Great service! Kimberly, our server, was prompt with our orders, she was very polite and courtious. The manager stopped by and checked on us twice. Everything tasted amazing. This was my boyfriends first time here and he was very impressed. Price was not bad at all! read more

I have enjoyed this pizza before here & in Surprise the service had been good until last time me and my family went we waited there for 40 minutes dine in of course and no pizza finally a manager noticed we were waiting there and came up and just said sorry; we forgot your pizza, I feel we were discriminated because we were the only Hispanics there.... Anyways I still left the tip and just told them to box it up I was going home by the way the pizza was free but was not worth the 40 minute wait:-( read more

After living in the valley for over 10 years I finally made my way to Avondale recently while scoping out locations for my next Hawaiian Experience Spa. One day I stopped at NYPD pizza for lunch and it was so good I went back again when I was back in Avondale a few days later. The service was quick and friendly and the menu had lots of options. My wife got a Strawberry Fields? salad because she is watching calories and she loved it. It really looked good. I tried the margarita pizza the first time and the bruschetta pizza the second time. Both where excellent. There is a bar but it was lunch time and we were working so we just got water. :( Speaking of lunch, there is a lunch menu M-F which has pizza by the slice. If we open a new day spa in Avondale or a new day spa in Goodyear (which is a block away) NYPD Pizza looks like it will become a regular stop for us. Give it a try. read more

First time I came here I got a calzone. Didn't like it cause it had ricotta cheese. I was not used to that. Next I tried the pizza and I love the Brooklyn pizza. Also tried the pasta these were ok not bad not great. Do like that fact they are a Pepsi affiliate restaurant. And the family all LOVES the zeppolis. read more

The soho salad is awesome and pizza is great. It's priced a bit higher than most pizza places (minus 1 star), but we continue to go because it is so much better than others. I think I could eat the soho salad every day! read more

After my previous review i was reached out to by the manager of this location who apologized and gave me a gift certificate to come back and have a better experience. Now i am very impressed. Not just with the way that they handled everything but how much they care about their customers. They make sure every issue big or small is resolved and strive for excellence. Good job goodyear NYPD!!! I am a regular customer and i love the food but theyve exceed my expectations this time read more

Have ate there quite a few times love the Greek salad and always get the works pizza!! Never have been disappointed and my husband likes it too read more

Came in on a Thursday night and had super good service by Kimberly!!!!! Super sweet with a great attitude. Great pizza too!!!! Will be back.

really good pizza when I'm in the mood I wish you had a deep dish pizza because with your ingredients it would be amazing read more

Being from queens New York and I say with absolute confidence this tastes just like the pizzeria pizza from NYC, best pizza in arizona hands down! read more

Love everything from the salad to the Hell's Kitchen wings and the best pizza. Ordering take out is a breeze and dining in is great too. A little bit pricey but superior quality. They have a good happy hour too! read more

Okay, so before I even get into how awesome the food is, I really have to stress how great of service I experienced from our server, Keith. Honestly, truly. From the moment my husband and I got sat at our table outside (and we were the only ones outside), Keith was super attentive to our needs. The service was quick, and not once did he forget about us or let our drinks ever get empty. He was very kind, and has a great personality. We really didn't even need to ask for much because he was already on top of it! It was just a plus that our food came out to us hot and fresh. I really do wish I could give Keith and this restaurant 10 stars because everyone we interacted with provided exceptional customer service. Thank you NYPD and Keith!! read more

NYPD Pizza - The best! - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

I absolutely love the pizza! Makes me feel like Im home in NY. My only complaint is the phone crew. I have to repeat everything what seems 15 times before they get it correct. read more

Pizza is awsome. Crust is delious. They have a wide variety of pizza. I get something different each time and I was never disappointed. Wings n garlic bread are great too. Service is wonderful. read more

Excellent! Great pizza begins with the dough. This place has it nailed down. The Hot wings are amazing as well. Just order anything and it'll be great. read more

Love this place specifically for their cicillian pizza. I love that you can take out or eat in and it feels like a fancy restaurant. Good service. And not too expensive. Definitely recommend read more

Delicious food. I recommend the Calzones, they are massive and full of flavor. One of my few favorite pizza joints in Arizona.

Moved here from Chicago via St. Louis one year ago. Pizza is one of my favorite meals and St. Louis is not the place for good pizza, HOWEVER, NYPD in Avondale at McDowell and Dysart is AWESOME ! ! ! We were there last night for the first time and definitely will return, OFTEN... our server was Tennille, better known as NeeNee. A girl with a beautiful smile, outstanding attitude, and excellent menu knowledge. She truly made my wife and I feel very welcome. The food was just GREAT ! ! Simple sausage pizza for me and the Brooklyn Pizza for my wife and we shared and loved both. Also, the Broadway Bruschetta was fantastic for an appetizer. This is a "Don't Miss" place. read more

Pretty good pizza spot. Beer was ice cold and the server was nice and on top of his game. Will go back.

