Nostalgia House Bakery

270

91

23

3 years ago

We needed a custom cake with only a week to find a baker and Nostalgia House Bakery pulled it off amazingly. Most custom cake bakeries want much more advance notice but Nostalgia House only needed 48 hours. The people at the bakery were very responsive to both my phone calls and messages via their Facebook page. Everyone at the party loved the design and flavor of the cake, Lemon cake with strawberry filling. The bakery literally said we could do any flavor so tons of options available to you. Arrived at the bakery on a Saturday around 10am and they had my cake ready to go and it was great. Also a fair price. I will say if you are going to this bakery looking for pastries on Saturday...go early. When I got there at 10 they were cleaned out. It's a nice space clean, quiet and cozy. Didn't really notice much seating though. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - a birthday cake with a race car on top - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Doug J.

42

291

430

2 years ago

Had some time in Port Orchard and made a stop at Nostalgia Bakery to check it out. While making some choices I selected a breakfast burrito with egg and sausage. On the one hand there is nothing extra like onions or peppers it is loaded with eggs and tasty pork sausage. The tortilla was very good, not too thick but thin and tender. Even though I was hungry it was difficult to finish the large burrito. I would definitely come back just for the burrito. I tried a blueberry streusel muffin- didn't care for it, seemed dry and lacked blueberries. The muffin itself had a yellow cake like batter and the streusel lacked sweetness or flavor. I also chose a Carmel pecan roll. It was much more to my liking, especially after I warmed it up. It was much like my grandmother used to make. Soft, nice amount of topping. Finally I tried a mini sourdough loaf . Made toast with it and it was tasty, toasted up nice. I will come back to try some of the other treats they have- and definitely another burrito!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Darren O.

99

623

4533

2 years ago

Really good donuts. Had an old fashioned and a cruller. Both were great. Definitely will get them again when we're in the region. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michele L.

0

2

0

1 year ago

Just stopped by this establishment looking for a dozen donuts for my co workers. I walked in and stated that I needed a dozen donuts. The counter worker said that she didn't think she had a dozen. She counted out 9. She then stated that she had a lot to do in the morning. I asked if this is a bakery. She said yes. I then asked why no donuts at 0600. She said we haven't had donuts in 6 months, where have you been? Then called me a rude assed bitch...hmmm....great service here read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jessica W.

0

4

1

2 years ago

Nostalgia made my daughter's 5th birthday cake, and did an amazing job! The cake turned out great, and tasted sooo good! The price of the cake was great as well. I will definitely be using Nostalgia again in the future for custom cakes. Everyone that works there is also very nice, and easy to communicate with. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Unicorn cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Nicole D.

30

11

5

3 years ago

5 PLUS stars, hands down this place is amazing!!!! This wonderful, family owned, small business took my order last minute for my 13 year old son birthday. Will definitely be using them again. Thank you! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Peter K.

11

413

278

3 years ago

Absolutely love going here. This place has better donuts than a major franchise that starts with the letter K. It's of hard to describe how these donuts just melt in your mouth. The staff is so friendly here and I have to say the prices are way better than even if you went to a grocery store I do highly recommend this place. It has a great atmosphere great staff and great prices. The filled donuts are the best. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kori B.

4

43

24

3 years ago

Great treats with a wide range of tastes available, friendly bakers, reasonable pricing! Highly recommend! Come support this business! The construction nearby has slowed business down significantly and they deserve to stay in business! Please support! read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Ham and cheddar breakfast sammy - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Nostalgia House Bakery - Dozen donuts - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Nostalgia House Bakery - Dozen cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marissa L.

Elite 19

273

345

661

5 years ago

I love this Bakery ! First off let's talk about the phenomenal bakers, artisans and staff . I always walk in there and yes there is usually a line , don't worry they always have more maybe not of the pastry you want but try something new ! It's just as amazing. They are so quick, answer all your questions take their time with you even though there could be a line they don't make you feel pressured . I always get a box and pick random items ! I am Always impressed . I also buy my sons cakes here since I truly dislike store bought cakes . I love going to Nostalgia they let you taste flavors of icing and truly make your dreams come to life for traditional cakes . The area is clean and very tidy I went with 30 Minutes left of their day and they do their best to have some pastries left . If not then then have a cold case that has yummy cupcakes and treats in there ! Cookies .. LARGE cookies too! They recently had to raise prices since they were cheaper than most , and was so thoughtful to let their fans know on social media but I will always support them and for the amazing work, devotion and determination! read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Total yum! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Alysia B.

