Papillon is another staple in our household and I can't believe it's taken me this long to write a review. The energy in Papillon has had us raving about it to all of our local friends. Along with a strong review on how amazing the food is. This is such a good dinner spot if you are looking to try something new, but will warn you, the food is addicting. read more

Great happy hour atmosphere, music and service was great. The food on the happy hour menu matches with the drinks to make for a perfect happy hour experience. read more

Papillon 25 - Catfish collard greens dinner with Mac and cheese - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

My daughter had the vodka pasta, I had the Organic Fried Chicken, collard greens and mac and cheese. Vodka pasta had all fresh ingredients with delicious fresh basil. Best mac and cheese I ever had. Chicken nice and crispy and juicy on the inside - collard greens cooked perfectly. Dessert had their bread pudding with Dolce Leche gelato - delish! Highly recommend. Wait staff was awesome. The bar is made with a butterfly looking over the patrons - fun atmosphere. A little pricey but worth it. Fya - tip is included in the bill. read more

Came here for a quick drink. The tall brown bald bartender was nice and quick. We ordered a couple of drinks, the pour was good and tasty. We got the jerk wings they were good jerk wings, seasoned well. The best thing was that ginger dipping sauce! Yes that was fire!! The music was good and a nice local crowd. read more

Let me start by saying this place had great food and our waitress was nice. When my husband and I went a week ago on a Sunday afternoon there were maybe 7 people in the place including us. We sat at the bar with the other 5 people present. The music was just right! It was the right sound level and genre of music for listening and chatting. My husband pointed out the unique insect shape that outlines the ceiling of the bar (a butterfly). He had some historical context regarding it. We had a look at the menu handed to us and I asked the waitress whether they served brunch. The waitress confirmed they served brunch, but everything in her words was not on the menu. She proceeded to read off some items from the brunch menu verbally. My husband wanted a dish from that menu (salmon with rice and he added a side of broccoli) and then he ordered a beer. I ordered a random cocktail she made up I believe it was a coconut sangria. I order off the menu that was initially handed to us, a shrimp and crab dish with risotto. All was good until.....my husband, being really disappointed, told me when we got in the car that our bill for two drinks and two meals was $166.00. I asked him to go and get a receipt because I just couldn't believe it. What had we ordered that would cost that amount of money??!! So upon looking at the bill, my husband was charged $65.00 for the meal plus $13.00 for broccoli and whatever the cost of the beer plus tax. The total bill for his meal was around $100.00. While mine was around $45 for my meal and drink. The end totally for everything was $166.00. Essentially he was charged a Brunch charge for his meal which was $65.00 for salmon and a side of rice. In my humble opinion, what he ordered should not have cost that much. Additionally, unbeknownst to us his charge was supposed to include brunch drinks. He hadn't ordered any brunch drinks. None of this was explained to us/him when the brunch menu was read aloud to us that brunch costs $65.00 or that it included drinks. I immediately called the restaurant to explain the disappointment about not being told the brunch menu price and was told that if/when we come back, we can get two drinks on the house with our meal. It was no real consolation. We feel taken and after finally finding a place where the food was decent, it's such a disappointment. We cannot reasonably go back because the prices are ridiculous. So I wouldn't say not to patronize the place but I would say to be careful because you might end up spending a mint for just that.. a mint (a little bit). read more

Decided to try this place again only to be reminded why I stopped. The service is awful and it seems the operation is poorly ran. Sucks as they had potential to be a good place but service needs serious improvement read more

Ordered the jerk wings and roasted shrimp. Both were amazing. Loved the vibe too. Great music but not too loud. Lively bar if that's your thing too. Lots of flavor. I'll definitely be back soon. read more

Had a great experience here. Staff was pleasant. Was seated right away on a Friday night approximately around 845pm. Ambiance was good. Bar was full but tables were available. For apps we ordered jerk wings and ménage de trios. I had the wings and loved them. My friend had the other app and she was in love with the jerk scallops. Said it was the best scallops she ever had. Drinks: lychee martini was delicious. The lychee itself was so good. Tasted fresh. I had two of them. My friend had some sort of blue martini with coconut flakes. She like it. Alright for dinner....i ordered a lot . I ordered the shrimp with grits, a side of collard greens and a side of djon djon rice. Shrimp and grits: shrimp was delicious. I wouldn't change anything about it. The grits were a little too loose for me. Would've liked them to be a little thicker and less cheesy however the flavoring was great. It came with a side of green beans which I don't recall seeing on the menu. Djon djon rice: flavor was there but I wish it had some moisture to it. It was dry but flavor was good. Had a nice level of spice. Collard greens: I needed to flavor it with hot sauce. I typically don't put hot sauce on my greens but this needed flavoring. My friend ordered the braised short ribs. She said it was delicious. Neither of us could finish our meals and took the leftovers home. read more

