Awesome must have pizzas. I have no idea which Mozzarella they manage to get, it tastes great. Pizza base is thin with a reasonable edge. Pizza sauce is fantastic. Right amount of toppings. Tastes best right out of oven. Didn't like it after it got cold, but a quick reheat in a small OTG did the trick. Overall, this in in my list of top 3 pizza places to go to. read more

We used to love the pizza but were shocked at how downhill it has gone. Heavy, partially cooked crust.... Barely edible. So disappointed.

A bit expensive for pizza but very tasty. Whole or custom pizzas are made fresh and can take a little while to wait for, so best to go when there's not a lot of people ordering. read more

They have delicious huge pizza and all the fixing's you could ever want. The ambiance of the restaurant is friendly.

Great pizza. We dropped in for lunch mid-week and ordered a pizza- the Brooklyn Bridge and it was excellent. The vegetables were fresh and crispy, the pepperoni and sausage flavorful. They also sell pizza by the slice- there were three types- for customers in a hurry. I would recommend. read more

Came here to get our first Pagliacci experience. A big change to the location of the previous restaurant that was there, the revised atmosphere is a welcomed site. This place will definitely give the adjacent pizza location a run for the money. When we arrived, it wasn't too busy, but quickly started backing up. We ordered the Margherita and a Spinach & Chicken. Unfortunately/fortunately they brought out a Spicy Chicken. When we notified them of the error, they told us to keep the pizza and they would quickly rectify the issue. They brought out the right pizza quickly, and this gave us the chance to taste more of the menu. The local craft beers were a great pair as well. The pizza was delicious, and will definitely keep them on the list for eat-in and take out! read more

Slowest Pizza Preparation on Planet Earth! I went to pickup my pizza after ordering online December 4th, 2020. I was told there were 107 pizzas in front of my order and that it would be another 70+ minutes to pickup a $45 dollar pizza, the most expensive pizza you can buy within Puget Sound. I asked to speak with the manager which they refused to produce. I would NEVER recommend Pagliacci Pizza to my worst of friends. You're better off going to Zeeks up the street where Mark Mullet will be much happier to take your order and provide much more human and friendly service. read more

This is by far one of my favorite pizza joints. Be carefully ordering the large pizzas, they are huge, and you will want to gorge yourself, it is that great! read more

We have ordered from them half a dozen times over the last year and never had an issue. The food arrived within the projected delivery time and has always been hot and high quality. This has become our go-to spot when we want great pizza. Yes, it takes a little bit longer and costs more but you get what you pay for. read more

Inconsistent quality! Sometimes over cooked, sometimes under cooked but the dough is hard to bite into. Super friendly staff, clean kitchen, would try my luck again next time, cause when it's cooked perfect, they are the best tasting pizza around. read more

Have effortlessly used their app to order pickup here a few times now. It's pricy for pizza but the taste of the crust makes it worth the splurge. Our favorites are the goat cheese pies. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Goat cheese primo, meets Hawaiian. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

I order from this place because the family likes the pizza. I'm annoyed as a consumer because the online app deleted the pizza when I applied the rewards and I didn't realize it. Just frustrating for an app fail when I have hungry kiddos that are now more cranky while they wait another 35minutes. Ugh. Advice is to check your online order twice folks. read more

Not a fan of them trying to force us to tip the cook. The ones they hired to cook as their actual job. Pizza. read more

Hear me out, I don't know if I can rate the actual delivery time and pizza as 5 stars, but their customer service is *chef's kiss* amazing. Each time I get on the phone with P's they're always personable, friendly and they always tell jokes or have humor! It gets me every time. I pay for their overpriced pizza because of the customer service experience. Keep it up you guys. 1 Gluten free pepperoni pizza for $30 will always have a special place in my heart because of you all. read more

Will. Not. Set. Foot. In. Here. Again. (Ever). Last night they ran a promotion for Pi day they were completely unable to handle, so dozens of customers had a garbage experience waiting. Every time I asked for an update the counter person lied to my face- lost an extra hour of my life I cannot get back, for average pizza. Even though they are an extra hour late, lying to our faces about it ("Oh, probably another six minutes... then another 15, then another 15, then someone admits they hadnt even started them...). They wont own the errors and switch to delivery, they wont compensate, no free drinks... just sit and wait. And wait. And wait. SO many forlorn, frustrated people in the lobby - everywhere. Dining in or taking out. WILL NOT BE BACK. EVER. To any of their stores. Going back to Pine Lake or Zeeks from now on, I learned my lesson. read more

Took out pizza tonight and it was great! Ordered online and food was ready promptly. Ordered one fresh veggie, one verdura primo, and one veganized fresh veggie with garlic and vegan sausage added. All simply delicious!! read more