1

6

0

2 years ago

We ordered a custom cake for my son's 5th birthday and it was delicious. The cake was soft and moist. Customer service was amazing. I will definitely be ordering again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

ALoe B.

23

12

6

4 years ago

This is the second year I ordered a custom cake with nostalgia! Found them on yelp and has some good reviews and cake looks great! 1st cake was Roblox cake then this year a Snoopy cake! Both looked great and tasted really good..the cake is nice and moist and it's not too sweet! My daughter loves her cakes! Thank you! Price is pretty good too! We will keep coming back and recommended them to family and friends! read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Snoopy cake! It's cute and my daughter loved it! Cake is good too! Not too sweet and moist - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Isabella B.

3

11

4

2 years ago

Best doughnuts and cakes! Love how friendly the staff is! I have been coming here with my grandparents for years. Lois and her staff are so kind and just overall wonderful people. I appreciate their uniqueness. :) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laura C.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Custom cake was lopsided and dry. Must have sat in a fridge for at least 24 hours because the frosting broke apart when we cut into it. Did not appear to be made by a professional. I was embarrassed to share it with anyone. What a waste of $80. Also the muffins are too salty. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elizabeth V.

108

214

61

5 years ago

If you are looking for an old school donut shop (I REALLY wanted to call it an Old Fashioned donut shop, but please, recognize my restraint!) Nostalgia House Bakery lives up to its name. Glazed, cake, maple bars, sprinkles . . . this place has them all in spades. Fluffy and sweet with a pump pot of coffee on a table next to the door, if you're in Port Orchard and are craving deliciousness in donut form, Nostalgia House is the place for you! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Geraldine L.

7

3

5

4 years ago

Nostalgia house bakery made us an Alien egg for Halloween. She did an amazing job. We told her to play around with it and do whatever she thought was best. We really didn't know what to expect and we were amazed!! Our Alien cake turned out amazing!!! I definitely recommend. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - a cake with an egg on it - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christine S.

0

51

14

4 years ago

Kudos! I live on the Eastside but needed a cake for my Mother's 80th bday. The caterer I used recommended this bakery so I called and ordered. The product was just as I asked for most importantly delicious. The lemon filling and icing was delicate and sweet (but not too much). I may have overestimated how much cake I needed-but no one complained about a second piece the next day with a side of Mora sherbet. I must say it was just as good day 2. I found price totally reasonable for the great product. I must the employee that offered to carry it to my car was a excellent example of above and beyond customer service representative. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Birthday cake. Double layer vanilla cake with lemon filling and buttercream icing. - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emma S.

0

20

11

2 years ago

will continue to be a returning customer, always great moist cakes with lots of options. everyone is always super kind and accommodating. they always do amazing copying the desired designs. plus my dad said their creme donut might be his favorite ever read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maricel S.

1

14

10

5 years ago

Wow!! I messaged Nostalgia through Facebook messenger to inquire about a specific cake I wanted for my sons birthday. They gladly took my order considering it was needed on Easter Day. We picked up our cake and it was what we asked for plus more! The design and look of the cake was perfect! We got a 9" cake and I was surprised by how it was fairly priced! Lastly, this was the BEST strawberry cake I've ever had! Seriously. My whole family came back for seconds. It was so moist and the strawberry flavor was just... Yum! Thank you so much Nostalgia! We know where to order our cakes for future gatherings! read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Strawberry cake with strawberry filling - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Nostalgia House Bakery - Designed cake. I added the cars myself and the "two fast" decor. - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Melody E.

