I'm really disappointed with my experience with Renzo's Pizzeria. I called to place an order and, yes, I may have confused the order for a moment -- but I was actively correcting myself and trying to fix it. I clearly said to forget the two eggplant parms and instead do one eggplant parm or one chicken parm. Instead of helping clarify, the person on the phone repeatedly said, "You're confusing me and I'm busy, can we hurry this up." I'm sorry, but that's not how you speak to customers. If you're busy, simply put me on hold -- I would have gladly waited. I also work at a pizzeria, and I would never speak to a customer that way. A little patience and basic manners go a long way. Very unprofessional and disappointing customer service. read more

The pizza is tasty. Thin crust with a flavorful sauce. We were disappointed with the amount of topping especially since it cost almost 10 bucks. The value is not there this pizza was 30 bucks and they should do better. We also had garlic knows they were overly firm, dry and flavorless. read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Two topping. Pepperoni and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

delicious, and fast service, and definitely worth the prices, which are pretty low. Not many seats though so best go with takeout

Renzos is the perfect hidden gem because its not your ordinary restaurant - it's a perfect blend of fine dining and a cozy pizzeria, giving you the flexibility to choose between a casual or fancy atmosphere. Mot only is their menu literally massive... I can simply guarantee you will have lunch the next day do you see how big that serving size is??? All of it tastes like a home cooked meal. Such high quality food and you're getting SO MUCH of it. Literally amazing. They have so many interesting pizza flavors i know one will peak your interest. Last time I went I tried a Mac and cheese slice?? That's literally crazy. The grandma corner slice is the one I'm consistently reaching for every time I'm there. It just stares at me I can't help it. Food included in Video: - Italian chicken soup - Penne vodka with chicken in a bread bowl - Angel hair with meatballs - Margarita Pizza - Sicilian Slice - Garlic knots - Misc slices: Definitely use them for Sunday football delivery, catering, or even just a family dinner in the dining room. read more

See all

Menu doesnt open with iphone. Now im ordering somewhere else. Get it together. Its 2026

Ordered a pie to go. Terrible. No flavor at all. Crust was thin which would've been great had there been any other redeeming qualities. Definitely a waste of over $20 for a plain cheese. Sadly won't be back. Extra star for the fun sign though. read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Interior sign - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Increase cook time and finish cooking the crust. Maybe evaluate and change the sauce being used.

Amazing food great friendly service. Monday /Tuesday dinner specials outstanding!!!! One of our new favorite places read more

Literally one of the best onions and sausage cheese pizzas and ham and cheese calzone I've ever had in a LONG TIME! Garrett was more than accommodating and even the nice young lady ordered from since was my first time ordering from there had patience to answer my questions and I didn't feel rushed or were trying to "hurry me up" lol... Wish I've been ordering from here for years instead other spots in area that just got more expensive and now use less inferior ingredients, truly one of the best spots I've been to and looking forward to trying their entrees and salads in the future! read more

Best Pizza I've ever had!!! Service is amazing, family friendly. Have been coming there for a while:) I brought some of my friends there and they wished to have place like this in their area ambiance is amazing also, place is clean, staff accommodating (and I am not an easy customer, always come up with deviations,lol) just love this place. Drove extra miles to have best experience in this location for several times because it worth it!! read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Kinds love pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Best Pizzeria in the Area! Friendly service..and a homey atmosphere... And they deliver! read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Barbecue Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Most delicious meals! Chicken and shrimp Parmesan tasted amazing! The service was excellent!

