Service was good. Got the Pegasus Special which was great. Their prices have gone up but you get plenty of toppings and cheese. Would not get the Shrimp Salad again as we both didn't feel well right after we left. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

I was headed to a seafood restaurant on this same strip. But while walking by and looking at others customers food I decided to try it out. I also love anything with a theme. I ordered a Cesar salad the Hercules pizza. My drink was called Aphrodite and it was delicious. I don't drink as much as I used to otherwise I have had two more. The server, Ralaina, was really nice. We did a half and half pizza and they put onions on my side so it kind of ruined the taste for me. Everything else was great. They played 80s music and we sat outside. I really enjoyed the experience. read more

See all

I went here to order a to go pizza and bought a chicken pesto 10 inch pizza. Pizza was amazing. No flop and nice crust. I usually a Neapolitan pizza guy, but this is amazing! The servers were friendly. I highly recommend people to pre order ahead so you don't need to wait inside. The waiting area is very small. Dining in is okay, but at 25% capacity due to covid restrictions. When things get to normal, this is a beautiful and cozy place to eat rain or shine. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Sorry, I was hungry lol. Had to eat half of the pie. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

We ordered 2 fettuccines with prawns. My husband specifically mentioned he wanted a Caesar salad. I mentioned I wanted the salmon chowder. Only one salmon chowder came out. Then the lady brought out one fettuccine prawn for my husband... with a spoon... 5 min later when she came back, I asked if my husband is going to get his salad and if I'm getting my fettuccine and she never even put the order in. She said oh ok I'll bring your salad out... What? I said I wanted a fettuccine with prawns 3x. She never listened. I can't with this place. This is the 4th time I came here where the service and food was just mediocre. I don't think I am going to come back here for awhile. The manager was kind enough to chime in. So I changed this review from 1 star to 3. I'm being generous. Me and my husband worked hard over the week and we wanted to enjoy our Friday evening on Alki beach. And this happens... I couldn't even eat with my own husband at the same time. What's the point of going on a dinner date? read more

See all

Great pasta, salads and dressings... usually good pizza but often get orders wrong and lately the amount of grease has really been a bit out of control... honestly though not sure if this makes it delicious or disgusting.... WillThe rose penne is amazing!!!!! The shredded pepperoni is as well! Honestly best ranch in Seattle... just that grease... woof... Still ate it all though.... read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Honestly not sure if this grease makes it delicious or horrible.... - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Pegasus on Alki has been a family tradition of ours for my entire life. I can't remember a time where we had visitors from out of the country/state come visit us where we did not come here. For me I love the nostalgia behind this place; the amazing food, and the views of the Sound. When I say that we have been coming here my entire life, I am really not exaggerating. We have spent decades coming here and have never had a bad experience. Most recently, I had the pleasure of having my entire immediate family together for Thanksgiving. We all agreed to have 1 full day of family time and without question, Pegasus was the first thing we all agreed on for lunch. We arrived a little after opening time - 11 am, and were immediately seated. Our server, Reuben, was a young guy who had a lot of spirit and his service was great! We really appreciated how social he was with us and never left our glasses go without being refilled. We are pretty consistent with what we order. We always order the Alki special - no onions, shredded pepperoni ON TOP, and lots of bleu cheese to dip. The Alki Special is great because it has spicy pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, yummmm. There is something magical about the bleu cheese here. I am somewhat of a self proclaimed bleu cheese connoisseur and this place has some of the best! We also ALWAYS order the feta bread. OMG this bread is LIFE. Perfectly warm, chewy, gooey feta bread. They recently remodeled, so they actually opened up the place a lot more. The bar is really cool and exposed, unlike how it used to be attached to the hostess station. They make great drinks and always have amazing local brews on tap. The best part is that after you finish stuffing your face with loads of amazing carbs, you can cross the street and either rent a Lime bike to roam around the beach or just stroll and admire the beauty that is the Seattle skyline. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Our tradition- Alki special, no onions, shredded pepperoni on top. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I almost feel that the person who is leaving 1star reviews is the same person because of the writing style. Total pet peave of mine so I'm leaving a review. And anyone knows that is what happens on Yelp, but I will say that pizza has cheese so there will be grease. Lol Anyway, I have been to Chicago, I have been to New York, I have been to Calabria and Naples Italy. I have eaten many styles of pizza and Pegasus is FIRE! Their food is fresh, their dough is perfect and they have a pizza on the menu for any palate. I give it 5 Stars because of the fact that their food is for all diversity of people and it's Bomb. Posting about an owner being on drugs or super greasy pizza is clearly arrogant and ignorant, because I met the owner when I dined there and on drugs was the last thing I thought and pizza can have cheese, so therefore there will be grease. I do think they could have a couple more salad dressings to choose from, but the friendliness, service, location setting and food were all a fantastic experience for me and my family. read more

