5 stars for the pastries. 5 stars for the pizza. 5 stars for the brick oven. 5 stars for the obvious quality of the food, presentation, and the business in general. 1 star for hiring DOZENS of spoiled kids from the neighborhood to the cafe where they routinely ignore a customer in an empty restaurant for an awkward 4 minutes. I burned a hole into the backs and sides of their heads and left no gratuity to the failson that decided to finally acknowledge me. 1 star for the never-changing menu. read more

This review is for their bakery. I love their glazed donut. The texture is fluffy inside and the glazed formed a thin crisp. All of their pastries are not too sweet. The vanilla cranberry danish had the perfect amount of tartness paired with the smooth pastry cream. I could taste the early grey tea in the London fog tea cake. It looked dense but wasn't inside. The pecan coconut blondie had a lovely chewy texture and the coconut flavor wasn't overwhelming. Staff was quick to greet and ask what I needed and there are plenty of parking outside if their lot is full. read more

Steel & Rye - Assortment of pastries - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

Lovely local spot! Service is great, the servers here are very kind. Steel & Rye's Pizza is literally the best. They always have amazing sauce, delicious toppings, & crispy yet airy crusts. You'll never go wrong with any of their pizzas. Their Shirley Temples are also incredibly refreshing. The only downside was their dessert. The Lavender Blueberry Cake was texturally hard so it was difficult to eat. The vanilla icecream on top didn't seem necessary either. Would definitely come back for their pizza, but would pass on the dessert. read more

Steel & Rye - Blueberry Lavender Cake - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

Great food and ambience! Went there for brunch and really enjoyed it! Will go back for dinner!

We went here a lot during and in the years immediately after the pandemic thanks to its ample outdoor seating, kids menu, and variety of options. We barely go anymore. With each visit, the prices seemed to go up, and quality seemed to go down. For a while it was our preferred go-to wood fire pizza take out spot. But we've since found Roundhead pizza is even better. read more

Just came back for a third time for lunch and they served breakfast and lunch options. Lots of salads, sandwiches, and pizza offerings. Great atmosphere, decent size with bar seating and outdoor dining. The highlight for us would definitely be our waitress, Francesca. She is hilarious, personable, super kind, and very accommodating, took really great care of us! read more

Came here during lunchtime. This is a very open and spacious restaurant with outdoor seating. There is parking available. The service was amazing with the waiter checking on us frequently if we enjoyed the food which we did. For my drink, I got the cookie butter latte which was delicious. It was more on the sweeter side which is what I like. For the appetizer, we got the spiced chip and dip. The chips were very airy and crispy where you can still taste the potato. The dip was a perfect pairing. It was light and creamy with a perfect amount of spice. I love that the pizza was wood fired. The Margherita pizza was okay but felt like I needed more flavor on the sauce. The mushroom pizza however was delicious. It was earthy and flavorful. Overall, I had a great time and would recommend read more

See all

Steel & Rye has to be my favorite spot in Milton! Growing up here, I must admit, I didn't really get the chance to visit often but I see why so many people rave about this place. They have a cute concept for breakfast/brunch where you can order at the bakery stand and just find a table to sit at & they will bring you what you ordered. What we ordered: -BLT sandwich -Chicken cutlet sandwich -Turkey sandwich -Iced matcha ube latte -Iced honey lavender latte -Cold brew I love the sandwiches from here! The chicken cutlet was my favorite; moist and not dry at all. I'm obsessed with their drinks... honey lavender is so good. The matcha latte with ube was also very nice. I like how both drinks didn't taste watery at all & had all the flavor! Nice and strong. Staff is very kind and helpful. Inside is very spacious & has lots of tables available. This is a great place to go to get some work done, study, or even just to meet up with a friend to catch up! Hours: On Mondays, they're open from 7am- 2:30pm. Tues-Thurs they have regular hours 7am-9pm, Friday 7am-10pm, Sat 8am-10pm, & Sunday 8am-9pm. Parking: they have a parking lot! If the lot is full, there is also lots of street parking spots on Eliot St, on both sides! Free parking. read more

See all

Haven't been by steel and rye for a bit so we decided to meet an o'l friend for some lunch / brunch! We weren't disappointed. Nice local spot with a small parking lot / street parking all up the street available. Walking in we were greeted right away. Directed us over to the order counter. Grabbed drinks and some sandwiches! - matcha ube latte - ice cold brew - honey lavender ice latte coffee - chicken cutlet sandwich - BLT - Turkey sandwich Everything was enjoyable. I liked my matcha latte especially after mixing it well the Ube and the matcha always goes well together as a pair. The lady liked her coffee not overly sweet! I got the chicken cutlet sandwich, it was much bigger than i expected and i was definitely full after. The chicken was fried well, still moist and not dry. Thin cuts! The sauce they have on there i forget what it was but it was like a pesto/olive oil/ Italian seasoning mix. You take your seat with a number flag and they graciously bring it to your table. Everyone was super nice and they bring out water for you as well. Will definitely be back. Light casual and pretty quick food. read more