So happy that Pagliacci has made it to Sammamish! Pizza by the slice, tasty salads, and a variety of whole pies including seasonal specials. Delivery area is limited in Sammamish. Sorry Klahanie and Trossachs. They don't deliver to us :( I am willing to make the drive to pick up the best pizza in Sammamish. read more

This location is typically busy during peak lunch and dinner times on the weekend. It is clean and the service is typically pretty good. You order and they bring out your order when it gets made. Try their Paggliccio salad. It is one of the best salads you will taste at a pizza restaurant. One large salad can be shared my 4 people. Come here during off hours and you shouldn't have any issues finding a table. read more

My favorite place for pizza in the area. By far. There is nearly no good pizza within a 30 mile radius of Issaquah. We usually order the centioli, cheese pizza and a Caesar salad. It's all amazing. Would like to try their pasta dishes one day but just the plain ol' cheese pizza has our family in its grips. The place is never overly crowded when we go, so that's always nice. The atmosphere and ambiance could use a little work, it's not a place where you are comfortable and want to hang out, but maybe that's what they are going for and why it's not so crowded. Overall highly recommend if you are craving good pizza. read more

Incredibly unorganized and slow. We have ordered online several time - you can't see when your pizza will be delivered until you've actually placed the order. When they first opened it was around half an hour, now it is 90 minutes on average! When I called, the lady suggested to come and pick up the order myself, whichh would shorten the wait time by twenty minutes. When my daughter went to pick it up, she still had to wait another 30 minutes, so instad of being faster now we had a waiting time of 100 minutes for three pizzas! Not acceptable, sorry. Will not order from them again until they get their act together. read more

Didn't like the salad and the pizza, neither liked the speed. Pizza was too oily, salad had too much dressing and the speed was too slow. Pizzeria across the street still wins. The service was great. read more

Unfortunately just echoing everyone else's sentiments. Ordered a medium mushroom pizza and a small Caesar salad for pick up. I came 15 mins before the pizza completion time. The order was not ready until 25mins after the designated time and they had about 8 customers in the shop. Pizza crust was decent but the rest was awful. Mushrooms were semi raw and scarce. Salad wasn't anything special and both costed us $31. Never again. You think the manager would read all of these reviews and get it together. I was super excited for another restaurant in the Plateau but this place blows. Met market down the road has delicious flat breads that are excellent with great customer service. Will stick with them for now. read more

I love Pagliacci pizza. I have been eating it for decades. I was so excited to finally have one close to where I live (Fall City). Unfortunately, it has not been a good experience. There is no consistency. Sometimes it's cooked just right, other times it is overcooked. The sauce is almost tasteless. The crust is the biggest disappointment. The last pizza we had tasted like cardboard. The edges were really flat, reminding me of a cheap, frozen pizza. The toppings are either sparse or too much. They need to put these cooks through another training program to get their recipes right. Will not be going back to this location. read more

I waited extra 20mins for my order because they forgot. Pizza is not bad but service is not good. Restaurant was slow when I was there so I don't understand why they forgot about my order. read more

We didn't realize how early all of the restaurants close in downtown Seattle on a Saturday night.... weird. We ended up coming back to Sammamish where our AirBNB was and stumbled upon this place, which was open later. I had a calzone, which was AMAZING. Stuffed full of meat and cheese. The breadsticks were also great. read more

Not so great. The slices were overpriced - thin and blah tasting. Mod is much better and virtually next door. First time in and the owner or manager, tall older gentleman, grabs a slice to put in the warmer, maybe my order? And uses his bare hands to squeeze the end of the slice to see if it's warm or not. eewww! Won't ever go back! Also, at 2pm there were four or five staff there, about two customers and several tables were left dirty and empty. No excuse, too unappetizing! read more

Very disappointing experience with pick-up. Ordering was a pleasant experience with a convenient online presence, however I am outside the delivery zone so I had to phone in my order anyway. I was told the pizza would be ready in 20 min in Sammamish, and to expect a text when to come into the store to pick up the pizza. So, I arrived at the 20 min. mark and expected a text at any time. There were cars pulling up along side me as I watched people run in and out for the next 15 min...I assumed they were busy but not too that my pizza should have been ready so I called to inquire. The person on the phone located my order and said he will call the store to find out what happened. As he returned to the phone he said your pizza is ready to be picked up, I asked if it was going to be cold now, his response was no it shouldn't. So I went in and was handed a pizza without any reference to any delays or apologies. When I got the pizza home (which is a 10 min drive) it was cold and disappointing. I understand mistakes happen but I cant not tolerate not recognizing or acknowledging them when it happens. Oh, on my way home I got a text my pizza was ready. read more

the pizza is amazing and they deliver which is a life saver when it comes to being lazy totally recomend. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

