Went here with my husband for a date night and we loved it! The service was so good and our waiter was so nice! Tried Burrata appetizer was delicious we both loved it! I highly recommend this adorable restaurant for a date night! read more

This place has totally just gone downhill. This small take out box in the photo was $25. It was horrible, lacked taste and was not the original flavor I used to know. Same with the bread. The last two times, the bread was horrible. I think we will try dining in one more time but this place is not what it used to be when it got new owners. It's a shame read more

Pasta Pasta - Italian Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

5-31-26. The service was great. The vibe is pretty cool. The food was good, but not great. My table ordered veal parm, penne Alla vodka, baked chicken parm over linguini, cavatelli, spaghetti with meatballs and sausage and a shrimp, scallop, chicken and sausage dish (which was the one standout). The garlic bread was also a standout. There certainly was nothing wrong with any of the dishes but in my opinion, the portions were on the smaller side for the prices they charged. read more

See all

On this cold January Friday night, we ventured out to Port Jefferson for a dinner out with friends. For all of us, this is a favorite spot for lots of reasons including location, warm ambiance, friendly attentive service and delicious food. This restaurant is a cozy spot that is brimming with hustle and bustle but not in a bad way. With a 7:00 pm reservation, we were immediately greeted upon entering and seated. It's a perfect spot to dine out and actually be able to chat amongst yourselves. We were never once rushed and we were able to savor not only our meals but each other's company. Warm bread with a homemade smear greeted us while we looked at our menus. Each couple started with the appetizer for two. It looked so yummy that I almost forgot to snap a photo - albeit missing one baked clam before I remembered! We each chose something different because they have lots of wonderful choices. Our dining entrees of the evening were seafood Fra Diavolo, black angus skirt steak, veal parmigiana and grilled chicken over salad. We were all happy with our dinner selections. We finished off our meals with a sorbet trio and crème' brûlée. We'll be back again! read more

See all

Here's a restaurant where we ate out while visiting my stepdaughter. We came here for lunch after visiting some shops in the area. We had a nice gentleman as our waiter, Anthony. He was very attentive, and I approved of him liking my stepdaughter lol. The food was very good. I had seafood pasta, Hubby enjoyed his burger, and my stepdaughter had pizza. We also had some appetizers, mixed Cajun-style shrimp and chicken. I wasn't crazy about the appetizer but i enjoyed my seafood pasta. Nice quiet restaurant. Stop by for pasta if you feel like having some Italian food! read more

See all

This was our initial visit to Pasta Pasta located in downtown Port Jefferson. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating options. We began with the bacon-wrapped shrimp, which was exceptionally tasty. For our main courses, we chose Penne al Vodka and Ravioli Parmigiana. The staff was pleasant and very polite. The food was satisfactory. Parking can be somewhat challenging since there is only a paid public parking lot available. read more

See all

Off the beaten path. But in the path of great food. Great pasta dishes Great seduction of wine , great selection of desserts read more

See all

This restaurant always delivers. The Monday night special is a great deal. Two apps, two entrees, two desserts and a bottle of wine for less than 90 bucks fantastic. We will be back for sure. The Monk Fish special was amazing! read more

See all

Enjoyed another great meal at Pasta Pasta. Tried the prix fix Calamari, Salmon and Tira Misu (no idea if I spelled any of that correctly!) Great service as usual. Very consistent here. You won't be disappointed! read more

Pasta Pasta - Back dining room - Italian Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

After a day spent at the Charles Dickens festival in town, the Honey and I were famished! I love when restaurants get into the Christmas spirit! The decorations with their sparkling lights and festive greenery lifted our spirits. A singer and guitarist serenading us with Christmas carols, put smiles on our faces. Our server Sarah was friendly and knowledgeable. There were no empty tables in our section. Between Sarah and the great team of bussers, things ran smoothly. We started off with baked clams. I was expecting little necks but was surprised when served cherrystones. The clams had a lot more breading than I prefer but, were flavorful. Our entrees of veal parmigiana with rigatoni and swordfish on a bed of field greens were fresh, seasoned well and totally satisfying! Swordfish can be dry if overcooked, this dish was moist and delicious! We finished with a slice of light and fluffy NY cheesecake. Tawny port wine and herbal tea. On the way out I made sure to tell the hostess what an enjoyable meal we had. We are looking forward to returning. This establishment has been around since 1991, there's a reason for that. Go and check them out. Thank me later. read more

See all

Nice decor, fantastic service and some good food. Most of the food was bland, some was well seasoned. Overall, the food was disappointing. Everything else was very good, but in the end it's about the food. Wheelchair accessible. read more

