My uncle and I stumbled upon this restaurant today and decided to try it out. We both ordered 2 slices of pizza which took a lot longer to place than expected...I'd say at least 7 - 10 minutes. There were 4 people working in the small kitchen so I'll chalk it up to that. The pizza was good but a bit too greasy for my liking. The slices are also huge. $10 for 2 slices of pepperoni and a drink. Do with that what you will. It personally wouldn't be my number one choice but if I was in the area late at night I would order again. read more

Do NOT order from here. I found a whole clump of hair in my food. Not a strand--a full, nasty chunk. It was absolutely disgusting and completely ruined my meal. When I called, they were rude and dismissive like it was no big deal. They offered to remake the food but didn't want to give me a refund--which makes no sense. With something that disgusting in my food, I should have gotten a refund, no question. Honestly, I should have gotten both. Instead, I had to go all the way back there in person just to get my money back--even though I paid for delivery. On top of that, I ordered a steak bomb with extra meat and somehow ended up with more peppers than meat. The whole reason I paid for extra was because the last time the portions were skimpy--and I didn't even complain then. I simply asked for it to be made correctly this time. Instead, they tried to flip it and act like I was "complaining from the beginning," which wasn't true at all. When I got there, I forgot to bring the other sub with me, and they were acting like it was a hassle because of that. Mind you, I didn't eat it--I threw it away when I got home. Either way, the attitude was unnecessary. And after looking at other reviews, I'm clearly not the only one who's had issues like this. If this is what's ending up in customers' food, I don't even want to imagine what the kitchen looks like. This is beyond unsanitary and honestly something the Board of Health needs to look into. Save your money and go somewhere else. I didn't order anything else from here, and I won't ever be ordering again. This place is dirty, unprofessional, and clearly doesn't care about basic food safety. My camera does suck but you get the picture looks like drain hair or pubic smh so disgusting. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - Clump of hair found in sub taken at pizza shop. - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

I ordered a Buffalo chicken sub, it was horrible they barely put any chicken on it. it was chopped in small pieces and very over cooked. also ordered a steak and cheese sub, again barely any steak on it. They are very stingy with the meat, I would never recommend this place and won't go there again. read more

Best pizza in Randolph I give it 4.6 stars Steven j Affannato Randolph Massachusetts & Quincy

Delicious pizza for real. Thin crispy crust that's handmade. I love the single slices by the register. Super affordable, yummy lunch. I hope they pay their back of house enough for how good the food is!!! read more

Don't eat here, they had an attitude because I wanted a fresh slice when that last slice could've easily been discarded, and I personally know that it wasn't sitting for just an hour because when I asked the cashier when was it made he initially said (without consulting the chef) "I got here an hour ago, I'm not sure when it was made", then the cook lied in agreement with the liar of a cashier. If you got here an hour ago you would've seen all 8 slices of the pepperoni pie & he could've ensured me that it was made an hour ago! Terrible cashier, no sense of customer service & RUDE! I asked if I can get a fresh slice of pepperoni pizza because the one he was willing to serve me was HARD & OLD (it was 1 slice left sitting in the heater, not 2 or 3 slices); I asked for a fresh one and didn't mind waiting, the cook in the back continued to have an attitude and told me that he isn't going to make anymore pepperoni slices until THE OLD slice is gone. The cashier and cook clearly lied when I asked them how long ago was the previous pizza pie cooked because like I said it was BURNT (hard) and basically completely dry! & yes I do have a picture. Then when I took the picture the cashier is gonna tell me "it's not that serious", I worked at multiple Taco Bell's I know what OLD FOOD looks like & I shouldn't be forced to buy it. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - The "1 hour" old pizza slice in question. - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

It's a quiet little hole in the wall type of restaurant. The pizza was pretty good. The fried chicken and the sweet potato fries were fresh and the prices are reasonable too. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - Pizza with mushrooms, onions, pepper - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

