Hey Nicky you so fine, you so fine you blow my mind... Hey Nicky!!! If you venture this town I do reckon you partake a munchy munch in another one of our delightful pizzerias. But I would not claim this to be a diarrhea pizzeria. In fact on occasion Lil' Nicky can be real damnnnn fineeee. Other times? Maybe not. It's like the Bagel Boys of Pizzerias (Check previous reviews.) If you enjoy gambling these are two places for you. - - - Oh baby my blood is ma ma ma moving. "Feel the vibration - 80's Background Dance Music - Feel the vibration..." My body is pulsing. I've got a fever. Awoooooooo. I love a nice gamble. Me or them. I am broke. - - - If you reside in the resident neighborhood, you've just gotta respect Nicky's. This joint is just there. It'll always be there. Everything has came and gone. But not this bad boy. In the corner lot of a failing outlet. This shit survives. Man do I love an underdawg story. They are intertwined into this community. Like that one long black piece of hair in the middle of your bulging bicep, it might not look like the other hairs but it's one in the same and it's gonna be there forever even if you clip it. Insider Infoooooo ------ The More You Know... Great to the local sports teams, they've got a classic Italian menu. They've actually got a few sickkkk speciality slices. The thick dough on the BBQ Chicken Ranch. Marrroneeeeee. And just fucking classic pizza guys behind the counter. What an underrated aspect of a pizza joint. Ya just wanna buy pizza from these dudes. *A bunch of curse words, not gonna use them I'm classy* how can I forget? Great interior photos of old school sports. Man what an atmosphere. I can smell the garlic. Grrrr I'm now in a mood. My current mood: I wasn't expecting to write a review right now, but my hands wanted some game. Nobody wants game from these hands. Physically, or sensually... which is besides the point. I want to fight. I'm bringing a lawn chair and some 12 oz gloves to Nicky's the next 4 sunday mornings. Can't go to church, this is the second best thing. I am ordering 2 plain pies and eating them with the gloves in. Impossible? Oh. Yes. Maybe for a sloppy slug like yourself but I'm made for this. If you want these mitts to cave in your already busted bopper of a chin then just give me the look. I'll put the pizza down. And I will mug you. I will. I will mug you there is no question. This is not a game for me. I will mug you off. I will leave you with no soul. Mugged. Get mugged! And I will go back to attempting to eat pizza in boxing gloves. Which is a harder fight than whatever that little scrooby scrap was. I'm sick of you. This mood was brought to you by Nicky's, this is what Nicky's is about. Meet me on Sunday at your own risk. Support your local businesses in these times. Yes I can be serious for a second. Shut up you roll of bread. read more

I've been ordering personal/small Veggie Combo for many years. Tonight I was told that was not possible, only a large. I said fine. $31.00. But it was just a large soggy cheese pizza smothered w veggies. Not that special crust w/ ricotta, cheddar, etc. I don't think I can freeze 8 remaining slices as they're too soggy Very disappointed read more

So I haven't been to Nicky's in over a decade. I don't see the usual people working there anymore. Anyway, two plain slices for $9.00?!?? The only thing I can say is that they were sized pretty good. Other than that, . The cheese seemed to taste......fake/cheap and overall the pizza had no real flavor and soggy. The dough seemed underbaked. I forced myself to finish the 1st slice and while the 2nd tasted different , I could not finish it. The slices even look different, which leads me to leave that they gave me one from an older batch, but either way both were terrible. I'm sticking to LaGondola in Ramsey NJ read more

It used to be okay, then for a brief moment in 2025 it was great...they started cooking the pies longer. Now, I wouldn't touch it...you're actually better off with a DiGiorno in this instance. A complete disappointment with whatever ownership took over. Save yourself the agony. read more

40 minute wait for 2 pizzas and a salad. They didn't know what we ordered after 40 minutes. They still didn't have it made. The pizza came out looking like something a preschooler would have made. Ridiculous. And tasted worse than frozen supermarket pizza. read more