Had a really great dinner tonight and our server Keith made the evening even better! Ravioli was great, meat lover's pizza was great, fried zucchini was great.. thanks for the suggestion Keith and for the great service! read more

Ordered pizza and a salad to my hotel. Everyone was very friendly. But honestly the pizza was pretty average. Wasn't bad but wasn't anything great either. I would eat it again, but I would try others before I did. They did bring cups and plates like I asked. So that was nice. read more

The closest thing I've found to good pizza since I moved to Arizona. I grew up in NY so I consider myself a bit of a pizza snob. I had very low hopes when I ordered from here. Every other local place had been very disappointing. The delivery was very quick. The pizza was pretty great. Their upstate (buffalo) wings were also true to NY. The only reason I dinged them a star because their prices. While you do get a lot of food and great pizza almost $40 for pizza and wings is way too much. I'll be ordering from them again. But I'll be ordering a small pizza and only saving wings for a special occasion. read more

Had a good lunch at NYPD Pizza. Had to try their new fried mozzarella. They were actually square shaped. I've never seen that before. They fell apart a little bit as we ate them because they are hand breaded and the juices were leaking out onto our hands. But they were good with the marinara. Not really seasoned, just simple. Pricey though... $7.99 for 3 squares! We ordered a medium 16" pizza with half pepperoni, half cheese. I liked that the crust was thin, yet soft. Sprinkled on some parmesan & oregano for added flavor. Good pizza. Our server was attentive and kept our drinks refilled. A $30 lunch for two isn't cheap, but we enjoyed it and had leftovers to take home, so I'm happy. read more

I must say I was very impressed by how the staff treated me. I came in 5 minutes before they were getting ready to close. I thought they closed at 10pm not 9pm. I ask if it was okay to still fine in and if not I wouldn't be offended and I totally understood. They we're so kind and said absolutely you can order and they didn't serve me attitude or give me the "look". A young lady named Mary Anne was extremely pleasant and made me feel comfortable and assured me I didn't need to rush but could sit and enjoy my pizza! She checked on me to make sure I was doing well and even gave me a to go cup for soda when I was ready to leave. Of course I ate faster than normal because I felt so bad but they were all so nice... I really appreciated their kindness after a long day... Good service is hard to find in Goodyear but I know where you won't be disappointed NY PD in Avondale! Very professional! Oh the pizza was perfect!! Glenda read more

My husband likes the pizza. I ordered pasta primavera. Tasted very fresh however it had no real flavor. Since we carried out it doctored myself. read more

Ok ignore my previous post. Nikki and the crew completely made up for the issues we had. I'm definitely a fan. My dad and the rest of my family enjoyed it. Light crust, but crisp, very cheesy it was so good. I'll definitely be back to this location even though there's one closer to me lol. read more

I don't know about it's authenticity as a "New York pizza restaurant" but the food is pretty good and so is the service. I thought the Sicilian pizza was a little on the expensive side ($19 for half which came out to about 6 square slices) but I haven't had Sicilian pizza enough times to know if the price is par with other places. read more

I loved our server. He had no idea what he was talking about when it came to beer/wine, but he was extremely friendly, paid us plenty of attention (but not too much), made us feel welcomed, and made our experience here wonderful. The pizza? PHENOMENAL. We got the Pizza Blanca and Vinny's Choice, both were cooked to perfection with a good balance of spices. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and this home-cooked meal --while more expensive than regular chain-store pizza-- more than lives up to its price with its outstanding flavor. Also, for the beer drinkers, the selection is limited, but their happy hour deals are exceptional. Will definitely be back. read more

Favorite pizza place out of all the ones we've tried in the area. Great, fast service and fantastic pizza! Friendly, attentive staff and a great atmosphere! Try the garlic cheese knots with marinara and the house made ranch! Two thumbs way up! read more

First time here. Our server Hector was in training but I have to say the service was flawless! Large servings, cold beer, immediate seating. We will be back! read more

My family goes here almost once a week and we love it. The staff is super friendly and nice to our young son. I love all their salads and my picky pizza eater husband loves their pizza. read more

A fave pizza place in the valley. The whole family loves it! I prefer to dine in as when we've had it delivered its never been hot enough. But it sure is yummy! The cheese is my faaaaaave! read more

Love this place! Pizza is absolutely delicious!!! Definitely recommend the garlic knots and zeppolis are addicting!!! Wednesday and Sunday's after 4pm, kids eat free!!! The staff here are so friendly!!! S/o to Tennille! read more

Went there for lunch today. Service was excellent and pizza was delicious! We will definitely be back. Highly recommend the bruchetta pizza and garlic knots. read more

Pretty bad pizza. Under cooked dough covered in cheep cheese. Their crust is crap. I wish I would gone somewhere else for lunch for $30 I'm sure I could have found a better meal. read more

TERRIBLE!!! I ordered a meal that cost me about $30 after the delivery fee. The food was disgusting!!! It was overcooked, and the Styrofoam had even melted. During the order, I asked them to replace marinara sauce with alfredo sauce for the Chicken Parmagiana - and it was smothered but tasted gross!! I also got zucchini sticks, and they were all soggy. I will NEVER order from this place again, because after the 1 hr. 15 minute wait, I was highly disappointed. I would not recommend ordering online, or even eating there for that matter. read more

Our server Nicole was fantastic. This was our first time in this restuarant and she was extremely informative and attentive. Food was pretty good too. Great service Nicole. We'll be back . read more

Their pizza is the best I've tasted. Their prices are slightly high, but it's worth it the pizza and pasta is so good. Make sure to save room for the zeppolies (sp).... They are to die for. My favorite is the raspberry sauce. read more

We just got home from our first time at NYPD Pizza. We heard that they serve vegan pizzas so we had to go try it out. We were expecting more of a typical pizzeria atmosphere...much more casual and just a few tables. It is very nicely laid out and decorated. The staff was very friendly to us and to all of the other customers. In addition to that, they seemed to be enjoying themselves while working. We ordered two of the My-za pizzas (each serves one). One was the "Veganizza", with Daiya "cheese", Roma tomatoes, spinach, basil, and garlic. The other was a build your own and had Daiya "cheese", mushrooms, red onions, and green peppers. They were both DELICIOUS!! They were very flavorful and seasoned very nicely. We will definitely be going back. read more

Okay this is the second time that I've been to New York Pizza Department and I have to say they got it right this time. Excellent flavor, plus they made it to order excellent crust and we really liked it. I would highly recommend this pizza parlor. I had some issues the first time but the management made it right with no stress or hassles thank you Josh and Angle. read more