I had an amazing dining experience at Papa Luigi's! From the moment you walk in, the ambiance makes you feel right at home--it has that perfect, warm neighborhood feel that's great for any occasion. The food was absolutely standout. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the flavors were incredibly authentic and fresh. Every bite was delicious. To make the night even better, the service was excellent. The staff was friendly, attentive, and really made sure we were well taken care of throughout the meal. If you're on High St and looking for a top-tier meal with a great atmosphere, this is definitely the spot. I'm already looking forward to my next visit! read more

Papa Luigi's is a quaint restaurant on High street in Sutton. I went in as most restaurants were closed and I was aware they served gluten free food as well. I had steamed fish and a large Greek salad. The salad was by far one of the largest salads I have eaten in my life and was very good value. The fish was bland, but I enjoyed the salad. The staff were friendly and they offer bakery and other diner type fare. read more

Papa Luigi's - Papa Luigi's Sutton. Purveyor of pizza and multiple options including gluten free, some paleo, and vegan. - Fish & Chips Near Me - Georgina, Ontario

Papa Luigi's is a great little storefront restaurant right on High St in Sutton Always clean and fresh Costas and family are doing a fantastic job of serving fresh, made to order food with a friendly and welcoming atmosphere Offerings include fish & chips, pizza, burgers, soups, sandwiches and Souvlaki read more

PAPA LUIGIS PIZZA IS THE BEST!!! Nice family restaurant & good quality food/service A definite hidden jem in Georgina read more

The best eggs Benny made on a beautiful sourdough bread! I've been on the pricey side, but I actually get two meals out of it.

I was working out of Sutton and found this on Maps . So happy I went . The pictures will show the beauty of their food and they also own a bakery ( the cookies and tarts are amazing sauce!!! ) Enjoy read more

See all

Historic spot.... Great pizza. Too bad it further than I like to travel for a meal. Best service for take out

Grew up going to this place. Recently moved back into the area so was excited to see how it was. Took the wife for the first time here. She is from the east coast, so is a fish and chips aficionado. Had the halibut and fries. We had one dinner and ordered a second piece of fish. Great big portions. Wife loved it. Decent amount of batter, but great amount of fish inside it as well. Fries were chunky and cut on-site - and nice and crispy. Gravy was very good. Definitely one of the best couple of places in the area. Will definitely be going back. read more

There fish & chips are amazing !! They have everything from pizza, seafood and even a mini bakery with desserts. Little bit of everything; it's a very cute place and the staff are very friendly. read more

Happened upon this place by chance, was just passing through. The pizza was amazing! Delicious crust, House-made desserts were a plus. Service staff was friendly and helpful. Would definitely bring my business back here! :) read more

Really like the pizza. .prices are a tad on the high side...doubtful we'd dine in..a few weeks ago we went to pickup our takeout and the place was freezing inside..not conducive to eating in... also...the staff don't seem very happy. .strange atmosphere. . and no menu to take home for future orders. . tried the fish and chips..the fish was nice..batter not to thick..but again..frozen fries..wish places would make real homemade french fries..a lost art read more

Based solely on the PIZZA. If you are going to advertise yourself as a 'pizza' (and fish n chips) place, you gotta make better slices/pies. This pizza was worse than a frozen McCains. Terrible sauce, cheese, gross pepperoni's. Staff is very friendly, to be honest, try a GOOD pizza place in the city (Toronto) or create a new recipe (look online), as bad a slice as we have ever eaten. To bad because the interior/exterior is nice. read more

Papa Luigi's - the front of a restaurant - Fish & Chips Near Me - Georgina, Ontario

We were on our way to the cottage when we found this gem. Definitely worth stopping in. The halibut and fries were fresh, crisp, and perfectly cooked. A great local experience. My friend had a strawberry milkshake and if he had yelp, he would give it 5 stars too! read more

Around Jackson's Point, this here's the best fish and chips you're gonna find. (the place right on the black river's good too, and their chips may be a bit better, but the fish and batter are not as good). Papa Luigi's Battered Halibut is HUGE and perfectly fried: golden, light, and CRISPY! The portions are well beyond what most places serve. I visit Simcoe once a year and when I do I always get my fish & chips at Papa Luigi's. Their pizza is awesome too! read more

