nicky's. Pizza slices were enormous and only $4 and a wrap was only $8-10. You can't beat those prices especially when the food is good. Do yourself a favor and stop here, just remember it is cash only. There is an ATM on site that you can use if you're like me. read more

Nicky's Pizza - Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

I found out that this restaurant is owned by Nicky whose brother Antonio also owns rival Liquori's Pizza up in West Springfield. Their food isn't the best in some cases however it seemed busy when we got here and it started getting quiet once we started eating. The waiter seems nice when giving us orders. The chefs should probably do better on cooking. The wings were not the best as it had kore bone than breast and Fried OREOs had slimy dough that almost looked raw. Their pizza however was really good as well as an Eggplant Parm meal (well cooked). I want to come back here soon but since Liquori's Pizza not far from this restaurant is still my go-to for Mass. Pizza and it's one of my favorite pizzerias to ever eat out, I prefer that pizza over Nicky's. We'll see what happens next year. Nicky's however is somewhat of an improvement from over a decade ago when I last ate here and thought it was kinda unpleasant experience with customer service and their food. Overall, somewhat average place to eat. I hear a lot of people come there to eat before or after they go to Six Flags. read more

See all

Best Pizza in Agawam. YUUUUGE slices at fair prices. The medium size pies are bigger than most other places larges. And the large and party sized? AMAZING! If plan on going anywhere else, "Fuggeta about it". read more

Excellent antipasto! My friend and I split a large antipasto for $11 for lunch. So much delicious meat and cheese, Italian dressing, couldn't be better! Great price, nice people. read more

OKAY, so the five stars wouldn't be about ambiance. But it's about EVERYTHING ELSE that is more important! Give me tablecloths and fine china with moderately good food, and I will RUN to Nicky's Pizza every time, even with their vintage tables and modest decor. It's clean and comfortable enough. So... First of all, the food is incredibly delicious and memorble. The pizza sauce is so amazing I want to go back for all of their pasta dishes. Everything is homemade, and I think they must be hiding an Italian grandmother back there somewhere, cooking up an authentic savory storm. The crust is fabulous, including their cauliflower crust. No pizza in the area even comes close to being this good on quality products (NO CANOLA EVER), taste, and preparation. Second, we tried the homemade clam chowder. Wow. If this is the example of New England chowder, it ROCKS. Third, this place gives family-owned and family-run a good name. Nicky hires his family. Tony, his son, and the spokesperson at the counter, couldn't be friendlier or more efficient. You feel like family even as a customer. He will chat, but his eye is always scanning, making sure every order is perfect. And by the time he introduced me to Giani, Pat, Enzo and problably someone i missed (maybe that grandmother), I was sure it was a happy family. It says something about a man whose relatives want to work with him. We haven't indulged in fried pickles, poutain, fried dough, or much else--but we will. I don't know why, other than the 8 mile drive, I don't go here more, but I will now that I have re-visited and recalled how good it all is--and very affordable! They only deliver in Agawam and Feeding Hills--not Enfield sadly, and they only take cash, so we imagine that is one reason their prices have stayed so low. Try Nicky's Pizza. It's a hands-down winner. read more

I got my usual again today, Gyro, which is always fantastic. Thank you for my very first Whoopie Pie, it was yummy.

Great Pizza and customer service and right next to Six Flags New England. I recommend the family suze Pizza.

Hands-down, the best pie in town you can never go wrong with Nicky's pizza, great food at a great price

ZThe pizza is absolutely delicious here. I like the combo pizza , so if you're in the area give them a try you will enjoy the food. read more

See all

There are only a few food options in this part of Agawam. Friendly service. Mostly a take out place but there is limited seating to eat in. read more

Nicky's makes great pizza. We place an order for a bar/lounge in Agawam every Friday night. Place is usually crowded which means every piece of 2 party size pizzas are gone...quickly. Highly recommend this place. Tuffi read more

Great, small informal family run Italian eatery. Excellent fresh food. Cash only! Pizza with great dough in multiple sizes. Excellent stuffed pasta and soups. read more

Not my all time favorite pizza in town but a good option when you are in a hurry and just want to pop in for 1 giant and inexpensive slice. Staff was also very accommodating. read more

Nicky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

There are a lot of crappy pizza places with tiny slices out there. Nicky's is not one of those places. They offer flavorful pies that will satisfy the pickiest pizza connoisseur. They have large slices available. One slice is a meal. Staff advised us we only needed one! Friendly staff delivered to our table. Nicky does exist. He was in the house. It's not just a name! read more