Elite 14

118

147

173

6 years ago

Recommended by my sister who has ordered her cakes here for years. So on Friday I needed a custom cake in less than 24 hours. Nostalgia House said they usually need 48 hours to bake a custom, but they had several 1/4 sheet cakes (enough for 10 people) already baked they could customize. I asked what they had available and went with a chocolate vanilla marble. Next day (Saturday) my cake was ready by noon. I arrived and the ladies greeted me very friendly. Our cake was just beautifuly decorated, better than I had imagined. I'd asked for an American flag and they'd draped it over the edges. Very professionally decorated. I took it home. How was the taste? Wonderful. My party devoured it, noting that it was tender, light, delicious and sweet without being overpoweringly sweet like the big-box store cakes. Everyone went for 2nd and 3rd pieces. Although our Nostalgia House Bakery custom cake was somewhat more than a big-box store I now know why my sister recommends them for beautifully decorated, delicious cakes that will have your whole party complimenting how beautiful and delicious your cake is. I'll be back. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Soren S.

1

22

0

3 years ago

A great local bakery. They are friendly and accommodating, and their baked goods are always delicious. Reasonable prices and top notch bakery classics. Can't go wrong with Nostalgia. Our go-to for birthday, holiday and special occasion sweets! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tania R.

0

15

6

4 years ago

Called for a custom shaped carrot cake and they were very accommodating even though it was almost too last minute of a request. They happily made it and my husband absolutely loved his custom birthday cake. I had visited before for their donuts which are super good. Everything they make that I've tried so far is delish. Definitely come here for the great bakes and great service! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tina F.

41

33

25

4 years ago

They have a large selection but donuts shouldn't be stale and cold at 8:00 in the morning.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sam M.

Elite 22

12

401

1471

9 years ago

Our first time visiting Nostalgia. Friendly staff greeted and chatted with us. Very personable! The donuts are very good! Plenty of seating and parking. Go by say hi and grab a donut! We will be back. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jennifer M.

0

26

20

7 years ago

The cake for my baby shower came out amazing! The price was so reasonable and the Baker is a dream to work with. Absolutely A plus and I will be getting many more cakes here in the future. Oh... And it was delicious to boot. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Two tiered Seahawks themed baby shower - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Donna G.

10

24

0

3 years ago

They made me a Custard pie (small one) and it was so good in fact all their pastry is fresh and good. Will go again .

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cherie W.

1

18

1

5 years ago

Very friendly staff and atmosphere. You've got to get here early to get the best selection. Decent coffee. I will definitely return. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashlee J.

123

5

2

6 years ago

We had a great experience with Nostalgia bakery and couldn't be happier with how our wedding cake turned out. I ordered it as a naked cake and we decorated it ourselves. The cake was super moist and flavorful. It was so affordable and we loved that they do half and half flavors on the sheet cakes. Well done, thank you for making our day special!! read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - My wedding cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tatyana Y.

0

1

5 years ago

The best custom cakes ever! I didn't know exactly what to put on the cake and just gave a general idea of interest. The person who took my order over an email came up with the cake design and got it so right! We got two cakes for a 4-year-old girl and my husband and will definitely be going back. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - a birthday cake with coffee beans - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

kayla b.

0

16

10

7 years ago

This bakery was probably the most stressful bakery experience I've had. I had emailed them to order my cake and they said they had placed the order. I then went in a month before my baby shower to make sure the order was in and see about getting a smaller cake as well. She couldn't find the order so I ordered the cake again. It was to be barely frosted with light pink. When my mom picked up the order from the bakery and brought it to my baby shower I noted the cake was totally incorrect. Once my sister in law went down to talk to them about it, they told us we were give the wrong cake and the owner ( or manager) proceeded to yell at the girl who gave us the wrong cake in front of everyone. What an unprofessional way to fix a mistake. The only reason this got 2 stars was our actual cake tasted great. read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christeenna T.

0

2

0

6 years ago

These guys use to be my favorite bakery hands down and there baked good taste great. Their decorating skills are fair. But their prices have become too high for the quality you get. I have used them for years but the last two times, I was either disappointed in their attention to detail, (on my kids birthday cake the colors were wrong); or shocked at the 25 dollar price tag on a dozen doughnuts ..... 25?? For basic box of doughnuts. I guess I should have asked but last year the same order... cost me half . I'll just go to a grocery store next time,same doughnuts but $8 a dozen. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tracy C.