I come here pretty often since I got a job in Sutton. I have had a lot of their sandwiches, burgers, fish and chips, pizzas... and I love everything. One special thing for the winter is that they have this PERFECT cider from a local orchard (I THINK it's Homestead Orchard, but I can't recall, I'll edit if I have to). That cider hits the spot if you're looking for something to take you straight back to your childhood. I definitely recommend their burgers, their pizza (it's not the pizza that you're used to from chain restaurants, I'll tell you that), and their fish and chips. One review says that they are undercooked, but if that WAS true, it definitely isn't true anymore (it's piping hot and crispy on the outside and perfect on the inside). They COULD add a lot more tartar sauce for the fish, though. They give you a small container with tartar sauce when they should just be piling it on. read more

The halibut here is excellent. The portion was huge as well as the fries. Here's the downside. The gravy was disappointing, fries slightly undercooked. I had actually come in here as they also advertised pizza which apparently they did not have? Wtf. Will come again for the fish, but will have it with one of the terrific looking Greek Salads. read more

Came here with a bunch of kids. Food was really good and it came quickly. Server and staff were very nice. My kids said the pizza was very good and we saw that they source all their ingredients locally. My fish and chips was very good as well. Would highly recommend it to anyone visiting in the area. read more

Food is dreadful. Halibut is as thin as sole - batter is like eating embossed wallpaper and fries appeared to have saw the light of day some weeks ago and have been fried many times. Food is expensive and execrable read more

Papa Luigi's is an institution in Georgina - an area where, based on a few other restaurants I've been to, isn't an easy place to serve up consistently good food. I've been here several times over the years and just got prompted by Yelp to leave a review, so that's why I'm writing this now. Their fish and chips (halibut) are top notch and comparable to my favourite dedicated fish and chip spots in Toronto (only once did I find the fish over-cooked and oily but they were getting slammed and I'm sure they would have made it right if I had brought it to their attention). The rest of their menu - breakfasts, burgers, sandwiches, homemade pizzas, salads etc - is just rock solid. Everything I've tried is fresh and done well. The atmosphere isn't fancy but it's pleasant and spotless. Don't come to Papa Luigi's expecting to be blown away by some signature specialty (although those fish and chips are pretty up there). Come for the consistently good, fresh food and nicely balanced menu. Oh - and I'm selfishly reluctant to write this because they're already in short supply - but come for their freshly baked cookies - which are some of the best I've had anywhere, period, full stop. read more

Love this place!!! I have been eatting here for decades now. Hands down the best fish n chips in the whole area possible the whole region. Everything else on the menu is top notch, have never had a bad meal here. Prices are fair and the portions are huge, you will definitely be taking some food home with you. read more

One of the better restaurant in Sutton, server is very nice and friendly but I can't say the same about the owners

Best pizza in town! Fish n chips are amazing too! Simple but nice decor and welcoming staff. read more

3.5 stars. I read the great reviews about this place and was really excited to try it. However its just deep fried fish with fries. Nothing special. Now to be fair, I neither like nor hate fish n chips. read more

Amazing pizza!!! Love all the food here. Staff are super friendly and attentive. Best restaurant hands down in Sutton

Had a great lunch! We all had the fish and chips. The batter and fish were both perfectly cooked. We also loved the fries! Only issue to note was we found the tartar sauce had a bit too much relish for our liking. We also had the mozzarella sticks and the marina sauce was perfect. We'll be back to try the pizza on our next visit to the area! read more

Best fish and chip place around! Love the Poutine and the halibut! The home made tartar sauce is to die for! I just wish they had better hours so I could go more often! read more

This place is my go to restaurant. The menu is written on a chalkboard. The interior is simple yet nice. Their food is sooo delicious. The halibut is cooked perfectly. Not too oily or greasy as other restaurants/pubs. Their fries and gravy are phenomenal. The service is the best. They always make it a point to remember your name. read more

I used to go there years ago and was driving from Toronto to Balsam Lake on Saturday and thought I would drop in. I picked up a piece of halibut only and ate it on the way. I was unpleasantly surprised when my stomach started rumbling. I made it to Balsam Lake but spent a considerable amount of time in the washroom. Something wasn't right with that piece of fish because I was fine before I ate it. read more