I've had the burgers which I enjoy, unfortunately they were advertising a meatball sub and generally I've had good luck wherever I buy them. So I gave it a shot and was so disappointed. It was on a soft hoagie roll which was saturated and mushy from spaghetti sauce. But the worst thing was biting into the so called meatballs. Looking at the color of the tiny meatball, I was surprised to see it couldn't have been made with hamburger, because it was grayish. I gave 2 stars only because I like other menu items . But please eliminate this from your menu. It was like eating a frozen microwave gas station sandwich! read more

Every time I've been here the food has been fabulous and the staff has been very friendly and professional. Some of the best custard around

The food is good a bit to much ketchup up on the burger. Still delicious. Service was great. I saw them wiping down the tables and Very clean and dressed up the people on the walls with Santa hat and scarf and many places to sit. They were playing music and it was really nice and a bit busy because it was the day after Thanksgiving but still happy, and Jolly Christmas, ho ho ho read more

Food is pretty good. I ordered a cheese burger and found it very filling. The taste was good for a fried burger. If it was open flames then it had no flavor. But still good. The fries are really good. I would just get them and some custard next time. I didn't get custard this time, but I will next time. read more

I love the fact that any time of year, Oscars delivers. I was in town for Christmas and after all the shopping and airfare expenditures, wanted to go grab a bite with my sister before strolling through Candy Cane Lane. We checked the menu on Yelp! first and decided we were in the mood for crispy chicken sandwiches and hot chocolates. For a sandwich and hot chocolate I paid just over $5 and my sister and I split fries. Talk about a deal! It was just enough food, and they made our hot cocoas to go so we could enjoy the lights. A classic MKE destination when you're on a budget, but enjoy a decent meal that's not Wendy's or McDonalds. read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - If I didn't already feel as big as a house.... - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

My sweet tooth kicked in. Decided to go to Murf's because let's face it, who doesn't love peanut butter party---vanilla custard with peanut butter and chocolate swirls and it did not disappoint. Despite the smoky air, we ate outside at the front patio. We ordered a pint of key lime to take home but they only had quarts....so we took that home with us. The key lime had bits of graham cracker and just the right amount of subtle lime flavor. Can't wait to come back and try the burger. read more

To many times the food was terrible no need to try again why the same manager is there, sorry but true

This is my favorite frozen custard in the city. Open later than most which is usually when we want to go. I would definitely recommend this spot and if someone asks for the best in the city, this is it! read more

One of the best ice cream places around! Everyone is awesome and takes care of your food. Keep up the super job!

My review is for their shakes and cones. I have been going here since the stone ages, not really, but a long, long time. I no longer live in Wisconsin, but when I visit every year I always stop at Oscar's for my favourite, their incredible mint thick shake. The custard is always freshly made and tastes excellent. This place is known for their custards, why would anyone expect this place to have the best burgers, salads, etc...? After reading some reviews, I see some of them are negative. No disrespect, but come on people, this place is mostly managed from high school kids from Nathan Hale. I went to Hale myself, my friends worked there back in the early 90's. It may seem that many people do not know how to grill burgers themselves, maybe they should learn, but if you want a darn good shake or a waffle cone with frozen custard, than look no further than Hwy 100's Oscar's. read more

Ummm, what?! The prices are awesomely low. Like, fast food places have higher prices! And this food is good! Oscar's has been around for more than 30 years. They make custard in delicious flavors. The burgers are pretty good. But the onion rings are awesome and I don't even generally like onion rings. I love ketchup and these don't even need ketchup. Get a whole bunch of extra pickles for a small charge. They are great. read more

See all

Oscars frozen Custard is very delicious to eat at~ yum The service was excellent and quick. It was made to order and very tasty. I'd have it again read more

I usually like/love Oscars but my mom went today and asked for a bigger cup for her ice cream and the lady was saying she was going to charge her for a bigger cup and she feels like why when she goes there all the time just put it in a bigger cup and she always gets her ice cream in a bigger cup read more

The food is delicious and fresh made and the service is fast! I've loved every trip I've had to oscar's and will definitely be back in the future!! read more