Never in a million years if you told me I'd find the hands down the best slice of pizza I've had in my life at a random town in Massachusetts after attending six flags theme park, I would've said you're insane... I've been around the world due to my work and ate a lot of pizza. This place nailed every aspect of a good slice. Crisp bottom, seasoned sauce, great meat/veg (I had the combo), crispy crust and great cheese!!!! The slice was GIANT too. Well worth your money and they actually give a damn about the food. Walking into the place it is definitely that local mom and pop feel. You can tell people in the community there know them and love the food too. Felt like a great casual atmosphere and the owner was great and so was the staff. If you're passing through EAT the pizza here, you won't regret it!!! Can't speak for other aspects of the menu but being from another state if I'm ever near this place, I'm coming back no questions asked!!! read more

Nicky's Pizza - Cheese slice and two slices of combo(supreme) pizza - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

This pizza is amazing! Stopped here after Six Flags on our way back to NY. Great find and a go-to for us stop every time! Staff are very nice and we appreciated them making us up some additional pepperoni and fresh mushroom slices at the last minute! Pizza was perfectly crusty and the sauce was delicious! read more

Excellent pizza. I couldn't believe the size of the large. It was enough to feed 7 of us. Absolutely delicious. Customer service was great, everyone was very friendly. We are outside at the picnic table. I would definitely recommend Nicky's! read more

Love the food. Huge menu of every Italian dish you can think of. Delicious.... always a pleasure to go to Nicky's. Great services. Staff always is so pleasant in their greeting. An important and well loved restaurant in Agawam. read more

Always great pizza, nice chewy dough and plenty of toppings. I have been going to Nicky's for quite a few years, always had a good experience. Cash only, but they have an ATM. read more

The food is always well prepared and tasty, having access to Big E food year round is great. Delivery is prompt and courteous

There's only one way to describe this hidden gem of a pizza joint. LEGENDARY. in all seriousness I've been hitting this place up for years, any time we are in the Six Flags area this is a no brainer. The staff is super friendly the pizza sizes and quality are nothing short of unbelievable and I promise you won't be disappointed. I've traveled all over the world, and I love food everywhere and there are some pretty great pizza places but this one is hands down either 1st or second place out of everywhere I've ever tried. It's consistent to boot, I don't know many places that get my five star rating and even fewer that I have loved for the better part of a decade. As far as pizza places go you can't beat Nicky's and if you're in the area and you don't stop in you're nothing short of a fool! read more

Nicky's Pizza - Large medium with olives pepperoni and mushrooms. The large is the size of a small car hood... amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

Why have I not ordered here before? This place is one of the best pizza places in the area. I got the small Hawaiian cheese pizza, a large chicken parm grinder, and a side of fries. The pizza was very cheesy (just the way I like it) and the small was a very generous size. I also like how the crust and bottom wasn't burnt (I don't know why I tend to get burnt ones from local pizza places). The chicken parm grinder was also generously filled with meat and cheese. The crispy side of fries tasted delicious and was still hot by the time we ate it at home. The best part about this place is that it's also inexpensive and quick! I will definitely become a regular here. read more

See all

Pretty decent place to grab a slice, definitely not the worst joint in agawam. I would recommend coming here

A solid option for pizza and grinders. Nicky's has been open for many years now and we have been going sporadically since the early 90s. Consistently good and fresh. read more

The pizza is good here. The best thing to order is the individual slices they are HUGE! always a fun time to go with the kids and see their faces when you hand them the slice! read more

Simply a very good New England Pizza shop. Food is fresh and service is right to the point. Pasta dishes and soups are also good and priced reasonably. Not a ton of ambience, but hey, it's a quintessential New England pizza shop! I'll take quality pizza and good service over a fancy-dancy pizza palace. read more

Legendary. Massive NY style pizza. The party box is great for at least 8 people. If I lived nearby, I'd be fat ;) Well done guys!

