If it's a 4 .5 do I leave 4 or 5 stars? Math is hard, but Flying Pie is awesome. ​If finding a legitimately great slice of pizza in Western Washington feels like trying to find a restaurant that doesn't give you food poisoning in a notoriously sketchy travel-advisory zone, you're not alone. The search is exhausting. Enter Flying Pie Pizza in Issaquah, which swoops in like a pepperoni-laden hero to save you . I've been here a few times now ​Here is my breakdown of the Good, the Bad, and the Quirky : ​The Good: * ​The Pie: Hands down one of the absolute best pizzas in the region. Their dough and sauce are homemade and made fresh daily, and you can honestly taste the difference. * ​The Vibe & Staff: The staff is wonderfully friendly. Plus, they have coloring pages and crayons for the kids and proudly display the masterpieces created by these little local artisans on the walls. * ​Retro Entertainment: By the soda machine is an old-time pinball machine. Head to the back and you will find classic 80s arcade games. (Just try not to lose your quarters before your pizza arrives). ​The Bad: * ​The Wallet Factor: It's a bit pricier than your average chain, but the quality easily justifies the extra few bucks. * ​The DIY Setup: You seat yourself, grab your own plates, and bus your own table. Think of it as burning off those incoming pizza calories in advance. * ​Service Style: The staff can sometimes be hanging out in the back, meaning they aren't always front-and-center. The silver lining? If you need something, they don't get annoyed at all if you just cheerfully yell out to get their attention. ​The Ugly (Or Weird): * ​The Ghost Bar: There is a very nice-looking bar in the back, but it is completely unmanned (they only use it to process alcohol requests). It's like a phantom watering hole. * ​The Bathroom Obstacle Course: Directly behind this ghost bar is a clothing rack with shirts for sale, which conveniently obstructs your view of the bathroom door. Consider it a fun little scavenger hunt after two slices of heavy-duty pie and a drink refill ​Final Verdict: Skip the culinary roulette elsewhere and hit up Flying Pie. Just watch out for the shirt rack on your way to the restroom! read more

We ordered delivery from flying pie. It took about an hour or so to arrive. The delivery person was very friendly. It arrived warm and was covered in toppings. We were grateful that they granted our requests for no onion and pineapple on half. I didn't see a different way to add and subtract toppings for modification on the ordering page. The pizza was really good, flavorful and a pretty good texture. It is denser than NY style but not thick like Chicago Style. The sauce had strong tones of herbs and garlic, there was vibrant fennel in the thick satisfying sausage chunks, and the crust was strong with butter and garlic. It was very satisfying. While I don't feel like I would want this all the time, I can imagine getting the hankering for it every couple months. Good stuff! read more

This place is amazing I'm new to town and this was one of my first food stops I made.i love the service they are amazing people working there. The ambiance of food drinks and sports and pinball old arcade style Pokémon and ninja turtles each playing for a quarter is simply an amazing deal. The gumball machines my daughter really loved. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Bbq pizza is the best - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

We ordered delivery and tried Flying Pie for the first time. The pizza was different from what we usually get, so it was interesting to try. It tasted fine, but it was not a hit with the fam. The garlic bread was good. read more

See all

Pretty good for the area. Seating is not the best though, you kindof have to fend for yourself and find something. There's a weird bar that's never actually staffed when I've been there. They sell pizza dough for to go which we do for homemade pizza nights. read more

Had a 12" veg for lunch. Enough for 2-3. Toppings were fresh and abundant. I could not see or taste any sauce. Plenty of cheese though. The crust was ok, nothing special. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

Can this possibly be correct; 12" x-thin pizza, (1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 I-Sausage with toppings: black olives, mushrooms, green pepper, fresh tomatoes), 1 brownie, 1 beer Including tip was just under $60. (12" pizza! NEVER again. read more

Ordered a giant slice of Hawaiian pizza and it came out super hot, fresh, loaded with toppings, and perfectly cheesy! The mango with chamoy and tajin was so ripe and delicious too. We did have to wait a few minutes for the pizza to be ready but it was so worth it. A meal here for 1 person will probably run you $15. Will definitely come back to this quaint pizza spot next time I'm over in Issaquah. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