Amazing food large portions reasonably priced. Nice place to bring the family. Located in strip mall. Parking in front is limited

First time Ordering a regular Sicilian pie from Renzo's which was very good. Personally I like my pies on the well done side, this was a little too underbaked for me. Next time I will ask for this. The sauce was good but again I like a pizza sauce a little more on the sweeter side, but overall it was flavorful slice of pie. I will be back. read more

Ordered a pie and when I get there they tell me "your slice is almost ready", no sorry I ordered a pie not a slice. Oh sorry give us 10 more minutes. Go back to get my pie and of course nobody makes eye contact with you, so I said is my pie ready? "Almost they say". So when I get home I take the corner slice and the bottom is burnt, so what they did was took the pie that was sitting out and never made a new pie. Don't waste your time or money with this place, go somewhere else! read more

If you want sucky pizza come here holy cow, guys are nice I feel bad but damn the slice is very powdery no flavor breaks apart and zero flavor ugh waste of money. Go back to the drawing board pizza is not hard to botch read more

We have now been to Renzo's for take out twice since it recently re-opened. The pizza was always good, bit we were equally impressed by the entrees and hero's, they may have even bee better then the old Renzo's (which was not bad to begin with). Nice guys running the place too; they forgot 1 dish and called for my address before I had even unpacked my order, and sent a driver over with it! Thanks guys, keep it up and you'll be in business a log time! read more

Tonight was our second visit since the re-opening and our party of 4 all loved our meals,from salad to start to chocolate cake to finish.Great service too. It will be our Saturday night go-to. read more

Excellent pizza and subs! I always get take out here. The staff is always friendly and happy. Had one issue where they forgot my garlic knots one time but they quickly made up for it by making a fresh batch and gave me some extra free for my troubles, read more

Fresh pasta, amazing sauce, great wait staff. The bread bowls! Highly recommend - salad was delicious-husband had stuffed rigatoni with chicken and meatballs in a vodka sauce in a bread bowl and I had lasagna. We loved our meals. We can't wait to go back again. read more

Went yesterday for dinner with my son's family ( party of 6 total) to celebrate my grandson's football victory I hadn't been back for about 2 years. I have been to many of the better Italian restaurants, but I must say everyone's dinner was perfect Amazing meal for all David was our server Thank you all We will be back soon read more

Ordered food for delivery, it took all of an hour to get here (1.4miles away) and when it did get here the pie was smashed and cold. So we're the chicken wings we ordered also cold. I didn't feel like waiting another hour for food but I should've just sent it back. read more

i have supported this business for years since moving into this area however they tip baited me after I shopped their order over 500 on Instacart! I shopped and deliver their order to the restaurant was in communication with Mike who advised me to deliver to the back of store! there was an women of Hispanic descent in the kitchen she did not speak English or at least she pretended not to, when i left they decreased my tip all the way to 0 read more

Normally I check the reviews before eating somewhere new but I was too hungry this time lol. Normally you don't see a sign out with the new & in with the old thought it was interesting but didn't think to much of it. Everyone was extremely nice and friendly. I loved the pizza and the wings. I'm extremely picky about pizza but I'm glad I tried here today it's definitely a go to spot for me. I never experienced the previous owner but the current owner and crew were wonderful. read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Sign - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Just ordered a pie now that they have new owners. It was delicious. Better than ever!

The food here is incredible! Huge portions and great food. The pizzeria has a great and extensive menu with lots of great pasta dishes and pizzas. A must try! read more

See all

Food is very good. Lovely waitress. We brought our own wine (corking fee) which we love! Large salad is quite small for what they are charging ($17) but all other portions were generous. read more

Gave this place multiple chances but everytime the food is bad. If you come in to get slices, they're old and been sitting there for a long time. If you like crunchy old pizza this is your spot! No such thing as a fresh slice here. So I got a pie and it was just bland and tasteless. Also oddly crunchy. On top of this a counter that forces you to sign a receipt because they want tips. Tipping to pick up your food... so sick of it. Tipping to pick up old pizza you made 2 hours ago, never again. read more

My husband and I heard Renzo's was under new ownership and decided to give it another try as it's just about 2 miles from our house. We are glad we did. We ordered a chicken Parmesan hero and a pie. In our opinion, it's the best pizza in the neighborhood. The slices were very substantial, not light and thin like a lot of places around here. The toppings were good quality and HOT. The chicken parm was perfect. My husband also had a nice conversation with the new owner and he was a true gentleman. Our new go-to for pizza. read more

