Loved the customer service! Quick dine setup with disposable plates and utensils but the interior design is posh for the supposed quick turnover of diners. Ample of parking space. Clean restroom. Highchair seen. BYOB but they have bottle and canned drinks to sell. Accepts credit/debit cards. See images for reference. read more

See all

I was able to try this at a company outing. The food was ready in a timely manner. I was able to eat two of their salads. I had the tossed and Panatieri's salad. The tossed salad consisted of lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, onions, and cucumbers. I had this with a balsamic vinaigrette. This was solid. Everything appeared very fresh and was just a simple salad done right. The Panatieri's salad had fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers over mixed greens. Again, this seemed to be fresh. The roasted peppers were cut nicely, and the mozzarella was tasty as well. Once again, a straightforward salad done correctly. Will I go back? I don't see why not. read more

Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta- Bedminster - Mix of Tossed & Panatieri's Salad - Pizza Near Me - Bedminster, New Jersey

The worst! Pizza is cardboard, gummy with no taste! The penne vodka is disgusting, and the staff is rude. Get pizza from Rocco's in bedminster instead! Panatieri in bedminster went down hill! read more

Very yummy local pizza joint. Solid choices for pizzas and Sammies. Convenient liquor store across the street. read more

See all

You must sell top drawer pizza in NJ to survive and Panatieris does it very well on a consistent basis. Besides , they have been successful for many years read more

Panatieri's has good Italian food, my family loves it but I think it's decent but not bad. I had a bitter sweet gluten-free experience: I was happy to see GF pizza on the menu and was even more delighted when it came in its own labeled box with a separate pizza server to prevent cross contamination. However, the quality of the pizza did not meet my expectations. The texture is grainy and the pizza falls apart easily. It appears to be a heated up frozen pizza. I won't be ordering it again. read more

Perfectly good run-of-the-mill pizza. Nothing to drive an hour for but gets the job done. Have had it by the slice several times and it has been consistently pretty good, particularly the Sicilian. Just ordered a whole Sicilian and didn't care for it nearly as much as the by the slice, which I found very strange. The crust was very dry and they were really skimpy with the pepperoni and sausage. Very disappointing. Many reviews were whinging about the service. Get over it. This is a strip center pizza place, not a linen tablecloth sit down restaurant. Get over it. All service sucks since COVID. I have never had particularly bad service there. So, if you live in the area, it's an OK choice. There aren't a ton of great places in Pluckemin. read more

Very friendly people. And the food was top-notch. I can't believe more people are not lined up to go here

Panatieri's is a small, New Jersey chain that consistently puts out good pizza. Other locations have not disappointed me and the Bedminster location is no different. The plain has a nice, thin, and crisp base. It also features a delicious, stretchy cheese. It's a great, foldable slice. The squares have a fluffier base with a crispier crust. The sauce is high-quality. Garlic and other spices add a ton of flavor. The Brooklyn pie has more sauce and a great flavor. Overall, you can't go wrong with this spot. -@BoroPizzaHunter on Instagram. read more

Great pizza every time. My family is pretty basic when it comes to getting a pie: plain and well done and we'll be happy! Panatieri's (we either go here or the loc in Flemington) gets it right every order. The crust is just the perfect thinness and sauce is super flavorful. I never seem to get a picture to post here on Yelp because it never lasts long once we walk in the door. A pie never takes more than 20 or so minutes, the staff are all usually really friendly and they are pretty affordable. Great choice if you are in the area and looking for a great slice! read more

Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta- Bedminster - Chicken Marsala with penne! - Pizza Near Me - Bedminster, New Jersey

We really love the pizza of this location. The pizza is never soggy, with just the perfect touch of sauce. The pie crust is excellent. The garlic knots are to die for. Penne Vodka is also very good. Service is always friendly. It is 5 minutes away from my daughter's horse riding stable, so perfect for us to pick up dinner on the way home. They are on the slice app. Order ahead of time if you can. Highly recommend! read more

Ordered Takeout several weeks ago and it was so good we did it again this past weekend. Located in a small plaza anchored by Fresh Market. Upon entering, they have all kinds of italian food displayed under the heat lamps. Sit down area is small but adequate and menu extensive. Pizzas, Calzones, Strombolis, Pastas, and Sandwiches, et al. We ordered our usual: Stuffed meat lovers pizza, small pepperoni, sausage, olive calzone with marinara. Twenty minute wait, food was ready, and consumed in short order. Both were very good and reasonably priced. (Less than 40 smacks all in). Glad we tried it out. read more

