This is our go to pizza place. The pizza is always delicious and the wings are usually great as well. We've also gotten the mozzarella sticks on numerous occasions, and the chicken parm is on fire as well. The place is family run and everyone who works there is super friendly. The lunch specials are a perfect amount of food and decently priced (about 10 bucks for slice, wings and large drink) my favorite is the slice special (pepperoni, sausage mushrooms onions peppers) and hot wing combo. read more

Original #1 Brothers Pizza - Hot wings and slice special - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Ordered a cheese pizza with 5 wings extra crispy for $8.99 it was worth every single penny if you love thin crust and hot buffalo. They offer beer on tap and subs, sides and salads. Small location however clean facility and attentive, friendly service. read more

See all

Best NY style pizza in the valley, hands down! I've been coming here for over 20 years.... They never disappoint! I recommend everything, but pizza, wings, and a beer are a must! If you can stay, I would recommend it... It's a nice little spot. You can eat, drink, watch some sports. The service is always to friendly and fun. And they make it how you want it. Extra, crispy... no problem! Family owned and operated, and you can taste it in the food. I come here to get my dough when I make pizza at home too. No matter what you need, they always take care of you. Can't recommend this place enough. read more

Stopped by after escape room challenge, perfect spot and across the parking lot so just a short walking distance. They have so many combo specials, pizza, wings, pitcher options. We tried out the classic: Pepperoni pizza Bbq/hot wings mozzarella sticks Pitcher of beer Pitcher of lemonade House salad Nostalgia at its best, background music dear Delilah! Large big booths, perfect for groups and families! Lots of space, very clean good food Price's incredible! Our total was $70 split 4 ways $18 a person Great value and variety Wood definitely would cone back after the escape room again! Service was amazing, very courageous and super speedy! read more

See all

Sorry not sorry,come on I know times are hard for everybody but four little tiny meatballs surrounded by this normal size bread I swear I could have paid half the price and went to Subway for a meatball sandwich this is not a New York place in Arizona this is an Arizona place in Arizona anyone who Compares it to a New York slice is out of their minds Pizza by Napoli on 35th Avenue is way better but needless to say I asked for a chicken parmesan hero and they don't even make their chicken in house they get Cisco chicken that's already pre-cooked and pre breaded so if you take a bite the breading flies off the chicken cuz it's not homemade and it's processed garbage and you pay like his homemade I'm tired of this these places they would never last 30 seconds in New York I'm sorry but an honest review very disappointed do better make chicken cutlets in house put 6 small meat balls come on guy I hate to leave a bad review but its my 3rd time getting different menu items and all 3 were lackluster and kinda sorry I spent money for pre-made crap read more

Original #1 Brothers Pizza - 4 tiny meet balls lost in regular sized bread - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

I used to go to these guys when they were in Avondale (?) moved a bit north and found they opened a shop less than a mile away. I missed my NY style Sicilian pizza and asked if they could make me one, "No Problemo!" Bottom line, it cost too much and was absolutely awful. Haven't been back since. I can't describe how it was so bad. I've had Sicilian pizza for MANY YEARS, authentic and New York Style and went dry when I came to Phoenix where they're had at the time "Straw Hat Pizza", "Streets of New York" (also awful), and several others and was glad to hear that someone close could make a NY SICILIAN pie! Fuggetaboutit...sorry guys, there are many others that can do what is ordered. read more

Love being able to support local, family operated businesses in the Valley! And Brothers Pizza is pretty dang good pizza! If you are from New England and miss that style of pizza, it's very reminiscent of the kinds of pizza we could get back east. We came in on a Sunday afternoon and there were some patrons eating lunch and watching the football game. Plenty of seating! Friendly service, relatively fast food-to-table, and the food was quite good. I really enjoyed the pizza. I had a bite of one of their subs, and thought it was okay (nothing special but a good honest sandwich). Really impressed with the good pricing! I always prefer to dine and shop local, and I usually have to expect a higher price tag to come with it. However, I was pleased to see that they have very reasonable prices! We will for sure be back when we are near this side of town! read more

Pizza always comes out perfect. Usually get a pie once a week and have been going here for a couple years now. Only downside is no delivery but that's manageable. read more

If you like pizza this is my favorite pizza place! I've been coming here for over 20 years and I love it every single time! The wings are amazing (extra crispy of course) and the pizza is always fire! I've even gone into the restaurant and just asked to buy pizza dough to make my own at home. They always gladly sell me their dough and make sure to give me all the directions on how to cook it. Let me just add that the scenery isn't bad to look at either! The Italian eye candy is always on point lol read more

I can't believe I live right around the block and have never been here. They have great lunch specials. The Pizza slices were a good size. I had the cheese pizza, which was really tasty. The wings were crispy, which I really enjoyed. Mine came with teriyaki sauce, which was more barbecue than teriyaki. But we also had some medium wings, and they certainly were nice and spicy. Will walk over here more often. read more

Service is always great! We usually grab a pizza to go after work on Fridays, but this time, we decided to dine in. We had wings and pizza, and everything was delicious. The place was clean, the server was friendly, and the staff behind the counter were welcoming. A solid spot in the neighborhood--we'll definitely be back! Oh.. on a side note.. we love their RANCH! read more

See all

The atmosphere is still chill as ever BUT our last experience was by far the worst my sandwich was put together on the sloppy side, manicotti was a bit flat, my husband's calzone was mostly bread, etc. The pizza is still tho!!!! read more

Food was delicious. Found our family's new go to spot on . Good job ... amazing quality , and refreshing feeling .

