Best pizza on the island. My wife has can't eat gluten and they had a gluten free pie and it was amazing. I can eat anything and I had 2 slices with sausage and it was hot and very flavorful. Everyone should come and eat here. The owner even came over and asked how our food was and thanked us for coming. read more

Pelligrino's Pizza - Gluten free Onions and Peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Shoreham, New York

We get Pelligrino's frequently. The pizza is consistently delicious, and nicely cooked. Their meatballs are excellent. The chicken tenders and fries are also enjoyable. The owner and their employees are very friendly and helpful. read more

Had food from this restaurant in the past and it was good. i ordered a meatball pizza and it was undercooked, bland and a couple of slices had no meatball and the rest had one thin square piece of meatball. Worst pizza experience ever. Stick to other food if you eat there. read more

Been all over New York and eaten at a lot of pizza places. I found this gem recently and not only is the staff so friendly the pizza fantastic. Plus they didn't charge me crazy price for some slices and a coke . Other places have gotten out of control. Great food ! read more

Good pizza crunchy and cheesy. The service was great. All the people were nice. Great place to come when hungry

The people are nice. The sicilian pie was not crispy, and it was not for me. I felt like I was eating frozen pizza. Sorry, I would not order from them again. read more

Pizza is just ok. Staff has been very rude in the past. So many other great pizza places to go to. Gave them many opportunities to redeem themselves. Oh well read more

This place used to be the go to for me in the area. Really close to home and super convenient. Their quality has worsened over the past few years and their prices have increased. Their slice is all soggy with oil, not enough cheese and toppings, I ordered a regular pizza and I felt like they only put half of the normal cheese portion. The second time, I ordered a pepperoni and onion, I could count each pepperoni and onion that were placed sparingly across the pizza, again, half of the normal potion of toppings. In essence, prices have gone up, I get a lesser amount of cheese and/or toppings, the oil/sogginess is out of control and to make matters worse, I had a terrible acid reflux a few hours after having their pizza! The service is not memorable, kind of get in and get out kinda spot, same as most pizza joints. Same goes for their atmosphere when you pick up a pie, you're a customer and that's it. Nothing more. Overall, you have lost a customer, I've read that there may have been an ownership change which could explain the vast difference [negatively connotation on vast difference] in quality. To the new owners (if that's the case) you're doing a TERRIBLE job and until I read positive reviews and hear of a change toward the old Pelegrinos pizza, I won't be returning here. To all new & perspective customers, proceed with caution. read more

Always fresh, it's always a pleasure to eat in or take out. My favorite is the grandma slice.

For years this place used to be a frequent stop of mine while out on the road. I liked their pizza because it was always perfect to eat while driving. No sogginess or excess oil, just decent pizza at a decent price. However, recently it has dive-bombed to inedible. The last few times have been just bad. The oil would just pour off the slice making it almost impossible to eat without falling apart. Maybe a change in ownership?? And to make matters worse they now charge $8.15 for two slices. Seriously !!!! Sorry, you lost a customer. read more

Pretty good pizza, especially for this area. The Brooklyn slice had a nice light, buttery crust. The regular " cheese" slice was good. It was a little doughy, maybe if they could get the underside of the pizza a little more crispy or well done without burning the top it would bump them up to 4 stars. The cheese & sauce were nice it just needs that crunch to put'em over the top. read more

Pelligrino's Pizza - Regular & Brooklyn slice - Pizza Near Me - Shoreham, New York

This week I found out Pelligrino Pizza now makes a vegan pizza! We had a pizza with an assortment of veggies and goveggie (plant based) cheese was used. Definitely ordering from here now on and wayyyy better service than Pazzo (20 mins means 45 mins) read more

Pelligrino's Pizza - 10'' Vegan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shoreham, New York