I enjoyed the ambience and patrons of the restaurant. The food was just ok, priced a bit high for what you get, but loved the variety. The Bartender was the best part, Brianna W, knows how to mix those drinks. Will definitely be back for drinks !! She is the rock star of the restaurant from what I could tell. read more

This place has a nice calm vibe and great portions of food. The aunties and uncs take over the bar and provide great entertainment for the folks eating at the tables in back. read more

I like to pop in every now and again for happy hour. The food is "meh". I've eaten here so many times and it fell off over time. The service is always good and respectful and well as the ambiance. read more

Bad vibes and unseasoned food. Very low vibrational setting. And they add gratuity for subpar service .

My friends and I came on a Monday night 7/21 to celebrate and a birthday. The bartender ( receipt says Terdoo ) the young lady with blonde braids, was rude & unprofessional. She served us shots then proceeded to ask for one ID after we took the shots bc my friend asked about the lemon drop. I also dropped my drink on accident & the bartender was annoyed and told us that the manager was watching the cameras like I purposely spilled my drink. This was unfortunate experience, we immediately got our food to go and left, This was my first & last time here. read more

Friendly neighborhood spot... The food is good, service is good, worth a try for sure!!!

Since 2003, the brainchild of the husband-and-wife duo team, Albert and Yanick Ranieri, have opened this premier restaurant and martini bar located on Valley Street in South Orange. Upon entering and translating from the French, a "butterfly" insignia floated above the bar, illuminating the various hues of the 57 martini and specialty cocktails offered. The interior evoked a sophisticated and modern vibe, with the lighting being subtle. Reservations were made by one of our party members calling the restaurant yesterday for some of us as first-timers. Greeted by the host, a table was waiting for us. The menu merges American, Caribbean, French, and Italian cuisine, leaning toward Southern and Cajun-style dishes. As an appetizer, my partner, our friends and I decided on the corn and crab croquettes. For our main meal, we opted for Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp with Maryland Crab Meat, Jambalaya, Coq Au Vin, Organic Roasted Chicken Breast, and Linguine with Shrimp. A complimentary assortment of breads with butter started our meal, which some of us washed with French martini. The food was delicious, and the sauces were flavorful. However, there was a slight snafu with the wording of one of the items on the menu, which was brought to the manager's attention. Listed was organic roasted chicken breast served with caramelized carrots, but what was received was the breast with part of the wings and carrots not caramelized. The service was wonderful, and our server was Mohammed. It was a nice time spent, which we could recommend. read more

See all

Great Friday night vibes with Valerie Adams and the band playing. The place was pretty packed the entire night. My bloody orange cosmo was great... the first time. Okay, the second time. But the third time..... it was even orange. Clearly, I had three different bartenders. I ordered the jerk chicken with mashed potatoes and veggies.. it was just okay. Felt like they basically Slattered the jerk sauce over pre made chicken to make it jerk. Bread pudding was sweet, but good read more

See all

Good atmosphere, mature crowd. Not happy at all though about the 20% service charge for just drinks at the bar! Especially since female bartender was rude to me which my friend picked up on, and upcharged me for a drink another bartender made for me. Friendly bar patron shared a jerk chicken wing with me, which was very tender. Prices were higher than expected glasses were small. Parking is tight in the area. read more

We went for a late Valentine's Day dinner and was still able to order from their Valentine's Day menu so that was fun. The inside is always nice. The waiters were attentive and food was served timely. We order buffalo shrimp, surf & surf (shrimp, scallops, and lobster in a sauce with white rice and veggies), surf and turf (lobster, steak, mashed potatoes and spinach w/ mushrooms) and dessert was a run raisin ice cream and chocolate covered strawberries. Lost a star bc we didn't like the lobster (not sure if it was overcooked but texture was off) and the ice cream wasn't for us (texture was off but maybe for you). Oh we had a sangria pitcher and it was great Will definitely be back read more

Nice atmosphere, food was a little underseasoned for me. Service was 5/10. Drinks were good! read more

Papillon 25 - Whole red snapper with curry crabmeat - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Amazing martinis! Terdoo was an excellent host and crafty bartender. We are coming back for lunch as I've been told that the scallops are the best in the city. It's a toss up between the Sidecar and Mango Martini. read more