Definitely our fav local family owned pizza spot! Family is very friendly, pizza is delicious! Wings and mozzarella sticks are a must too.

the food is super delicious. This is our go to family owned pizza place. It's literally a hidden gem & worth the try! read more

See all

Finally a delicious veggie pizza! Amazing flavor and I was able to add my eggplant to the mix too Love this spot and will definitely be back. read more

Original #1 Brothers Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Always a great pizza & excellent Calzone They have a big dining room with a couple of huge tables. read more

Original #1 Brothers Pizza - Happiness on a Monday night - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Love the wings and the zucchini and the pizza , this pizza spot is so good and they were friendly. :)

Line went quick. Lunch special is good price. Pizza was good, wings were good, salad was good, zucchini was good. Restaurant was clean and server was friendly. read more

We've been coming to this family owned location for years. I can't believe it's taken me this long to spread the word about how amazing this place is! Let's start with the staff. They are so welcoming and unless it's just me, they really look like they're having fun serving their customers. I appreciate feeling welcomed and like I'm the most important person there. The pizza is out of this world great. Everything is just the right amount. Anymore or any less and the blended taste would suffer. Aside from the pizza, there not a bad thing on the menu. I've cold soda and beers! What's not to like? read more

Absolutely the best staff and food too. Salads are great as well. It's a weekly event for us.

Have been going to this place ever since I was a kid! You cannot beat their pizza or the ranch so delicious, amazing local business to support on top of amazing food, always a great laid-back friendly environment. I drive out of my way to get pizza from this place anytime I can no matter where I'm living in the valley I come from wherever to get this pizza only downside is they're closed on Mondays lol read more

Great food, atmosphere & friendly staff. After a couple of visits there, they remembered us which made us feel very welcomed. It is our go to place for pizza & Italian food for our family. read more

One of the friendliest restaurants you will ever find. A very special place to enjoy tasty food , an adult beverage or two and socialize. The entire staff is smiling all the time and truly seem to care about their customers. We are regulars and will continue to be so. read more

Food is always great! They have plenty of seating and a great menu selection. Staff is always happy and friendly which is very refreshing.

If you are in the mood to take the family out to dinner, or bring dinner home, this is the place to go to. It is an old school pizza place. Counter service, tvs with sports on and a very familiar workers. Reminds me much of my childhood stomps in Chicago (though this is more of an NJ or NYC feel). Pizza is ok, not gourmet, but good for family with kids. I always think the skimp a little too much on the cheese. What I like is the full list of pasta options for dine in or take out. Really nice to come home not just with pizza, but some pasta options. For me, the highlight is there anti-pasta salad. It is nicely complemented with real salami's capicolas etc. We always get the large family version. I would go here more often, but my family like a variety of pizza styles and will only do this one once in a while. I love the staff's friendliness, I mean they call me 'boss' the whole time. "Here's your change boss." read more

Excellent pizza and wings! I had the XL Special and hot wings! LJ and his brothers were good people and made me feel welcome. Thank you for the hospitality! I am an out of towner from CA visiting my parents. Would definitely go back! Good product, price, and customer service! read more

Fried Zucchini New York Pizza wings hot bone in. Delicious, and made to perfection. I love going there it reminds me of the pizzeria back home in Yonkers. When I was a child in Grammer school, Dunwoodie Pizza across from St. John's the Baptist school back in the early 70s. These people remembered me when I came back at 18. Just like these guys. I try to eat healthy but I like certain things and at 62 and my friend who ate with me from Chicago who is 79, loved the pizza and zucchini. I love their products, pizza, and wings. First time I ordered their to go pizza and it was great, as usual. Just like home, people ask me where to go for pizza and wings. I say try Brother's! I usually sit down, but we wanted to finish watching the Giants and Cardinals lose once again. Sad but true! Great service and food, everytime. His dad still cooks sometimes. I love talking to him! read more

We ordered Sub sandwiches for our Super Bowl party Everything tasted awesome! We go to their restaurant every Friday. The staff is awesome! The food is awesome! Everyone is friendly and professional! Would highly recommend them if you need food for any event! read more

This has to be the best pizza I've had since moving to Arizonia from New York. The service is good, very friendly.

Not only is their food good but the service was excellent! The guys working there were true gentlemen!

The most perfect crust sauce and toppings but not only that the owners and all staff are exceptional above and beyond and we'll make it the way you've asked every time the consistency is outstanding and very much appreciated read more

Amazing crew! Love them they slay so hard, the food here is God sent. Genuinely awesome people, love y'all.

Probably some of the best pizza I ever had. The wings are good too! Great service as well. Please visit

Amazing pizza every time! Wings are great everything as you order it! Bring the family

Long time, family restaurant that no longer holds family morals whenever we go, they think that they intimidate because of misperception and wrong accusations of a bad review that I never wrote. I've never made a review on this restaurant, but it held to be accused of making a review every time I go in there they always look at me stupid give me attitude and then they don't make my food right so much for a family resturant. read more

Best Pizza and wings in the Valley Our families go to! Food and prices are good Great place to watch the games and the family there treat you like fam! Love this spot Boss! read more

This location is my new go to when I need to satisfy my hunger for pizza. Ranch is delicious, wings are delicious, and most importantly pizza is delicious. It is everything I ask for when eating pizza. read more

Love the pizza and wing. It's our families go to! Have dine in and take out. Both have been great experiences

SO FUCKING GOOD. from the ambiance, the cleanliness, and the food. Jesus lord have mercy on my soul. The wings [BBQ HOT] were cooked perfectly. I got a cheese pizza and it was perfect just the way it was. Pat was incredibly helpful and friendly. He 100% deserves a raise. What a great character and a marvelous establishment. I'll be fucken back. read more