Cancel

Open app

Search

Peel Pizza

2.8 (81 reviews)

Peel Pizza Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Peel Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos - Peel Pizza

Clam chowder - white pizza with clams (or lack thereof...), bacon, potatoes.
Daniel N.

This was a super letdown after having such a great experience at the Hingham location. I arrived a few minutes early, but overall it was timely as they handed it to me right out of the oven. I then had a short 9 minute ride home, only to experience shame and disappointment. It sucks when you talk up the food to guests, only to have everyone be super unimpressed and full of regret after the meal. Ordered wings, 1 large cheese and 1 large clam chowder pizza. The wings were well seasoned, and I like that they don't smother them in any sauces and let the plain flavor shine. However these wings were overcooked and super dry - no indication of any moisture left. An order came with 9 wings. Now onto the pizzas - both were also incredibly overcooked. The crust and dough were so dry, that our mouths and teeth were sore after dinner from pulling, shredding, and trying to chew. Literally cut up our mouths because they were sharp croutons at that point. Also had to actively search for clams on the clam chowder pizza - found maybe 8 tops. Overall such a disappointment since we had great wings and pizza from another location and were excited to try to Milton one. Will not be ordering from here again. Ordering/delivery also available through doordash and ubereats. Street parking can be a pain around dinner time and will likely have to double park to run in and grab.

Amelia B.

I ordered a pizza and a salad for delivery using their text to order feature. When the driver came he only had a pizza. I mentioned that I had ordered a salad and it wasn't on the invoice. He also mentioned that I didn't include an apartment number, which I did, so they are clearly still working on this system since there were apparently multiple errors inputting my order. He basically just shrugged it off. I decided to call and get the salad, because when only half our dinner came that was obviously an issue. The girl on the phone was actually nice and said it would be right out. I said i would be happy to order the larger size salad to make it more worthwhile for the driver. Minutes later I got a call back from a man who acknowledged it was their mistake but basically said "too bad" we won't be sending it out because we don't want our driver to make another trip because we are busy. I tried to discuss resolution and he hung up on me. Truly disappointing to receive such awful service from a place I previously enjoyed.

Waldo S.

My name is Jarrett Sweeting. Peel Pizza in Milton is Horrible. My large calzone was the equivalent of a large sub. But thats not the worst part. The pizza that I ordered for my son was a sick joke. (SEE PICTURE) i opened the box to find all the cheese and all the toppings in a pile on one side of the box. HORRIBLE. Merry Christmas to you to Peel Pizza. FIRST AND LAST TIME I ORDER FROM YOU GUYS. You deserve negative stars. UPDATE!! JANUARY 2019 Brendan the owner of peel pizza mad this situation all better on Superbowl Sunday. He delivered a large calzone a large hawaiian pizza and an order of wings that were absolutely perfect. Now I can say that I will order from Peel Pizza often in the future. 5 STARS

Beef Lasagna

Probably the worst Lasagna I have ever had from a restaurant. Quality akin to just above inedible cafeteria lasagna. Ground hamburger meat, flavourless tomatoes, overcooked ricotta, and rubbery sponge mozzeralla, drowning in grease. You would be better served buying a discount frozen entree from your local supermarket. A marked step up in culinary effort.

a pizza with mushrooms and cheese
Duy L.

BEST PIZZA IN BOSTON!!! I ordered twice, once on UberEats and once take out. The pizza is delicious. You get to choose your own CHEESE! They have a list of them. The crust is thin. The pie is not over baked. The taste is so good, you still think about the pizza afterwards! I am a vegetarian so it's great I get to choose my own toppings as well. I usually choose caramelized onions, mushrooms, olives, garlic with BURRATA cheese. It looks amazing and taste amazing!

See all

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Peel Pizza

You might also consider

Steel & Rye

Steel & Rye

3.9
(693 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$$

This spot has been on my "I should try that someday" list for a few years, and I'm so glad I…read morefinally made it in. The first thing that surprised me was how much seating they offer. The outdoor area is inviting, and inside there's a great mix of low-top tables, high-tops, bar seating, and cozy spots to settle into. Everything feels thoughtfully spread out, and I loved being able to see the open brick oven and activity in the kitchen. The space also has a bit of a bakery/café vibe, making it feel like a place where you could stop in for a quick grab-and-go item or stay awhile for a full meal. The staff made a great impression too. The people at the front were incredibly helpful to my guest, who was having some trouble with their phone. I also ordered one of the specialty drinks but asked for it without alcohol. The bartender absolutely nailed it--it was so good that my only complaint was that it didn't come in a bigger glass. For food, I had the grass-fed burger and fries (see photo), and it exceeded my expectations. The burger was so juicy and flavorful that I ended up cutting it into pieces just to make it manageable. Every bite was delicious. What I appreciate most is that I left feeling like I hadn't even experienced everything the restaurant has to offer. I already want to go back, choose a different seat, and enjoy a completely different perspective of the space. Honestly, it feels like the perfect place to spend a rainy afternoon. This is your sign, visit now!

5 stars for the pastries. 5 stars for the pizza…read more 5 stars for the brick oven. 5 stars for the obvious quality of the food, presentation, and the business in general. 1 star for hiring DOZENS of spoiled kids from the neighborhood to the cafe where they routinely ignore a customer in an empty restaurant for an awkward 4 minutes. I burned a hole into the backs and sides of their heads and left no gratuity to the failson that decided to finally acknowledge me. 1 star for the never-changing menu.

Photos
Steel & Rye
Turkey sandwich
Turkey sandwich
Large iced matcha ube latte

See all

Large iced matcha ube latte
Creation

Creation

5.0
(3 reviews)
0.5 mi

Excellent place for salads and pizza conveniently located within the Common Market food court in…read moreWest Quincy. I went there to get a salad. There are two different ways to order a salad here. The first choice is to order one of their signature salads. There are at least 5 or 6 different signature salads that they make here with set ingredients. The other option is to have them make you a salad with ingredients of your own choosing. You get to pick what type of lettuce you want for your salad and then they let you choose up to four different ingredients for your salad and whatever salad dressing you like. For an extra charge you can also add a protein to your salad such as chicken. There is a huge list of at least 40 possible toppings that you can have them make your salad with. I opted for romaine lettuce topped with cucumbers, tomatoes, onions and broccoli. For a salad dressing I went with the ranch dressing. I really enjoyed the salad. Very delicious. If you are wanting a pizza they have ten or so signature pizzas that they make here or you can create your own by choosing from their list of pizza sauces and cheeses plus up to four toppings from their huge list of different items to build your pizza with. I love that they have so many choices available and part of the fun of eating here is that you get to create either your salad or pizza with so many different choices of toppings. The service is always pleasant here and I've always received my orders quickly. They also have a comfortable dining area in which you can enjoy your meal or you can do takeout. I will certainly be back for more salad.

Loooove their hot honey pizza! Ordered it 3 times in one week. Their salads are good too- but order…read moredressing on the side (mine had too much dressing on it/was way too salty).

Photos
Creamy Bleu Salad
Creamy Bleu Salad
Margherita Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Mexicano Salad

See all

Mexicano Salad

Peel Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...