Unbelievable food at a value cost. The food was prepared fresh and it was above my expectation. I had the patty melt well done. Absolutely wonderful. The onion rings were great too. This place slays the fast food places. Great food done fast. read more

Did you know - cruising Hwy. 100 and getting custard at Oscar's is A THING? It's true. I did it and I'm old. If I can do it, anyone can! Last Sunday I found myself on Hwy 100 in the afternoon - You guessed it - cruising. O was meeting up with friends and had a little time to kill so there I was and there IT was - Oscar's. I stopped in and had myself a hot fudge sindae. It hasn't changed much. It still has the crazy brick interior that makes me wonder if it was once a Godfathers Pizza and the plastic seats that remind me of Dairy Queen. I had a seat in the sunroom to enjoy my sundae. That was great. And so was my treat. Creamy, cold and just the right amount of fudge. Love me some hot fudge. The sundae was inexpensive and I just loved it. I will return to get something a little more fancy - there were lots of items on the menu that caught my eye. Ooohhh! Next time! read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - My delicious and affordable hot fudge sundae gets a moment in the sun. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This was my first stop into Oscar's at this location. We needed some dessert, and as we always stalk their delectable looking Instagram page, we knew that they had Key Lime Pie as their shake of the month. Their ice cream is definitely top notch, but their Key Lime flavor leaves a lot to be desired. To be honest, it tasted more minty than lime-y. Beware that their sizing is generous as well. Which is a great thing! We ordered large shakes and because it was directly post dinner, I could only drink half of it. I took it home and gave it to my husband as a blind taste test. He thought it was mint flavored as well. All ends well, we still like mint ice cream. We'll be back for less adventurous flavors, and to try some of their dinner menu. read more

I recently stopped at Oscar's for the first time. A friend notified me their shake of the month was Key Lime Pie (my favorite) I get it as often as possibly at Kopps in custard. The ice cream itself was great but the keylime wasn't my favorite-it almost tasted like a shamrock shake (a little minty), kind of interesting. We ordered a large and it was way more than I needed-which is awesome! Places aren't often generous with their sizing anymore. I only had about 1/2 or less of mine before I had to throw in the towel. My friend had a different special which was the parks and rec sundae which looked amazing and she said it was delicious! read more

We have been going to Oscar's Custard for many years and enjoyed the food. However, at this time, something's gone wrong with their hamburgers. We ate lunch there on July 19th and the hamburgers were awful. We used to get fresh off the grill food that was hot enough to need a little time to cool off. But this was the second time in 2023 that the hamburgers appeared to have been fried ahead of time, then slightly warmed up in a microwave with a cold bun. I'd like to advise the owners that this situation is not acceptable and they should prepare the food hot off the grill and make sure their buns are warmed, preferably toasted before serving. i know we are only 2 customers out of many but I hope the owners wake up and improve the food. It won't bring me back until I hear of major changes. read more

The ONLY thing to get here is Custard...Wow- I can't believe any of the positive reviews for their food- my burger was utterly underwhelming and tasteless. The "secret sauce" is a mimic of Big Mac secret sauce, aka, "Thousand Island Dressing". My son ordered the hot dog and it looked like it had been sitting in water for days...completely disgusting. The onion rings lacked any sort of taste. Big fail. I've had better onion rings at BK and A&W. Although one kid behind the counter was pleasant, the customer service here is not on par with Kopp's. All in all I wouldn't come here for anything but custard. The Chocolate covered cherry special flavor custard of the day, with hints of amaretto, and plenty of chocolate covered cherries was good. But Kopp's is better at that, too! Ha. read more

