I go to the nutley diner for one reason and one reason only....DISCO FRIES Theres no magic to it, its french fries, brown gravy, and cheese...but they do it well. Anytime i need a snack or im craving some NJ diner staples i head to Nutley Diner and grab some disco fries, i get mine with their waffle fries and it takes me straight to heaven every time that steaming hot plate hits the table read more

During this crappie covid pandemic restaurants are struggling and need our support. The nutley diner is working hard to please its customers. Me and my family had breakfast here today. Waiters were extra attentive and the food was well prepared. Portions were generous, so we all left food. I plan on returning again. Keep up the great service. read more

Uninspired nonsense. Typical diner grub. The tuna salad platter was piled with potato salad and cole slaw. Way too much for one person to down in one sitting. Cajun shrimp po boy sandwich? Not good. Unseasoned, cornmeal breaded shrimp on a basic hero roll with lettuce, tomato, and Dijon mayo. The shrimp were flavorless...but the aioli was fine. Service was ok, but seemed like a new hire. A nice demeanor though was appreciated. There's plenty of these places around here. Go elsewhere. read more

Nutley Diner - Shrimp Po Boy - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

It is a really comfortable place to eat - varied menu- interesting wait staff. When I want something quick and dependable, this is my go to place. The front staff - cashier - person who seats you, etc - not very smiley or up beat - kind of distracted and not friendly - but I go for the food read more

Food at the Nutley Diner is Delicious! You must try their Cappuccino!!!! You won't be dissapointed... ITS THE BEST read more

See all

One of my favorite diners! Try the emerald isle or jalapeño breakfast bowl! Its HUGE and absolutely delicious. Their desserts are phenomenal as well. One of my favorite places to go for a lazy Sunday breakfast. Staff is also very fun and prices are super competitive. Give it a try! read more

Nutley Diner - Jalapeño breakfast bowl. - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

You get more for the money here than at some other diners. Good sized portions. I recently ordered a prime rib dinner for $21.99. The prime rib was huge, probably larger that what you would get in a steakhouse. read more

Nutley Diner - Another shot of the interior of the Nutley diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Been here a few times before and they never fail to impress with great service.. Presentation is on point and delicious... Best diner I've ever been to, service is 5 star... Highly recommended. read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Great food.. a lil pricey but not too bad.. food is always fresh and the desserts are excellent! read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Love this place breakfast lunch or dinner. If you are ill or have a cold get the Matzah ball soup. Monday is beefsteak bonanza!!!

We were looking for a classic diner experience and Nutley diner delivered! Yankee pot roast was great, purple cabbage was just the right touch to dish and my wife said the fish was really tasty! I would recommend them! read more

Nutley Diner - Yankee Pot Roast broiled fish - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

A can't miss if you're out in Nutley, they'll make your $ stretch with hefty portions. Friendly staff

Place is a typical diner. Decent selection, good service but there are better, cheaper places around. Not so much diners, but similar, especially for breakfast. read more

I recently had breakfast here and just had to say how great it was. I ordered a spinach, roasted red pepper and goat cheese omelet with chicken sausage and home fries. The omelet was delicious!!! I also was very excited to see chicken sausage, it's not something you see very often so this was a very refreshing surprise. The coffee was great and the prices were average. All in all, can't wait to go back. read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Always a good meal from here. Breakfast is very good too. Apple cinnamon pancakes are great ! Burgers - Very good Apps - Very good. French Dip and crispy fries with brown gravy and Mozzarella. - Great ! Open Turkey sandwich - Highly recommended. All the Triple Decker Club sandwiches are awesome. This is a Very good dinner in Essex county. TV's - Alcohol - Yes read more

I ordered soup to be delivered via Uber eats. I'm sick and wanted some soup delivered. Only writing this review to warn other Uber eats people. This place does not staple or put any kind of safety tape on your bags. So the driver is free to rummage through your food. So just a warning. I won't be ordering from here again for that reason alone. Matzoh ball soup was good though so it's unfortunate. Hopefully they'll make a change. read more

Not the best but not the worst had a burger with fries kids had breakfast. On a scale of 1-10 I'll give them a 4 for taste Very pricey food portions on the small side for what you're paying, I would not recommend unless you're in a pinch and there's nobody else open I wouldn't go back.... read more

My husband, four year old daughter and I come here all the time. It's definitely one of our favorites! They have so many food options and they always have great seasonal items. The staff is very friendly! This is definitely a great place to come with the family to just relax and have great conversation. It's very homey. read more

We had dinner last night at the Nutley Diner. The food was great and our waitress even better. Next time you stop in ask for Carol. The service will be great! read more

just a typical diner, nothing special at all. overpriced, boring options. if you need something classic and easy to decide then i guess go here, but not worth the prices at all. there are much better diner options around the area read more

Went there for the first time and the service was excellent you were waited on appropriately you didn't feel like you had to actually wait they were quick to take your order and so surprisingly quick to bring your food. I enjoyed a delicious Caprese Panini and my husband had a huge open face Ruben and we shared a delicious Caesar salad. I will absolutely be coming back as much as my husband will let me!! read more