Excellen service, food quality was excellent. Delivery wins on time and food was hot. Good job!

went to six flags and wanted something local instead of spending a arm and leg on six flags food. the second we walked in we just knew the food was going to be amazing. i got a single slice of pizza it was $3.50 and oh god it was absolutely amazing. nothing could prepare us for the size of this slice. got the mac bites and salad, it was all delicious and cheap. 10/10 would recommend. definitely will be coming back. read more

We stopped after six flags, very welcoming folks and pizza is good. We ordered 2 large for hungry kiddos some wings! Delicious! Still had leftovers! read more

My first stop at Nicky's was a pleasant one, I ordered a cold Italian Combo with lettuce, tomato vinegar and oil; I was surprised at how quickly it came out. An Italian sub depends on a go sub roll this one was semi soft and tasty as was the variety of sliced Italian deli meats. A half combo was more than enough and at $5.50 a nice value indeed. I felt the quality of ingredients was well above average so I'm eager to return and try one of Nicky's pizzas. read more

Nicky's Pizza - 1/2 Italian Cold Cut Grinder $5.50. Molto molto bene. - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

After a long day at Six Flags you have got to stop by Nicky's pizza! The pizza is HUGE and full of flavor! The pizza crust is perfect! We usually get pepperoni, olive and mushroom! The staff is also super friendly and nice! Just an FYI they only take cash but have an atm read more

Delicious, fresh, NY style pizza. Family owned type of place. Huge slices and the staff were all helpful and polite. There is one large bench for outdoor seating and plenty of places to sit inside. They allowed us to sit outside with our small dog with no issue. read more

This is right on Main St. near MA 57 so if you need a pizza fix before Six Flags New England this is a good idea (and they deliver in town as well). Pizza is done as specified 7 got a good crust so that's good. Curly fries are spot on & same with the grinder I did so that is good. Note on this is this spot if you do this one is cash so no credit/debit cards but this place is worth the money. read more

In my opinion the best pizza place in Agawam . The employee are great & the food is incredible !!!

Great pizza joint in the area! Their grinders are amazing as well. The best part though? Is the price and value! Their pizza sizes are bigger than most places. Especially if you step in for a slice, which trust me is A LOT of food for $3. Mac and cheese bites are really great. Food is always fresh and hot. Because they prepare everything and it takes time, if you're ever in a rush make sure to call ahead. Lastly... please note that if you go into Nicky's, it is cash only. There's an atm and it has a conventional fee. read more

My boyfriend and I were headed to six flags last night and we were hungry and we wanted to find a place to eat that didn't cost an arm and a leg(anywhere at six flags). As we were driving we spotted nickys and decided to pull in and give it a shot. On the outside it looks like a small little side of the road hut, you can tell it has been there a while. We almost walked out but we mutually decided that this was probably gonna be our best bet. And it most definitely was our best decision. We both ordered grinders, his being a steak and cheese and mine being a chicken parm. When we got our grinders, they were huge! And the chicken parm was super cheesey and saucey, while his steak and cheese was also cheesey and loaded with chopped beef. Both of us were amazed at how delicious they were and how well they were made, and for just 20 bucks, how could we possibly complain?!?! My chicken parm was even so big I had to take the other half home! If you are in agawam and need a quick, but hearty, bit to eat, GO TO NICKYS!!! REALLY!! you will not be disappointed! read more

Nicky's Pizza - Their chicken parm! - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

Let's start w cash only, seriously its 2019. Then I ordered a cutlet grinder that they didn't have on the menu, again what Italian, pizza restaurant doesn't have chicken cutlet grinder. After all this I have to pick a drink from a cooler and Pepsi products only. Meanwhile about eight guys are hanging around behind the counter yuking it up. They were nice and polite but not a nice place at all. I then get my grinder and it was made with frozen pre made tenderloins like I buy at Costco. And tomatoes the were mealy and far from fresh. I will say one thing the pizza slices at other tables were big and looked good. As far as my meal, let's just say I wrote all this while sitting on the toilet. read more

I was staying at airport coming back from Rhode Island and dove to Nicky's because the airport pizza sucks based on my past three experiences. I remember coming here a while back before we went to six flags and it was very good so I tried it today. The slices were gigantic and very good, the fries with gravy and cheese curds was so great! Great service, value and best idea for great pizza in the area! See you next time! read more

Like others my family just finished our day at Six Flags and were ready to head home to Maine. My wife wanted pizza and I wasn't interested in the sauce covered overpriced cardboard you get at the amusement park. A quick search of area restaurants and I saw Nicky's with great reviews. Took the wife and 2 young kids (8 and 10), and ordered a couple of large pizzas. The pleasant woman at the counter showed me the size of the large and I was amazed and appreciated her insight as it would have been way more than we would have needed. The small pizzas were as big as a large most places and the kids half and half cheese and pepperoni, the bacon with white sauce for the wife, and my pastrami grinder were superb. While we waited there was a steady stream of customers who were greeted like family and quickly taken care of. I wish we lived closer so I could try more of the menu. Best beleive I'll be back next time I'm in the area! read more