Walked in around 5 on a Friday. Few people at bar and no one sitting. We stood there awkwardly before the bartender noticed and said sit anywhere. We sat there and sat there and sat there. I finally asked for a menu and the bartender got the waitress. Waitress came over visibly aggravated. She threw the specials on the table. Didn't know the beer selection. Just overall rude. No smiling. We almost walked out. On the plus side food was excellent but pricey. $20 burger and fries. read more

Best kept chicken wings secret that needs to be shared. Amazingly delicious homemade chicken wing sauce that is a must to try! Great fish fry's too. Check'em out! Great atmosphere, people and service too! read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - Single order of hot wings extra crispy and extra saucey - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

Bridget our server was great especially since she was was taking care of every table Garlic parm fish was outstanding read more

Great food and service!! Not super big inside but we were seated in a booth on a Friday night as soon as we walked in. They had some Oktoberfest specials so I got the Wiener schnitzel which was lightly breaded veal with gravy and came with red cabbage and spaetzle, it was absolutely delicious, and I'm German so I've had it many places, this one was great! My husband had the beer battered fish fry and his mom had the beer battered shrimp dinner, both were great but the shrimp were so unique and really tasty so I'd say try them if you get the chance! Overall a wonderful casual neighborhood place for dinner with great food! read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - Beer battered fish fry - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

See all

The service was friendly and efficient. It's a great location. The banana peppers were great! My friend also got a fish fry to go which they normally can't do but they were able to make it happen read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - Banana Peppers - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

Good food, Service, ambiance. Well stocked bar and the meals are better than bar food. Nice corner bar locals joint read more

So disappointed. The fish fry looked amazing when it came to the table. It was the worst I have ever had. Mushy and flavorless. It tasted as if it sat in water all day. However the butter parsley potatoes were very good. They also only had 1 server, serving 9 or 10 tables during peak dinner (6:30p) . They did offer me something else, but by that time it was too late, since my.husband was almost finished with his meal. read more

Went to dinner here at 6pm on a Wednesday. The establishment is a smallish one story building with an attractive partially covered patio and a private parking lot that holds around thirty cars including one accessible space. The interior is that of an attractive neighborhood tavern. There are around nine tables as well as bar seating. We entered through a small vestibule with fancy double wood and glass doors and joined another couple already seated in a booth overlooking Abbott Rd. The restaurant was moderately busy with a staff of three (cook, waitress, bartender) serving the patrons. The waitress, Lauren, warmly greeted us and took our drink orders. I ordered a Guinness on tap, others ordered a bottled beer, red wine or mixed drink. The drinks were served within eight minutes at which time Lauren took our food order. The drinks were as ordered and satisfactory to all. I ordered ten wings (single) medium while my wife ordered a burger with fries and a small salad. The other couple each ordered a steak sandwich. The food orders were served fifteen minutes later, exactly as ordered. My wings were crispy and tasty. The burger was ok with crispy fries. The other couples steak sandwiches looked good ( maybe next time). Our salad was simple but fresh. Lauren was attentive and pleasant. They only accept cash for payment. The crowd there appears to be mostly regulars that seem to have a sense of ownership, a man standing at the bar near our table spilled part of his beer on the floor and immediately went and got a wet mop and cleaned the tile floor. All in all a very pleasant dining experience. We will surely return. read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - Menu -October 2021 - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

See all

When you are here you feel like family. After a long day I needed a good comforting meal. I walked in and was warmly greeted by the owner and was served in a timely manner. I was in no rush at all and could really just sit and relax and the place allowed me to just soak it all in. I am in upstate New York so I had to get some Buffalo Wings to add to my wing tour and theirs are among the top. Perfectly crunchy with a good amount of sauce that doesn't leave you too thirsty. I got the special panini and it was incredibly satisfying. The meat was juicy and not chewy at all. The bread was not too crunchy and added good texture with the meat. The French fries are a must get. They are seasoned well and have a good snap to it as well. This is a local bar and has everything your favorite neighborhood dive bar has to offer. When you are in the area or if you are looking for a place to watch the Bills on game day be sure to go to O'Daniels read more

See all

I have never had a bad lunch or dinner here. The owner is awesome and accommodating. The food is always served piping hot. There are daily "specials" and a nice sized menu. The staff is friendly and helpful. If you've been here a few times, they'll remember you and what you usually order. Bring cash. No credit cards. It is a typical tavern restaurant: a few booths at the front and quads further back. It is a smallish space - cozy. There are a couple tables that will accommodate 6 or more at the owner's/management discretion. (Like I said, he tries very hard to be as accommodating as possible.) Friday's, especially during lent, are jam packed probably because the food is so good. With that said, parking in their lot may be an issue on those Fridays. There is an adjoining residential street available to park. read more

Visiting family and needed a good Buffalo fish fry and I wasn't disappointed. read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

