My family has been eating here since back in the day when Sal's was in Springville. We love their food and appreciate the consistency! Portions are huge and you truly get your money's worth. With everything you purchase you get bread and a salad. My favorites are their pizzas, the ziti, and the manicotti. Their location is super convenient for many people in a place where there aren't many food options at all. Glad to have them around!! read more

We haven't been here in a while so I was anxious to see if it was as good as I remember. First the good. The food was spectacular as always. Yummy. I had the meatball Parmesan sub and my wife had the chicken parm. Both met expectations. The meatballs were very large! I couldn't finish it all. The not so bad. How can you call it bad when the meatballs are so big? Well, it did make the sandwich hard to handle. Also, fries with meatball sub.... that's just wired. And I didn't like the combo so much. Wifey had spaghetti as her side but she didn't eat it (too full). And the not so good. We ordered a cheesy bread app, but it didn't come out until about 2 minutes before our meal - and it was a bit overdone. So overall a good meal. Not perfect but pretty good. read more

Papa Sal's - Italian Near Me - Pinson, Alabama

Great Food! A sweet family friendly atmosphere! If you are ordering takeout, call ahead or be ready for a wait!

They have daily specials written on a white board! Veal Parmesan was one of them! My very first time trying veal, very hesitant to try but I am so glad that I did! It was so good! Waitress was nice and attentive. Food came out in an appropriate time and was warm and yummy. It was delish! The only reason I don't give them 5 stars is because the place needs a little TLC! But if you see past that, it's great and you will love!! read more

Papa Sal's has a great steak dinner. Only negative is the salad is tiny. But great food and great service.

We have always been a fan, of Sals. But after today, we won't be going again. My husband has been under going cancer treatments, and the tomato sauce, bothers him. We ordered the veal special. Simply asked for white sauce on the noodles. They would not do it, because they said, they couldn't change the special. In business you sometimes have to make expectations. read more

This place here is a fantastic little restaurant. It has almost everything going for it you would want. Food is great and I mean great. Portions are huge and prices are really good. It's very family oriented. I don't believe alcohol is served here but I could be wrong. It's not a fancy place but it is clean and suitable for a casual meal. The staff are warm and friendly and It feels like the kind of place you'd become a regular after two or three visits. I don't know the owner but he did some catering for my family this past mother's day which was amazingly good and he also opened and cooked for us on a day he was supposed to be closed. This was a small group so he must have agreed out of kindness Not profits so we really were grateful for his kindness towards us. If you go try the mozzarella triangles. It's cheese and it's fried.... How can that NOT be awesome??!! They come hot gooey and delicious with a perfect marinara sauce for dipping. I got the shrimp Alfredo and it was just right. Creamy and a lot of shrimp. .1599 and i didn't even eat half of it. It came with a really good salad and the best bread. I will enjoy this again tomorrow when I have the leftovers. I can't wait to go back again and try something else. They have specials and many other menu items priced well below 15 so you can't go wrong. read more

Great Italian food. Have been eating their food since their father ran it back in the 90s.

I recently had the pleasure of a ABSOLUTELY AMAZING MEAL! WITH EVEN BETTER SERVICE. The steak was PERFECT, and KRISTEN WAS right on time, her service was as precise and friendly as she was cute. Thanks Simon. read more

Great food. Location is deceptive. Worth the trip to go here and eat. Portions are filling, and food quality is what you expect from a local food place, simply amazing. Definitely going back. read more

I are here again last night and boy was it good! The first time I came my sandwich was a little dry. But last night I ordered the lasagna. It was great. Would definitely recommend this place. Looking forward to trying their spaghetti and meatballs. read more

Terrible service. Mediocre Italian food. Marinara tasted like a plain can of stewed tomatoes.

My family and I are all Papa Sal's customers. They have great food and are super friendly. The portions are huge. My favorite dish is the lasagna; it's amazing. Highly recommended. read more

Omg!!! Absolutely phenomenally delicious!! Enjoyed Baked Spaghetti to the fullest!! Fresh cut salad, homemade dressings, huge soft drink glasses perfectly brinked!! Damn!! Batting 1000!! Been gone four years out of state...was worried things may have changed here but I am delighted to report perfection all the way around!! Did I mention yummy hot crusty bread and the attentive charming waitress??? Hello Papa Sal's!!! Thank you so much!!! read more

Papa Sal's - Omg Delicious Baked Spaghetti!! - Italian Near Me - Pinson, Alabama

One of the best of the best, I will be coming back. I'll come eat here over olive garden any day. We highly enjoy our waiter Hunter!!!!! read more

See all

Our family of eight had dinner at Papa Sal's tonight and I cannot day enough good things about our food and service. Our server was kind and attentive. We had calzones, eggplant parm, chicken parm, the 14 oz ribeye, and the crawfish and shrimp pasta. I would say that we cleaned our plates, but we all got to go boxes because the servings were so big! Definitely will have a delicious lunch tomorrow with those leftovers. We had a wonderful experience there and will most certainly return. read more

