Cancel

Open app

Search

Papa Kelseys

3.5 (18 reviews)
Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Papa Kelseys Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like Papa Kelseys

Recommended Reviews - Papa Kelseys

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos - Papa Kelseys

Back east you'd be run out of town if you served a sangweech like this. Meet scimp. Outrageous

Back east they would run you out of town if you served a meatless sangweech like this. Outrageous. Will never go back. Do better.

More bread. Less filling.

See all

10 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 2
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 3

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 1

10 months ago

Great service and a great sandwich, the pizza on the other hand was not good. Go get a sandwich though you won't be disappointed.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Troy M.
33
11
0

1 year ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Papa Kelseys

Review Highlights - Papa Kelseys

But back to the oven baked sandwiches, Papa Kelsey's claims to have the "best dough" & certainly lives up to the hype!

Mentioned in 3 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Bardenay Restaurant & Distillery - Eagle

Bardenay Restaurant & Distillery - Eagle

3.8
(613 reviews)
0.9 mi
$$

Ohmigosh yes! Such delicious sweet potato fries and salmon. Also, their gnocchi is really good as…read morewell. I like how the ceasar salad even had a lil spicy flavor to it along with the fries. Love spicy the waiter was super friendly. I loved where we sat, and even had some cute ducklings visiting us.

Headed to Bardenay in Eagle to celebrate my birthday with some family tonight. They arrived first…read moreand got us a table out on the patio. It was the most perfect day for outdoor seating. And with the view by the patio, how can it not be the most perfect setting to enjoy my birthday dinner. We just stuck with water since it was on the warmer side today. We just went straight in for dinner. As much as the appetizers sounded lovely, I was ready for the main event. So for dinner tonight I ordered the charboiled salmon with seasonal veggies in place of the salad. My salmon was plated beautifully with nice char marks on it. The veggies were a variety of squash and were sautéed nicely. And you can tell visually that they were seasoned nicely with spices and herbs. I dug right into my salmon. My first couple bites were delicious. I did spread some of the sun dried tomato butter on my salmon. The butter was fantastic! It added a nice flavor element to the salmon. After I ate about a a fourth of my salmon, I noticed that it was not cooked all the way through in the middle. With my new kidney, I can't have rare or undercooked fish. My immune system can't handle a parasite if the fish were to potentially contain any. I shouldn't have assumed that it was going to be cooked all the way since our server didn't ask how well I wanted it cooked. I did have to send it back and have another one remade. While my new fish was being prepared, my server gave me a small salad plate to transfer my veggies to. I got to work on them so I wasn't staring at my family eat. The veggies were cooked perfectly. They weren't overly soft or still raw. It had a nice bite to them while still being tender. Unfortunately, they were overly seasoned and was on the saltier side. I was hungry so I polished them off. But I did have to drink a good amount of water to help with the saltiness. Thank goodness the portion was on the daintier side. As hungry as I was, it would have been bad if it was a bigger portion. All that salt would not be good on my new kidney. My second round of salmon came out. Was it as pretty as my first plate, no but it will do. I'm sure they set the flame on high, let it sit on the grill for a while and then flipped it to cook the other side. I have cooked salmon well done plenty of times and have it come out tender. When you cook for a living, having cooking times for your dishes should be down to a science in your kitchen. Unfortunately, the salmon was super dry and flavorless. As hungry as I was, I ate it. The butter did help with the dryness of the salmon. But I shouldn't have to rely on butter to make the dish edible. For my birthday, I got a free dessert. I chose the gluten free carrot cake. My cousin eats a gluten free diet so I thought this cake would be perfect for all of us. I enjoyed the cake very much! The cake was moist. The spices in the cake were fragrant and very noticeable in each bite. I loved the frosting on the cake. Since the cake wasn't overly sweet, the frosting added a nice sweetness to it. I enjoyed the cake very much! Our server did a mid job. There were times when she would be gone for long periods of time and we had to wait for her. The patio was perfect with its stunning view. Dinner was ok but dessert was fabulous. Overall it was a decent experience. I do look forward to coming back and enjoying the outdoor patio with my husband for a date night. I just know now to make sure I vocalize everything to my server so I don't end up with dry salmon again. I do want to come back and have a better experience.