Wow, I was pleasantly surprised by this place. I've driven by this place hundreds of times and never stopped in, but was recommended to come here by a colleague. You walk in and there was a bar and some booths to the left. We sat in the furthest back area as we were there with my Mom. The music was way too loud, which was annoying. I did ask them to turn it down and it was still really loud, which I found odd because it didn't seem like there was any need for that. We enjoyed a crock of french onion soup which was delightful. Plenty of cheese and bread and a nice flavored broth. I split the turkey club, which they used real roast turkey. It was more than enough even splitting the sandwich. My sister ordered the chicken satay with sauce which was very good. She thought it was spicy, but I did not. The waitress was good. Looks like they might have a nice porch in the summer. Be careful, the parking lot was very icy, but it was a cold day. I would go back, but I wish the music was not so loud, that was a turn-off. read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - French onion soup - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

Delicious food & great service. My favorites are the chicken fingers, burgers, wings and French Onion soup. Great neighborhood pub.

Heres a quick review of O' Daniels Gin Mill and Grill I don't do this but god damn was it bad, I literally feel sick. so first my drink, vodka ginger ale was horrible, the ginger ale was taped, still was served knowingly, whatever asked for redbull, no Redbull so vodka sprite it is,.. 3 flys in my drink... bartender even said she was "warning people of the dirty taps".. I should've left... On to food, order peppers, no peppers ok French onion soup, bitter and sour tasted weeks old.... My broiled fish, well it must've been broiled for an hour cause it was hard as stone tasted bland.... Asked for fries was given soggy red potatoes I wouldn't serve this shit to death row... I threw a 20 on the bar in good faith and got the heck out Also the cook should have been wearing a mask... Edit: So I went back and took a picture of the Person who was supposedly the owner he Was wearing no mask, I took his picture and left. He Then chased me out and physically assaulted me and demanded I paid for my tab. I said fine and informed him thay I had already left $20 (aparently there is no cameras) He insisted on calling the police. I'm fine as I did nothing wrong and he assaulted me. the police came and a 1st they were fine and understood Until his buddy cop showed up And threatened to arrest me unless I paid him his money wouldnt even listen to me so I gave him the money And left, never to come back.. Just to be followed by the police into Walgreens where I was going to buy a water for my walk home And was harassed For my name address and date of birth. I was made to feel like a criminal when all I wanted was decent food and service. Share so everyone knows how trash they are Edit: The food poisoning is real, read more

O'Daniels Ginmill & Grill - Cook/ owner caught not wearing mask! - Bars Near Me - Lackawanna, New York

Came in tonight and found out that they have a different menu on Friday's. Ok well I don't like seafood but my fiance does. He ordered a appetizer the stuffed mushrooms which were watery and cold. I ate half of one he ate the other three and a half. Ps he'll eat anything. He ordered the seafood platter. Scallops shrimp with penne pasta and swimming in butter. I ordered chicken fingers. Food was just ok. As we waited we were seated near the waitress station and on two occasions watched a waitress (not our waitress) bring customer orders to the station and picked up the fish and French fries with her hands to place into the to go container. Gross doesn't she know how dirty money is etc. I had two chicken fingers left and a handful of fries. When the waitress asked if she could box it up my fiance said "no thats ok I'll do it" Not sure we'll be back. read more

Wonderful visit to O'Daniels for lunch with work associates. Great and friendly service by Tracy, very good selection, soup, fish chowder was excellent! Engaging crowd with excellent lunch selections and all were delicious. A fun visit with many laughs and we'll definitely be going back! read more

Warning, only accepts cash! Stopped by today for dinner, walked out. Owner behind bar is a total jerk. I've been here before, food is mediocre, people behind bar are always unfriendly and have tons of rules. It's simply their way or the highway...so this evening, highway! read more

A great place to go for a relaxing, casual evening. The burgers and wings are great but don't forget to try the salads...I had one last night and was pleasantly surprised! The only improvement that I would really make to this restaurant/bar...Guinness. read more

We had a great time at the bar and eating apps. The bartender (I cant remember his name, his Uncle owns it and he's a firefighter and bartends on the side) - anyway he was really great. We came in on a quiet Monday after a family funeral over the weekend so we were all ready to unwind and visit a bit with each other. The bartender was great, unobtrusive and the food was very good and the prices were great. Thanks ! The French onion soup was the bomb. read more

Home of my favorite Friday Night Fish Fry! Something about the batter is slightly sweet. Always crisped to perfection! Served with several sides. Wonderful staff, moderately priced, and very clean. read more