We decided to go to our old favorite place tonight, due to exploring something different. Great choice. We ordered online, got immediate information on pizza ready time. It kept us informed up to the minute. We walked a couple minutes prior, and waited about 2 minutes to get our fresh hot pizza. The team working acknowledged us immediately, gave us the status. And when the pizza was ready let us know! Cute ambiance to this place, quaint is a good description. They've added a small sit / stand bar on one side. They also offered grab and go items inside. Mostly beverages. The price was very good for our two pizzas as well! Pleasantly surprised. Very friendly, hard working bunch. Thank you! read more

You've been here a few times so I can give your general idea what it's like. Do not go to the Spider-Man pinball machine because it frequently doesn't work and we eat your quarters sometimes one of the cooks can get it restarted but it's mostly pretty annoying. The bathroom are typically speaking clean, but they're also hidden in a weird part of the pizzeria. Speaking of weird in the middle of the pizzeria is a bar that is not functional whatsoever. It really seems like they're losing out on a great customer base by not utilizing the bar Down to the main event pizzas appetizer sodas what you're really there for I would say the food is pretty mid. I'd compare it to the quality of Papa John's without the franchise taste in the dough. They're definitely more generous with their toppings than Frankie's pizza even though Frankie's pizza is definitely way better. read more

Office lunch, our boss wanted our team to tire Flying Pie pizza. I tired the combo slice and slice of ham&pineapple. It is good. The ingredients are fresh. Everything tasted proportionately. Each bite got the toppings, sauce and cheese. I was full after two slices and could use a nap after that. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Primo Pesto Zappi - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

Went by to grab a slice of pizza. I enjoyed it very much and will be going back. Great taste and good texture in the doug.

The food is amazing and the staff is so kind. Such a cute little place. A little pricey but so worth it.

We ordered online and it said it would take about 30 minutes. We did notice the menu ingredients online for make your own pizza didn't quite match the online order form. We asked in the comments section for them to add roasted red peppers if they had them since it wasn't listed. We ordered one Miss Piggy 16" pizza and one make your own: thing crust, pepperoni, meatballs, mushrooms, roasted red peppers with red sauce. If you order online and spend more than $35 be sure to add the coupon code "FREEPIZZA" for a 12" free cheese pizza. The bill came to $79.20 for two 16" pizzas...honestly it's a ton of money for two pizzas for four people. Knowing we also were getting a 12" pizza made it a bit more tolerable for the cost. But let's be honest- $5-6 PER TOPPING is just crazy when the basic pizza begins at $22. They were ready when we drove over. They are tasty and were not overcooked. BUT the make your own pizza was thin crust on the order and the crust looked exactly the same as the Miss Piggy thick crust so that was confusing. The amount of ingredients was good- thank goodness because $5-6 per topping is a bit insane. For me it's the taste of the pizza that gives it 4 stars along with the coupon code giving us an additional 12" pizza...the cost of the pizzas was 2 stars for me. I want workers to get a living wage but costs have gone up to a ridiculous amount for everything lately- even pizza. My husband said they have certain pizzas each day (pizza of the day) that are discounted and if we had gotten the Miss Piggy pizza on Wednesday it would have been $19.97 for the year they opened 1997. I see us ordering from them again but we will be strategic in ordering on the pizza of the day and/or coupon code for free cheese pizza. read more

See all

My dad really liked the pizza from here and I liked the pasta and my mom thought it was OK

Went here for lunch after short hike. Ordered the Italian salad. I really like the dressing! It has good blend of sweetness nd tart. The salad was enough to feed 2 . We Lo's referred the combo pizza. It took about 15 minutes to cook our order. They do have sliced pizza on sale. Cheese, peporonni. Basic, cheese, pepperoni. , Rough the left over and out adult kids enjoyed it. read more