See all

I'm not a fan of Nickys Pizza. I've tried the cheese and pepperoni pizzas probably 20 times over the past three years due to events and it's never been something I like or enjoy eatung. I don't usually finish the slice. Fast food pizza tastes better for a much cheaper price. The chicken wings are good though. Sometimes they taste a bit stale but 75% of the time it's been good. read more

Nicky's Pizza & Deli - Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Montebello, New York

I've been going to Nicky's on a regular basis since 2017. When I went a few weeks ago, I saw an entire new staff, and was told that the owners were "on vacation". Went again recently and was told that it was sold. Just by being handed BS makes me want to ignore them now. Too much BS everywhere these days, and when a pizza place lowers themselves to that level, I say go somewhere else. The pie was good, but isn't THAT good. read more

Zero stars. Absolutely pathetic. Canned spaghetti sauce, chicken cutlet dry and same quality as fast food. NO Mozzarella cheese for a chicken parm dinner. NONE!! They raised the price for the dinner by three dollars in the last year and it doesnt include salad. This place is worse than bad. It's an actual scam. This was done ON PURPOSE!! Definitely new owners. PLEASE DON'T EAT THERE!! read more

Ordered some food right after long days work. Pizza had a nice crust, crispy and light.Toppings were fresh.The spinach calzone was jam packed with and the sauce had justennoguh acid to break through all that cheese well. The plain cheese calzone didn't fair too well. My husband and son split it and it was just ok. The only issue was after i picked up my order & half way home ,i get a call that a item was not given. At first they asked if i could turn around. Absolutely not, had a crazy day just wanted to be home. They delivered it to my home. Got it about 10 minutes after they called. It was appreciated read more

See all

I tried a selection of sandwiches from Nicky's for an event, and the group was satisfied with the selection. Ordering online was easy, and they have a wide selection of sandwiches. I personally tried one of the Italian Combo cold sandwiches, which was full of quality meats and well dressed. read more

So we recieved a $24 coupon dinner for 4. "Why not", I exclaimed with nervous enthusiasm. We picked up the food that smelled great but, that's as far as it went. I'm not sure what they did to the chicken, but several pieces were inedible, I mean, it was literally like chewing beef jerky. Flavor was fine, bit wow. Pasta was fine and the garlic knots were great. I'm not a fan of there marinara but then again, you cant beat moms now can you. All in all, I wouldn't recommend the $24 meal.. read more

The best!!! Staff is incredibly nice and they beat every Italian place with prices in a big way. The food is delicious. We get family meals and the chicken Marsala was jammed with tender chicken breast. The penne vodka one is great too. They are all good and my family of four gets 3 meals. The salad that comes with is huge.Best pizza place around!!! Chef's kiss! read more

Nicky's used to be the place to go but a recent Chicken parm dinner was possibly the worst I have had. After requesting and getting a replacement order the dish was the same. Chicken was thin, overcooked and mostly inedible. Pasta and knots were good but the chicken parm was not. It is close and convenient but I will drive farther for my next takeout order. read more

inedible. We use Nicky's 3 or times a month. We received 2 meals which were inedible. I'm done

Chicken Parm dinner was pretty bad. Portions were huge though so that's a plus. But it was both overcooked and undercooked. Extremely unappetizing but luckily I'm starving. Just gonna put the undercooked stuff in the oven read more

Past several weeks I have ordered meals for my weekly Rotary Club meetings from Nicky's. The twenty or so members give Nicky's a thumbs up. Pizzas, salads, wraps, trays of meatballs, eggplant parm, sausage & peppers all tasty, hot & delivered on time wrapped very nicely. read more

My husband and I ordered a mushroom pizza and calamari from Nicky's tonight because we have had decent food from them in the past - not so for tonight. Yes, they delivered promptly but that is the only good thing that I have to say about them. The calamari was not crisp or hot and the sauce that came with them was tasteless to the point where I could not eat either. There were canned mushrooms on the pizza, but as if that was not enough, only one half of the pizza had any mushrooms on it. The pizza was pretty tasteless as well, and I had to add a variety of seasonings from my pantry to make it edible. Ricky's is off of our list for pizza! read more

