Ordered take out from here, took nearly TWO HOURS to come. When I called to check on it, the staff was very unprofessional just saying they're "busy". When the food finally arrived, the delivery driver brought the wrong food to the door. When we finally got our food it was ice cold, had no flavor, and just gross. Definitely would not order from here again and do not recommend. read more

They make a nice pie! Grandma's is excellent and so is the regular pie. Good sauce, cheese and dough. If their prices were a little lower they'd be reasonable too. Stay away from the heros. The quality of the chicken is not good,rubbery. The eggplant is mushy. Hero prices on the high side too. read more

The pizza was pretty good the first few times we got it. But it seems to have fallen off. It's convenient and close.

Delicious high quality made food. I enjoyed every last bite. Staff seemed a little off. Almost felt like we annoyed them but the food was great so we will be back read more

Awesome staff who serve some sweet pizza, quick to get me on my way with a friendly smile. Always enjoy their Sicilian or their Margarita slices when need a quick yummy bite! read more

These people had the nerve of making us wait almost 2 HOURS to deliver a pizza pie that was COLD and had canned disgusting mushrooms ( when they assured us they were fresh). When I immediately called and asked them to pick up the pizza and asked for a refund the rude employee told me "we'll refund you, don't call here no more". No apology for anything but the complete opposite! Rude, disrespectful employee AND disgusting pizza! Don't go here! The only reason they got 1 star is because you can't write a review otherwise! read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Ice cold and disgusting. Mushrooms tasted rancid! Gross! - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Great tasting pizza, cheesy, perfect crust, tasty sauce, just right. What's not to like? I stopped in a few times so far & never disappointed. Great lunch specials including $5.95 for 2 slices & a medium drink. The place is nice & clean too, I might add. Highly recommend! read more

Love this pizzeria. They make the best macaroni and cheese slice. Today I got Marissa to take my order for delivery. She is super sweet extremely good customer service. Wish more people had customer service like Marissa... read more

Food is always good the bbq slices to the buffalo chicken rolls, just the attitudes from the younger employees are terrible. Understandable that you been doing this for a while but take time in the customer equally not just regulars. & pls pay attention to not over heating food. But great food just fix that. read more

Fabulous pizza ! 3 of us stopped to grab a quick slice to hold us over until dinner .... a grandma square , a sfincione and a spinach slice ... one better than the other . I wish I lived nearby, I would make this place my "go to " pizzeria. I'll have to settle for a slice when I'm shopping in the area on weekends . read more

I go here almost once a week and today I went in and got Shrimp Pesto Pizza, and I cannot describe my experience with words, this pizza specifically was the best food forget pizza best freakin good I've ever had in my life (and I've eaten some pretty damn good pizza mind you). Thank you for serving me with such goodness I REALLY APPRECIATE it. Like it was so good that this is the first review I've written willingly because I just think everyone needs to know how good this is as well as they deserve this rating. So yeah basically I recommend eggplant pizza or Shrimp Pesto Pizza. Shrimp Pesto is not always there so like go during the weekends or Friday. I don't think I'll be getting any other pizza I am committed to this for sure. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Eggplant Pizza and Shrimp Pesto Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Best pizza and pasta in Patchogue! The pasta ala nonna is amazing. The crust on the pizza is always crispy and everything is always fresh. Huge selection and friendly staff! read more

Called in an order for pick up... Had a Greek salad and a regular cheese pie. Great food, great service.

Not a fan!!! We are visiting from out of state and it is our last day here. We decided to get our pizza fix one last time but the staff at Nonna's put a bad taste in our mouth. Our total came to more than we expected so we questioned it when we came back to pick up the pizza. We were told that the boss has not updated the prices on the menu or board. When we told them that this is false advertising, we were brushed off and one of the guys even said they have no control over that stuff. This is just not how you operate a business. The customer is almost always right and prices should be upfront and correct. We will not recommend them to anyone and will advise our family to do the same. read more

The best pizza on Long Island....and chicken fingers too always fresh and tasty thanks!