Papillon 25 - Sidecar was smooth and slightly sweet. Nicky's Mango Martini is the bomb refreshing and strong. Coming back as the kitchen opens at noon. - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

Automatic 20% tip added to bill. Poor service from bartender, likely because the tip was already included . Customers should never have to pay an automatic service charge. I will not return. read more

The food is good. Service is good and the overall style of the restaurant is nice. However, the prices are way too high for what they are serving. I guess they are trying to make up for their lack of customer's by charging double the prices. For example, they were charging an extra $15 to add shrimp to pasta. That's crazy!!! I had a Ceasars salad and pasta with a water and my bill was $60 and on the bill they added a 20% tip! $80! They not right! I want to support a black owned restaurant However not if they going to overcharge... I wanted to give a 5 but because of the whack bill I give it a 3. read more

This restaurant served up wonderful authentic recipes. The ambiance COZY although I went alone I would take a date there. The service was excellent & parking after 6pm free. The lovely owner greeted & thanked me for stopping by read more

My diner was not good, black own business should do better then this... You're going to serve Italian dish it should be equivalent to or better than anything you could get in an Italian restaurant. read more

Papillon 25 - Stuff Jumbo shrimp and crabmeat.... - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

This place is horrible only good thing is the drinks and bar staff the owner is rude and nasty as well as the food. read more

Papillon 25 - This lady has lost her mind, 20$ for 5 small shrimp - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

Great environment great food. Great drinks. My family and I had a blast year after coming here after my daughter's recital down the street not to mention is black on so we definitely took great pride in supporting this establishment can't wait to be back might make this hour yearly stop after the recital since we always bicker back-and-forth about where to eat this place is down the street perfect location and great food can't go wrong with that read more

Papillon 25 - Penne Alla Vodka with salmon - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

The atmosphere was very pleasant. With the exception of the bartender over charging for the happy hour drinks. The owner was very nice. The bartender seem like he was a little over worked. I not sure I would ever visit the establishment again. read more

This was one of my FAV spots before the pandemic I haven't been in awhile I went last night and I was completely disgusted my food was HORRIBLE!!! My Mac & cheese was hard and rubbery and bland. Fried chicken was dry and collard greens tasted yuck! I asked for a side of sweet potato soufflé it tasted like there was too much nutmeg an cinnamon it was awful. Never have I been so disappointed this made me sad I really use to love this place not sure what happened. The workers were very nice the food was just a fail. read more

Papillon 25 - Mac & cheese was extremely rubbery and tasteless just a blob of cheese, chicken dry, greens not seasoned well just awful - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

They charged a mandatory 20% for sitting at the bar...I emailed the restaurant to request that this tip be adjusted as while the service was decent I decide what percentage I will tip. BEWARE this restaurant includes a mandatory tip on all bills, which is illegal and not explained prior to dining. We( 2 ppl) sat/ate at the bar by no means did the service require a 20% tip. read more

Papillon 25 - Receipt - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

I went with a group of about 10 people. The bartenders were great as they usually are. The service at the table however was not so great. The food took forever to come out and the waiter was very absent. When I said something to him he had the excuse of having home issues and had an attitude. This is why I choose not to eat here. I will stick to drinks only. read more

Papillon 25 - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

I remember coming here some time ago and having an awesome experience full of good food and live music that kept my attention the entire night. It was a classy evening in a classy restaurant. I am guessing a lot has changed. I returned on a Friday evening and was never greeted. The bar was packed and loud, and I had no clue as to who worked there and who didn't. We were waiting awhile just eyeballing everyone in there trying to figure out if maybe the dining part was closed for the night. After watching someone who was standing right next to me be seated by a gentleman that I now realized worked there, I then flagged the same guy down. The dining room side of the restaurant was pretty much empty when we sat down. It got a bit busier as we were waiting for our dinner, but there was still only one server working the entire dining room. Overall, the server did pretty well and was very nice; although we did have to wait longer than expected at times for service. I ordered the Cajun catfish with macaroni & cheese, collard greens, and sweet potato soufflé. The catfish looked burnt; however they were well cooked inside and had a great flavor. I would've liked a whole portion of catfish rather than the "chicken" fingers style that I received or at least wish to have been alerted of it in advance. I asked the server if the mac & cheese was microwaved, and I was told no. If you look at my picture, the mac & cheese looks as it was bagged for storage then thrown in the microwave per order. My date and I ordered the same exact meal, and both of our mac & cheese looked exactly the same, with the edges taking on a hard plastic-like round shape. The only part of the mac & cheese that was edible (and tasty) was the center. The sweet potato soufflé was okay but not sweet. The collard greens lacked seasoning. I have this thing about bread pudding, so when I saw it on the dessert menu, I ordered it to go. I tried it when I got home -wasn't a fan. Also, their seating chart needs some help. There's no way for the staff to reach certain tables without bumping another table or constantly having to excuse themselves. The third star is because of my previously positive experience and the server. I used to refer everyone to Pavillon 25 but won't be doing that right now. read more