Since I first posted my first review two years ago it's literally NIGHT AND DAY at FP. While the service at FP has always been bad....i can't tell you how many times I stand at their counter COMPLETELY IGNORED. They never greet you when you walk in. They just continue working and basically acting like you aren't there until IT FITS THEIR SCHEDULE to finally look up and ask "what do you need?" Ummmm....no "HELLO?" No "HOLA?" No "thanks for coming in would you like to order something?" Nope. You are clearly JUST A NUISANCE to them. With that said...I chose to overlook their crap service cuz I felt their pizzas were at least good enough to negate their poor customer service skills. However, they don't even have that going for them anymore. You ask for extra sauce. You don't get it. You ask for extra cheese. You don't get it. You ask for no olives...guess what? You get olives. Sauce is BASIC tasting at best. Tastes like it comes out of a can...not homemade like they state. I'm Italian. I know HOMEMADE RED SAUCE/GRAVY. regardless....even IF (that's a big IF) homemade...it's still blah tasting sauce and blah tasting other ingredients. So because of their deteriorating quality of food and poor customer service I basically stopped going to FP. Until the other day. An unexpected change in dinner plans left us scrambling to find something to eat and since it was already kind of late we didn't want to have to drive too far for pizza so decided to give FP another try. I went online to order a couple of pies. My son's fav pizza is BBQ Chicken pizza so I went to order that first. I'm sorry...but WHAT?? You are asking HOW MUCH FOR A PIZZA?!? I even asked my son and my husband to GUESS how much FP was charging for a large BBQ Chicken pizza. Both thought they were hitting high with their guess when they said $29. Nope. $30? Nope. $35? NOPE. FLYING PIE PIZZA...WITH THE CRAP SERVICE AND BLAH TASTING INGREDIENTS (btw....who puts WHOLE PIECES OF CILANTRO....STEM AND ALL...in their dishes?..too lazy to even remove the stems?! So you have strings/stems all over the pizza too....You can tell they just grab it and toss it on....with minimal prep) is charging $37...basically $40 for a pizza!! Was it always that price and I just didn't notice?? Or is this yet another GREEDY restaurant spiking their prices....gouging their customers like we just gonna continue to pay insane prices for CRAP FOOD?! Regardless....i thought Pagliaci's was fairly expensive when compared to other places (that's our fav pizza place now btw....but I was willing to give FP another chance cuz it's just a five min drive to pick up dinner as opposed to having to jump on 90 and pick it up from Pagliacci) but at least with Pagliaccis you get GREAT SERVICE....you are greeted every time you walk in like they actually are APPRECIATIVE of you choosing to give them your business...and you get fresh, flavorful ingredients, sauce, etc. But even at Pagliaccis...they don't charge that much!! I'm sorry. Far too many dings against FP to continue giving them our business. You gonna charge $40 for a subpar, with stringy cilantro stems on a BBQ Chicken pizza..the least you can do is say "HELLO, THANKS FOR COMING!" We will NEVER go back and I would NEVER recommend this place. Far better pizza places to choose from in Issaquah. Pagliaccis is only two exits up on I90. And yes, that's where we ended up getting our pizza that night. Only bummer is they don't have a BBQ Chicken. But if they did I know the chicken would not be dried up BLAH tasting JERKEY NUGGETS with stemmy, stringy cilantro all over it! read more

I came here for dine in last night, but we ended up doing take out because they require vaccination for dine in and not everyone was. It took about 45min for our order to be ready and we were able to wait inside for our order, but it was so worth the wait! We had 1/2 vegetarian and 1/2 pesto (no feta) and I think the vegetarian was my favorite, although they were both tantalizing. The crust was the best part! Thick, golden brown and chewy. It was loaded with all of the toppings of a combo and I loved the addition of the fresh tomato. With a side of ranch it was the perfect slice of pizza! The pesto was also amazing. Smothered in artichoke hearts, tasty pesto, olives, mushrooms and tomatoes. 10/10 pizza!! read more

See all

Pros: daughter thought the overpriced rotisserie pizza oven was cool, the owner was nice and gave stickers to her. The homemade sausage was good and you can tell they use quality mozzerella Cons:. Just about everything else! Some people might like that heavy crust, it's not terrible but not my personal favorite. In general the pie was very heavy, more cheese than needed given the bake time. There was an aproperate amount of sausage (not overloaded) yet it was incredibly greasy. It was so greasy the pizza chef dabbed it with napkins for a while (very unprofessional in an open kitchen) before placing it in my to go box. It was still sloppy & better air fryer reheated once the grease cooled. Oh and I forgot, when I first ordered in person I wanted a 16" with 3 toppings. It came to I think $54 with tax. Insane they can get away with those prices. I got a $14" 1 topping for like $27. Slices are also a ridiculous $8 each. read more