Nonnas is my new go to spot! November 2 2020. The ladies were very pleasant and efficient! Ordered a well done pie,2 chicken parm hero's with crispy well toasted bread,a cheese and ham calzone and garlic knots. OMG THEY NAILED IT!!! Whole family is loving it,so good!We w definitely be back at least once a week. Ladies you did an awesome job,thank you! read more

Worst service ever, Came to Long Island to link up with a group of friends for a reunion. One suggested this place being close by. Called to place a large order, girl put me on hold. I hung up. Friend stated I was being to harsh, I stated I'm not being put on hold while attempting to give THEM business. So John called them, once AGAIN girl answering states "Nonnas Pizza please hold" over TWO MINUTES later he was still holding and hung up. That's when our friend Gina says the food stinks there anyway, I'm sorry way too many other pizzerias around to be dealing with this piss poor managed place. Look at other reviews of someone stating they waited TWO hours for delivery and another one stating the prices CHARGED are not the PRICES stated on menu? NO THANKS! read more

we have been regulars ordering from Nonnas for 7 years and have catered parties as well. is seems whenever they give you a pickup time and you go there you wind up standing there for double the time. went in Saturday night and as usual nothing ready - asked the owner behind the counter very politely why and maybe they should be a bit more conservative with the times . he responded - if you don't want to wait then go somewhere else ???. surprised he said that but will take his advise - apparently he really doesn't care . read more

Honestly, this is the place my family always goes for specialty slices. Favorites are the shrimp pesto, eggplant, and salad slices. Always filling and always fresh. We used to go to Mama Angelina's, but follows the chef who is at Nonna's now. So maybe the older reviews haven't been there since this change, and I recommend that they give it another go! read more

I always get lunch here not bad place to get a quick bite and very good prices. Only problem I've had is some stuff I've gotten was undercooked and not just once but twice but other than that pretty okay stuff . read more

I'll start off with this place was a gem for a quick slice in this shopping center until it was sold to the new owners. The pizza is an inedible oil slick with low grade cheese. Adding more to the misery were plates of eaten food and crumbs on each sticky table, also the floor appeared to not see a broom or dry mop the entire day, if not week. Counter help is clueless, and cannot or refuse to follow simple common requests such as "Please make it just warm, not boiling hot" after which my request was met with 5 slices of pizza with the molten bubbling cheese falling off the weak thin dough. Also, maybe brush out the ovens every half hour or so like every other pizzeria does. The large black charcoal crumbs glued to the bottom of the slices made our decision even easier to throw everything in the trash can and forfeit our $22.73 and leave. I will never return, shame because this was once a decent place to eat. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Inedible "pizza". Right in the trash it went - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Solid meatball and chicken parm and pizza is hit or miss but friendly staff no matter the time of day

Great selection of specialty pizza Regular style slices are well flavored and their selection of Italian plates have been great. The folks behind the counter are friendly. Nit sure they are priced high or not as others state but I think there is a lot of value for what they offer. We counted up 8 pizzerias in a 5 miles circle from our house. We tried most and hit up Nonna's only for a couple of years. read more

Nonna's is one of the best pizzeria's in the area by far. I can't believe all the bad reviews. Their pizza's are excellent quality, and they have a lot of original creative pizza's, outside the box, not like the usual pizzeria's around here. Their shrimp parm pizza is amazing, as well as their spinach pie, chicken parm, eggplant, etc. Everyone I know (friends and family) really like this place for take out. read more

The prices they have posted are not the prices they charge you!! When i questioned why my total was so much more than i thought, I was told that the boss hadn't updated the prices on the sign. This is not right and not how you invite repeat business! We are not talking a 50 cent difference it was almost $4.00. Will not recommend them to anyone! read more

I'm not sure what is going on with this place but the service is declining. The last three times I've ordered from here there has been an issue with my order. Very disappointed read more

I love there pizza and food but there service stinks. The people behind the counter are nasty and the owner is as well. Attitudes all around. read more