Today I had a lunch break at work and was suggested to try this spot since I'm not in a familiar area and boy was it a suggestion! Small inside, clean but small. Seemed like they have somewhat of a dining area too, but it wasn't open for use when I just walked in. This spot seemed like more of a takeout or order to go spot, but the food was super and the service was friendly. Not only was the menu huge and full of all different options from Italian to Greek and even Mexican food, all the plates that I ordered were truly really good. The spicy fries weren't actually spicy though, but they were flavorful. And flavor wasn't shy with both the Italian Sub and Gyro too, all very fresh and you could see them making your food behind the counter. I would love to go back and try more of their options on the menu because everything was seriously so good and hot when served! Super reasonably priced too. read more

See all

Tried it for the first time and it did not disappoint! Food was hot. Steak and cheese is huge and tasteful. Chicken Alfredo is well seasoned. Must try. read more

I supported this place buying pizza and subs throughout the early months of covid19. They typically serve great food and are a terrific neighborhood restaurant. Sadly, they really let us down Friday night. I ordered 3 items including a "small Italian sub with lite hots." In any of the pizza sub joints within a fifty mile radius you might see some variation but never would you see four slices of cold cuts on a roll with a few peppers. No oil, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onions...dry. Calling back the waitress was dismissive, and said they give you exactly what you order, no more. I asked to speak with the manager and at first she balked saying he was "fullfilling orders." He did come on, impatient and repeated same...also unapologetic (also dismissive), no offer to fix in anyway. When i told him i was sorry but i didnt think I'd be coming back he just hung up. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - Small italian, lite hots - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

Spinach and Mushroom Delight is spectacularly delicious. Love it! I haven't tried much else to be honest.

It is so sad that this is the only place that doesn't know how or what a Greek salad is. The first time I thought it was an error. So I ordered my second Greek salad from them and nope it was no error. This is the first time in my life that a Greek salad has carrots, purple cabbage, cherry tomatoes, and no feta cheese, to top it off a tiny cup of dressing. Great Pizza but man that Greek salad by no means looks Greek. Last time I will order from them. I'll just stick to Randolph Cafe!!! Last weekend we order a buffalo tender plate with fries and to be honest these looked like they had been refried after the tossed them in the buffalo sauce. All crispy it is sad great Pizza but that is it. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - Never seen a Greek salad look like this, then again I'm not Greek. - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

Order takeout about every 2-3 weeks, always tipping far more than expected. Last night, I was told it would be 45 minutes... ok. 1 1/2 hours later called cuz it's not the usual experience... I was falsely told, " oh! We're very busy tonight! It's just coming out of the oven." Nope!! It was delivered COLD & SOGGY meaning it was finished about 45 minutes before! Usually I would have called but if they cared, they would have been truthful, but I HATE being lied to! So disappointing since it's my guilty pleasure read more

I always order from here but this is my first time ordering this, not only was my drink forgotten and the hole in my bun which are fine they told us that this is a normal portion of fries in the special, 11 fries, is a normal portion read more

The Tomato and Cheese - 11 fries is a normal portion - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

See all

The food was very good. I have been getting food from here for years. The tacos are huge, but so greasy that they get the shells wet and they stick to their paper. That's the only thing I would change. Great individual deals. We usually get it to go, but we have sat in before and someone usually checks on you. Don't eat too much so you can get an ice cream cone next door! read more

Hello my yelpers , in deccember 2015 I purchased 2 cheeseburger baskets , upon my son eating his burger he found a medal wire in his burger. I called and they said sorry , wich I was grateful , manager told me he would take care of the burger next time I come in. I went in 1st week of February. ""Oh yeah , I remember you , all I can do is give you 10 % off of your next burger"" really ! I cancelled my order and. Said no thanks ! Tomatoes and metals . I'm totally serius. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

See all

Been a customer here since the last half of the 90s. Recently have been back a few times, as it's a favorite of my partner. The pizza is great, perfect cheese to sauce ratio. The salads are fresh and crisp. The staff is super friendly and professional. It's a little pizza shop, not a full service restaurant. They do it perfectly. read more

The Tomato and Cheese - Beautiful Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Randolph, Massachusetts

See all

Used to be a great place.... Just ordered a gyro and got a chicken pita instead somehow. I wouldn't mind so much if it wasn't so dry!