Great place. Super friendly staff. The owner makes true Italian pastries. The food is great and prices are good. read more

Love Renzo! We enjoy their pizza, sauce is good, pizza does not have that oil dripping off it! We ask for cooked lite, done perfectly! Every time have eaten in their dining room, we have never received a bad meal! Make a reservation because it can be busy! read more

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

See all

Great food and great atmosphere! I've had their regular pizza and specialty pizza and they're all delicious. Highly recommend the Burrata Pizza and the cheesy garlic knots. The pasta with clam sauce is a 10/10. Definitely stop here when you're on the area. read more

Pizza in front, Grandmas dining room in back. A cozy dining room where three generations of family prepare and serve amazing Italian food. From the moment you walk in you feel like you are at your Grandmas house. You are pampered and fed amazing food, large portions and then tempted by the all homemade desserts! Every dessert looked and tasted better than the next! This place offers specials with three different foods on one plate! Amazing! read more

We just moved to the area and Renzos was the first place that we tried. We also just placed a catering order with them. Their food was honestly so good. Everyone raved about the food. All the guys in there are so nice everytime you walk in. All the food in our catering order was priced very reasonably and they even included plates, utensils, serving utensils and napkins. Do not hesitate to give this place a try. Their spaghetti, meatball and ricotta cheese roll is sooo good. This will be our go to Italian restaurant, hopefully for many years to come. Thank you to everyone at Renzos! read more

Don't know what happened this place used to be great I order from here alot don't know if they have a new cook or what but EVERYTHING we ordered tonight had no flavor. This is the 2nd time this has happened! Penne with vodka sauce and chicken franchise both tasted like plain pasta. Penne had almost no sauce on it and the chicken had the opposite it was more like pasta in soup, chicken was pink as well. We also ordered mini Italian desserts for $7 and got a small piece of cheesecake. $67 dollars later and noone ate thier food . read more

Terrible attitude grouchy mean owner Food over 2 hours wait for delivery Rude & clueless in customer service. Doesn't honor recent coupons. read more

The best meatball hero in NY. If they have the Italian love cake don't miss it. The absolute best way to end a meal. The pizza is also delicious. The crust isn't too thick and the sauce is perfection. The restaurant area is small but has a cozy feel to it and you get that authentic Italian home cooking experience. They also deliver. read more

This place used to be amazing under the previous owners. Not only is the food just meh, but the owners is extremely rude and mean. I have severe food allergies and politely asked him if there was an ingredient in the pizza, he yelled at me NO. I then ordered a slice and asked for a side salad which came with dressing. I sat down to have my salad while I waited for the pizza and when noticed that the dressing could potentially have one of my anaphylactic allergens. I asked if the dressing contained that ingredient VERY nicely and this man WENT OFF. He was yelling at me and my mom saying he had already told us and we were saying no before we were asking just about the pizza. SHEESH. Will never EVER come back. Pizza was also trash. read more

If you are looking for an upscale, fancy, Italian restaurant that will have you considering taking out a second mortgage to pay the check, Renzo's is NOT for you. What Renzo's DOES do well is to churn out tasty, authentic Italian dishes at a reasonable and fair price point, served up in their small but intimate dining room. Case in point is their amazing meat sauce that, in my humble opinion, rivals your Italian grandmother's homemade sauce. You would be hard pressed to find a better meat sauce at any other restaurant at any price. Additionally, try their mouth-watering stuffed mushrooms as your appetizer; you'll thank me later! read more

Was so excited to hear Renzos was reopening with the original cooks and staff. Went for dinner opening night. We had an assortment of things from the kitchen including calamari and manicotti that were delicious!! Let's not forget about the Buffalo roll... the dough is so crispy and tasty! Will definitely be returning soon. read more