Wife got a recommendation to check this place out. Was definitely happy with our meal here. Atmosphere is like a cross between a pub and Italian restaurant, with some yellow walls that brighten the place up with a lively feel. We sat in the booths up front but the patio looked especially nice, not very big and was full with only tables in sun left. For food we tried 3 things their burger for my son, a pot roast panini special for wife, and I the bleu raspberry steak. Steak came with a soup choice, I got the french onion also a potato choice which i got the butter parsley. Fries with both other orders. I think you can judge a place by their french onion soup and this one was good. So credit there. The steak itself was only OK though, ordered because it came with bleu cheese crumbles and a raspberry brandy sauce. But the butter potatoes literally left a big pool of butter on my plate to which the steak was then in, so couldn't taste to much raspberry brandy sauce. Was only cooked OK too, would like a little more char outside and rare in middle. If you like lots of butter potatoes were good. For $13.95 I'm not really complaining about it, but was my least favorite of the three because the burger and pot roast panini were phenomenal. Burger is totally homemade style, cooked medium well to perfection with slight char on outside but still moist in center. Panini was super tasty pot roast with with the crunch of the panini adding to the whole flavor. Other bonus was some good beer on tap (Got Brooklyn Brown for my meal). Also Service, I think there was one waitress working about 6 tables and she was on point for our whole meal. Friendly to my son, great timing seating us, getting order, asking how meal was, getting bill. Our waitress from Polish Villa II last week could learn a thing from this seasoned pro. Would definitely check this place out. read more

Local tavern I'd come back to again and again. Food was of excellent quality and the service was equally as good. I had the Kevin Seafood Collage special during my last visit which was prepared very well and a nice sized portion to boot. Kudos to Chris and his staff! read more

A nice neighborhood bar and eats. Clean, friendly...the wings are solid. Slow down take it easy and and enjoy

Caribbean Pork sandwich and Turkey Club are the best. Service and food are outstanding anytime we stop.

Great wings, great bartenders every day of the week. This place has character. The people who show up there to drink are good people. Owner Chris will always have dinner nice words with you. Wings and the sauce are very special, however, the rest of the menu is just as good (especially the fish fry on Fridays). From the Spring to early fall you can sometimes catch a game of ring outside on the patio. Music is good, better when somebody's not paying the juke. read more

This is a great and chill place to come and have a drink and/or dinner. Friendly staff and good food with fair prices. I will definitely be back! read more

Not impressed...a few booths by the drafty door...and a few tables write on top of the bar...cheeseburger was mushy and tasteless....fish fry was watery and so tasteless...a running theme for our dinner...will not return. read more

We sat for a late lunch/dinner on a Sunday. Table of 6 and there was only one server and one bartender working. We started with the crab and artichoke bread, which was awesome! The entrees weren't anything special, my boyfriend had the Caribbean pork loin sandwich that was recommended to him, he said it was good and very tasty but nothing special. I had the grilled chicken sandwich, plain. The drinks were TINY and expensive. read more

Good food, great prices and very friendly and attentive service. Where this place falls short, however, is the bar. As an avid lover of gin, I was excited to stop in and grab cocktails with dinner. I ordered a Tom Collins, which was not made according to any recipe I'd ever seen, and was much too sweet. So instead I ordered a gin rickey, which neither the bartender nor server knew how to make. It seems to me, that if a place is going to tout itself as a gin mill, the staff should have a decent knowledge of at least basic gin drinks. Great for dinner, not so much for drinks. read more

Beware! We were apparently given old menus so when the bill came we had been charged about $14 more than expected. I brought this up to the owner who simple said "Would you have still ordered what you did?" Well, actually, no I wouldn't have. When I told him I didn't appreciate being deceived he started walking away. Nice customer service! Even the waitress agreed this was terrible service. I guess he doesn't need repeat read more

Two of us had the chicken sandwich special it was very good. The other two of us had the turkey club which was recommended. They only had wheat or rye bread as the choices very little turkey or bacon. It was good and i was fine with the bread choices the other person was not. Wouldn't rush back not much of anything on the menu that i couldn't get somewhere else read more

Awesome food, beer selection and atmosphere. Fresh food and an ever changing menu. Seafood and steak dishes are excellent. Pub food is spot on. Quality beers for the craft beer fan. Hard to get a table on a Friday or Saturday, but it's worth the wait. The best outdoor dining space in South Buffalo. A gem. read more

Great restaurant. I suggest you try one of their daily specials. It is truly a friendly neighborhood place.

Nice and cozy spot for lunch, dinner or just drinks. Right in Lackawanna close to the south buffalo it's the best bar to eat at in the steel city. The Caribbean pork loin sandwich is really good, soups are hot and tasty. Nice atmosphere and a pleasant staff. Caesar salad isn't great, I didn't like the dressing, but the salad was huge. The place is frequented by nicer people and not the usual rough crowd you might find close by. read more

Food was ok, nothing super special. Just an average burger, peppers were good. We thought it was strange that our server wore flip-flops, then never told us her shift was ending. A different server came over to ask how our food was as we were about finished eating as we saw our server walk into the parking lot. The first booth we sat at was either dirty or stained with rings from glasses. read more