Ordered a chicken parm hero which was sloppy but good. Rice ball was terrible. Probably won't try again.

$70 worth of pizza is getting thrown out. What a shame. Disappointing at best. We ordered a well-done trifecta pie, but it arrived soggy and flavorless. I heard it was a local favorite. Won't be ordering from here again. read more

Good good food and great friendly service. I've gotten to the point where they even remember my name when I walk in.

This was great until new ownership a couple of months ago. Pizza quality went down hill. Such a shame. My last straw was when I asked for Parmesan cheese shaker and they handed me a couple of packets of pre-packaged cheese. Got in the car out the cheese on the slices and took one bite and threw it in the garbage. How does a Pizzeria on Long Island hand out pre-packaged Parmesan cheese. Plenty of options in the area that are not trying to save a few bucks on Parmesan cheese. I can only imagine what other cost cutting ideas they have taken as far as food quality goes. read more

DELICIOUS! Unique pizza options. My new Long Island favorite. Doesn't work for my WW program but hey while on vacation the calories don't count! Yum! read more

See all

ordered online to pick up in store wanted to pay cash but when I got there, it was three dollars more in store when I wanted to pay cash. There's a point is do not eat here if you want to be ripped off and if you do want to eat here, make sure you pay online because you pay more in the store and they're ripping customers off. read more

***ZERO STARS*** Pizza is nothing special. $5 for a plain cheese slice!!! Highway robbery. Never again. I am so done with this place. read more

Used to be our favorite spot. Wings are different even gave them another try after I was told recipe didn't change. Pizza shrunk and is much smaller. Very disappointed. read more

One of our favorite local spots! The pizza is always fresh and tastes great. Staff is welcoming and accommodating to special requests as well. Our first time here, we were not aware of the time changes at night. They offered to get together a pizza for us at a discount as we were heading to the door to leave. Was a very nice surprise! read more

Crispinos Pizzeria - Eggplant Rolatini - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

See all

Got a delivery order today and was very unhappy. Angel Hair Pasta was stuck together, shrimp scampi consisted of 5 very small pieces of shrimp that were over-cooked and had no flavor. $ 10.00 for a serving of Garlic Bread with Cheese. Over bill came to $ 96.00 for 3 people. I don't mind paying that much for good food, but this was not worth it at all. Most of it went in the garbage. Crispinos's recently changed ownership and the place has gone downhill ever since. read more

Pizza is delicious! Has a great crisp to it. I usually get a cheese, pepperoni or a Buffalo pizza. All have been satisfying.

Got a buffalo slice from here probably the greasiest slice of pizza I've ever had also wayyyyyy to much ranch or blue cheese what ever it is completely covers the taste of the buffalo sauce. And the chicken is fat gross chunks of chicken most people make chicken cutlets and chop them up and put it on top. Tasted like boiled chicken. Awful won't go back. read more

I LOVE their Margherita pie. Best I've ever had. It just sucks they're all the way in West Islip. Wish they opened a location closer to the port jeff / stony brook area but it's totally worth the half hour/45 min drive. Never a tattoo appointment WITHOUT a pie from Crispinos. read more

Crispinos Pizzeria - a pizza with cheese and herbs - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

This place is the best in the area by far. Try the vodka grandma pie it's amazing. The margarita, salad slice, and Crispinos slice are also phenomenal. I come here often, and I grew up in Brooklyn next to the best pizza places. I will say I have yet to be impressed with a simple regular pie in Long Island so I stick to the specialty slices. I wasn't feeling pizza one weekend when our friends were ordering so I tried the pasta with broccoli. It's very good! I don't order pasta from pizza places, but this was delicious. Not too much oil at all. Very tasty and good amount of broccoli in the dish. read more

Pizza is mediocre at best on a good day but they are local. Advertised a 40 minute wait for delivery. Almost 2 hours later I'm still waiting for my pizza to show up. Shop is unapologetic about it and offered nothing to rectify the situation. There are 10 equally mediocre pizza shops within 1 mile of this place. Go there instead. read more

They have a good variety of pizza and very good garlic knots. The vodka slice is amazing and my daughter loves their Mac and cheese slice. Their pizza is delicious, it has a good tasting sauce. read more

Literally the best everything!!!! Real deal authentic pizza hot foods salads etc. the sauces are ridiculous and the Cesar dressing is amazing. read more

Too expensive ($26 for 4 slices) and bad atmosphere. Employees treat you like you're bothering them. The manager yelled at a delivery driver in front of the whole restaurant because of a customer complaint and forced the employee to pay for it. read more

Ordered last night... fast delivery.... Followed instructions !.....BEST GRANDMA PIE!!

The food sucks and the employees are not friendly!!! Don't eat there!!! It would be a waste of your money!!