This place has New York's best pizza and Italian food. Yes, it looks like a little hole in the wall, but I cannot recommend it enough. From Italian Combos to the Lasagna, they don't disappoint! Love that they deliver tooo. Great pizza for the money. read more

Just ordered my first chicken parmesan from Nicky. Been in quarantine since March 15. Haven't gone shopping., . I give Nicky a 10+& the young boy a big 10+ also. More than enough food to feed a family of 6. Garlic knots delicious chicken parm awesome, pasta the way I like.Nicky delivery boy was very polite.. again thank you for bringing me some sunshine. Virginia I can't agree with some of you that your not happy with the food. Yes, sauce isn't like what I make. Just be thankful that Nicky delivering and not afraid well I just want everyone to be caring! His delivery boy is young helping us, to bring a smile on your face. Instead of complaining be grateful. God Bless all that help us in this night mare. read more

Usually a 8/10 place. Last night the pizzas were SO full of Oregano, I couldn't eat more than a bite. I ate the crust only. Eggplant parm was good, and always love the fried ravioli. Not sure what happened to the pizza this time around read more

This review is not about the quality of the food or the service. It is the safety of its staff and customers. They have very little safety procedures. None of the staff wear masks. They do not to encourage customers to wear masks or distance themselves from other customers. For that reason it will be a very long time before I purchase their product. read more

I came here for lunch today for the first time. We did not eat the pizza so I can't review that but, it looked really good. I had a hot Veggie wrap and it was delicious. The kids had Turkey Sandwiches and my friend had a salami sandwich. The service was great and the workers were all so friendly. I'm surprised with the negative reviews. This place is kind of hidden so you may not know it is here :) . It is next to 7-11 and all the other places in the shopping center are now gone. Although, it was getting pretty busy when we were leaving. I would definitely stop back when I'm in the area. read more

I come here on my lunch break for some slices when the mood strikes me. Plain slices are huge and delicious! A bit more expensive than NJ slices, but hey they are huge! Had the buffalo chicken slice and wasn't too crazy about it. It seemed like it was lacking something I couldn't put my finger on. Not horrible but not worthy of me trying it again. I tried the ziti slice and fell in love! The dough is thicker than the normal slice. Plus you have the ziti on top. Definitely a best seller there. I got the second to last slice and the next customer quickly grabbed up the final slice. This shows me others like it too. Haven't tried things other than the pizza so I can't comment on that yet. I also like the old school arcade machine. They have a series of classic games on there to chose from. Must note you can't play two player because one of the coin slots is jammed. Oh well. So all in all this place ain't too shabby. I'll update after I try a few more things off the menu. read more

Nicky's Pizza & Deli - plain and ziti slice - Pizza Near Me - Montebello, New York

The pizza is fine but, ugh, they started adding a 4 percent service fee to credit card purchases. This will definitely reduce the frequency with with we will patronize Nicky's. read more

I was a big fan of Nicky's and it has been my go to delivery place since I moved here in 2000. I am fairly sure this is under new management at least in the last few years. It has gone down hill bad. Even worse the prices have gone sky high. We used to love the wings here but have had some recent bouts of stomach pains after eating them. They have also been overcooked and over fried till dry. Ordered a Chicken Parm, Slice of Sausage, Wings and a plain salad and it came to 40 dollars! The pies are not bad but the slices just sit all day and are disgusting. The prices are higher than others in the area. Even the salad was borderline disgusting. Ironically, I would prefer the pizza at Dominos any day to what we have been getting at Nicky's lately. I'd love to see them succeed and pull this place from the abyss but they need to cut their prices and improve the quality, freshness and cleanliness of their food and establishment. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. We ordered a large order of food and every single person was left disappointed by their meal. Their sauce literally has no taste. And that's not an exaggeration. We ordered a large salad and got a small and when we called back and asked for a large they rudely said "no I'll bring another small one". So on top of their well below average food they have well below average customer service. Bottom line: go somewhere else for Italian food. read more

Great pizza and quick service. Large and cheesy pizzas. Also workers are extremely nice.