Came here with my cousin, we're working in the area & not many options. I found the small pizzeria clean. The Staff & I think the owner friendly. Now my take on the pizza. The flavor of the items on my pizza was good but I didn't care for the sauce. It was very sweet. I want my tomato pizza sauce to taste like tomatoes. I know some tomatoes can be sweet naturally I.e. San Marzano, but this was sugary sweet. I got a Margherita slice & a House Special with chicken cutlets on it. I tasted the House Special first. Good seasoning on the cutlets but that Dag gone sauce was ruining the flavor profile. So I thought it was the House Special. Then I tasted the Margherita Razzle Frazzle! Same sauce for both! Not cool. For me that is. Taste is subjective to personal preference. Would I go back if I was in the area? Yes. Would I seek it out? Nah, not likely. read more

Pelligrino's Pizza - Margherita & House Special - Pizza Near Me - Shoreham, New York

I love my local pizzeria. They have great specials every day of the week. Best value for pizza and Italian food around. Owner and staff are always super nice. Small dining area, we use primarily for take out. We are spoiled with so many pizza/Italian choices around. I choose to order from the closest pizzeria to my home because it's always good, and we love to support our local businesses. They are always so generous to our schools, and hire local kids to work there. That's important to me that they are invested in the community they serve. Is it the best pizza around? No. It's good. I have my preferred place for pizza but it's farther away and much more expensive. The coupons in the local papers for Pellegrinos can't be beat! Great place to stop for a cheap lunch, and you leave full! Can't say enough about my neighborhood pizzeria. Love them! read more

Just a quick stop In this time but I will be back. Enormous slices. Perfectly cooked and the counter service was so pleasant. They even had a table delivery for the dining room. Many types of specialty slices, garlic knots and pinwheels. Pelligrino sodas. Perfect, classic and recommended. read more

Pelligrino's Pizza - One slice cut in half for a little pizza lover. Hot, gooey and smells fantastic. - Pizza Near Me - Shoreham, New York

Nice people and very friendly. The owner knew I'm deaf and got married! Awesome! Good food!

Over priced for bad pizza. 2 slices and a soda 11.19$ thats crazy! Didnt even finish it.

Absolutely delicious catering!! Just hosted a holiday party yesterday & ordered chicken franciese, chicken marsala, meatballs, eggplant Parm, beef & broccoli, & it came with garlic knots. The sauces were all great & the meats were all juicy and cooked perfectly! The garlic knots were soft and full of garlic and so delicious. 100% recommend this place and will continue to order catering from here :) read more

Amazingly delicious pizza!! We order it all the time now. They have so many great deals for pretty much every day of the week. The staff is very friendly, both on the phone and in person. Today we did the Weds special buy 1 get another 1/2 price! (Accepted for delivery as well). We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza and the Buffalo chicken pizza. They both looked and smelled amazing. The taste was incredible! This place is so good I love ordering from them!! The delivery came early than the time I was quoted. They are very accommodating with methods of payment accepted. My only advice is that the pizza should be cooked a little longer the crust was slightly doughy. I might just order well done next time too. Other than that, thumbs up all around ! read more

Pelligrino's Pizza - BBQ chicken pizza.... pretty bomb - Pizza Near Me - Shoreham, New York

See all

I love this place! The regular pie has a great crust, the Sicilian is the right mix of cheese and crust and their delivery is almost always early. They have been my family's go to place during this quarintine but honesty, they were my favorite pizza joint before that. I wish the Wild Wednesday Special was listed online, but we can't have everything, can we? read more

Food is outstanding! When we use the online ordering they delivery in a reasonable time. Staff are pleasant and courteous. I highly recommend Pelligrino's Pizza in Shoreham.. read more

Delivery is fast, prices are unbeatable, and the people who work their are friendly! Sunday's and Monday's they have a special for 2 pies and we get it almost weekly. read more

Ordered takeout tonite for the first time. A pepperoni pizza, a cheese pizza, 6 knots and a side of meatballs. Both pizzas were greasy and mushy. The garlic knots were so undercooked they were still pasty white! The meatballs were spongy and had no flavor. I have never had worse take out from a pizzeria. Awful. read more