The people on naked and afraid wouldn't eat this food. First time back in a while due to zacks hours and randolph cafe being closed. Burned the Buffalo fingers and the pizza is just greasy and awful. Have a little pride t and c there are 12 year olds that can make a chicken finger. read more

The food is good but the girl behind the counter is atrocious- it's amazing how every single time I order she manages to screw up my order over the phone. It's honestly so consistent her screwing up my order it's almost comical. She also sounds half dead when she's answers the phone and shows no energy. Horrible front counter service. Thinking twice about this place and it's right in my neighborhood. read more

Pan Pizza - 3 choices: Pepperoni, Feta cheese, Spinach was the BOMB!!! Would have given 4 stars but it took over an hour to deliver the pizza to my house. read more

Clean place, polite people. Ordered 2 different slices: cheese and chicken Cheese was just ok, could have been better. Taste wise the chicken wasn't bad but the dough and crust was HARD. Probably made it that morning. Surprised I could bite into it. read more

This place was recommended to me very highly, especially for their steak and cheese subs. Unfortunately, both large subs had what appeared to be bones in them. I don't know if they ground their own steak; however, there were definitely chunks of what appeared to be bone in both subs. I got a calzone which was good. We ended up not even eating the rest of the subs because we were afraid we might break a tooth. read more

Tomato and Cheese is great for a cheap simple meal. Good Portions. Good food. Great price. Would totally recommend and return! ***** Time: Friday, June 15th from 4:30-5:30PM Venue: Very small diner, not many seats, plenty of easy parking. Clean. Service: The boy taking our order was patient and attentive. Food came out in 10-15 minutes. ***** Food: The food came out fresh and hot. The portions (for the price) were very generous and filling. * Pasta and meatballs: Giant plate with 5 medium meatballs; I liked the flavor and texture. Cheese baked on top, with 4 big pieces of garlic toast, not too salted. * Calzone with brocolli and chicken: MASSIVE. Cheesy and delicious. * Parmesan Chicken Sandwich: Huge. Chicken was too dry. * Garden Salad: Big. Cruncy, cold lettuce. Nice vinegrette. read more

The Tomato & Cheese Co is always a Go To spot for my local pizza. The Spinach and Mushroom Delight is my favorite pizza. Love it. You will not be disappointed. The workers are a bit immature and they could use an update behind the counter and kitchen area. A thorough scrubbing would hurt compared to other places I have visited. Whenever we order fries they aren't crispy when we get home. It's not that far of a drive. They put in a foam container and that's never good because foam hold moisture. All that being said, I'm still going to go and you should try it too. read more

This review is a few of weeks late and more about hygiene. On my visit, I noticed the delivery guy standing outside with the pizza delivery bags in hand, looking like he could've used a good hot shower, sweating and smoking a cigarette...GROSS! Then he proceeds to enter T&C, goes behind the counter with no mask, probably still exhaling cigarette smoke, GROSS! Also, the cook is over the grill cooking...she had her mask under her chin...really!!! If you're going to mandate customers wear a mask, then your employees should too! With that being said, the pizza was good. read more

I use to come here for years... I've been coming here since I was a kid. Tonight was the last straw. I ordered my usual every Friday 2 large pizza special. The delivery guy came with one pizza and said your right we owe you one. My order was 27.50 and I got one pizza. The "owner" said it was my fault for the way I ordered online. I explained I clicked re order on the same order I ordered every Friday for years. Basically the owner told me he will not honor it. I will call my credit card company and get my money back and they lost a lonnnnnnng time customer. If I wanted to pay 28$ for a pizza I would have went to Italy myself. read more

Always late order is almost wrong every time . today I called at 1030 and asked them to deliver it at 1140 it is now 100 and nothing if you order from here make sure it's a year in advance. read more

Foods great. We have been ordering from them for years, over the past year its all gone to craps. The food still tastse good, that is when they get the order right. I have given them multiple chances but if they get one thing right, they get something else wrong. The latest with message said "Allergy: No Cheese" guess what was all over the sandwich? Cheese.. Or the turkey sub with lettuce, tomato, mayo, even cheese but guess what was missing? The Turkey. So order at your own risk... read more

I've been ordering from Tomato & Cheese for months now and they have incredible food! Great selection and variety of meals, drinks, and sides! Additionally, I am always treated kindly by the staff and they have consistently made sure that I have a pleasant experience. I suggest trying one of their alfredo dinners. Their alfredo sauce is the awesome, homemade kind of alfredo sauce that won't leave you disappointed. Thank you for providing quality food and for being so friendly! read more