Giving three stars only because I didn't try the food. They have a display case for the pizza, but they keep their pizza on a rack by the back door so you can't see the pizza or what the choices are so you have to ask. If I'm ordering a slice of pizza that's going to be reheated I need to see what it looks like. I went in around 7ishy, it is kinda late, but the pizza places down the road still had theirs in the case. Not sure if I'm willing to go back to try the actual food. I'm sure I'm not the only one who's weirded out by pizza being kept on a rack by the back door. read more

Great food as long as theyre not busy. When they're busy the food is considerably worse, under cooked pizza and mistaken orders.

very bad, I hate it, uneatable food. from 1 to 10. I give them 0. I ordered chicken parm and they send me Beef patties with out parmesan chesse read more

I think they changed their sauce this year, it's just not good anymore. Nicky's used to be our go to Pizza place, but no one in my family likes it anymore, it's actually really, really bad. read more

Great neighborhood gem. They are very friendly in a NY way. Deliveries are fast, food is hot. Variety of items available from the take out and delivery menu. This neighborhood pizza joint is my go to when I'm disparate for a great pepperoni slice. Their Sicilian slices are so good I usually order a whole pie. This truly is the best pizza parlor in town. read more

I've heard many mixed reviews about Nicky's so I figured I'd give them a shot. Well, much to my disappointment it was disgusting! Walking in to Nicky's I was hit with crumbs and dirt and used napkins in the floor- it just felt dirty, grimy, and run down and grossed me out from the start. The workers were rude and acted like I was bothering them from texting or their private conversations. Their pizza smelled good on the way home and was excited to have it! Unfortunately, that was the only good part. The crust had flour or something all over the bottom of it and their cheese wasn't that good old-fashioned chewy cheese. I was so disappointed and turned off by the poor customer service that I will not be going back. I'll go to other pizzerias in the area. read more

I have been disappointed the last 2 times I ordered sandwiches. I ordered a wrap and a couple of the ingredients listed on the menu, were not in the wrap. Next time I ordered a sandwich. The description said it had Swiss cheese. My sandwich had Swiss AND American ( the Kraft singles kind). The American cheese had melted over the sandwich and it tastes really gross! read more

Nicky's Pizza & Deli - Melted processed American cheese on a sandwich... The cheese ruins the sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Montebello, New York

I regularly go for their pizzas. This time I tried their meatball park in a hero and it was delicious. Tries garlic knots and plain cheese pizza. The knots were not even properly cooked. When I called the guy in the phone was most rude. Never going there ever again. read more