This place has been an institution in the area for years and years! I started going here as a kid many years ago. The burgers and onion rings are really good, however it's the custard that is a standout. Creamy and delicious! They always have amazing daily flavors that make you want to visit every day for a scoop. During the summer months, it's Hoppin' and can be challenging to find a parking spot. Don't let that discourage you, it's worth it."! read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - Great rings and "death by chocolate " flavor of the day! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This is a local favorite of mine. I don't come here often, even though it is one of my favorite burgers in this area but I always find myself going to Kopps instead for their burgers. However, Oscar's has some of the best custard. There are a ton of options for different flavored shakes and malts as well as a variety of sundaes. The wafflecones are awesome. My favorite is a peanut butter banana malt :). The burgers aren't out of this world, but I'd take this over almost any burger from a chain fast food joint. I'd rank these burgers right up there with Goody's and Gillies. Best part about the burgers is they are CHEAP yet offer a very good portion size. I absolutely love old-time design of this Oscars too. It's fun to come here on a summer night... though, it does get very crowded then also. read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - Peanut butter sundae! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I'm a recent transplant to the Milwaukee area, so I'll be the first to admit that I'm new to all of the frozen custard brands. Now that it's more regularly spring-ish weather, I've been on a bit of a frozen custard tour trying the different varieties around town. Oscar's was recommended to me and I stopped by while I happened to be in the area one evening. First, the food. I had a cheeseburger and fries. This is where the three stars come in. Both were just ok. Nothing great, nothing terrible. I wouldn't suggest coming here just for the food. Frozen Custard? A solid 3.5-4 stars on its own. I had chocolate and added in some oreos. Creamy, filling and rich, but not overwhelmingly so. Good enough in my book to drive out to Oscar's again! Two tips: 1) Bring cash, they don't take credit cards!! 2) Check out their website for a monthly coupon for deals like half off or buy one, get one free. read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - Menu boards and order/pick up counter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I got a banana shake and it was a banana cut in half with liquid ice cream, or custard what ever it was, poured in it. There was no one at the front to talk to them about the shake. VERY disappointed. Food was good though. I just don't feel that this place makes good custard anymore. would have rather ate Culver's or Dairy Queen. read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - "Banana Shake" - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Really friendly cashier service and positive vibes on a Friday night! It was a perfect spot to just relax a little and enjoy some fantastic custard. I ordered the classic cookies and cream custard and it was no joke. Great service and cool times! read more

My first time at Oscar's was great. Prices are very reasonable and the food is good. The frozen custard is awesome! In addition, the staff there is amazing. read more

I finally stopped at Oscars this week. The bacon cheese burger with the works was my choice. The food was fast and fresh. My first impression was the nice flame grilled taste. Unlike most burger chains the beef was moist and not all dried out which was impressive so I had to take a closer look at it. Over all it was good and different from all the chains because it has it's unique flavor and that's why I will be back. The sweet stuff looked good that other people had. read more

Our favorite and only fast food place. Good menu and great custard. Many service attendants behind counter at the West Allis location. Last experience, I tried calling ahead for pick up, was put on hold it was 445pm. So not too busy yet. So I drove there in the meantime, ordered my food thru the cashier and waited. Was still on hold while I watched everyone taking orders. They never came back to the phone and I hung up just before getting my food. During this Covid time I would assume they are used to taking more call-in orders. I wonder how many orders they miss out on? Overall good fastfood but service needs to improve, there are enough people but not trained or employees don't care -probably a little of both. I will give Kopps my business next time we want burgers and custard. read more

The BEST in custard. Reasonably priced with generous portions unlike other popular custard venues. No " icy" custard like some of the others. Oscar's is the leader for custard and delicious sandwiches. read more

Simple, basic, classic since my cruising days in the 90s. Good burgers, good fries, my favorite turtle sundae in the city

The staff was nice, but the food almost felt like cafeteria meals. Which with the price, I'm going to say it's alright, but I certainly wouldn't eat there again. The custard was fairly yummy, while also being decently priced. read more

The custard selections are great and tasty. But don't have lunch there. The patty melt was some kind of mystery meat, took only 2 bites. And even that made me nauseated after coming home My chicken tender children - said they were "yucky" So have lunch elsewhere and oscars for dessert! read more