12

20

26

4 years ago

I cant believe the price!! We got 2 dozens donuts! $75! My friend asked if they had an mobile bulk coffee, they told him he could take the caraf but bring it back when he could. I am apphauled at these prices for $0.05 of ingredients per donuts. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Jennifer S.

55

113

68

5 years ago

I was in the area and had a hankering for donuts....simple Yelp search lead me to this bakery. It showed they were closing in a few minutes so I called to confirm. Excellent customer service on the phone....(it was 12:50pm) she confirmed they were closing at 1 but that I could stop by until 2, as they would be cleaning up. Thankfully I arrived by 1 and bought the most amazing turnovers....the dough was so fluffy and light....the French curler dough melted in your mouth and the cookies were perfect. We also bought a beautiful birthday cake. Excellent service, excellent products. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lauren G.

1

21

4

6 years ago

I grew up in Port Orchard, and Nostalgia was always the best place to spend long mornings before school with friends! Nothing would put a smile on my face quite like hot coffee and a buttermilk bar. Now, I live across the state so it's a delicacy I can only have when visiting. Between you and I, their donuts are easily one of the best parts of visiting home. I'm not a huge fan of yeast donuts in general, but I can demolish (far too many) buttermilk bars. These guys know what they're doing and will not disappoint. Their maple bacon bars are also a huge hit in my family. Thank you nostalgia for being so consistently awesome. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ted M.

482

17

19

11 years ago

Positives: The doughnuts are great, everything is fresh Negatives: They are frequently out of doughnuts. The hash browns were undercooked, as was the biscuit for the "Biscuits and Gravy". We ordered our eggs over-medium, and they were definitely over-easy (way too runny). Overall, they have great food - but when they get busy, I think they feel rushed. Id rather wait the extra few minutes, and have my order cooked right, then get an undercooked order quickly. I hope they can improve because I would really love to see this business stay open read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Janet C.

8

2

0

8 years ago

Order red velvet cup cake , very dry and over Priced for as small as they are I could of made that from a box better read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sheila M.

22

14

2

9 years ago

Awesome job on my daughter in laws baby shower cake!!! It was adorable and yummy to boot!! read more

Nostalgia House Bakery - The cutest and honestly yummiest cake for my daughter in laws baby shower!! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Conner L.

139

26

12

7 years ago

Best donuts in Port Orchard hands down! Make sure you get there early to get some donuts! My husband and I were talking about these donuts recently and made me crave them and will have to stop in again soon! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Korinne P.

0

3

0

4 years ago

Thank you so much to Nostalgia House Bakery for providing such delicious donuts for our boat club this weekend! They were a hit and gobbled up in no time. Your donuts do not disappoint in size! Thank you for accommodating an earlier pick up time as well! Thank you, thank you! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ed R.

44

7

8

6 years ago

Fantastic find! I appreciate a bakery with more than pastries. They had some savory treats that were delish. Friendly helpful staff. Will return. read more

Business owner information

Lois S.

Thank you Ed! We are happy you found us too! We enjoy making new…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daniel D.

43

33

9

9 years ago

Their donuts are great! I have one in particular I get each time I go there and it is the maple bacon donut. Imagine a fluffy donut based covered with spectacular maple topping that just melts in your mouth. Then on top of that is tiny bacon bits covering nearly every part of the maple topping giving you crunchy bacon in each bite. This is by far my favorite donut and more so this is more just a review for that donut. Staff is always kind and prompt when I have been there. This is a hidden gem and one of the better donut spots in kitsap county. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 3

See more reviews

More info about Nostalgia House Bakery

1341 Bay St
Ste D
Port Orchard, WA 98366
Directions
(360) 443-2977
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.nostalgiahousebakery.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Nostalgia House Bakery open?

Nostalgia House Bakery opens at 5:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Nostalgia House Bakery opens at 7:00 AM on Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Nostalgia House Bakery close?

