I really want to like Pantry Pizza. It is incredibly convenient to my house, and the owners and staff are always nice. That kindness is the only reason I've given them so many chances. The ingredients taste like the cheapest options available from the distributor (nothing is homemade I'm convinced), and the assembly feels slapped together with zero pride. With better competition moving into the neighborhood, Pantry needs to understand that convenience isn't enough anymore. You have to actually try. Here is the breakdown of our disappointment: - Cheese Pizza (2/10): It is baffling how a pizza can have absolutely no flavor; the sauce is bland, the cheese bland, and the dough bland! - Calzone (1/10): I live a five minute walk from the shop, yet this was already a soggy mess by the time I got home. - The Gobbler Sub & Boneless Wings (6/10): These are the only redeeming items on the menu and only things I recommend. And my god the tomatoes they use!!! Please stop using these. They are the unripe, flavorless, watery stereotype of bad sub shop vegetable. Just leave out if you can't get better ones. I want to support local, but I can't anymore. Please make some improvements. read more

Pantry Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

S/O to Dorchester! I LOOOOOVE DORCHESTER! Pantry pizza is a great place! Been around for yrs! But customer service ...... eeeehhhhh. There's this white girl who works front desk... ATTITUDE ALL THE TIME!!! LIKE IDK WHATS UP WITH HER! But she doesn't like her life and that's fair!!!! BUT GIRL YOU'RE AT WORK! I'm sorry with you're going through.. but I didn't do it do it to you. I know customer is hard when you're going through things but her attitude was so unprofessional. I have dealt with her multiple times, and I always give grace... but being on the phone and handling personal business was insane.... The face of the house is important so please check your attitude ! But I thank yall for giving these good slices out in the city! #LOVE ! read more

We ordered an XL pizza with banana peppers and mushrooms. The banana peppers were gray, and overall the pizza was bland. Crust didn't taste like anything, only flavor we could identify was vinegar from the sad banana peppers. It's so disappointing that the ingredients are such low quality. read more

Heart of savin hill. Best pizza and wings in the area . Very clean restaurant, a friendly service lady at the counter. It's very nice. Fresh slices, ready to go I was in on Dorchester day and he had a special going on small Cheese Pizza for it. It's six dollars is seventeen cent.. it's a Boston thing. If you know you know. I would like to go there and try other things next time. I'm around in that area. read more

See all

Literally no idea how this place stays in business. I live next door and only come here when DoorDash messes up my delivery from another restaurant and I'm forced to order something in a pinch. They use the lowest quality ingredients and the pizza is always super undercooked and soggy. It's really a shame because the previous owners actually delivered a product to be proud of. Would love to see this place go out of business and something better open. read more

It's convenient. That's the only reason people go here. You live around the corner. Nobody is dying to eat here. Everything is just so sloppily and unprofessionally done. read more

The Cobb salad is to die for! If you're a salad lover, you absolutely have to check out this gem! The salad is fresh, flavorful, and packed with delicious ingredients like blue cheese crumbles, mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, romaine lettuce, avocado, hard-boiled egg, crispy bacon, and perfectly grilled chicken. Every bite is a combination of savory, crunchy, and creamy that hits the spot. What makes it even better is the mom-and-pop feel of the place, with fast and friendly service that makes you feel right at home. Plus, the prices are incredibly reasonable for the quality and portion sizes you get. I always have some left for lunch the next day. And don't even get me started on the peppercorn Parmesan dressing it's hands down the best in Boston! It's so good, I drive all the way from near Dedham just to get my salad fix. Highly recommend it! Please GO! read more

Wings are are 9/10 The Big Island Calzone is 10/10 Rest of the food is pretty meh or miss. Menu is bigger than most places I've ever been too. Could probably benefit from cutting down the menu size and focusing on the quality of what they have. Also can be pricey. Even before covid the place had pretty high prices for stuff like specialty pizzas. They are all the same price despite having much different toppings. 100% worth going for that calzone and the wings tho. read more

Used to be my go to spot. Now it seems they put sugar in the sauce which ruins it for me.

Love love love Pantry's Hawaiian pizza (Aloha). Instead of cubed chicken, they offer shredded chicken. Make sure to get it well done and PRO TIP, add jalapeños. You'll thank me later! Pair it was an order of their wings. Low key, one of the crispiest wings around Dorchester. I tried their garlic Parmesan dip on the side, I was surprised. It was so good lol read more