I have been eating at Oscars for a while, specifically the one on 27th and Rawson. It had been my favorite place to eat -- up until yesterday. I pulled into the drive through and asked for my usual, burger and fries, except this time I asked for a quart of chocolate custard with extra chocolate chips in it. The girl at the drive through window said "Okay pull around" and everything was normal. (I had asked for this a week before and there was no issue.) I pulled up to the drive through window and saw the girl packing the quart with vanilla custard instead of chocolate. When she handed me the bag with the quart in it, I asked her, "Excuse me, did you pack that with chocolate or vanilla custard?", she replied Vanilla. I then reassured her that I asked for the quart to be Chocolate with extra chocolate chips. She then told me "Oh uhh, yeah we're actually not suppose to mix toppings in like that unless it's the flavor of the day.". Confused due to the fact I got one last week with no issue, I told her "Oh uh, I actually got a quart of chocolate with chocolate chips last week" she then asked "Was it the flavor of the day?" In which I replied that it wasn't, that the flavor that day was Butter Pecan. She then let out the longest, most rude *Sigh* and snatched the bag from my hand with no words being said. She came back and gave me the quart of chocolate with, *what I thought I ordered* "Extra chocolate chips". After I got my food, I went home. That night I started to eat the quart and after the incredibly rude customer service by the drive through window girl, there hasn't been a single chocolate chips in the quart. This is all after terrible customer service by the girl, along with paying extra for the chocolate chips that I had not gotten. This place had been my favorite until now. If I need any custard, i'm just going to go to Culver's or Kopps from now on. read more

I can't thank the staff at Oscar's Custard enough. We had ice cream for my son's wedding and Susie was awesome enough to put malted milk whopper on the menu for us since we weren't able to have malts. Laurie and staff were extremely accommodating in filling the order and carrying it out to my car. The custard was a hit and survived the 86 deg. temps with the help of dry ice and a Yetti cooler! You guys are awesome and I will recommend you 100%. P.S. The malted milk whopper is definitely a new favorite!!! Barb read more

I have been to Oscar's many times, and will return. I've never been disappointed, until today. Hot day and wanted something different, so I ordered a grilled chicken breast sandwich. It was the driest, most tasteless piece of chicken I have ever eaten. Skip this and have a burger. read more

It is discouraging when there is 12 people behind the counter and maybe 6 people are doing any work. Go there 3 times a month and it just gets worse. My friends say the same thing. It's time to go elsewher. read more

I've eaten here too many times over the last 20 years. Burgers, Custard, and the like, done right. If your in Milwaukee this spot is definitely worth a visit. Love the Buffalo Chicken sandwich and have never had a custard there I didn't live. We live scary close which means the siren that is Oscar's is always singing it's sweet song. read more

I go to Oscars quite often and have never been disappointed. Their sandwiches are great! Hidden gem is the crispy chicken. The custard is worth the trip. They have a great assortment of sundaes which I am quite fond of. One of the best custard malts as well. That's it I am going right now! read more

I don't often get to Oscar's but when I do, it's for the Chocolate Covered Cherry Custard. Amazing. All of the custards are so rich, creamy and delicious. The taste of the custard brings me back to my childhood. I have had the burgers in the past and they are great! Thin, juicy burgers that won't disappoint. The place is usually swarming with people on warm summer nights but there's plenty of seating space inside and out to accommodate everybody! read more

There are so many Milwaukee things I just don't understand. George Webbs. Real Chili. That weird orange starbust thing on the lakefront. Fonzie. Oh, and before I forget, lets add Oscar's to the list. I'm not just some FIB interloper though. I love Custard! I love Kopp's custard. And I love burgers! Like Fred's, in Washington Heights. But someone will have to explain to me what I'm missing at Oscar's, 'cause I just don't think it's all that hot. Went for lunch the other day and got the Reuben special, which was good. I got the reuben because I know I don't really care for their burgers. The burgers are small, thin, and just kind of blah. The reuben was good! Everything else was underwhelming. I had a cup of the chili, which they claim is made fresh every day. I don't buy it. It was almost certainly frozen at some point and I wouldn't be surprised to hear it came out of someones warehouse. This is just conjecture, but it wasn't good chili. The fries too, aren't that good. Nearly my entire order of fries were an inch or two long, which when you're trying to dip into a tiny cup of cheese is sub-optimal, at best. If the person I was with hadn't wanted to stop here I wouldn't have gone and until he wants to go again I don't think I'll be back. read more