See all

Good food nice place . Located near the boat terminal. Small but the service and food were great

For what this place charges this is some of the most mediocre and bland Italian food I have tasted. Confused about the amount of strong positive reviews. We had multiple different pasta dishes and each sauce was flavorless (even lacking salt) in particular the lemon white wine sauce in my dish tasted of nothing but oil. On a positive note for those looking for a vegan option the whole wheat penne pesto was good with a variety of vegetables. Service was lovely and why not 1 star. read more

A local favorite for dates, family gatherings, and celebrations with consistently great food, intimate seating and friendly service. Their garlic bread is always fantastic and favorites include the baked chicken, Tortelloni Stuffed With Six Cheeses, and Sautéed Chicken Breast, along with the Dark Chocolate Bag. It's been a reliable classic downtown in Port Jefferson for years! read more

See all

have been coming here for years. the bread and Classic Caesar Salad was delicious it has anchovies which most restaurants dont include but was awesome. i also got the six cheese tortellini and the lobster chunks were delicious and so fresh. finally i got the rainbow cheesecake which was good too. service was ok almost a bit too attentive read more

Pasta Pasta - rainbow cheesecake - Italian Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Wow! So impressed and greatly surprised. Our waitresss was PHENOMENAL She was constantly on point and had great recommendations. We had multiple appetizers and the bolognese was fantastic! Tiramisu was so great too. Wine pours were huge and we loved the atmosphere. Coming back with friends. read more

There was a huge dinner party, sharing the same space as my group and the table with the children was unattended to. It was very very noisy. The staff should have mentioned something to this group. It was our friend's birthday and another table nearby their friends birthday. It was so loud it was unbearable. It could have been avoided if the children were attended to. The waitress knew we were unhappy. Good customer service would have been to offer a drink or a dessert, something because the experience was horrible, and I will never go back. read more

Very small, quaint restaurant. We came here on a weekend for dinner and didn't have to make reservations. I had the Seafood Fra Diavolo and my wife had the Blackened Chicken and Shrip. We also ordered sides of Mashed Potatoes and Sautéed Spinach. We both thought the food was okay. read more

See all

We really wanted to like it but the food was not that good. The pear salad was too sweet and the pears dry. The cheese pizza was just not very good. The chicken dish was eh. The spaghetti bolognese was mediocre at best. Service was good but we were disappointed that they didn't bring something on the house for our special birthday celebration - as most restaurants would do. This meal cost almost $200 so a small scoop of ice cream with a candle would have been nice. I'm sorry but we would not recommend this nor eat here again. read more

Had lunch there on a weekday. Bread Quesedillas Fried calamari rings. Fried.escargot.in yummy white sauce read more

See all

Had dinner here recently. My friend and I were sat at the table literally at the entrance of the doorway. It was so uncomfortable and tight that the table behind us spilled their wine and it got on my friend's shirt. Way too busy to have a table in that location. I asked for our table to changed and they said no... Food was nothing to rave about. I will not be coming back and I don't recommend. FYI - I made a reservation. read more

I've enjoyed this restaurant for 2 decades. The flavors, diverse selections, service and ambiance always come through. And the bread!! Always a pleasure, even under recently changed ownership read more

Had lunch at Pasta Pasta today, a little gem in Port Jefferson. Food was delicious and service was great!!!

Great, great food! The restaurant is super quaint and clean and the staff were very friendly! They had a great menu options and they also had a great deal of a fixed price menu which honestly came with a lot of the price and it was delicious! Will definitely be back! read more

Such a cute hidden gem in Port Jeff! Accidentally stumbled upon this place on Apple Maps when looking for a place to eat for a birthday. Had a reservation, and was sat down 5mins later. The place has 3 rooms and very busy for a Thursday night. Lighting decor is very cute. The table bread is to DIE FOR. There is garlic butter already melted into the bread itself - no need for dipping! Delicious! The food overall was very good. A steak needed to be sent back for being undercooked. The soup was VERY thick. Other than that, we had a good time. Would love to come back to try more things on the menu. read more

See all

Food was flavorless and over rated. Not sure what the good reviews are about. The service was okay. The place did not meet our expectations. Family if 5 went and 5 different dishes with no flavor. Just bland. read more

Absolutely fantastic. Jake was the best server. I never leave reviews and felt inclined to do so. We are traveling to port Jefferson for a wedding and this was the perfect lunch after a long flight. Their red sauce is amazing! 10/10 read more

I went here for an impromptu lunch date with my husband and first off the decor is SO cute. Next up, their bread is like next level good. I could eat a whole meal on the bread alone. We got the calamari and while we did not care for the sauce, the calamari itself was expertly breaded. And thankfully at a restaurant called Pasta Pasta the pasta itself and the sauce were good. read more