Photos
The Bartender
The Bartender
Pho
Pho
Blue lagoon(mocktail), huckleberry lemon drop, can't touch this (mocktail)

See all

Blue lagoon(mocktail), huckleberry lemon drop, can't touch this (mocktail)
Panera Bread

Panera Bread

2.3
(21 reviews)
0.1 mi

I didn't check the reviews before heading in for lunch today. The brand has a good reputation, but…read morethis experience was a bit all over the place. There's so much to choose from, which is great, but it might be a bit much for first-time visitors. It was quiet today, and the staff was very nice and helpful. We both ordered the soup and sandwich combo. The seating is a bit cold and not the most comfortable place to relax, but it's okay. My first big "yuck" was the beverage area. It was filthy! There was sticky liquid all over the counter and the floor! The floor was disgusting, not only with sticky soda but also crumbs under every table. By the time I sat down, I was sure it was my last visit here. The buzzer went off, and I walked up to get our food only to be told it wasn't ready! (What?) Anyway, I got it, and it looked really good! I had some hot Italian sandwich and tomato soup. It was amazing! I also got a small piece of a baguette that was wonderful! My wife had broccoli and cheese soup and said it was wonderful as well. She also had a one off custom sandwich that she loved. I hope they take a bit more pride in their store and clean it up as we really did enjoy there food. So many new places coming to town this kind of experience can hurt. I hope the management reads these reviews!

Constipated. That's the word that kept popping into my head for this new Panera. Starting with…read morethe location for awkward access off of State Street to Edgewood before making an immediate right turn onto a narrow access way into the parking lot. The description also applies to the to tight and awkwardly built parking lot. And for Pete's sake, city planning review people, there is a Chik-Fil-A now under construction in this same place that will be using the same access way and parking lot. (And eventually fast casual pizza franchise, Slice House.) You must be kidding. No wonder this was such a controversial project as it was wending it's way through approval processes. But that's not Panera's fault so let's get to what seemed constipated, or at least not smooth moving, at the store. I detoured here on the way home from a morning haircut to pick up a cup of hot chocolate, I had been getting Panera emails in the way of "insider special" and also a pastry, both to go, as I had also received snail mailed discount coupons to my house. I live in this city and they have been trying to make locals aware of the new store. Although the inside was not crowded, after waiting a good while to try to place an order, I left because I had an appointment at home that I didn't want to be late for. The reason I couldn't place an order was that it was unclear to me if I was supposed to use one of 3 kiosks at the front or if I could order at the counter (my preference) and there was no way to ask the single person working the counter "how do I?" Also the sign at front said if you are having a beverage to get your cup first. OK then, where? Also, the item in the case I thought I wanted to order had no label on it so I wasn't sure, if I used the kiosk, what it was I was ordering, and no one to ask about that either. So I decided to do this the old fashioned way and wait to order the counter. But I could not do that because there was only one person working at the counter and she was behind the register trying her best to help the customer who also wanted to order and who was asking questions. This poor (obviously new) employee was out of her depth for what to do. Not her fault, where was the manager to help her? But just as the employee had a "eureka" moment on how to get the order placed, the customer presented her discount coupon that she received via snail mail and the employee once again was thrown for a loop, said that coupon was for orders placed via XYZ method and now she would have to try to find someone who could help her figure out how to apply the discount. That is when I turned around and exited. They need to work on this. The service snafus are all fixable by management. And the space itself is not welcoming, warts and all, most Panera's are that, and it seems to me it would be from difficult to impossible for a person using a wheelchair to find clear path of travel to a table to sit at. Panera, you can do and have done better for mere ADA compliance. This is the closest location to my home but I won't go back. Meridian or Boise are better options.