Wow! Great pizza! Great service! If it's "good" Pizza you're looking for, try Flying Pie. By far the best Pizza I've had in a very long time. The budget pizza places fill a void but for a few $$ more you can eat a great pizza that will fill you up. I had the Combo2 w/Alfredo Sauce, Pepperoni, Sausage, Onions, Mushrooms, and Black Olives. Generous amount of toppings, very good crust and cooked to perfection. The Sausage was bite size pieces instead of the pea size like the other places. Mine was carryout to pick up after 10:00 (they close at 10). A young lady met me at the door to unlock and let me in. Very helpful and kind. Try it!! read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Don't lick your screen! - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

Drove all the way up from Cottage Grove, Oregon to see my granddaughter and her family. She recommended this place for pizza and it was great. Love the comfortable atmosphere and the friendly service. I do have one complaint though. I ordered a large combo number two and my daughter, her husband and their kids ordered a Canadian bacon with pineapple pizza and a plain cheese pizza. And you know what?! They all ate MY pizza. We took most of the other two pizzas home. Should have ordered a combo to go. It would've made a good breakfast if it made it home. It's a very long drive from Cottage Grove, Oregon to Issaquah, but it's worth it to have a combo and see my Great Grandkids, in that order. Ha! read more

I'd heard a lot about this place from word of mouth and wanted to try it with my fiancé since we've recently moved to the area. We went for lunch and we're able to seat ourselves quickly! We ordered 12 Italian mild wings, a 12 inch supreme #1, and their mac and cheese with chicken and bacon. The appetizers arrived in 15 minutes, and the pizza came hot in 25 minutes but everything came out piping hot! The big wave ale I had cold and the staff were very nice to us! I think we'll definitely be back again! Their pizza was especially delicious! Crust was crispy and the spicy sausage was amazing! The mac and cheese could have used more seasoning, but the wings were crispy and tasty! We also must say that the atmosphere was really laidback, sports channel on was great, and their decorations gave me dive bar vibes! Awesome time! read more

See all

Hey, pizza lovers of Issaquah! If you're on the hunt for the best pizza in town, look no further than Flying Pie Pizzeria! I recently had the pleasure of experiencing their mouthwatering pizzas, and I'm here to share my excitement with all of you! Check out this slice of heaven ! read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Slice of heaven - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

We went in ordered 2 pizzas and drinks they brought 1 pizza out we waited another 15 minutes. Went up and asked about our 2nd one, they said it would br right out. 15 more minutes pass. No pizza. They came and said they gave our pizza to someone else and we could take the stromboli the other person ordered or we could wait ANOTHER 15min for ours. Finally for our pizza about 30 min later. So we waited over an hour, asked for a refund but were offered a free salad. WHAT? We paid $100 for pizza and sodas for 7 ppl and were offered a salad when they messed u0. And we had to go ASK about it...and then we got a rude response when we felt we had the RIGHT to be upset. If we had not asked about it we might still be sitting there. AND NO OFFER TO MAKE IT RIGHT other than a free salad seeiously? ​ This is how you handle your mistake when customers waor over an hour for their food? We will not be back or recommend to anyone. read more

Delicious pizza, slow delivery. Drive and pick it up if you're hungry, we're going on a 90 min wait for 1 pizza just to the highlands. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - (Ordered at 4:30) - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

The Zappi Primo was excellent! Good service. Earned points for discount on future meal there. Loved kid's drawings posted in the wall and good atmosphere there for family & friends. read more

So rude. Undercooked, overpriced pizza with rude service. It used to be great, now it's just another strip mall joint. read more

Gluten free pizza. Presto and BBQ chicken are great. Safe handling and I think a separate oven