See all

Great pizza! Pricey but worth it for a treat. Their pizza oven was recently replaced - feel like it was just as good as before the change in oven. Awesome dough recipe and good variety of pizza options. Fans of margherita, pepperoni, and fennel sausage. read more

Steel & Rye - Pizza - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

As always, good service, food, drinks and ambiance. Especially for a last minute reservation read more

Steel & Rye - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

There is something special about Steel & Rye. It's the kind of place where hospitality isn't forced, it's felt. From the moment you walk in, the staff makes you feel genuinely welcome. Their menu strikes the perfect balance, you can't really go wrong- solid choices. read more

Service is nice but the food and coffee is OK at best, I think there's a huge upside here and the space is nice but the food and value just doesn't match the rest. read more

Even though I don't live in the area, I've been here a couple of times. The vibe inside is rustic dining /bakery with a morning ToGo bakery that is amazing to a dinner experience that is as gastro as it gets. The menu is artisan everytime. The chef is clearly an artist. I've had their dinner pasta specials and the lasagna bolognese and the kale Caesar. Service is clearly outstanding and the servers grasp of the menu is superb. This is a cut above everyone else. I look forward to all my future trip here. read more

See all

We got seated quickly. Our server was friendly and helpful. The food was fresh, hot and delicious!! Would return and enjoyed tremendously! read more

See all

My second visit in about a year. I went for the pizza but ended up getting the cheeseburger. For $26 dollars I figured it must be amazing. Had to try it but wish I hadn't. So not worth the money. First off, I asked for med-rare and it came med and was dry. Secondly, the onions were ok, but not great. The bread to meat ratio was way off. The patty is too small for the size bun it comes on. After a couple bites I took the top off of it. But worst of all is the burger sauce. It is thousand island dressing with so much liquid smoke it tasted fake. Left a sickening taste in my mouth and I could not finish it. I also do not like their beer menu at all. Extremely disappointing. It's a beautiful space with a nice bakery, but that's about it. read more

Stopped in for the morning bakery items. While expensive, the flavor and quality is very high (at $6 a piece, it can get pricey trying them all!) staff have always been friendly and helpful/welcoming. Inside is a bakery/coffee shop that is great for meeting friends or getting a little work done. The pizza oven can be a great warmth in the winter when in use. read more

Steel & Rye - Ham cheddar croissant and a cardamom kouign-amann (offered on weekends!) - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

I have been to S&R many times and occasionally sample their baked goods at the Hingham Farmers Market. Their brunch menu is consistently excellent (fresh ingredients and farm to table quality) and their espresso drinks and martinis are always good. The atmosphere is great as well. It's in an old ambulance depot so it's very large and roomy inside. Can't speak to their dinner menu but hope to try it soon. read more

Tried this restaurant over the weekend. Like someone else in the reviews, no idea what the hype is about. $26 burger and it was just ok Chicken sandwich bun was SO huge and dry. Pancakes = dry. Everyone's meal was just ok. What a bummer. It is a beautiful spot though. If I ever go back, I'd stick to pizza as that looked more promising coming out. read more

Vibrant, Warm, Energetic yet intimate, Steel & Rye captures local comradery & an enjoyable moment for a couple just having dinner after a long week. Starters are fun, interactive, rustic.. entrees are filling , well- manicured! Service is engaging & quirky at times, in a positive way. In a very removed small town like setting though in Milton ... Wonderful! read more

Great place for coffee in Milton! They have many options and specialty drinks! I have not tried the food here but will definitely be back to try! The staff was very helpful when explaining how to order since it was a bit confusing where to order when I first walked in. I ordered an iced Ube latte and it was great! It was the right amount of sweetness and nice balance of flavor! A portion of the proceeds from the ube latte and taro latte are donated to the Maui Wildfire Relief until mid September as well! read more

Steel & Rye - Iced Ube Latte - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

Don't know what all the hype is about. The only thing that is good here are the bakery items. Two weeks ago I got a turkey sandwich to go and was shocked that it was deli turkey! For what they charge why aren't they carving real turkey breast? Was in there today for sit down lunch. Wish I had taken pictures. Ordered heirloom tomato salad, $18 for 5 tomato slices, sliced marcona almonds, and fresh dill! Margarita pizza, 10 inch, charcoal burned for $19. Again I don't get the draw or excitement. Won't be going back except for pastry. read more