Papillon 25 - Catfish, Mac & cheese, collard greens, sweet potato soufflé - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

Waitress was AMAZING and attentive. The food was so good!!! Even the salad was great. The vibe was fantastic. The martinis are always on point. read more

Oh my God, the food, the Service, the clientele so wonderful. See Tajh;our bartender, waiter, really catered to us. An amazing southern comfort spot. Do not miss this!!!! read more

The jerk wings here are the main event. It comes with this green dipping sauce, and OH. The flavors paired really well. The Mac & cheese could've been better, especially since it wasn't Haitian macaroni au gratin. The Caesar salad? YUM. It was super filling- I almost didn't make it to the wings. I've been here twice so far & the waiters/bartenders really add to the experience. They made the best drinks & were so kind and friendly. I love coming here after work with friends & they have a great happy hour. Don't think twice about stopping by! read more

Safety...safety and knowing every iota of your menu is KEY...it's crucial...it's a matter of life & death. Last night we (a party of 6) dined here. A member of the party whom I've never met before casually mentioned he could smell the fish upon entering the restaurant and he's allergic to fish. Fast forward we're seated and ready to order. The gentleman who says he's allergic to fish orders the Caesar salad with chicken. I informed him Caesar salad has anchovies (fish) in it. The waitress says, "We only give you anchovies if you ask for it." I told her anchovies is in the dressing, not the body of the salad. She disagreed. I asked her if Papillon 25 makes their own dressing she said yes and went to inquire with the kitchen. She returned and stated anchovies was indeed in the Caesar salad dressing. How does she not know the menu? Fast forward to the meal. I was highly disappointed in the lack of seasoning. I was excited to try the Djon Djon rice; but the texture was hard as if it could have cooked longer. On to dessert, we order apple dumpling. I specifically asked if it was a whole apple stuffed with dumpling or if it was aesthetically like peach cobbler but with apples, she replied, it's more like an apple turnover. She must not know what an apple turnover looks like. This was a whole apple wrapped in a singular pastry sheet with an entire cinnamon stick shoved in its core. Additionally, it was a bad idea. Again, how does she not know the menu? I'll be rooting from the sidelines for this establishment. They seem to have a nice crowd which stays around the bar. Perhaps the drinks are better than their food. The waitress kept asking, "Can I get you anything from the bar?" ‍ The staff is friendly and the layout is nice. I like the way their booths are set-up. The bathroom was clean. It's a hard pass for me. I didn't bother to take pictures. read more

Really great menu and cool vibe. Huge selection of specialty cocktails. Would definitely recommend

Amazing food (Zucchini bread... OMG!!!), drinks, atmosphere, and staff. Siobhan (or Shivonne?) was the perfect waitress. We loved her smile and cheery disposition!! read more

Papillon 25 - Pomegranate Martini - New American Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

The food was excellent- I had the whole snapper and my wife had Shrimp stuffed with Maryland Crab. The breads they start with are great. The drinks were amazing! They specialize in "martinis" but most are sweet cocktails. I had two bourbon based drinks which were excellent. *The check /billing needs to be addressed. Adding an automatic 20% tip for a couple, after drinks is a bit distasteful, but ok. The worse part was when using the QR code to pay, it adds 18% automatically on top of the 20%, resulting in 38% applied on top of cocktails. Our $115 dinner became $175 had we not caught it. I would highly recommend the restaurant, but watch the bill read more

Food, service, ambience all first rate! We had no idea what to expect, and took a chance before we went to a concert at SOPAC. Wish we lived closer to make it a regular place for us! read more

This spot has easily become one of my favorite spots! Everyone is so warming and welcoming. The blood orange cosmo is by far my favorite. It packs just as much flavor as it does alcohol. I tried the calamari and it was perfectly fried and crisp. I also tried the Cajun catfish filet, the Mac and cheese was exquisite, and the catfish was perfect. Everything was honestly good. The only thing is the dish comes as is and there is no substitution so make sure you're ok with everything before placing your order. I will definitely be back again! read more

See all