See all

This is more of a 3.5/5 than a 4/5, but as it's definitely better than a 3/5, I'm giving it a 4/5 since half points aren't possible on Yelp. The bottom line is that the pizza here is good - not great, but good. It's certainly not bad. It's above average but nothing too impressive. That being said, I did have a pretty plain order, and there are no complaints. 1/2 Cheese pizza: This was above average - the crust was crunchy, but a bit too crunchy for me. It had some chew but not enough for my preference, and it didn't really have that much taste (though at least it wasn't burnt). The cheese and sauce ratios were on point, and the sauce had a nice, deep flavor that puts it above plain marinara sauce. A solid cheese pizza that could have had a better crust, but it wasn't terrible. 1/2 Cheese and basil pizza: The basil did a lot of work here and it felt like an entirely different pizza from the cheese half. Maybe it was the mix of the basil and the sauce, but this really had a deeper flavor that tasted distinctly Italian. The crust was the same however, and it let this pizza down a bit, but I'd highly recommend adding basil to your pizza here. When it comes down to it, this was an above average pizza. There weren't too many substantial complaints, but there wasn't anything super distinctive that would make this a pizza I'd travel for. Still, if I were in the area, I'd probably go here again. 3.5/5! read more

Pantry Pizza - Half cheese and half cheese and basil pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

Ordered from a place called "pasta glory" on uber eats the food looked amazing. When it arrived I immediately realized the garlic bread looked nothing like the pictures on the app. The spaghetti and meatballs were bland and, the sauce to noodle ratio was weird and had more water than anything. Finally after some investigation I realized the garlic bread box said "pantrypizza.com". The only pasta glory is in Florida. We were completely deceived, bamboozled and highly disappointed. However the cheesy garlic bread that was supposed to be regular garlic bread turned out to be good and, really big. read more

Solid pizza,good dinners, wings are ok! friendly service and always hot. Will be back.

Pizza was good! I got the buffalo chicken pizza, it comes with blue cheese crumbles on it. They always forget my sauce though! That's okay, still delicious! read more

I've been eating from Patty's for over 30 years and have always been satisfied up until this Summer. I don't know what happened but I've been disappointed the last 3 times I've ordered from there. Yesterday was the worst! Both the Italian and Meatball subs were HORRIBLE! I'm DONE! I guess all good things must come to an end. read more

I ordered a pineapple chicken pizza and some chicken wings The pizza had a taste of feathers/spoiled chicken Chicken wings were unedible. Texture was rubbery and stale like it was cooked 2 days ago read more

Pizza was below subpar it was supposed to be a thin crust and it was a traditional style. I called the location and said my pizza was supposed to be thin crust and she noted all of our pizzas are thin crust. Wtf, The flavor was meh . read more

Very disappointed in my order today. Food came on time and order was correct. However, for a $11 steak and cheese sub (with extra cheese) I was extremely upset with what we received!!! Photo attached. Can't even see anything resembling cheese, and from the second I picked up the sandwich before unwrapping it I could tell something was off. There's hardly ANY MEAT!! And my pizza didn't have ANY of the toppings I ordered and PAID FOR! Just a plain old cheese pizza. Tried to call back but no answer. I used to love this place! Would rant and rave about it to others. But slowly with each order, one or two things go wrong and I'm slowly learning my lesson. Sad times :( read more

Pantry Pizza - Large ($10) steak and cheese with extra cheese. Do u see ANY cheese? Or steak for that matter??? - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

See all

My favorite pizza place on earth. Moved away a couple years ago and damn I miss it. Excellent pizza but don't sleep on the pastrami

Love love love, this neighborhood spot! I live right down the street, delivery has always been prompt and the menu has a huge variety! My usuals: Astrid's creation on a sub grilled (8.5) my first time trying it was amazing! The last few times has been underwhelming. Essentially it has a "healthy" feel to it compared to a traditional steak and cheese sub. I'm a really picky eater but when I hear grilled teriyaki chicken, avocados, spinach and honey mustard; I go crazy! Those are the few things I chose to eat. Next my other options would be the crispy fried chicken- which has so many sauces and options! I typically like to order the Buffalo chicken (8.0) Honey mustard (7.5) Hawaiian teriyaki (7.0) Mango habanero (9.0) My comfort dish for football games would be the pulled pork quesadilla (9.0) read more

Pantry Pizza is one or the best sub shops in the Savin Hill area. No questions asked. I have been ordering from them for almost 8 years. The drivers are excellent and courteous also. Keep up the good work! read more

Pantry Pizza - Chicken Finger Mango habanero plate with French fries and house salad. Sauce on the side - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

Really good grilled chicken sub with fries. Would get it again. The staff were friendly and my food was on time. read more

Pantry Pizza - "The Fat Guy's Diet Sandwich" with fries - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

Always good. Local folks and if you order delivery, they are right there. Please tip!! read more

The hours got away from me and I had limited options. I ordered a salad from Pantry Pizza and the next day was violently sick. Never again.

Burnt pizza no flavor at all.. all grease... don't recommend at all. Save your money.. better pizza in the north end..