Nostalgia House Bakery is closed on Monday.Nostalgia House Bakery closes at 1:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon ClosedTue-Fri 5:00 AM - 1:00 PMSat-Sun 7:00 AM - 1:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Nostalgia House Bakery take Bitcoin?

No, Nostalgia House Bakery does not take Bitcoin.

Does Nostalgia House Bakery take credit cards?

Yes, Nostalgia House Bakery takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Nostalgia House Bakery have catering options?

Yes, Nostalgia House Bakery does have catering options.

Indoor Amenities

Does Nostalgia House Bakery allow dogs?

Yes, Nostalgia House Bakery allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Nostalgia House Bakery have bike parking?

No, Nostalgia House Bakery does not have bike parking.

Does Nostalgia House Bakery have parking?

Yes, Nostalgia House Bakery has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Nostalgia House Bakery wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Nostalgia House Bakery is wheelchair accessible.

From the Business

Specialties

With over 50 years of cake decorating, baking and cooking experience, we specialize in custom decorated cakes and cupcakes. We make breads from scratch along with other baked goods such as cookies, pies and bar cookies. We have turnovers, cinnamon rolls, sticky buns, cream horns and other delicious pastries. We also make savory items, breakfast burritos, kolaches and soups.

History

Established in 2012.

Our tag line is "Tastes that make Memories" because we want the experience to be like coming to Grandmas house. We do things the old fashioned way, with real butter and eggs and make it ourselves from recipes we have used for years.

Meet the Business Owner: Lois S.

Lois has over 50 years experience baking and cake decorating and has worked many different types of food service establishments. She was the Executive Pastry Chef at the Washington State Convention Center for over 8 years and has won awards for creativity and innovation.

You might also consider

Mad Cakes

5.0(3 reviews)

3.5 mi

Great place to get a GENUINELY GOOD and SUPER CUTE AND CUSTOM cake!!…read more They came thru at the last minute for my grandsons 7th birthday! I was able to tell them What kind of cake and the were pretty spot on with the requested decoration! My grandson is in to lady bugs rn so they were able to put lady bugs on the cake!! And from what his mom told me the cake was DELISH!!! Highly recommend!!

Mad Cakes by Miquel is my go-to baker! He is so creative, talented and simply amazing at what he…read moredoes. He always makes sure my vision comes to life. Would highly recommend for all your sweet treat needs!

3-Tier Wedding Cake in fall colors

See all

Mmmmm - macaron

Ashley’s Sugar On Top

5.0(118 reviews)

24.9 mi

I'm so happy I chose Ashley to design and bake the cakes for our engagement and birthday…read morecelebrations. So many people kept coming up to me and complementing the cakes and the cupcakes. Ashley was super helpful and designing the cakes and offering unique concepts. When I first reached out, she responded very quickly and we were able to hop on a call and design the cakes from A-to-Z she's very knowledgeable about how much cake you'll actually need as well as trending designs. She was very good at communicating and I thought her cakes were very well priced. She takes a lot of extra care and boxing the cakes and cupcakes. The service was very professional.

Ashley's glitter cake was my daughter's dream! Everyone was just in awe of the beauty of it and we…read moreall loved the strawberry flavors. The fruit was noticeable in the cake and filling, nothing artificial, perfectly balanced, soft and delicate. Can't recommend her enough!

My daughters Peppa Pig chocolate Birthday cake, it was so DELICIOUS!!!

See all

Lego candy to decorate

Spilled Butter Desserts

4.8(86 reviews)

22.5 mi

•$

Amazingly light and flavorful bakes, it's very exciting when you do pop-up sales in your Oakland…read morelocation.