We just had one of the worst dining experiences. We had been before and had a good experience but this time it felt like something went wrong every step of the way. First they brought the wrong appetizer, then they brought the wrong drinks, they forgot other drinks. when it came time for the main meal 2 of 3 of our party got our food while the last person's food came out so late the other people were already done with their dinner. The whole time this was happening we were also being given other tables'' drinks and food while the people next to us got our orders. The water seemed very confused by everything and the manager ended up comping our entire meal. It was so disappointing because we had had such a good time the first time. I will likely never return after such a bad experience. read more

I love their margherita pizza and their homemade chips!! It's so crispy and fresh. There is a ton of street parking as well as lot parking. In the morning, they have a bakery section with coffee/tea and baked goods. They have free Wi-Fi here so I would come here with a friend and do work together. There is patio seating so I love to come here on a warm beautiful day and do some work outside. read more

Steel & Rye - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

My wife and have made this restaurant our go-to spot. It's a very special place. BUT...the last two times we went we're just ok. The food was good, but not exceptional. And same for the service. The waitstaff were very young and inexperienced. Considering the price, our expectations were and are high, thus the feedback. At this price point, everything should be excellent. We'll keep going, but I'd like to see how things go. read more

Came here on a date night tonight with my partner. We had a phenomenal night the atmosphere was great, the food was even better, and the service was the best. We started with sour dough bread and split pepperoni pizza and the burger. The burger is one of the best we had in the greater Boston area. Our server Josh was wonderful! He was attentive and extremely polite throughout our time there which made our experience even better. We will definitely be coming back here. read more

Steel & Rye - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

met here with some college friends for a girls day and so glad we did! The service was phenomenal, Aaron was so attentive and kind, we really appreciated him checking in on us, and taking care of us during our extended lunch while we caught up! The ricotta toast was so flavorful and filling! I loved the crispy potato sides (ask for a side of the horseradish mayo) you will not be disappointed! read more

Steel & Rye - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

I just had to give a special kudos to their sourdough bread. It is some of the best that I had especially if you take it home and pop it back in the oven. Personally I enjoy the bread when it isn't sliced. I also learned from the baker that the bread is okay for gluten intolerant people (but not gluten free / celiacs) because of the long fermentation process that breaks down the gluten read more

See all

I don't think I can say enough about this place. My last day visiting Boston started here and it was fantastic. Just the vibe around this place really set the tone for how the service and food would be. Watching the locals pour into this place was a sign that this place was good. The coffee and my breakfast sandwich was fresh and just down right good. This is the perfect example of how a local restaurant should be. Loved my visit to Boston and my breakfast here. AMAZING!! read more

Oh my goodness! I just moved to the neighborhood and am so excited about this bakery. I ordered the Italian sandwich and ir was incredible. Homemade pickles, charcuterie, and the best bread on this planet, (miles better than Iggys.) They have an outdoor seating area where dogs are allowed. 10/10 so excited to living walking distance to this place! read more

Great decor, it seems like a hidden gem but I learned about it first on phantom gourmet so I guess the cats out the bag. I ordered a custom seafood pizza with chicken and a garlic base and it was amazing. The service was great also had a burger which was juicy and perfectly cooked. It was a slow night but the attentiveness I received was A1! Great place to try out! read more

Steel & Rye - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

One of those cases where I found myself doing research. If I am going to bop a place on the noggin, I want to make sure I more-or-less know what I am talking about. Steel & Rye appears to have something of an identity crisis, though somehow it works? S&R is the amalgamation of a hip brunch and dinner restaurant combined with a bakery/cafe that bakes pastries and loaves of bread. Complete with a bar, of course. I stopped in for a non-boozy Sunday brunch and ordered the chilaquiles and a regular coffee. I later bought a piece of Cherry & Pink Peppercorn Shortbread to satisfy my sweet tooth and go with the coffee once the chilaquiles were gone. The Chilaquiles were excellent! The chips were warm and felt homemade, and the chicken was in ample amounts and very tender. The salsa verde was fantastic, too; it brought a gentle level of heat and acidity and tied everything together. The only thing that would have been nice would be some avocado. Then again, that's just the millennial in me talking. The execution here works. Having the chicken and most of the sauce be towards the bottom meant that the chips could shine on their own without being turned into a soggy mess. As great as this dish was, I found the price steep relative to what I got. $21 for a plate of (though tasty) chips, a modest amount of chicken, an egg, and some veggies and sauces seems relatively high. Moving to the baked good - I immensely enjoyed the shortbread. It wasn't overly sweet, and the cherry and pink peppercorn flavors worked well together. I only wish I wasn't so desensitized to pepper in all forms! The service here was solid, nothing to write home about, but nothing to complain about either. read more

