This place is great! I've only ever ordered takeout or catering, so nothing will be based on a dine-in experience. For dinners, like eggplant, chicken parm, etc., this is basically the only place we'll order from. The food is always fantastic and you're guaranteed to have leftovers. They have a user-friendly, online ordering site that I highly recommend. We've ordered catering from them 3 or 4 times now and the experience is always seamless and the prices are reasonable. Guests ask where we got the food from every time. Picking up your order whether catered or just for the family is always very convenient and quick. Lastly, the staff is super-friendly. I don't think I've ever walked in without multiple people greeting me as I approach the counter. Nonna's gets my highest recommendation. read more

Food is tasty. Many creative pizza options. They have lunch specials which helps you spread your dollars further. It's a family owned business. Sit down service could be hit or miss at lunchtime since the waitress also is working the front take-out counter and register at the same time. I will be back. read more

Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe - Party Room May 2025 - Italian Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Went there once never again. Got two slices and the cheese they use on the pizza was garbage of low quality. I'm Italian so I know good pizza. Thanks, but no thanks. read more

Recently ordered dinner for my family however we received the wrong order. When we called they were rude and not helpful at all. We were planning on ordering a big order for a surprise party but sadly no longer thanks to their rudeness and unprofessionalism. read more

Delivered great salads and pizza to good sam hospital! Always delicious and enjoyed by all!

We have been sleeping on Nonna Bella's. Why?! I don't know, but mi dispiace Nonna! What a great place. We placed a scheduled delivery order a day in advance for a small birthday party at our house. We weren't sure what to expect but saw the reviews were really positive. We ordered two grandma pies and two regular and a half tray of eggplant parm. The delivery driver was super friendly - and arrived promptly at the scheduled time. We were super surprised to see them throw in 2 dozen garlic knots and a container of sauce. Score! Who doesn't love knots and sauce?! I will send you on a search to see if such a person does exist (spoiler alert: they don't). Everyone loved the food, it was fresh, tasty and everyone was full and happy. We would absolutely order from here again and if you're looking to shake up your regulator pizza joint I'd urge you to consider Nonna Bella's. Mangia Bene! Thanks Nonna's! read more

Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe - Half test of eggplant parm (sorry we started eating from it prior to the picture lol) - Italian Near Me - North Babylon, New York

I finally had the Chicken Francese slice yesterday and it is worth the hype. I highly recommend the following... chicken francese, marsala, parm, cesar, fig slices. The counter ladies are very sweet too. read more

Had a delish chicken parm slice! Flavors were great and not overwhelming. The slice had a good balance of chicken, sauce and cheese. If this how their chicken parm SLICE is, their chicken parm meal must be delish! I will definitely return to find out. Service was super friendly and welcoming. As I was waiting numerous staff behind the counter asked if I was being helped. I would definitely return. read more

Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Good pizza with breadcrumbs baked into the crust. Will definitely go back to try some other tasty treats.

Plastic in my calzone. I bit into my calzone and found a thin piece of cooked, half melted plastic from the inside of a ricotta cheese container or something. Like the inner seal thing. Actually bit into this. Was offered half hearted apology and a "what do you want me to do?" Maybe it's wrong to post this. I dunno. But I just feel like they really don't care when they mess up. And my kids could have choked on this. Thank goodness it was for me. Soup was bad also. read more

Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe - A calzone with nasty plastic cooked into it - Italian Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

Their staff is all extremely friendly. The food is great! Their take home pizza kit is very affordable and perfect to cook pizza at home.

The dough isn't that great, but the cheese makes up for it. There's just no real amazing pizza places out here in NY anymore it's sad. The price for a slice here is insane... this is LI not Manhattan read more

More types of pizza (by the slice) than I'd ever seen anywhere. I love their eggplant, my friend is fond of chicken. We've gotten slices there several times with different toppings & have never been disappointed. It's always busy (for good reason). read more

Love this place. There is lots of selection, including some slices I don't really see elsewhere, staff is always friendly and welcoming. Prices are reasonable too. They have lots of promotions and deals too, which keep making me come back anyway! I appreciate you can eat outside too. Overall, what more could you ask? read more

This recent pickup at Noona's was less than good. It seemed we got a reheated hours old pizza, ultra dried out and overly crisp. The operation has changed since we first started going there. read more

Great food, amazing service and very nice private dining room. Went here for private event and they were very accommodating. Would go back

Great pizza, delivery people are so friendly, great food will and have been goind back

My scallops and shrimp were over cooked. The fried calamari was very cold. I told them I wanted the risotto but got pasta. I know they were really busy so I kinda understand. Usually the food is top notch read more

Delicious pizza!!!macarroni and cheese!! Granmapizza And you won't believe it (but not me ) Hawaii pizza Amazing read more

Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - North Babylon, New York

I have been ordering for years from here. I don't know what is going on but it has been horrible lately. I ordered delivery and the pizzas have been coming cold for the last four deliveries. I ordered delivery this week and received a burnt inedible pizza. read more

They seem to have more varieties of pizzas than any other pizza restaurant I'd ever seen! It's always hard to decide which slices to buy. Their crust is scrumptious, very chewy & well baked. They also have a lot of staff & there's never a wait (except to have our slices heated, of course). Wonderful, friendly service. read more

Our to go pizza place Never disappoints Service is great !! Order ahead, they're always busy Wednesday's is Pizza special !! (lol) read more