I took a chance and ordered an Italian sub from this business. I left instructions for them in the detail box. They didn't follow them. Left out the mayo. When I called the establishment the woman said "well Italians usually don't have mayo. They have oil. " Needless to say, both were missing on the sandwich, and the attitude was not appreciated at all. The filling was kinda old, specifically, the tomatoes. She informed me that that they would deliver a new one. I wasn't happy about that, particularly when she said "save the old one and we'll switch it out." I had already put my own mayo on it. On top of which the driver called me from the wrong address on the first attempt. Had to wait another 10 minutes before he could find my address. Overall, I cannot recommend this place at all. read more

Extremely disappointed. After reading good reviews, I had hoped for a much better experience, especially since Pantry is located very close to my home and would be a convenient spot for regular take out. I ordered a chicken parm sub and a Caesar salad. I specially asked for the bun to be crispy and not soggy. When it arrived, the bun was super soggy, only 2 barely visible slices of cheese (under the chicken?), soggy breaking on the chicken, and the chicken was extremely dry and stringy. On top of all of this, I paid $24.00 for this crappy sub and tiny bowl of lettuce, only to also have it take over an hour and a half to be delivered. Extremely disappointed. read more

Pantry Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

We order wings/subs/salads/pizza a few times a month and have rarely been disappointed (except today when we got a sausage parm sub instead of the meatball parm sub we ordered.) The wings have stayed consistently good even with the new ownership. If you can eat them hot, that's when they are the best. Very large, crunchy, good simple seasoning on the original (we always get Buffalo sauce on the side). The salads are also very large and fresh. I've gotten the west coast a few times and only recently felt like there wasn't enough chicken... Pizza is good, also best when eaten hot. It's good reheated too. The only thing that has bothered us is the inconsistency with packing us ketchup. Take today for example, we got (the wrong) sub but also did not receive any ketchup to go with the side of fries we ordered. It's gotten pretty bad especially because when we call it in we specially ask for ketchup. So overall, we will continue to order food from pantry but will also make sure to always have ketchup at home. read more

Steak and cheese. Ordered extra steak and extra cheese....it had neither. Is there some cheese shortage I'm unaware of?? Every time I get this sandwich it's got virtually no cheese! I'll gladly give the rating another star or even the full five if they just were just more generous with the toppings. GO SOX! read more

Pantry Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

Had a large cheese and pepperoni delivered. The pizzas were great and they were delivered early. Will definitely order from here again.

Our go-to pizza place in the neighborhood. Lots of variety. Always on time. I like their wings too. Can't go wrong here.

Got a Fish Sub for the 1st time here @ Pantry Pizza & it was DELICIOUS!!! & 1st time LIKING SubShop Tarter Sauce ever!!! read more

Very friendly people and great service! I went in for pickup and this place was live! 4 delivery drivers in and out on top of a ton of customers! The food was amazing! read more

Pantry Pizza - Steak tip potato skins - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

I ordered 15 pizzas for delivery for Post Game food for the Umass Boston Lacrosse team. Pizzas were awesome! Delivered hot, great sizes and very fresh. The team loved it and many if them asked where I got them and plan to order themselves! read more

Be CAREFUL!! I ordered online and decided to pay at store; however I was going to pay with my card, this guy asked. 1- to hand him my card (Verizon from the point of sale was perfectly working) 2- My zip code and charged me 7 times the amount. After that happened, same night I saw an online purchase which obviously was made by that guy. Since I ordered on-line the already have my correct address, my full name and phone number. He only needed my CVV ( 3 digits from the back of my card) That is scam and to take your money on my face. BE CAREFUL read more

I ordered a chicken quesadilla from this place and was extremely disappointed. They literally only sent me boiled, shredded chicken and cheese, and no seasoning. will never order again from here. read more

Pantry Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dorchester, Massachusetts

I love pantry pizza formerly Pattys Pantry! This place has been a staple my entire life! When they revamped things a few years ago and turned into Pantry Pizza it changed for the better! This place has amazing food! I've tried most of the menu items and the favorites are the pizza particularly we love the hamburger pizza! My dad loves the steak and cheese and my niece is a fan of the buffalo wings. When no one wants to cook we go to pantry pizza! If you are a new user make sure you order online they give you five dollars off of your order. The prices are pretty reasonable as is so that's an added bonus! The delivery is also super fast! The food always arrives warm and I've never had a mistake when it comes to an order. They are very nice and accommodating. I've never had a problem just great quality food hot and ready when I order. read more

See all

I'm giving them another star. The quality of their pizza has improved tremendously since we first ordered. It gets better every time. The last two times we ordered, it was simply delicious. The last pie, with pesto and mushrooms was excellent. So glad to have this place in the neighborhood. read more

This review is for the pizza only - I've tried it a few times. A couple times it's been good, but the last few times it's been too dry. Like literally barely any sauce on it. Very disappointing :( I think this is an issue with the white sauce pizzas specifically. I'll stick to the subs and salads here. read more

The place is super convenient, but the pizza is not really good... there just isn't a lot of flavor. They usually have slices if you want to stop in quick. The chicken is dry and not seasoned so it's not great on the pizza. Also they don't have chicken bacon ranch available on their online ordering BUT they always have it in the slices. When you order a CBR it's super expensive because they charge per topping. The sandwiches are alright depending on what you get, I usually get the renzo which is good and they have tons of toppings you can add. read more