After trying several of their baked goods at local coffeeshops in Tacoma area, I discovered an…read moreopportunity from social media that they were having a pop up at their own brick and mortar baking kitchen, with collab with local coffee, Civic Roasters, a few months back. I know they do not have regular open hours for just walk in purchase, but rather, they're custom order type business, but I have yet to place any custom orders so I cannot speak to that experience. What made me write this review is how accurate the owner (Brianne) described cake and desserts in the description and the baked goods taste matched 200% of the description. The pistachio cake was out of the world, so was the whoopie pie!!! I got to meet Brianne in person and she was very friendly, and was kind to explain everything about each of her baked goods she had out that day. I've tried their baked goods from pop tarts to cookies to housemade Twinkie and the creation and taste are unmatched. Single serve baked goods were more on pricier side, but well worth every bite. I would definitely order custom baked goods from here, knowing the quality and taste of products from this shop!!! Currently, you can find Spilled Butter baked goods at Cosmonaut coffee, Outer Dark Coffee, and at Tacoma Farmers Market (also known as Tacoma Broadway Farmers Market) from time to time. Enjoy!!!

Raspberry moon pie with raspberry marshmallow center!

Spilled Butter Desserts - Civic Coffee Roasters pop up at Spilled Butter bakery's kitchen! They're opening their coffee shop in Downtown Tacoma soon!

Civic Coffee Roasters pop up at Spilled Butter bakery's kitchen! They're opening their coffee shop in Downtown Tacoma soon!

See all

Pour over by Civic Coffee Roasters. Excellent.

The Chocolate Nest

5.0(1 review)

8.9 mi

My daughters Frozen Cake was absolutely beautiful. The communication with the owner was amazing and…read moreseamless from start to finish. Highly recommend for special events.

Frozen Cake

See all

Lulu’s Bakery Shop

4.8(19 reviews)

27.0 mi

Lulu's Bakery Shop is located in a residential area of Tacoma. It is a small, local, Latina owned…read morebusiness. I have seen it plenty of times on my walks and runs around the area, but finally decided to stop by one day with a group of friends. We were able to talk to Lulu and learn more about her bakery. She is a super sweet and friendly person! We all ended up leaving the shop with a little treat in our hands thanks to Lulu. We all got a Strawberry Tres Leches Jello cup! Excited to try more things from her bakery in the future!

at Lulu Bakery, and everything was seriously delicious! I ordered the Nutella cookie, red velvet…read morecookie, flan, strawberry cake, churro cheesecake, and a cheese danish--and every single item hit. The Nutella cookie was rich and gooey, and the red velvet cookie had the perfect soft texture. The flan was smooth and creamy with just the right sweetness. The strawberry cake was light and flavorful, not overly heavy, which I loved. The churro cheesecake was probably my favorite--super unique with that cinnamon flavor and creamy filling. And the cheese danish was flaky and fresh, a perfect balance of sweet and buttery. Great customer service, definitely will be back

50th Birthday

50th birthday

See all

Rosie Bakery

4.9(24 reviews)

21.5 mi

My friends and I have ordered two different birthday cakes from Rosie's and I cannot say enough how…read moregreat they looked and tasted. I highly recommend Rosie's for all cakes. I will be ordering from this bakery in the future. Ordering process was super easy and very accommodating.

There isn't that many highly rated bakery that does swiss rolls but this spot does it. There menu…read moreis pretty limited but the favors are good. I tried several of their Swiss rolls. They are pack with flavor (not too sweet and not too dense nor fluffy). The flavors are Persian inspired and stay very well even eaten on the next day. Don't be intimidated that it's location inside a grocery store in a small area. I highly recommend it for their Swiss rolls.

Custom cake - vanilla and chocolate sponge cake with vanilla chantilly frosting and fondant. Cake topper ordered separately.

I was visiting Seattle and was blown away by this surprise birthday cake. Yes, it tasted as great as it looks.

See all

Chocolate ganache cake!

Dlala Bakery

5.0(7 reviews)

14.9 mi

Such an incredible experience with Linh!! She was responsive and gave great suggestions for our…read morecake selections. When I picked up our 2 cakes, I was blown away by how beautiful they were....and so beautifully packaged!! Oh, and did I mention how fantastic both cakes tasted? I ordered a white cake with lemon curd and blueberry preserves- YUM!! And a red velvet cake,not normally my favorite, but was delicious !!! Everyone said that the cakes were some the best they've ever tasted! Absolutely delicious!! Highly recommend Dlala Bakery!!! Thank you Linh!!