We came came and ordered a bunch of foods to try. We started with the sampler app and it was fried golden and crispy to perfection. We really loved the chicken balls. We moved on to a rib eye, which was deliciously seasoned along with the fries we ordered. We also tried the sausage pasta dish. Our favorite part of it was the sausage, it has a lot of good flavor. My husband got the muffalata sandwich and he really enjoyed it and I myself liked the baked ziti. We finished off with a chocolate lava cake and a Cannoli. The creaminess of the cannoli mixed with the crunch of the shell was magnificent and my husband loved the lava cake. Great food and amazing prices with good service we will be back! read more

First off, this is the first experience I've truly felt compelled to leave a review for. This is a review of my overall first experience of PaPa Sal's, I ordered for pickup on the date of Dec 21st (yesterday). I called the store and was greeted with a RUDE "Hello?!?!", making me think I misdialed. No "This is Papa Sals, may I take your order?" NO politeness at all. I wondered if I even dialed the right number I but I still asked "may I place an order for pick up?", and the person on the phone was awful, sounded like they hated their job and honestly they need to be retrained or have an attitude adjustment of some sorts because the whole process of ordering makes me not want to return. On top of that, I was told I'd have a 30 minute wait (which is fine because food has to cook, I'm not peeved by that) however I ended up waiting OVER an HOUR for my food. Meanwhile plenty of other cars were receiving their food (these all being cars that showed up AFTER I did to pick up my food) the wait staff never assured me the food would be out soon, or asked if I needed anything, nothing. No "hospitality". I thought I had been totally forgotten about, my order too. And I was asked to pay as soon as I arrived so I couldn't even take my business elsewhere without a commotion. The service was so poor, I honestly didn't even want to tip (did so regardless). I'm giving it two stars because the face of an establishment actually matters and so does how you treat your guests, the wait staff needs a reminder. The ONLY thing receiving stars is the food, the service sucked and the extra 45 minutes of waiting with zero communication did any chance of three or four stars in. So bottom line, the food was great, the chef sure did his job but the service makes me really reconsider going back. We already have so few Italian food places in the area so this experience was a massive bummer. We all have our days but you do NOT inflict that onto your guests. read more

Love this place. Great food n great price. Bring your appetite. Everyone leaves with a to go box..tell Keith the owner ROLL TIDE! read more

Their pizza is so-so. For their geographic location, they're tasty and they have a good selection of toppings. Less cheese and more sauce would really reinforce that third star. That being said, they are the only establishment that will deliver food to my parents' rural McMansion in the middle of nowhere. Note: I am not alone tonight and there are panic buttons, working telephones in the house, and fast police responders in the area :) The people who work here are nice. Service is really slow for take-out when they're packed. Which is most nights since they are the only real food/dinner establishment all the way out in the middle of nowhere. Unless you count the Piggly Wiggly across the road. In which case, if you are in a hurry and live in the middle of nowhere, it may behoove you to go get a frozen Red Baron or whatever you like, take it home, and pop it in the oven. Take away a bunch of stars for not serving wine or beer...oh my god, I've waited 30+ minutes here to pick up a take-out pizza and wanted to poke my eyeballs out and stick pencils in my ears because a beer or a glass of wine would have put a smile on my face and lowered my ever-rising blood pressure as I waited...and waited...and waited. Bottom line: Horrible lighting (I strongly suggest not eating in here if you enjoy NOT eating under fluorescent lights that will age you by 10-20 years and have you leaving seeing spots), sweet servers, slow service, slow takeout, tasty pizzas, out-of-this-world cannolies, and no beer or wine. I really like wine. I like their pizza. I don't like their lighting. I like that they are out in the middle of nowhere just like my parents. read more

We visited today and got the daily special manicotti, with hot baked bread and a salad and drink $6.00. Food was great, good service, we'll definitely be back read more

This place had a good selection and decent prices. The wait staff was friendly, and the food was good. The place was kind of warm inside, so eating hot food made me sweat even more on the 96 degree day it was. Overall, good experience and would definitely go there again. read more

One of the best Italian places in Birmingham, easy to miss but you won't forget it once you try it

I love this place! If you love Italian food, this is the place to go. I almost always get the lasagna and it is incredible. You also get a huge salad and bread with it. By the time I finish my salad, I can barely eat the lasagna so I always get at least 2-3 meals out of it. I have also tried the chicken alfredo and it is to die for and the helpings are HUGE! I will definitely be getting it next time. The food is always hot and fresh. We generally do to-go because it can get a little busy and a little slow sometimes. read more

Went there on Saturday after lunch hour not very many people there. It took over 25 minutes to get our food. Had to ask for straws, napkins etc. Waiters first day with no one helping him with only two other tables with people there. Food is not good enough to go back. Lousy service counts. read more

I love this place! The food is great and the portions are so huge you can literally get 3 meals out of your entree. The servers are all very nice, but the food does take a little while to get to the table. It's totally worth the wait, though. read more