3.5. My brother used to work here back in the day so have experienced the ups and downs of Flying Pie over the years. Still use quality ingredients and one of the rare places offering linguica (though razor thin nowadays). I recommend they watch their quality control given the price point. Ordered 4 pizzas totaling over $100 and 2 of them were missing many toppings. Pep, bacon jalapeño ended up just pep. Chicken and Chiven had no bacon nor chives. That much missing makes customers hesitant or loses them. Hope they pick up their game. read more

For breadsticks, I'd rate them a 2. For edible recycled cardboard, it's an 8! Pizza was marginally better. My kids liked it. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

Service is friendly pizza is fresh baked and full of flavor. McConnell, Stromboli, & Miss Piggy. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Delicious pizza fresh baked and full of flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

Currently taking orders onliNe! It was super easy to order online and at least right now they are offering a great deal where you get a free small cheese pizza if you order over a certain amount, which we qualified for after just ordering one large pizza! I always order their #2 special. They make the most amazing sausage in house. It's a little spicy but not very. I don't have a high spice tolerance. I walked in and my pizzas were boxed and waiting for me. So easy and didn't have to get close to anyone or use a pin pad machine. Highly recommend during social distancing! read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - #2 pizza has sausage, pepperoni, onion, black olives :) - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

See all

Small, busy and good pizza. It can get hectic with all the online orders for pick-up that was taking place, but I was entertained by several old pinball machines as well as a couple vintage '80's video games. I had fun and it helped to pass the time until the Pizza arrived at our table. Good pizza, lots of toppings and a fun and quaint little gem. read more

Great little pizza joint that turns out excellent pies. Delicious crust. Superior sausage, pepperoni, and other toppings. Friendly service.

Worst pizza ever. Period! 1. Had pieces of meat on a vegetarian pizza which is extremely ridiculous. 2. The slices without meat were extremely extremely bad. I have baked pizza only couple of times and I can make a 10X better pizza than these people. 3. Presentation: who puts an entire slice of tomato on top of a pizza slice. Well these guys do. What on earth are they thinking. read more

Flying Pie Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Issaquah, Washington

This is the best pizza. Though their menu is meat-heavy, I was able to build my own pizza combination, and they pulled it off better than any others have. Thin crust with marinara sauce, roasted garlic, and black olives are always a good pairing, but Flying Pie constructed it with such delicacy and intention. The crust was crispy and golden, the sauce and cheese just enough to stick the toppings on (I have quite a horror of pizzas overdressed). The proportions, too, of garlic and olives were well balanced: neither stingy nor overflowing off the slice. Each bite was more delicious than the next; I had to fight myself to not finish the whole pizza myself. read more

I finally had the chance to try this place out after being recommended by a coworker. Their pizzas are loaded and each pizza can definitely be split between two people! The crust is just right and the flavors are on point. Also, I would recommend checking out their ranch sauce. They sell it in 12 oz containers, and it was definitely all used up by the time this food was done. Also, I'm not sure how long the promotion is going for, but if you spend at least $25, they will give you a free cheese pizza which is totally worth it! read more

See all

I learned about this place after a friend shared a photo of a slice of pizza overflowing with toppings! It looked so good I made the 30 mile trek to try it for myself. Ordering the "Combination Supreme Number 1" seemed like the best place to start... And, it was worth the drive! Fresh, flavorful and filling! I wasn't in a hurry so the wait time wasn't a bother to me (they're short staffed like everyone so I came expecting it, you should too). read more

Always so good. Especially love their Ranch dressing and house italian sausage. The folks are always very welcoming there. Cozy place to take the family. read more

This review is more about the total lack of FPP Management response to our last visit experience. FPP has some of the best pizza in the Seattle area. We love their combo II. We have been going to their Issaquah location for many, many years. The number of less than stellar visits total less than 3-4 so wouldn't you expect FPP Management would respond when we detailed a totally overcooked pizza and asked for a credit? Not a word after two "contact us" efforts! When you pay over $30 for a 16" pizza and almost $20 for a pitcher of beer the pizza should not be so overcooked that the usual great flavors and moisture are baked away. This was the case on our last visit even though there were few customers in their restaurant at 5:15pm? Really sad! I guess its time to start looking for another pizza outlet? read more

See all