Truly outstanding! We were celebrating a special birthday and Dlala delivered such beautiful cake…read more The ordering was easy, pick up was easy and the birthday girl was delighted. No need to 'get by' with something from a grocery store. Make it special and connect with Dlala. What a hidden gem right here in Gig Harbor.

Strawberry cake with custard inside

See all

Mini cake

Celebrity Cake Studio

4.4(390 reviews)

23.0 mi

•$$$

This will be the second cake I have ordered with celebrity cake and I couldn't be happier. Their…read morecustomer service is top tier! Can't wait to see how this cake turns out.

What a beautiful shop! Don't let the neighborhood fool you--this is a gorgeous shop run by lovely…read morepeople. From the friendly greeting I received to the fabulous decorations, I had a wonderful experience. The prices are very reasonable given the high quality of the cakes and design work. I also appreciate how responsive you are to emails, as well as the immediate online receipts and order confirmations. I am excited to work with your shop again in the future!

See all

Beautiful cake for baby shower. The outside was perfect but the inside was very basic , like a grocery store cake :( very pricey :(

Cakes By Creme de la Creme

4.3(127 reviews)

21.5 mi

Beautiful cake! And delicious! Ordered a sheet cake for a celebration of life event and the owner…read morewas so happy to suggest the decorations on the cake. We ordered a chocolate cake with vanilla filling and buttercream frosting. When I sliced it, it was a 4 layer cake - moist, delicious! I highly recommend Crème de la Crème!

Ordered a cake for my friends baby shower and sent Bart an inspo photo and it was completely spot…read moreon! The cake was to feed 25-30 people but we had 50 people. We had plenty left over and barely cut into the bottom layer. The cake was also very tasty! It was lemon raspberry.

See all

Top 2 layers choc pb truffle torte, citron, lemon rb, bottom choc lovers truffle torte (my fave). DELICIOUS

Min Bakery

5.0(4 reviews)

30.5 mi

You can't go wrong with any types of desserts from MN Bakery. The cakes and cream puffs are…read morecustomizable, so you can request the types of design and flavors. The desserts are also never too overly sweet. And this Bakery does lots of unique flavors (black sesame, ube, pandan, matcha, biscoff) that are hard to find at other Asian bakeries while also getting the flavors spot on. I've tried a variety of cakes, tiramisu, and cream puffs, and nothing disappoints. The cakes are always moist even after a few days in the fridge. Depending on the timing of when you want the cake or cream puff, I think usually you should place your order within a few weeks in advance.

What an amazing delight! The fluffiest, flavorful, deliciousness to savor! Thank you, MN Bakery,…read morefor being an amazing part of our special birthday celebrations!!

Fresh, fluffy, tasty, Chocolate Cream Cake

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lainy G.

0

5

4

2 years ago

I recently ordered a custom Wednesday-themed tres leches cake for my friend's 30th birthday! When we came to pick up the cake, it needed a bit more detail but the bakery staff were incredibly accommodating and jumped right in to enhance it. I'm so grateful for their dedication--they truly transformed it into something beautiful! The flavor was absolutely amazing; the tres leches was rich and delightful. Everyone loved it! My only suggestion would be for better communication regarding my initial requests, especially since I gave them almost three weeks' notice. Overall, I'm thrilled with how everything turned out and truly appreciate the effort they put in. I highly recommend this bakery for their delicious cakes and wonderful service! read more

Kathy D.

9

1

0

11 years ago

Love this bakery and the staff is great. Down to earth foodie lovers paradise. stopped in this morning for a coffee and donut and yo visit their new digs. Everything was better than I remembered it. Had biscuits n gravy topped with eggs and an atmosphere that was a trip down memory lane into the late 50s early 60s. Location is right on Puget Sound bay with a little lunch park to the dude. Keep up the great work Lois! A place like yours is a treasure one rarely finds these days read more

Matt G.

0

1

0

2 years ago

awesome place to be around all the great people there thanks for everything so I hope to learn so much from on another thanx

Zoe B.

0

9

1

4 years ago

Nice folks... but... $3 for one donut??? Come on! That is just insane!