Photos
Panera Bread
My adorable so and rock hard, nasty cookies.
My adorable so and rock hard, nasty cookies.
Panera Bread

See all

Spitfire Tacos + Tequila

Spitfire Tacos + Tequila

3.8
(264 reviews)
0.9 mi
$$

I have wanted to try Spitfire since it opened, but the fervor and lack of availability for me to go…read moredelayed my visit. I had a day off for my birthday and decided to celebrate at Spitfire to coincide with my first visit (finally!). We had to initially decide on indoor or outdoor dining. Since it was a 96 degree day, we opted for indoors...though the only downside is they have the outdoors only separated by a magnetic screen "door", which still lets in heat and flies. The happy hour menu was presented as soon as we were seated with a cheerful ask if we wanted to start off with bogo margaritas. Yes, please. Keep in mind, this is bogo per person, not to share around the table. I started off with the Huckleberry Acapulco, which was slightly sweet with a hit of tequila. Next, I tried the Tijuana Tamarind which was more savory and evenly balanced. Next came the "Street Corn Named Desire" street corn appetizer with chips. The corn was heavily seasoned and spicy. I can handle spice and it made me sweat a little...but it was crave-worthy spicy, not "burn your tongue off" spicy. Next came the plethora of burritos and tacos that the family and I ordered. I opted for a single smash burger taco, filled with a crispy-edged thin burger patty nestled with fresh iceberg lettuce, cheese, dill pickles and the "spitfire special sauce" (which closely resembles thousand island dressing) in a beautifully griddled flour tortilla. Every bite was like eating a balanced burger, but just as a taco. I genuinely each bite. Everyone eagerly gobbled up their meals with "yummmmmm" occasionally floating around the table. Next, they brought out the churro lava cake to celebrate my birthday. That cake was so uniquely fun and decadent. They made everything so special for me! With the exception of the flies joining us for dinner, I cannot wait for my next visit.

We ordered al pastor tacos, Baja California tacos, a burrito, and nachos with salsa, along with a…read moremargarita and a glass of wine. Everything was tasty and well-prepared, with good portions and a reasonable price. The atmosphere was lively and pleasant, and the service was friendly and efficient. Overall, a solid spot for casual Mexican-inspired food and drinks in Eagle.

Photos
Bar
Bar
Korean BBQ Pork Belly Taco Korean BBQ Pork Belly Taco
Korean BBQ Pork Belly Taco Korean BBQ Pork Belly Taco
Decorations

See all

Decorations
Kosta's Taverna

Kosta's Taverna

4.8
(161 reviews)
0.9 mi
$$

Food was excellent and we met Mr Kostas. A Greek immigrant…read morecame to America to bring us a taste of the Mediterranean. We had the Kefta beef and lamb pita, hummus, falafel and Ice cream Baklava. Everything was excellent.

In reality, I will rarely choose Greek food as a dinner choice. Not because it's bad, but because…read moreI love other food options more. However, we had a double date planned and Kosta's was chosen for us. One of the best choices ever. The atmosphere is welcoming from the moment you walk in; friendly greeting within seconds of walking in, calming colors of blue and white adorn every wall with charming tablecloths on each table, and cute decor. Service was immediate with a carafe of water and a huge smile. I loved the vibe! Ordered a German Hefeweizen that came cold and frothy. Next came the Greek salad with the most juicy, crisp tomatoes, green peppers and cucumbers, then heavily sprinkled with feta cheese, a pinch of capers, and a side of the best Greek dressing I've ever tasted. I was originally taken aback that there was no lettuce, but real Greek salad doesn't have lettuce! I had no idea. Hubby and I shared the Broiler Mix from the appetizer menu so we could sample multiple items. The Broiler mix has 2 chicken skewers, 2 beef skewers, 2 Kefta patties, 2 chorizo, 2 pitas, fries, tomato wedges and a healthy dollop of tzatziki. The pita tasted homemade; it was soft, thick without being too think and didn't taste chalky. The skewers were exceptionally cooked...tender, flavorful pieces of chicken and beef. The kefta (lamb & beef) patties had a nice texture, which was enhanced with the herbaceous tzatziki sauce. The only disappointment was the chorizo as it was overcooked and dry. It was easy to overlook as everything else was a shining star. We would go back in a heartbeat....totally made me want to explore more Greek food there!

Photos
Bathroom hallway tinge tight for wheelchair but doable if u ask for chairs to be removed
Bathroom hallway tinge tight for wheelchair but doable if u ask for chairs to be removed
Broiler appetizer with chicken and beef skewers, lamb and chorizo.
Broiler appetizer with chicken and beef skewers, lamb and chorizo.
Kosta's Taverna

See all

Papa Kelseys - sandwiches - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...