Just passing through and wanted something quick. Ordered on the way into town. Nico's is nestled in corner of party store. Was able to pick up a cold adult beverage to enjoy with it. Restroom was clean. Staff were friendly. Food was ready when we arrived. Hubby said grilled chicken salad was big, jalapeños delicious. My small chicken bacon ranch grinder was the perfect size for me, still very warm and yummy. Bread was perfectly crispy. And the baked pieces of melted cheese were awesome!! Ty! read more

We vacation in Kalkaska and have NEVER had a bad experience with Nico's, whether we pick up or get delivery. My New Year resolution is to leave more reviews so after our lunch today, I figured it was time to share our love of Nico's food. Delivery was so fast today and I'm grateful because I put my order in later for lunch than I should have. (But last time we ordered from a local competitor it took forever, so thanks Nico's!) We normally get pizza, but today I ordered a 16" chicken club grinder and pepperoni sticks for me and my kids to split. The grinder was delicious! We even ate the crusted melted cheese pieces and extra chicken chunks that were leftover in the box. The pepperoni sticks were also great! They weren't quite what I was expecting- more like hollowed out pizza crust with pepperoni slices loose inside and plenty of Parmesan cheese sprinkled all over it, rather than pepperoni- and cheese- stuffed breadsticks, but still very tasty! Sooo good! Thank you, Nico's! We'll definitely order again! read more

Nico's Pizza & Grinders - Pepperoni sticks and chicken club grinder! Delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Kalkaska, Michigan

Our food was superb!! Full sandwich! Gal on phone and delivery gal were extremely friendly!!! Worth the wait!!!! I don't order often. But I'm never disappointed!! read more

Ordered a large pepperoni pie. Was waiting for me when I got there. A little on the greasy sude, but what's a pizza without a little grease. Good solid pizza pie! read more

Yum! Servers were kind. Fast service, great Monday specials but one,get one. Great crust!

Thin n crispy... flimsy and burnt. Don't get it, it's very greasy. My mom said thin n crispy...it's nothing. Get pan tossed or nothing.

Stopped here for beer and needed a quick bite. Quick and was better than expected. Seems like I've been here a while and is popular for locals. read more

Pizza was great! No masks in sight during COVID though. We had to pop the pizza in the oven once home to be safe. Loved the crust!

How the heck do you forget the meat and v cheese on an antipasto salad. And when you call it's just "oops, she forgot".

the workers are shitty and they where being rude and saying there busy but there is no ones in there and there food is so ter

We were out of their delivery range, so they agreed to meet us at the very edge of their delivery zone. Pizza was great, service was better. Jordan delivered our pizza, she was fantastic! read more

I haven't been to Nico's in years! When they use to deliver, I ordered 2 subs from them to be delivered. I was very specific about what was wanted. They arrived 45 minutes later & the subs weren't even close to being right (suppose to be 1 club & 1 Italian). We received a philly & ham with cheese. They sent a driver back to my house with the correct subs & wanted to charge me again! After I refused the driver called his manager & she said no charge but wanted back the old subs. I showed the driver the subs were sitting in the trash. He's still on the phone telling the manager this who told him to still get them or else we don't get the correct subs. I had to dig in my trash to get all the sub pieces so he could return with them so I could get the right subs to feed my family!! I will never order from Nico's because of how that manager handled the situation, even with her own driver confirming the wrong subs scattered in the trash this manager was somehow fearful that we'd do something with them?? I felt bad for the driver & still gave him a small tip, but never ever again will this house eat Nico's! read more

Stopped at the Citgo once for gas on my way to Bellaire. The smell from Nico's was amazing, even though I wasn't hungry. The next trip down 131 I decided to stop. My husband and each got a grinder, which was delicious and full, and I think what Quiznos wishes it was. I got some Nico's bread nuggets for my 3 year old. It was a huge order, and the tastiest (and unhealthy) hunks of pizza crust ever. I confess, I ate more than half of them. I guess I know where I'm making my pit stop on my trips up north from now on. read more

I've never been disappointed but my favorite is the Bbq Chicken Pizza with extra bbq sauce! Every time I order I get what I ordered with friendly service! Thanks Nico's! read more

The employee made my grinder in a very unhygienic way. After taking my payment at the cash register and then taking a call on his cell phone, he proceeded to make my grinder without first washing his hands. After a minute he put on gloves almost like an after thought. Then when I came out of the bathroom a couple minutes later, he was no longer wearing the gloves but was still handling the grinder. I ended up going to G's Pizzeria next store instead - I couldn't bring myself to eat the grinder, having no idea how clean his hands may / may not have been. read more

Pizza's are pretty standard fare, but the best bread nuggets(sticks) I have had! Would recommend.

Friendly staff, good prices, good food. The original grinder & the Stromboli was yummy.

I was pretty disappointed when I walked in to order food at 9:45 only to find that they wouldn't take any more orders for the night - open sign on, sign clearly stated they were open til ten. Cashier was counting her cash at the time. Bummer. read more

I've had a variety of Nico's pizzas and grinders as well as their normal and cinnamon bread nuggets--they are all delicious! There is a wide range of toppings and grinders to choose from, and I always eat more than I should of whatever I get! Very worth the stop. read more

Pizza tastes good, but they are skimpy with the toppings and will charge for 2 toppings when you order half and half. Ordered 1/2 mushroom 1/2 pepperoni, paid $2 extra (the menu lists $1.79 per topping...) and if there was 1 whole mushroom used on the pizza I'd be surprised. There were barely 2 bits per slice. Way to Cheap out, Nicos! When I complained to the guy that was supposed to be the owner, he did nothing at all about it. (I ordered from the Boyne Falls location, which isn't listed here). read more

My 2nd favorite place in town to get pizza and subs. Great pizza and fast delivery. Way better then G's