This place was wonderful the waitress Anna was so attentive and just created the best vibe. The reason I gave this a star less is the host Omar spoke very degrading and disrespectfully towards the other staff. Made it quite uncomfortable for out 1st visit. Thank you Anna ! You are wonderful! read more

One of the best diners around, the staff is fantastic and the food is always quality if your in Nutley and enjoy doing new food this is the place to get it! Matthew DeFede Nutley Realtor read more

This diner was phenomenal however things change. The service was lousy they can blame it on Covid. The appetizers were Inferior I could've done better with Shoprite frozen appetizers. the Waldorf salad And meatloaf which were my fav. Epic disaster. I'd rather go to Tops diner and out of my way into Harrison for good food read more

Newly remodeled Park Diner is now the Nutley Diner. Clean and well lit, this Diner is totally new in appearance. The breakfast was very good and the menu choices had something for everyone. Server was attentive and very pleasant. Would certainly recommend Nutley Diner and would return when we come back to visit in NJ. read more

That Cheese Burger deluxe is BEST around!! No competition in my opinion!!! Always on point

Definitely more of a breakfast place than lunch or dinner. The homefries are delicious and the food comes out quickly. It's a very friendly environment and once you go a few times you are recognized quickly. Main meals can be a mix, really depends on the option. I definitely recommend for breakfast! read more

I've actually ordered from here a handful of times on Uber eats but never stepped inside the diner because it's not near my home. The food when i had ordered it, is always delicious so i decided to actually stop in on a Saturday morning for breakfast. Surprisingly there was no wait, which you don't expect for a weekend. The food is great, the service is good and the portions are really great for the price. Plenty of seating inside to choose from and has a good family owned vibe when you are inside. read more

Ordered the Protein Omelet. You get your money's worth here. Pretty good size selection on the menu for whatever you're in the mood for. I unfortunately for to take a picture but for 10$ you get a really good size omelet. Order took a little longer than expected. read more

This was my first experience at Nutley Diner and I can honestly say that the people who worked tonight were EXTREMELY racist! So tonight my friend and I went to this diner to have an enjoyable meal. My friend is a chef at 2 restaurants and I was once a server so we understand the business. The moment we walked in I asked the host if we could sit somewhere other than the window seat & she said "fine pick a place and I'll follow" but it was said with an attitude. My friend and I walked to the table we wanted to sit at and in the distance I heard her say to the manager and our server "they're trying to sit wherever they want". That should've been my cue to leave right then & there but my friend & I were hungry and chose to ignore her ignorance. (Just so you know sweetie, if you're reading this, a customer can choose where they want to sit if the restaurant is mainly empty & the section they've requested isn't closed). Our waiter comes up to us, older Italian or Spanish guy and does not introduce himself. He just asks if we're ready & has an attitude when we say we need a few minutes and storms off. Mind you, there were 3 white people sitting next to us and our "server" approached them way more times than he did our table. Normally when I was serving I would go to all my tables to make sure they were okay?... but I don't know, maybe that's just me. When we were giving our order he almost walked away and I had to call him over to let him know that we weren't done. The whole time when taking our order it was if he was in a rush and couldn't WAIT to get away from us... but where were you in a hurry to? There were only 3 other tables other than ours. Also, when he took our order he didn't write anything down. Normally that means you have an amazing memory right???... well not in this guy's case. He forgot certain details from my friend's order. My friend kindly let him know the mistake and the manager corrected it... well sort of. It still came out wrong the second time. Regardless, we let it go. After all we've worked in restaurants so we understood how certain things can get messed up (although we've worked in much bigger restaurants that were also 1000x busier). Although what I've already mentioned was a bit frightening in itself, the ABSOLUTE WORST PART OCCURRED ONCE WE RECEIVED THE BILL! The bill came up to $56.35 (nothing too expensive). When it was time to pay our server, let's just call him Screw Up since he never mentioned his name, was nowhere to be found for several minutes. Tell me, Screw Up, how could you disappear for over 20 minutes when the restaurant was as dead as it was? I'm sure you weren't THAT busy were you? We had to give the bill to the manager. The manager swiped the card and then my friend had to use the bathroom. Then the manager got skeptical and asked if I was done with the bill? What?! My friend just went to the bathroom and didn't even write the tip yet. You are open 24 hours, WHAT'S THE RUSH? When my friend got back we left a tip that was over 25%, which was not deserved at ALL, but it is something we have a habit of doing when we go out. When we were leaving out of the door there were about 5-6 other white people leaving out with us but the lady host looks at my friend and I and says "have a nice night" only and directly to us. Now if you are black I'm SURE you know what that means. In that moment I knew that when we stepped out I had to look through the windows to see if she would check to see how much we tipped. And just as I suspected, this girl walked RIGHT TO OUR TABLE, OPENED THE CHECK BOOK AND LOOKED AT THE TIP. For one, there are multiples wrong with this... 1) you were not our server, just our HOST! WHY WOULD YOU LOOK IN SOMEONE ELSE'S BOOK?! 2) a 5-6 party top filled with white people JUST LEFT right along side us, wouldn't it make sense for you to check their book? Seeing as how that was a MUCH bigger tip. My friend and I continued looking through the window and saw the server and the host talking around our table. This place is evil. And RACIST. They did not deserve a tip and they DAMN SURE DESERVE NO BLACK PERSON'S MONEY! Or anyone's money who ISN'T RACIST for that matter! I felt so strongly about what happened that I am here at 3:49 am writing this review. I hope this helps someone and prevents them from receiving poor customer service. Also, the food was subpar at best. I am a big fan of finding "hole in the wall" places with great food and amazing energy so I will be posting about those and reviewing them soon. xoxo Karyn read more