If your looking for a pizza in a minute this is not your place. Now if you want or need a fabulous pizza give them some time. They make an excellent pie. I always call ahead for takeout. Seems to work best. The staff is very good and not a lot of wasted time. Usually they are always busy and the phone is always ringing. Love the menu and they are all good. We go here a lot and the kids love it. read more

Just had pizza here for the first time. Will be back. Had the extra pepperoni slice and the salume' slice for lunch.the salute was ok but the pepperoni was Great! Will definitely try the other combinations of ingredients. Fantastic crust, crisp on the outside soft in the middle. Excellent flavor also. Best crust I've had in years. Looking forward to the future tastes at Pagliacci's. read more

I've had nothing but excellent service and amazing pizza at Pagliacci. I love all the seasonal options plus some of the standard options.

Best pizza within a 10 mile radius with their only competitor being mod pizza which is essentially a whole different style. Pagliacci in my opinion has the best cheese pizza around, cheap and delicious while always being fresh. You can buy by the slice which is a huge bonus. Highly recommend if you've never had it. Whether your on a date, or hungover, or just looking for a snack you won't be disappointed. read more

We ordered via phone. The person who took my order was very helpful. He suggested I have my dressing on the side as it was spicy. Good suggestion! My small Sicilian salad is overpriced. Literally 3 pieces of chicken. I got a bunch of greens, token artichokes, roasted peppers and currants for $7.49!!! Hubby's calzone was delicious and he would order again. Bread sticks are amazing. Pick up was crazy! We showed up when we were told to arrive. Waited in line with everyone else who was placing orders. Calzone was ready, no salad. Waited almost 10 extra minutes for salad. Step up your game for pick up and put some chicken in the salad and we would go back. read more

Got a ready made slice of cheese and romana pizza, and they were both really good! Breadsticks took 15 minutes to come out, but were good and hot. If you're short on time, I'd recommend getting ready made, but otherwise they have some very good options if you're fine with waiting. read more

Thought I would try this place for lunch. Ordered the lasagna which says it has Bolognese sauce between layer's of pasta. It's more like marinara sauce with some blended cheese. I asked if it was vegetarian and the woman said no there's meat sauce in there. I showed her that it had none and asked for my money back. I was informed that they order it in from another company by the staff. Since then they have reached out to me and explained that it is actually made fresh elsewhere by pagliacci. Maybe they missed the meat sauce in this one. I will give them another try at some point. read more

Have ordered over phone around 5 times now. Pizza is consistently excellent and tasty! The crust is perfectly moist and crispy/flavorful. I usually get the current mushroom special and cheese pizza for the kids. Super friendly and efficient customer service on the phone. They remembered my pizza preferences on kids cheese pizza and sizes, offering to apply it. Also, had credit card on file which was convenient. Pickup is a breeze and cashier has always been professional. Looks like seasoned pizza makers in the back. Inside is fun and always packed in the evenings. Finally a good pizza place on the plateau. read more

This is a good pie! Love their thin chewy crust. Toppings are fresh and generous. If you're in the market for a slice or a whole pie, Pagliacci's won't disappoint. Also must mention that their Caesar Salad is authentic!! Friendly workers, clean and spacious environment. Good vibe. read more

Pizza is delicious! Unfortunately the service is awful and the staff are more interested in socializing than in making pizza. Today the slice I bought for lunch didn't even have toppings on half. Staff was rude. Unapologetic for not having pizza ready. Actually sent me out the door with an empty pizza box among my full boxes. I had to go back- no apology. Ordered pizza to be ready for 4:00, staff insisted it was supposed to be ready 30 minutes later. Fortunately I had confirmation of the order & time. 3rd example of bad service was seeing my order on top of the ovens, a staff member insisting it wasn't mine, got a different person to check and I was right. I want to live Pagliacci but each visit disappoints. Too many pizza choices in Sammamish to bother with this nonsense. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sammamish, Washington

I don't understand all of the low reviews! In the Puget Sound this is the best pizza available. The crust is a perfect consistency, the sauce is delicious, and the toppings are all fresh. I'm guessing the only poor reviews are due to the place being overcrowded, something operational/staffing related, which is an easy problem to fix. Have a slice here and you won't regret it, the pizza is great! read more

What you would expect from Pagliacci, solid pizza. However this location has a serious problem with keeping a pizza as basic as pepperoni or cheese at their slice station. So the idea of stopping in quickly for lunch is a no go most of the time. And forget calling ahead because their number is a Corp line that won't transfer you to the store to find out. Ill keep checking from time to time and upgrade my review if they can do a consistently better job at managing slice stock of the basics. Until then, I'll avoid them for quick lunches and order out whole pies to go for dinner when feeling the craving. Note: the attitude of the employers here is solid as well, but advertising drop in slice culture without managing it properly is a real frustration. read more