Nostalgia House Bakery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Nostalgia House Bakery also viewed

Nothing Bundt Cakes

4.6

(30 reviews)

This a cute little place to get a decent premade cake. Lots of flavors including a seasonal one…read morethat rotates. The store area has a lot of gifts. Customization available too! 3 different sizes, the cupcake size is only available by the dozen. Is it worth the drive....yes

Love this small bakery and when you sign up, you receive a free Bundt cake for your birthday. They…read morealways have great promotions going, and the staff is always friendly and knowledgeable. Their prices are reasonable and often times on your receipt. You will get a survey that you will get a Bogo for the next time you're in. New limited edition coconut cream is outstanding, and I'm not really a big fan of coconut either.

McGavin's Bakery

3.6

(83 reviews)

The big foot sugar cookie was delicious but the cupcakes were just ok. My husband did not like the…read morelemon crumble because he thought it would be like a lemon bar. Overall my family did not enjoy what they bought here. The person helping us did not seem happy to be there.

Cute little bakery love their champagne cupcake friendly staff been in business for a long timeread more

Wilson Patisserie

4.0

(7 reviews)

We were finally able to sample Wilson's baked goods at a local farmer's market. The cookies were…read morepretty good. The pastries were great. We look forward to trying more of their offerings at coming events - and were thrilled to hear they'd have a permanent home in the new McCormick Woods retail center. Pro-Tip: Eat the pastries the day you purchase them. Like many fresh baked goods, by the next day, they were not nearly as good.

We purchased 2 cherry oatmeal cookies at the Farmer's Market. We have had many cookies of this…read moretype (oatmeal/fruit combo) from many different bakeries that never seem to have adequate flavor balance--usually the oatmeal overwhelms the fruit. But these were exceptional--oatmeal was moist and tasty with brown sugar overtones and the cherry element added a key tart counterbalance. We will definitely look for Wilson Patisserie cookies when we are next in the area.

Dude's Donuts

3.7

(23 reviews)

I absolutely love Dude's Donuts! My daughter has celiac disease, and there isn't anywhere else…read morewhere she can actually go in and pick out a treat, especially something like a donut in Port Orchard. Most of the time, she has to watch everyone else get things she can't have or we have to search for a gluten-free option somewhere else. Dude's Donuts gives her a place where she can actually get excited about picking out a donut and feel included. That might seem like such a small thing, but when you have a kid with celiacs, it really isn't. Having a local place that offers gluten free treats she can enjoy means so much to our family. We are incredibly grateful to have them in Port Orchard!

While I'm not normally a fan of GF "healthy" donuts, Dudes Donuts did not join that category. We…read morevisited while doing the downtown boat scavenger hunt, and of course, my three year old could not resist the urge to want a donut. And who am I to say no? He got the basic sprinkle donut and he loved it. My wife and I were each able to snag a bite each and were pleasantly surprised how good it was. The inside of the shop looks great, wonderful service, and smelled amazing inside. Thank you!

Crumbl - Silverdale

3.5

(37 reviews)

Delicious 10/10 gonna get it every day and the flavors melt on my tounge and sink in my throat I…read moreneed it everyday crumbl isn't a little cookie its a life style

We came here for a birthday treat. We ordered the 4 pack. It was exactly what my son wanted for his…read morebirthday. He enjoyed all the cookies he chose. We used the kiosk and the service was a quick turn around. It's a small shop so it's very quiet.

Crumbl - Gig Harbor

4.0

(69 reviews)

Yummy cookies! Good variety. Good customer service. Convenient location. Easy to order.read more

Went to try and pick up some cookies for their "Free Thins Day" promotion twice (once at 3pm and…read moreonce at 7pm), both times came home empty handed. Our three kids were realling looking forward to it and we even promoted this amongst our friends. The first time they said they're "behind on baking cookies" and didn't have any to hand out, the second time they said "they ran out of cookies." This store is absolutely terrible. Don't participate in the franchise promotion if you're going to be cheap and sluggish about it. It only invite bad review (like this one and possibly more subsquent ones). There's plenty of other places to spend our money on desserts in Gig Harbor, this store won't be one of them.

Bon Bon Bakery

5.0

(2 reviews)