Wow the people who work here are so friendly and helpful and they have my favorite food chicken tenders and they have yummy looking desserts read more

See all

A great neighborhood diner. Friendly staff and food that is tasty. Breakfast is affordable & abundant. The French onion soup tasty & the burgers here are tasty and large. Never disappointed when eating here. They have their own parking lot on the side. At times it does get crowded, but wait if any is minimal. A great place to eat if you ever get the craving day or night. This place is open 24/7 and also has a nice selection of desserts. read more

Successor to the Park Diner, their skills with a soup pot have remained solid. This is a quiet and relaxing place to enjoy a meal, tainted only by the fact that not all of their food is enjoyable. For the most part it's standard diner food; knowing what not to order, and not placing too high an expectation, usually has its rewards. Service is, and has always been, a cut above-- David S's story is, however, remarkable. read more

This diner is slowly becoming one of my local favorites. It has what you want in a NJ diner, but they do it slightly better than the average diner - food is prepared well, large portions, good selection, welcoming service and open 24 hours a day. It's also always calm inside. Nobody yelling. I don't hear the staff's nor the other customers' conversations too much. This is especially good after a night out. I just want to eat my corned beef hash/ omelette/ burger in peace. read more

My family loves the Nutley Diner. We were slightly depressed when they remodeled because we liked the old diner look but it was getting a little ratty around the edges so it was needed. The soups are very good and their hamburgers are the BEST around. Breakfast is probably their best meal. Great coffee, fluffy pancakes and very good egg sandwiches. I've never had a bad meal here. No, it's not fine dining. If you want that, go somewhere else. read more

Happened to stop by here to kill some time until my car was ready from repair. Ordered a slice of sugar free cheesecake which came with mold on it. After pointing it out to the waitress and asking them to take it back, she came back and told me she would cut me a slice of the "fresh one". Since when is putting a slice of the "old one" the right way to go?! Thumbs down! read more

The servers are great, they really are. They are friendly, willing to make substitutions, ask the kitchen with any questions you may have. However, the food is pretty standard, mediocre fare. What was annoying was that the restaurant was pretty darned empty, and it still took forever for the food to come out of the kitchen. My garden salad had a whole lettuce stem in it (yes, the thick part that connects the leaves together), so it's not a salad comprised of Romain lettuce leaves, it's a salad comprised of Romain, edible and inedible. My Western omelet looked pretty darned good when it came out, but there were pieces of egg shell in it (I found out the morning after, when I was enjoying my leftovers). Completely made the remainder inedible, and ruined my appetite as well. The buffalo chicken sandwich was huge, but uninspired. Given the food, we will not be coming back here even though the service is very friendly. read more

This is Just Another Diner. It enjoys a good location in the center of town, it has plenty of parking, and it's pretty clean -- in fact, it looks new. The staff are friendly and got the orders right. That's the good news. The bad news, though, is that they didn't ask or offer toast choices, I had to pester the waitress for more coffee, for the water we ordered, for napkins that a table of three adults and four children would need... and I hate to pester wait staff, I really do. It's a tough job, largely thankless, but the deal is this: I never see the bottom of my coffee mug, napkins and water should flow freely, and don't fuck with my weekend breakfast. I get to eat one breakfast a week with my life's hectic schedule, so the bar is set high and many fail. This diner failed. Having vented, the food was good, a little pricey for the Eggs Benedict, but I liked the a la carte omelet options. Didn't like the 4 ounce "large" grapefruit juice, either: four ounces of anything other than cocaine should never be considered "large". Uneven, don't know if this diner gets a second shot, but there it is. -C read more

this has to be one of my favorite, if not my favorite in jersey. I got the French toast with Taylor ham and it was amazing. the service is fast, the people are nice. the Oreo pancakes are to die for. I also love how this place is right across the street from Rita's. after dinner we can grab some ice cream. anything you get from this diner will be delicious I promise you. read more

Nutley Diner - French toast with Taylor ham - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Good reliable food. Just about the only place open last night during the blizzard. Last night hubby had bagels and lox with cream cheese, he said it was very good. I got a patty melt and it was excellent. cooked rare just the way I Iike it with lots of cheese and onions and nicely grilled rye bread. This morning hubby had a goat cheese omelet with spinach, tomatoes, onions and home fries. He liked it very much. I got the cheese blintzes with warm blueberry compote and sour cream. Yummy delicious comfort food. The service here is very good. We are always greeted warmly and the servers are always attentive and helpful. And the diner is open 24/7. Can't beat that. read more

See all