See all

My wife and I have been to Steel at least 20 times, and I've been with a friend probably a dozen more. The ambiance is great. Staff is usually good. One of the main managers (a guy, forget his name) is kind of a prick. That's not really a big deal. The reality is that it's inconsistent from a food standpoint. The food can be excellent. The food can also be terrible. It's not that I expect perfection every time, but the range of outcomes is pretty extreme here. I've gotten the burger, pepperoni pizza, one of the pasta dishes, a bunch of different things, and they were great. Well worth the money (not a cheap place) and tasty. The pastries are pretty good. I've also gotten the burger before and it wasn't great. The pastas as well. Some of the appetizers are now tiny portions. The lunchtime menu, while enticing, can be a joke. The Cuban sandwich is a coin flip any hour of the day - it's either great and crisp, or skimpy and overloaded with yellow mustard. A few weeks ago I got a latte and it was so sweet I couldn't drink it. The most recent last straw was this Italian sub. The photo does the justice, and for $14, you're better off at Blasi's or Lamberts. This was a bread and lettuce sandwich. Really sad. My wife and I both think it used to be better, but has gone downhill, up in price, and it's like rolling the dice going there now. We have two friends that live nearby and they also agree. We're more likely to goto Bowery (much more consistent) if we're in that area. I'd give it 3.5 stars if I could - some days it's a 5, others a 2, so 3.5 would be the average. But it's not good or consistent enough for 4 stars or more. Pains me to write this review but after the Italian sandwich today, it was time to say it out loud. Disappointing stuff. read more

Steel & Rye - Italian Sub - c'mon man! - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

Nice laid back vibes. We went around 3:30 pm and between 3:30-4 the food menu changes over and only serves pizza. The pizza was really good, had a nice crisp to it. It was a little oily but taste was very fresh. The smash burger was good as well. Could be a nice date night spot and they also have a bakery during the day. read more

Steel & Rye - Pizza - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

Recently came here with a group of friends and the service was great. A friend has food allergies and the staff were able to accommodate her. Not only that, but every time they dropped off a dish for the table, they made sure to notify her whether those contain allergens. The rest of us were impressed because while many restaurants do take allergies seriously, none of them have gone as far as having staff inform us for every shared dish that was put on the table. My friend really appreciated that extra mile. The food was good - I loved the roasted chicken that I ordered and apparently so did my friends as they kept talking about it and didn't turn down any offers from me to take some. I'd love to come back and try the pizza once they replace their oven. read more

Off the lunch menu - the turkey and swiss sandwich was absolutely scrumptious. I would usually never go for turkey or swiss, but this beautiful sandwich was one of the best I have ever tasted. Their adorable honey lavender latte is so good I nearly fainted with the awe-striking deliciousness of this beverage. (basically, it's to-die-for and you should get this if you're into that kind of thing) The restaurant itself is adorable. It's basically a barn vibe with cute lighting, plenty of seating variety, and some of the cutest glassware. I didn't get pictures, but the water is served in the cutest sets!!! Bathrooms are super obvious, a little hall right before the bakery counter when walking in the door. They have free wifi available and it didn't seem too slow or anything, there was music playing in the background at just the perfect volume to hear yet not too loud as to overpower conversation. They have many service options, but I ordered at the bakery ordering space. Each table, however, has a QR code to scan, order, and pay for the order without having to use their little "register" (perfect for the average introvert). Every staff member I saw was friendly and incredibly helpful to this first-timer. Make sure you figure out what time of day you are going so you know what menu(s) you could choose off of, though because they have schedules for meal rotations. read more

Steel & Rye - Hot Honey Lavender Latte with skim milk - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

It's a large space and looks very inviting- both inside and the patio. My first time eating from here. Only did take out but would definitely try dining in. It would probably be a much better experience. The Caesar salad was decent. The service was pretty good but they ran out of cutlery and it took them a while to find it. Found street parking nearby easily on a Sunday morning. read more

Steel & Rye - Caesar salad - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

See all

This is for their pasta alone! Just wow!!! So delicious! I bought it there and cooked it at home, will not disappoint! Also, their breads are also noteworthy! read more

Steel & Rye - Fresh pasta to go - American Near Me - Milton, Massachusetts

It's a very small space inside. But hopefully if not many people are there you can sit and it's a nice cozy spot. The Turkey apple and Brie sandwich was DELICIOUS! The grilled bread it was on also made an impact. My friend got the Buffalo chicken sandwich and I did try a bit and it was also equally as delicious. My iced chai latte was different than normal but in a good way. They don't make it super sweet, it's more of the spiced flavor which was nice and refreshing. The service was poor. The girl at the register was not very friendly or welcoming. It took a long time for our sandwiches to come out and then they put mine on the pick up shelf and I had to ask about the status 10 min after my friend got hers. They didn't even say sorry or look like they felt bad at all. read more

Cute spot! Went with a girlfriend for dinner, and the place was busy and kind of loud, but very cute atmosphere and yummy food. Had a variety of people of all ages, including kids, and different seating areas. Definitely would like to come back at different times to try their different menus! read more