Had a bunch of great food from Crispinos tonight, meatball hero, chicken parm hero, and some specialty slices. Been going here for a few months and it's always delicious. Definitely a great selection of specialty pies and their employees are very nice. Clean spot, a few tables to sit at, they deliver, and I met the owner tonight, very nice guy. Worth stopping by if you're in the area. Pictured: Chipotle Chicken Slice, Spinach and Mozz Slice, Vodka slice. read more

Unfortunately, I used to like Crispinos. But with the lack of care and cleanliness, I found hair in my food, not once but twice.

the service in this restaurant is disgraceful. the manager in the front is beyond rude, and the food is simply not good enough to ignore the incompetence in this god forsaken store. AVOID!!! read more

We have been going to Crispino's for a few months now, and we love the food. Tonight my husband asked for an off menu hero, chicken cutlet with broccoli rabe, crushed red pepper and fresh mozzarella on a hero. He said it was absolutely delicious. I had an eggplant hero with the pizza sauce, which I absolutely love. We HIGHLY recommend this restaurant!! Love it.. read more

...Anddd I randomly found one of my favorite places. I've hated so many places on Long Island that sell pizza. Why did I have to find this place right before I moved?! (I still order from here whenever I visit!) if you're looking for some Real pizza, check this spot out. I usually get a round pie but this grandma pie was amazing too! Sauce is great, crusts are perfect. read more

Crispinos Pizzeria - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

Great food, great deals! Friendly staff as well :) 9/10 The pasta is great as well! Meatballs cooked great, would totally recommend for a good lunch! read more

Great pizza. Great service. Try the Brooklyn slice. It's out of this world. All of the specialty pies look outstanding. If you're ever in the area give this place a try. read more

Crispinos in West Islip- Higbie Lane just south of Union Blvd/John St. This place has, by far, the best pizza on Long Island!! Their Mac & cheese pizza was so damn good, I dreamed about it! Then I went back a few days later to get another slice. The capellini cakes (angel hair, cheese, ham, & peas in a crisp breaded, burger-sized "cake"((think crab cake)) are equally delicious-! But the most important part of a pizza is its crust, and that is what makes Crispinos the best in my book! Crisp, thick-crust pizzas that don't get soggy even when taken a 20 minute drive home read more

Crispinos Pizzeria - Took this from my car. Best pizza around!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

This place is really good. I don't know how I never knew about it living in west Islip. My boyfriend and I crushed a pie in record timing.

Finally after 25+ years found a pizza pie that tastes as good as it did in the late seventies....and they actually season their pie with oregano! Unheard of in every pizzeria on Long Island...was actually getting charged extra to add it read more

So just looked up something different besides Gino's and man was this place awesome! Pizza was delicious not chunky sauce which is so hard to find and the garlic knots and chicken Parmesan was great. This was a great find I'm sad it took so long to come across here and take a chance. The prices are great even for specialty pies and the 18" was def 18" bc bigger of the slices I've seen. Trust me you will not be disappointed plus you can order online and it was easy and they came within the time they estimate. If you're looking for good pizza at a great price this is definitely a go to! read more

Great pizza, but was less impressed by the customer service. I was ignored for 5 minutes even tho i was the first person at the counter, then was told "we'll be right with you" and then still nothing. That same clerk tended to someone and someone after them who came in after me. Hard to figure out the system....a secret word? or just every man for himself? LOL ordering a slice is typically a pretty simple thing but i found it to be not easy here. read more

I had ordered for New Years Eve, the food was delicious and everyone went home with doggie bags. The food was great and the antipasto was amazing. I will be using Crispino for all my parties. Also the gentleman who delivered the food was so nice! I highly recommend them!! read more

Crispinos pizza has a mild but tasty sauce and a nice coating of cheese that is not overly greasy. Their crust has room for improvement however. The crust was a bit tough and lacked the signature bit of chew one would expect with NY style dough. I stopped by on a Saturday and found that they currently have $1.00 slices from 11:00-4:00. Overall, you can't beat that. read more

Crispinos Pizzeria - Neapolitan slices at Crispinos! - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

Called in an order for a large pie and was told 25-30 minutes. I realize how busy Friday nights are so tell me 50 minutes and that's when I'll pick it up. Instead, I stood waiting for 20 additional minutes and just got my pie. read more

Beware! They charge you 4% to use your debit or credit card but not on what you are paying but on their price before the special advertised! I'm pretty sure that is illegal! They don't tell you of this BTW, I happened to realize because I went there I asked how much it would be and it was $2.00 more when I paid so I asked. The girl behind the counter felt bad. You should be told and it should only be on the amount you are actually paying. Also the amount of salt added into the sauce and chicken, meatballs for their hero's was way out of control. read more

Used to love their pizza but most of the employees were walking around both the back and front (touching food talking to other employees) with not a mask in sight. read more

Love their salad slice. Brooklyn slice is VERY good. And I grew up on L&B pizza in Brooklyn. Plain slice is good. Not too doughy. I have been living in this area for 4 years and finally found a good pizza spot. read more

Good pizza, terrible service! They all seemed like we were bothering them, especially when we asked for the rest of our food. Had to wait 10 mins for regular slices? Where are your backup regular pies? Will not go back, plenty of other pizza places in the neighborhood! read more

I thought their pizza was ok! Gave them a good review on Grubhub. Only after checking my bank statement did I see they put and extra $4.00 on my order. Can not get a straight answer from them or Grubhub. Pizza was not worth the amount!! Will never use them again!! Wish I didn't have to give them any stars. RIP OFF!! read more