Worst meal I have ever had. Literally inedible. This was our second visit here hoping it would have improved since we saw them listed as one of the top restaurants in AL for steak. So maybe our mistake was we didn't order steak. BTW - they only have one choice of steak - Ribeye. Anyway, I ordered the shrimp scampi and it was what I can only describe as gross. The scampi was made with linguini pasta and the noodles were mushy and falling apart they were so overcooked. There was no lemon that I could discern and even though it was full of garlic, there was no real garlic flavor like you would expect with fresh garlic. The shrimp were the worst part - they tasted and smelled like ammonia. Not going back. Ever. The one star is for the waitstaff - they are nice and friendly. read more

My husband and I love this place. We order the 10 ounce steak dinner and you receive two sides and a salad with dinner. The steak dinner is less than $15 per plate. Lots of food ....you will need a box to take left overs home. Delicious! We also have had their pizza...very good and inexpensive. My husband had eaten the muscles dish. He loved it! Their service can be a little slow at times but the food is worth the wait. I would recommend this restaurant and I am not sure why the other reviews are low....but we have never had a bad experience here and we eat here weekly. read more

Three visits and I am happy. Moved from California about 5 weeks ago and fretted over one thing. Would there be any decent restaurants close by. As far as Italian goes I need to relax. This place is awesome. It ain't sexy, but nor am I. The food gets a happy 9 from me. Now for Chinese. . . read more

Terrible service! On a date night with my husband. He gets his food before me. Who does that? Brings out one entree? My husband refused to eat until my food arrived. 20 mins goes by. The people who sat down after us all got their food. My husbands steak and sides were cold by the time my food arrived. The food was good as usual. However, they didn't offer to take my meal off or give a discount. We usually get the food to go. Think we will stick to that route! read more

What can I say? We heard that Papa Sal's had a great steak. Our first visit was a couple of weeks ago and I have eaten the steak 4 times. Last night we had spaghetti and baked ravioli and it was great. We have taken about 15 friends and everybody loved it. Kelsey, Gabriel and Keith are great and make you feel like family. Our waiter (black guy with French name) is very good. Great prices and great food. read more

Worst service i have ever experienced. Waited an hour and a half before being served, and waitress poured sweet tea in my water and didn't even provide straws. Also, the steak was 80% fat. Half the steak was charred when we ordered the steak. Hot inside as well. Do not recommend. read more

Best Italian food I've had! I love the calzones and the chicken alfredo. I'd have yup say my favorite is the chicken paremesan. I haven't had a bad meal here. The service is always great and friendly and they have great prices for the amount of food that you get! I always have leftovers for the next day! Give them a chance and you will become a regular! read more

Gordon Ramsey would have a field day here, starting with the decor and furnishings. Shabby, mismatched, dingy and sad are adjectives that come to mind. No greeting from staff or indication that we should seat ourselves so we stood in the dining room for a good minute... Waitstaff are mostly young and poorly trained, one was overly loud in conversations with kitchen staff and was coarse. The food was meh. Marinara too thick and overly garlicky; too liberal with garlic powder and not fresh. Plates left in broiler too long and developed an overly brown plastic-y cheese crust. Husband's mufalletta was best of the entrees. Did not get requested ketchup for fries until meal almost concluded. Servings were large and would be a good value if properly prepared. A fellow guest advised their server that her fork was not clean and was told that they were certain they had already handwashed that same fork five times today! Erm, gross . read more

I have one word to sum it up muffaletta. My family's from new orleans and u can't find a good olive salad any where in Alabama, and this man makes his from scratch a real taste of home. Thank you for u love and passion for food it is what keeps us coming back. read more

Papa Sal's is an excellent value for the money. I've never had a bad meal there. Also, they have an excellent 14oz ribeye steak that is excellent considering that Papa Sal's is an Italian Restaurant. The steak is good quality and is very flavorful. You don't even need steak sauce. The lasagne is wonderful as well as the baked ziti, and the pasta marinara. Again, excellent value for the money. read more

Consistently good pasta and great ribeye steaks for the money. Calzone and pizza a little too bread heavy for my wife and I.

Great pizza. Fresh ingredients. Excellent options for lunch and dinner. Always friendly and efficient staff. Without a doubt the best bang for your buck in the area for Italian fare. read more

Food was slightly above average. Service was slow, and had to continuously call for our waiter for the smallest items. From time we sat down until food was in front of us 58min. read more

This was the first time I attempted to try this place. My mother recommended it and needless to say her recommendations have not had a good track record when we try them. Well needless to say I didn't get to try the food bc when I was there, there were 2 waitresses with only one table filled. Another woman was picking an order up and still waiting for them to complete it. The 2 waitresses just starred and never greeted me or nothing. Finally when I was fixing to place my order, I get told their "internet is down" and cannot process debit or credit cards. You couldn't tell me this when I was sitting there waiting while you didn't bother saying squat for about 10 minutes?? For the record, that's usually a direct network service to the authorization center..not actual internet. You can't Google on it. Anyway I said never mind and was walking out and she wanted me to go to an ATM??!! Hell No! I'm not paying a fn atm fee to convenience you. Doubt I'll go back as this was all service...I suggest a new staff. read more