Has anyone ever not talked about the bread from pasta pasta... well if you haven't heard of it, it's incredible. All of their apps are delish and the pasta is great as well. The staff are all very respectful and attentive. There is a nice moody vibe inside as well. Definitely recommend checking it out. read more

Comfortable spot but the food is mediocre at best. Had penne Alla vodka with spinach and shrimp and a cold piece of goat cheese cut off a block and placed on top. Really was no better than if you put that together real quick at home. The pasta was undercooked as well read more

The most difficult part of my experience was choosing a meal from the amazing menu. Everything sounded so good. I went with the Ravioli and I was not disappointed. It was delicious! The service was impeccable! It was a nice quiet dinner under beautifully placed lights. Thank you! read more

Great place for dinner! Food was fantastic! Refreshing given there are only a few restaurants in Suffolk that you actually walk away from with nothing but positive thoughts and discussions. Service was spot on. Well trained staff. Was a busy Saturday night. The staff kept up great. Not a frustraighted face in sight. Ambiance was nice. We had a center table. Though a booth would be preferred we gladly set at the table and it was still a great experience. We'll done Pasta Pasta. read more

The food was excellent, the ambiance was also very nice. We ate the lunch specials and they were a great deal and absolutely delicious.

When we arrived at 5:30pm the dining area in which we were seated was almost empty. By the time we left, around 8:30pm, the room we were in and the adjacent room were almost completely full. Our waiter, Anthony, arrived, with our menus, shortly after we were seated. The menu is comprehensive and includes a variety of choices. The prix fixed menu, is not as generous. I ordered the veal parmigiana with angel hair pasta. My wife chose the grilled fish plater. We ordered a bottle of red "Valpolicella Superiore" (2018), Zenato winery. Both dishes were ample. The angel hair was cooked al dente and topped by a delicate marinara. The veal was breaded and seasoned under a perfectly melted parmigiano. The veal was heavenly. My wife thoroughly enjoyed her entree as well. The wine, although red, enhanced the flavor of both our meals. For dessert, my wife ordered the apple blueberry crumble and I had the warm molten chocolate cake. Both were excellent. While I finished my glass of wine with my cake, my wife ordered a cappuccino to accompany her dessert. THE TAKEAWAYS 1. Make a reservation! 2. There is only street parking. 3. Experiment, you will NOT be disappointed! 4. Perfection comes at a price. If you want to save a little, order wine by the glass. 5. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and unobtrusive. read more

See all

Still a wonderful spot. Came a few times and never disappoints. Try the seafood lunch special. Only $18 with a large delicious portion. Check in with Yelp you may get a free something read more

Pasta Pasta - Inside view of tables when we entered. People came flooding in a few minutes later. A must try. - Italian Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

I enjoyed my lunch at pasta pasta in port Jefferson. The staff is young and polite and very accommodating for my elder family members. Seating is comfortable. Pasta was firm and tasty I had the stuffed mushroom ravioli delicious. One complaint was a loud obnoxious man eating next to us who pretended to be a waiter for his party. He walked around his table of 20 or so pouring wine, explaining the menu and then talking abusively throughout dinner. What a JERK, and no one said a thing to him to settle him down. Unfortunate ass-xxxxxs like him can ruin lunch for everyone! I'll be back hopefully but hopefully the racist isn't there!! read more

Our first time here for lunch was very good. Adorable decor and a very nice menu to choose from.

Thank you Danielle for a wonderful dinner. We celebrated our son Nicks 26th Birthday and had a great meal. read more

Pasta Pasta - Salmon - Italian Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

We love this restaurant! The food is amazing and so is the service. It's always crowded and even though we make reservations, there's a little wait, but it is soooo worth it!! Everything about this place makes you feel like you are eating right at home. I love the cozy booths, but the tables are also intimate, and you never feel crowded or rushed. I recommend everything on the menu, you can't go wrong with any dish. They have a great wine list, and awesome Champagne! They don't serve hard liquor, but what they do serve is excellent! This is my favorite restaurant in Port Jeff, and it is also a favorite of the couple we had dinner with. The food here is consistently excellent, and I can't say enough about the staff. They are awesome, and do such a great job, even though the place is always packed. They are friendly, patient, never make you feel rushed, and are always happy to great you and thank you for coming in. I can't say enough about how great this restaurant is :-) read more

See all

Food and Service are dismal. Waited over 45 mins for appetizers and food just not that good. Disappointed because we had great experiences in the past.Expensive too! read more