Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa

    3.6 (201 reviews)
    Open • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa Takeout or Delivery

    Services - Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa

    Catering services

    Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa Photos

    Business Info

    OLD SHAWNEE PIZZA-LENEXA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa

    Recommended Reviews - Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Cannoli
    Amanda P.

    Checked out OSP in Lenexa and I would go back again and for that Rangoon dip they have!! It's absolutely delicious. We half & halfed 2 pizzas and tried 4 kinds. Their pepperoni is so good! Good flavor on good crust. The margarita was delicious also! Their luau was okay. I do really like their crust. Not too thin and crispy enough. The cannolis were okay. The staff were super nice and it gives a woody bar vibe.

    Chi H.

    Pizza here is so fresh and worth it. I enjoyed the vibes here and it's always a pack here whenever we come in. Friendly staff as always. They got daily deals and lots of drinks to choose from too. Would come back again.

    Cannoli (1)
    Jauwan S.

    The service and atmosphere was great. Family friendly. The food was hot and delicious and the menu had a great selection.

    Joe K.

    I was going back and forth between a 3 and a 4. We came here after a dinner for some night caps but I couldn't help order some pizza since I love pizza and it's in the name of the restaurant. We ordered two whiskey flights and a small personal pizza as a snack to soak up the whiskey even though we just ate . It was a pretty chill environment but we came later in the night so I don't know how normally weekend nights are for this establishment. I will say they had the best whiskey collection I have seen! They have everything you can imagine from rare and allocated products. Our waitress was having a long, tough night but she was super sweet. The pizza came out fresh and hot. Since it was smaller, it reminded me of pizza I made at home but I will say that it had a nice crust. Topping, cheese, and base wise was fine but the crunchy cracker like crust was solid. I will probably be back here to try a larger pizza to get the true experience and also definitely for the whiskey flight specials like on Wednesday. Tequila will be on Tuesday I hear.

    Large (14") Pepperoni Pizza

    See all

    Photo of T D.
    0
    1
    0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 6 of 6

    Ask the Community - Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa

    You might also consider

    Buenos Aires - Taste of Argentina (first serving)

    Buenos Aires

    4.0(36 reviews)
    7.7 mi

    I ordered ahead of time to get food to go. Upon entering I was a bit confused about the restaurant…read more, there is a seating area up front for while you wait. The menu looks like there are a lot of options both food and drinks. I will go back and eat there when I have more time to do so. The food I got was good and had good flavors.

    There's something suspicious about the reviews for Buenos Aires Restaurant in Shawnee. They're…read moreeither glowing five-star praises or scathing one-star warnings. My experience leans toward the latter, though I'm giving it two stars solely because our server was kind and genuinely tried his best. I initially asked for a cocktail menu, having seen several drinks featured on their Facebook page. The waiter informed me they don't have a bar, had just gotten their liquor license, and could only make a drink if I provided a recipe. That was a red flag. He ended up calling the owner, who texted over a few recipes. At that point, we settled for sangria because I didn't feel comfortable letting someone wing a cocktail from memory. Then came the next blow: they were out of all steak items and all desserts. This was frustrating, especially after ordering a pitcher of sangria under the assumption we'd be enjoying a full meal. We ordered the "Taste of Argentina" to sample a variety. The first dish to arrive was an empanada and it was passable, but the filling was slightly cold, clearly reheated, likely in an air fryer. That was fine. Next came a plate with a basic ham and cheese sandwich, a small salad, and potato salad. The sandwich was generic, something you'd expect from a deli cooler, though the salad was fresh. The second plate was, frankly, inedible. Everything tasted like it had just come out of a microwave. The pizza was soggy, the chicken with cheese was flavorless, and another meat-and-cheese item had a strange, off-putting taste and again, cold in the center. The only remotely decent thing was a sausage sandwich, which was just okay. What baffles me is that it wasn't even busy. It was just one other table occupied, so there's really no excuse for this low level of quality. For a $40 sampler plate and a $40 pitcher of sangria, we received maybe $5 worth of food, both in taste and presentation. I won't be returning, and frankly, I'm confused by the flood of five-star reviews. Based on our experience, they do not reflect reality.

    Photos
    Buenos Aires - Dessert table to left as you enter. Similar one to the right.

    Dessert table to left as you enter. Similar one to the right.

    Buenos Aires - Our tea assortment of sweets and savories

    Our tea assortment of sweets and savories

    Buenos Aires - The space

    See all

    The space

    Pizza Man - Vienna beef dog. Legit snap. Perfect steamed poppyseed buns!  Takes me back to Chicago. Atomic green relish!!  So good!

    Pizza Man

    4.3(167 reviews)
    3.8 mi
    •$

    A bunch of amazing Yelpers, including Steve D, love this place and left amazing reviews. I see why…read more Pizza Man was my choice for lunch today. Having had pizza just a day or two ago I decided to scratch my itch for a Chicago dog. This one was pretty good. I am a purist for the Chicago dog, having lived in the area for a short time. This one is spot on. It's exactly everything that it should be; nothing more and nothing less. If there's a better Chicago dog in the KC Metro, I don't know about it. In my opinion, the Polish sausage with sauerkraut is not only the best deal on the menu, but it is absolutely perfect! They asked me if I wanted a spicy mustard on it and of course that is an automatic yes. The sausage itself was beefy and substantial, and the kraut was excellent and just the right amount. Plenty to taste, but not falling off. Having seen others, enjoying their pizza and Italian beef, I will absolutely return to try at least the beef. Buona in Chicago is my favorite so I look forward to seeing how this stacks up.

    Got here just as they opened on a Saturday. The service was friendly and efficient as always…read more The food here is always good. I ordered my usual Chicago Dog plus an Italian Beef sandwich. The food and service here rate high, but the booths could use an update. In each booth I have sat in, the seat cushions are so worn and broke down that one is sitting on the wood frame. However, this slight inconvenience will not stop me from returning.

    Photos
    Pizza Man - 11/19/2025 inside

    11/19/2025 inside

    Pizza Man - Italian Beef Sandwich and small Cheeseburger pizza.

    Italian Beef Sandwich and small Cheeseburger pizza.

    Pizza Man - Entrance

    See all

    Entrance

    Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - italian - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...