See all

Oh wow! What a terrific taste treat! If you're looking for authentic New York pizza right in the heart of Suffolk County, this is the place to go. The sauce is tangy and the cheese is delightfully chewy. But the real hero here is an excellent crunchy crust. So crunchy you might get a headache from listening to yourself chew. The regular is better than the Sicilian, but they're both great. Truly tastes like your grandmother's recipe. read more

For a small family gathering we order for a 3pm delivery if Salads, Pastas, Heroes and Pizza. The food promptly arrived at 3pm. The food was amazing. The salads were fresh amd did not arrive wilted. The Heroes were pretty big and overstuffed. They toast tje bread which is always a nice touch. They packed in a box instead of wrapping it or putting in a plastic clam which alway steams the bread and makes it soft. The bread stayed nice and toasted in the box. The Pizza were pretty good and one of the best in the area. Great crust and sauce. The pastas were good too. If you order over $55 you can get something for free and we chose the Grandma pie. This place is legit. read more

See all

Ordered the 59.99 dinner special,because we were having company.It included a choice that I made of chicken cutlet parm,penne ala vodka and a ceaser salad.It also included a large pie,garlic knots and a 2 liter bottle of soda.I also added to my order a grandma pie.I was thinking that this was enough to feed my party of 6.WRONGGGGGGG........ who was I kidding?I ordered early asking for a 5:45pm delivery.Well the pizza must have been made then,when I ordered,was more than overcooked,it was crunchy.The serving size of the chicken parm would have fed two toddlers and the same for the penne and salad. The amounts were so little that I actually had to order another pizza,of course not from Nonna Bella.I usually order the dinner special from Salpinos for 45.00,but because it was late in the day I couldn't.Lesson learned,I spent $100.00 dollars,which included a $10.00 tip,also another $20.00 for the extra pizza.Needless to say I will not be doing this again,so buyer beware.I will also go back to my regular pizza place MANGIA PIZZA...... , read more

The food and choices are out of this world! Tha staff is warm, friendly, welcoming and cheerful. I have NEVER been disappointed by any purchase at Nonna Bella's. I travel about 10 miles for the best people and food. MOLTO BENE!!!! Love Nonna Bella's! read more

we order a large pizza extra cheese pizza it was cold it taste like it has been sitting there and far as extra cheese there was no way that they put extra cheese on it, and the crust was so hard. It was awful. read more

Hands down one of the best spots on the island to get a pie. I highly recommend the hot honey grandma pie...never disappoints!

Never again with Nonna Bella's. It was our pizza Friday and we've been giving business to all our local pizzerias. This was our first and last time with NBPC. We ordered one regular pie and two white slices. We both felt sick after eating. Today we tried leftovers and immediately regretted the decision. I don't know what's up. Pizza tasted fine, good, nothing spectacular. Wonder if anyone else suffered the same consequences after ordering last night. Update: changing my review to one star. Myself, my wife and my daughter remain under the weather 36 hours later and the only thing we all are together was this pizza. read more

says they close @10pm, but staff saw us walking towards door at 9:40pm and proceeded to lock the door on us. great customer service. read more

Nonna Bella's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - North Babylon, New York

No margarita pizza on a Friday during lent at 11:30 at a pizzeria. Was skeptical when cheese sizzled when they heated up my slice. Taste was not great, read more

Excellent food and excellent staff- always! We have never had a bad experience. It's our office's " go to " spot for lunch!

My family and I have been regular customers of Nonna Bella's for almost a decade at this point, and will continue to be. Their regular pie is the best in the area consistently. The crust is thin, perfect crunch, no flop, and they use sesame seeds which I've always loved on a pizza. Their grandma pie is perfect as is. Plus, their weeknight pasta & entree specials are phenomenal. Would recommend anyone to go here at least once if you're in the area. read more

The best for a plain pie. Classic NY-style slice. Flavorful, thin, nice light crust that gives under the weight of the cheese but stays crispy on the bottom. Don't bother with the specialty slices here - the plain pie is one of the best around. read more

The reason I call back is the efficient manner the Justine handles phone orders The pizza is above board delicious but to have a worker handle a busy phone like Justine makes ordering a plus plus read more

I've lived here for 3 1/2 years and this place has been our go to. My family loved to order a fresh pie whenever they came to visit. However, the past few months the food has been mediocre. Tonight we ordered a pie and it was thin, over cooked and had those burnt bubbles all over the pizza. The chicken fingers were pretty good. My son is usually easy to please when it comes to pizza but he even refused to eat tonight. Last month same problem, that time we called back immediately and they returned with a new fresh pie that was delicious but i shouldn't have to do that every time. I cut my loses tonight and let him eat anything he wanted to. So breakfast for dinner is was tonight. The customer service is always great but the food quality has gone down. read more

This pizza is always so good! I always get a plain slice, the crust is so thin and crispy the way pizza is supposed to be. Try the chicken parm egg rolls those are great too. read more

Pizza was solid 7 1/2 / 8.Crunchy and tasteful.May have rubbed extra grease on my asshole because it was warm and enjoyable. My girlfriends dog didn't run away this time. Got the lick down of the century. read more

The quality of their food has gone down dramatically in the past several months. I ordered a pizza yesterday and it was comparable to dominoes. This used to be our go to pizza place but I give that a second thought now when I'm ordering takeout. I've spoken to the manager in the past about their food quality and not much has changed. Portions as well as taste are lacking. read more

Update, so yeah we kept our promise to eat in. Friendly staff and clean place - nothing fancy though. I heart my regular slice. Thin, crisp, cheesy and balanced sauce. This time though hubby wanted his slice a bit more well done. read more