Came here today since my mother and I happened to be in the shopping center. Asked for a pepperoni slice and the guy behind the counter didn't use gloves to put pepperoni on the plain cheese slice, also got a Sicilian slice that was so burnt. While waiting for the slices to come out of the oven the same guy that didnt wear gloves proceeded to wipe his runny nose with his fingers and then handle someone elses pizza. The girl behind the register was very rude and the bathroom was so dirty. Will not return here. read more

Well this place is extremely OVERPRICED. Food is ok, not bad. However once you factor in their price and attitude you are much better off going elsewhere! Also if you do not like thin pizza, stay away regular pie is paper thin. read more

Although the food is very good, the owner is horrible. We had food delivered, with everything going on the driver came to my door with no gloves and mask which is completely dangerous especially with this virus going around. We called the restaurant to advise the owner of the matter, he did nothing but yell and scream at us as the customer(telling us the kid didn't have it and to not worry...how is anyone sure about that especially doing deliveries & coming in contact with people) . Pretty sure you suppose to assure your customers that it will not happened again, disgusting. read more

Great improvement to this old place, food is good and service is outstanding

My first time trying pizza on the island and I'm unimpressed- I tried a buffalo and margarita slice, and my cashier's demeanor was less than stellar!!! read more

Rarely do you come across businesses that actually have a strong overall Yelp review. The reasoning is because Yelp! is simply a sounding off board for complainers. And that's why I'm here...to write about how terrible this place is and always has been. No offense intended, of course. Having grown up in the area and always in that shopping center for carious reasons throughout the years, every so often I'll take a walk into Nonna's and they are consistently below average with their pizza. Gotta give them credit for that consistency but unfortunately it's for never straying from the path of being sub-standard.They're not far from Marshall's so if you want an overall mediocre day, go shopping at Marshall's and then eat pizza at Nonna's. read more

Nice big slices with a light, crispy crust that taste very very good. I'm only giving 3 stars because I just paid $7.50 for 2 regular slices and a small drink at noon, which I think is a bit expensive. Meanwhile there's a lunch special between 11-4 with 2 regular slices and a medium drink for $5.95. I realized this after I paid and I'm a bit pissed the young man that rang me up didn't say "if you get a medium soda, with the lunch special you save $1". I feel like I got ripped off. The walls are dirty and scuffed up. The chairs are worn with paint chipping off of them. read more

Stopped in for a quick bite before heading to Best buy. What a gem. The food is delicious and nutritious. I can't wait to get more next time. They will definitely be put in my pizza rotation. read more

Been ordering for a while. Always pleased with the service, delivery and food. Thank you for feeding my husband and I when we're too tired to cook. read more

I've ordered before and it was good pizza, plus they delivered. I ordered pizza, knots, a soda and a side of sauce to be delivered. I was told 45 minutes yet it took over an hour and 15 minutes. Pizza was cold and they didn't deliver the side of sauce. Very disappointed and will not likely order again. read more

Best array of specialty slices that I've seen in years!!! We tried the chicken Marsala slice, tomato and pesto slice, and the shrimp a la vodka slice. Excellent crust: light and crisp, with a perfect chewiness. I'm really impressed! Can't wait to taste all the others! (Lobster ravioli pizza, veggie pizza, white and spinach slices, Hawaiian, Mac n cheese slices, ziti slices, shrimp parm slices, grandma slices, salad slices and more! Amazing!) read more

I have been going here a couple of time a week for a while. Truth is I like their pizza, BUT the owner and the employees leave a lot to be desired. Recently I am seeing different people working there that are totally incompetent. On top of that the owner has been anything but professional. They won't be getting anymore of my money. Going elsewhere.... read more

Staff were very nice and friendly, don't understand some of the other reviews. Pasta Fagioli was huge and came with delicious bread. Unfortunately had ordered a slice of Tomato Pesto (soo good) and couldn't finish all the bread. Love this little local place and will certainly be coming back. read more