My new favorite Bedminster Pizza! I been to every other shop in and around town. I must confess that I avoided this one because it's a chain. I guess I had it in my mind it would be like Sbarros mall pizza but I was way wrong. Their plan pies are solid, great sauce and they aren't afraid to load on the toppings. We tried a couple of cheesesteaks the other day and a couple of the specialty slices. All were fresh and very good. I wouldn't say any of their food is off the charts "heart of Brooklyn" amazing, but it's still pretty darn good pizza and worth checking it out. This is officially our family pizza joint when we don't feel like leaving town to get pie. Service is also great, orders done fast and staff is always friendly. My only criticism is they don't deliver. We have used DoorDash but then get wacked with all their fees and delivery charges. This is the only reason I knocked a star off my rating. read more

This spot is perfect for to-go dinner! The calzones are so huge! Order a large and it'll be perfect for two people! I personally love the Bianca pizza -- which is a gourmet white pizza! They also have an amazing selection of pasta which is great for those who would prefer noods over bread! read more

Man, I've missed New Jersey. The bar for pizza in this state is high. Even though the locals may not find this place to be all that exciting, they do really good work. Pizza's are hand formed. The pies are cooked directly on the oven floor. The sauce has character. The cheese has actual flavor. And toppings are delicious. Now, I know what you may be saying to yourself if you're from Jersey. That's just the definition of pizza. What else would it be? But in most of the country, pizzas don't even begin to measure up to the minimum criteria of the form. It's a tragedy. And yet, somehow, pizza is one of America's favorite foods. I was into the rosemary added to the sauce, and I loved the bottom crust. I did wish for more end crust, and more lift. But a slice at Panatieri's really hit the spot. read more

See all

Very good food and excellent service. The atmosphere is great too. Can't say enough about it!!!!

Just awful...ordered calamari which was stone cold and wings which were tough. NOT a repeat

Best pizza joint in the area Pizza and hot subs are awesome Friendly staff too. Highly recommended read more

I was initially excited about the pizza varieties and the convenient location. I've given this place several tries and although the pizza is decent, it would be masochistic to continue to expose myself to the hellish service. Literally stood and listened to the woman behind the counter curse me out in a language she didn't think I understood. Not sure if it's incompetence, or just not giving a damn about customers. Will not be returning. There are too many other options in the area. read more

Great pizza - secret is in the sauce, the dough and the plenty toppings available! Side trip unexpected turned into a lovely lunch for two!

Very good food. My wife loves the salad. We enjoy the pizza, meatball sandwiches and wings for usual pick ups. Definitely recommend

Panatieri's used to be great hands down. Unfortunately, our last 2 orders have been incorrect and it's the last time we will order from this location. The people who work at this location cannot seem to get their act together whether it's forgetting item, not taking the orders correctly or not having their food ready on time. This last time we ordered a sub and a pizza. I had the order read back to me because of the woman taking the order was absolutely not listening. We were told 40 minutes and when we arrived to pick the order up they handed us a sub, having totally forgotten to make the pizza. They did not appear too busy, and certainly had adequate staff. How does a pizzeria forget to make the pizza? Needless to say we returned home without dinner for 3 of us. Management has either changed or just doesn't care. read more

Got pizza delivered cold and undercooked. Cheese steak hoagie w no lettuce onion tomato Mayo like I ordered. Was like road kill. $38 terrible read more

We've only ever had the pizza -- slices usually. Maybe not the best, but much better than average. The standards are good, but their specialty pizzas are hit-or-miss. All in all, I'd say a B+ to an A-. The selection of pizzas is OUTSTANDING and happily are available all the way to closing. The staff is very friendly and the dining room is pleasant -- especially for what is primarily a pizza joint. read more

See all

I've had Panatieri's before but not at this location. I was pleasantly surprised at the decor and set up for the pizzas. It looked like it was newly renovated (was it? Lol). Upon entry, I noticed how clean it was. I ordered their version of the Chicago deep dish (mostly meat). It was ready not long after I called so only needed to wait a few minutes....not good for me to sit there hungry staring at the lovely display of pizzas. When I say lovely, I mean kind of like a showcase of their pizzas. They were all neatly arranged and well lit. Paying and leaving was uneventful. I got home and my husband was surprised they had a pie like that. We tried it and we were pleasantly surprised they it was tasty and not overly doughy (and not greasy at all!). I like Pizza Hut but they tend to be super greasy (like squishy greasy lol). One slice was enough for me. I'd like to try out the other Chicago style pizza. Next time! read more

Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta- Bedminster - Pizza Near Me - Bedminster, New Jersey

The girl working the cash register was rude. I asked her a question (if they could make a certain kind of pie) and she didn't know. I later asked another employee the same question...which prompted her to come storming over, screaming at me, asking why I'm bothering him when she already answered me. read more

Worst customer service ever. I ordered a margarita pizza and was told it will take 10 min. After waiting for 15 min I found out my order wasn't even in the kitchen. People should carry attitude if they have a customer service to match that attitude otherwise it's just rude behavior. read more

Came back because my family ordered from here. A much better experience where the food tasted great. I do not know what happened since last time but keep it up:) read more

I have not encountered bad service - the staff has always been friendly and I've gotten my order on time. Honestly, just not the greatest pizza (there are better options, but this is a super convenient location). The pizza tastes better reheated the next day. Pasta is pretty good, but pricey for the small portion. read more

Been here many times but the staff has a difficult time communicating with each other and then it upsets the customers. A little more training will go a long way or maybe one person specially assigned to take out on a Friday night so people don't wait 45 minutes after being told 20 minutes for an order. read more

Everything is fine but there is no seasoning, like on the pasta , wings, and etc but overall good service

Painfully slow service for dine in. 5 minutes for the one waitress to come over and greet us. 2 pasta dishes took 30 minutes to get- 2 very basic not baked pasta dishes. Your best bet is to call ahead and order. They really can not handle large crowds and do so much take out business they neglect the restaurant side. Food is good and worth it if you don't mind the wait. Monday is half price entree dine in night. (Must buy a soda). Bottom line, come during an off time and enjoy. 3.5 read more

I get carryout from here a few times a month and have never once been disappointed. The deepish style pizzas are literally to die for. Brooklyn Grandma and Jersey pies are my go to. Always polite on the phone when I call and prompt service when I'm in the restaurant. Would highly recommend. read more

Been here a few times for pizza and once for dinner entree. Huge variety of slice pizza selections as soon as you enter. They have all your standard toppings and quite a few gourmet flavors like chicken masala, cheesesteak and chicken Caesar salad pizza. The spinach gourmet has fresh vegetable toppings with tomato, mozzarella cheese and spinach. I especially like their deep dish pizza with the crispy crust. They have Sicilian pizza too. They run half price entree specials on Mondays with the purchase of any drink which is not bad at all. The staff here are pretty friendly. Definitely going to give Rocco's some competition. read more

See all

Been here twice for their various selection of pizza slices and wings. They have a wide array of kinds, ranging from most your common pepperoni to the more exotic chicken ceasar salad slice. words I would use to describe this restaurant are authentic, fresh, clean, and most importantly, delicious. read more

The food was good the service was HORRIBLE! Will not be coming back again. We ordered Strombolis and waited was 40 minutes. Maybe take out is the way to go. read more

The pizza is horrible and almost taste like rubber with no flavor. I was starving so I ate it but I will never return. Rude staff too. Waste of money... read more

Having never been to a Panatieri's before, I was a little worried that a "chain" pizza place was opening up. Upon first slice, I was clearly mistaken. Definitely my favorite pizza in the area. Bedminster Pizza was the previous winner, but even their slices can get a bit soggy at times. Panatieri's uses the right amount of (delicious) sauce, throwing on a heap of cheese, and always cooks it to the right texture. I'm not really worried about any of the odd pizza slices they sell (another reviewer gave them a poor review due to this selection) as I tend to keep it pretty standard and always order a full pie at a time. Now I want pizza. Thanks. read more

The pizza is great, I've tried so many pizza places and usually are disgusting but this place is totally the opposite. since I moved here , this place it's my favorite for pizza and pasta.(You should also try their pasta, it's good ) Their service it's a little mediocre, can't lie about it. I've been here so many times and honestly I prefer to order by the phone than stay there. But don't blame the pizza because of the crappy service they offer. Domino's or papa John's can't be compare to their pizza guys. read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would. Horrible food and service! Clueless staff, dirty kitchen and unsanitary handling of food.