I love this pizza place!!! Ive been coning since i was very young like 14! They have always been my favorite pizza place around! They even make good wings too! If you haven't tried them, please do!!! Service is always great also! read more

I had lunch here and t was excellent and low priced. I use to cook professionally was very happy with this place. Told owner I will be back and I meant it. read more

We order from this place once a week. My family owns pizzerias and I grew up working in them. This place is always consistent, the staff is always pleasant and I've never had a bad experience. I enjoy supporting local businesses since I grew up in one. I understand how important these family owned places are. I recommend this place 100%. The owner often makes deliveries himself and is always very respectful. I will continue to be a customer and I wish this business the best of luck. Vincenzo D read more

As a Virginia resident and visitor to New York, the infamous pizza is a must! This location is very close to where I stay and always has delicious, 5 star New York pizza that I crave every other day of the year. I've always carried out or delivered so I can't say much as to the service, but the delivery is always quick and hot! The other day we ordered a large penne in vodka sauce that was absolutely to die for!! If you're looking to serve a large amount of people or cater an event, I highly recommend this incredible dish! Everyone was going back for seconds and heating up left overs! read more

Heroes are almost as bad as their pizza. My meatball parm hero was made with one piece of sliced cheese. This is my third time trying their food in hopes they had an off day but it is atrocious read more

We ordered from here the other night and I just really did not like the flavor of the pizza at all. I found it to be bland and the dough was under cooked in my opinion. The sauce didn't have a good flavor, it tasted just like tomato paste with not much seasoning. read more

I like to call pelligrinos the pizza factory, because their pizza is bland and unappealing. Wouldnt go there, unless you like bad pizza.

They say an elephant never forgets, well neither do I. I wish I could give this place a higher review because I'm sure the owner is a good person and the pizza is actually pretty good. People don't forget, if you are reading this and you are the employee who intentionally burnt my pizza after I walked 3 miles over the tundra know as the sod farms, you know who you are....and so do I. read more

Food is excellent! Pizza and baked dishes are phenomenal. Very nice owner too. Tried this place on a recommendation from our neighborhood Facebook page and was genuinely impressed. read more

My favorite pizza place on long island. I don't understand why people go to Alfredo's in Ridge, it's so bad. Always cold, too much cheese, or something, there's always something wrong. GO HERE. read more

Amazing good, great prices, very friendly staff. They have been in business for over 25 years (and for good reason)! Thank you so much Jimmy for feeding my family for years ! read more

Yum yum. Ordered delivery Vanessa brought our food fast and with a smile it was hot and delicious !! Thank you will be ordering again ! read more

Friendly staff, amazing slices and the dinners were excellent! Prices were great considering the high quality ingredients. Definitely will be back read more

Tried Pelligrino for the first time tonight. We got a speciality Buffalo Chicken Pie and it was very good ! The prices are super reasonable and we will definitely be back. read more

Not only is the food amazing, but the staff are just as great. They do everything with a smile on their face. they have some of the biggest slices of pizza i've ever seen and it tastes so good. Their brooklyn slices are my personal favorite. I've gone in a few times and they were out of them, but made them for me on the spot. truly such a nice place with great food. I highly recommend to anyone looking for a good slice of New York pizza. read more

Good, not great. Need to buy some pepto if you go here cause you'll be on the toilet all damn night. Trust me I had experience and the rumors are true. On another note these are some the the best guys ( and ladies ) you'll ever meet. They gave me napkins when I needed them and said thank you. You don't get a lot of that in the WR. I usually don't tell anyone this but I was constipated until I came here. My doctor is actually looking for a cure in the pizza they gave me! So , pellegrino pizza came in the clutch;) read more

Great pizza!!! Quick service, friendly staff - kids love it! They have a good selection of specialty pizza by the slice.