I am surprised by some of the reviews for Nicky's. I've been going here for years and have never had bad food from here. I'll admit that the people that work here are a bit strange and seem like they hate their jobs, but I've never had any problems with them either. The guys they have working here now are a lot friendlier than the guys they use to have working there a few years ago. Like I said, I've never had a bad thing here. The slices are pretty big and you get what you pay for. For pizza, they have hands down the best Buffalo Chicken and Chicken Parmesan slices I've ever had. They are perfect. The Buffalo slice has a ton of chicken on it and just enough spice to not be overwhelming. It goes perfect with blue cheese on the side. The Chicken Parmesan slice also has a lot of chicken on it, but I love the sauce and the dollops of ricotta and red sauce they spot all along the pie. Other worthy slices to try are the Penne Ala Vodka slice and their stuffed slices (once again, I love the Buffalo Chicken one.) Nicky's pizza crust is different from other pizza parlors I've been to. It's hard to describe, but I guess you could say it's got a slight buttery flavor to it. It's just a hint of taste and it makes the pizza taste that much better. I don't know if anyone else actually notices that, but it's kept me coming back for a long time. Another interesting pie to try at Nicky's is the Chicago Deep Dish pie. It's a little expensive, but that is one huge pizza. Not many places around here offer Chicago style pizza so as soon as i saw it, I jumped in and bought it and I didn't regret it. I'll usually do half plain and half mushroom with extra tomato sauce. Like the Chicago Deep Dish pie, they also do stuffed pizza's with whatever toppings you want in. I believe it's about $26, but that too is a giant pizza and extremely heavy. Last time I got it, they couldn't close the lid. For the most part though, I usually stick to my beloved Buffalo Chicken and Chicken Parmesan pies, they are the best! They offer pan pizza which makes the crust a little thicker and that is especially good with the Penne Ala Vodka pie. A side from Pizza, they have your typical Italian fare like pasta dishes and they branch off with burgers, fries and of course hero sandwiches. My wife loves their Italian Hero. The sandwiches are really big and they don't go cheap on the cold cuts like so many pizza parlors who put a few slices of each cold cut and call it a day. These sandwiches are big and they earn their Hero Shop title in their name. Do yourself a favor and pick up a specialty pie of any kind, especially a Buffalo Chicken or Chicken Parmesan pie. You won't be disappointed! read more

I've tried various pizza places in the area, and Nicky's is the best I've had. The place is kind of a dive, but I just pick up or have it delivered. They have lots of different kinds of pizzas, and I've liked them all. Mind you--this isn't fancy pizza, this is local take-out. I've gotten their other stuff and it's all sort of standard pizza-place Italian food. The heroes weren't that great, but everything else has been fine. It is kind of pricey for what it is, and I've used coupons only to figure out they didn't add them into the final cost. read more

I used to go to this place frequently, but my most recent visit was my last. There were no customers when I walked in to grab some slices to go. One employee was looking toward me, so I said hello, and he completely ignored me because his focus was gazed up at the TV screen above me. It took almost a full minute for someone to ask me what I needed. Later, as I was waiting for my pizza, a loud and obnoxious employee was ranting about something, dropping a lot of "f bombs" in almost every sentence. The food has also considerably taken a downward spiral and everything tastes bland, but even worse are the disrespectful employees. Lucky for me, there are many other places to get pizza, with a friendlier staff, tastier food, and better prices. Nicky's, you've disappointed me. read more

Food used to be good. I stopped in last week at around 9:15 PM. I got four slices of pizza, two with mushrooms and two plain to go. I don't live far and when I got home and took the first bite it was like burnt cardboard, had to have been sitting out for hours and re-heated. The crust was so hard you could not bite into it. The joke was that I was charged close to twelve dollars. Well the joke was on them as they lost a good customer. Do they really think people will come back when they serve bad food. read more

If you attend or have ever attended Ramapo College, chances are you have eaten Nicky's Pizza at a club meeting or other school event. In that case, you also already know how bad the pizza is. As a freshman, I went to club meetings because I was enticed by the idea of free pizza, which is exactly what it's supposed to do. However, I quickly realized that every single club meeting I attended ordered pizza from the exact same pizzeria, because of how bland and bad tasting it was. It's hard to call a pizza 'bad' because even bad pizza is tolerable to eat, but Nicky's Pizza really is terrible. The school doesn't trust each individual club and organization with the money allocated to it, so all purchases, including food, must get approval. They essentially have an "vendor" agreement with Nicky's. A club orders pizza or whatever else is on their menu through the pre-approved "vendor", it gets delivered, and the school reimburses them later, in a lump sum I assume. If you want food from somewhere else, you are stuck paying for it yourself, which is not usually feasible for college students. Literally the only reason anyone eats this pizza is because it's free. If it wasn't for all the business they get from the College, Nicky's Pizza would have been out of business a long time ago. I don't eat the pizza anymore at any of the meetings I attend, despite it being free, after I got sick eating it last time. Regardless of that, I wouldn't want to eat it anyway. read more