The worst delivery experience I've had in a long time. Maybe ever. First of all, they didn't deliver one of the two pizzas I ordered.The forgotten pie happened to a cheese one, for my toddler's dinner. The restaurant refused to come out and deliver again the forgotten pie. The other, buffalo chicken, was unfortunately too spicy for a two year old. Even if the buffalo chicken pie were appropriate for a two year old, I would never have fed this one to her. The top of the pie appeared as though someone spilled the bottle of generic, old blue cheese dressing atop it. Inedible. Also, delivery was late and cold. We had to eat something else. read more

I've ordered there for over a year, if there not late it's the wrong item. The more I talk about it the more I realize, I should take my business elsewhere.. read more

I was very excited about trying some good Mexican food and then very disappointed with my order. I got soft beef tacos with rice and beans and an order of nachos. The sides were cold; the nachos were awful, both cold and dry; the taco portions were generous but the salsa was more like a thick tomato paste. The prices were on the higher end so I truly was expecting a better dining experience. read more

Used to be so good, now service is awful. Been going for years , but the unresponsive staff has led me to decide to go elsewhere

I called in an order for my grandchildren. I asked for a chicken broccoli alfredo pizza, please don't dry it out because its for a baby. if it is dry he can't eat it. the pizza was dry and they would not fix it. He told me he don't fix things he don't see a problem with to find somewhere else to feed my grand children. I asked why he never want to fix his errors he said he does just not in this case I think that means if I was white or Italian it would have been fixed but because I'm black who am I to point out his errors. three times this has happened I will no longer do business there. his pocket is more important than customer satisfaction. He said he cook the same all the time and requests don't mater everyone gets ot his way or find somewhere else to go. read more

Ordered the cheeseburger and 2 slices of pizza.... I rarely give out 1 star, if I could've given it a -1 star I would've. This food tastes like shit...I take that back. I would have rather eaten human feces. The bread was hard, the burger was dry, the spicy fries had 0 spice, the pizza tasted like failure...literally if failure had a taste, this place would be a 5 star restaurant. It's like they got a big pot and poured mass amounts of failure into it and aaid "wallah". read more

The staff has never been very friendly, but the food used to be amazing and that made up for it. My household would order from here at least once a month. Lately though, it has gone way downhill. I recently ordered a BBQ chicken pizza that smelled as if it went bad. I dove in anyway, thinking it was just me, only to discover the thin crust was doughy and oily, and the BBQ sauce under the cheese was pink and had the flavor of burnt cleaning chemicals and dirty dishwater. Needless to say I won't be ordering from here again for fear of becoming sick. Really hate to have to find another pizza joint... Wish Town House of Pizza was still next to Tedeschi's. read more

Speaking in terms of just take-out, Tomato and Cheese dishes up some great Greek-style pizza. Prices are reasonable and they are always accurate with pick-up times when you place an order. The large pizzas are huge and will easily feed 3-4 people. Be warned, the pizza is extremely greasy. In our last Tomato and Cheese adventure, our large pepperoni pizza was drenched in grease and it was actually "bleeding" through the bottom of the box. Yuck. The salads are rather small, but the Greek dressing is delicious (although it's creamy). However, if you can get past the grease part (or you don't care, but it's best to at least warn your intestines), the pizza is pretty tasty. We don't go out of our way to Randolph for pizza, but when we are in town, it's a good deal. The best part of Tomato and Cheese pizza: still tastes great on day #2!! read more

I love order from there good pizza and hot dogs with french fries. I like their food. The staff work there are nice and cool. I don't have problem with them. read more

See all

I never had an issue with the worker or picking up an order but the last time I went in, the worker at the cashier was a bit rude and when I said I'm picking up an order, he says it's on the counter. The counter where people sit at to eat or wait for their food. Why would you put someone's order on that counter knowing someone can come in and touch it or grab the bag of food away when no one is looking. Why was it so hard to just leave the order behind the counter like it always has been done?? I thought that was just not the appropriate way of handling someone's order. I hesitate to order from here again. read more