We came for dinner. We had a very large salad (to share) and pepperoni pizza. Server was great Salad was great Pizza ...I personally wasn't a fan. Neither was my husband. I did t like the crust at all My 19 year old nephew liked it. read more

Fantastic local Alki Beach eatery that I've been dining at since the beginning when Tom opened it up. This is the place for summer time dining when your in West Seattle because you get the view of Alki and quality food. This menu has something for everyone but some of my highlights are Tom's Pizza, but ask for it with shaved pepperoni, it makes the pizza. White Spaghetti with chicken & mushrooms is THE BOMB and I cannot lie! This pasta dish if the perfect me. It's served with salad and garlic bread, but asked for the feta bread is so yummy! Now if you must get one item it's the THE GREEK SALAD, a treat of culinary bliss. I've never had a better salad than this and I eat a lot of salads. The perfect blend of feta cheese, Greek olives, onions, sunflower seeds and lettuce tossed together with secret sauce. Plus this salad is huge, enough for a party of 2 or 3 to split so you may want a half version of this delight if dining alone. Ambiance in the restaurant is casual and warm with excellent wait staff handling all your dining needs. Rain or shine you'll enjoy coming to Alki for some pizza pie. read more

See all

Update: They straight steal from you. We went on Sunday night, and ordered a draft beer and some pizza. Black Butte Porter on draft. And they popped it from a bottle and we watched the MANAGER VICTOR, agitate the beer to make it try and foam the last four ounces. After not being served even water for a whole 20 minutes, we asked if we can just get the pizza to go. When we arrived we gave card for the pizza, and cash to the ONE girl who bothered to help us. We crossed out cash tip. As some people who like the place, we called back to let Victor know we saw him messing with the beer. We didn't want anything free but that they should communicate that they no longer have that beer on draft. 4oz difference between a bottle and a draft, you gave us a 3/4 full beer and charged us full price. We just wanted to make sure this wasn't a regular thing. He said, "Yeah, the menu is a mess right now." And we understand how it can be to disappoint customers by telling them you don't have something you use to have. But you HAVE to be honest and communicate with the customer. MAJOR ISSUE: Charge came through today that they went ahead and wrote in their own credit tip. *remember we did give the good hostess a cash tip for RUNNING ALL AROUND trying to find us a server. Eventually serving us herself. We called a second time, left our number for Victor to call. And he hasn't gotten back to us. I'm really disappointed at this. We would like a full refund, we aren't sure we will be back despite the food. Service and staff disappoint. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Expensive but it's my favorite pizza in WSea. They load the pizza with toppings and offer a tasty, unique number of specialty pizzas. They also do g-f crust that my wife claims is much better than anyone else's. Pegasus offers more than pizza. I jus never get around to trying it. read more

Nice location, okay place. The pizza is alright, nothing special. We got a cheese for the kids, which had waaaaay too much cheese on it. And also a chicken pesto pizza (sans mushrooms), which was better. Sodas were $4-5 a pop, so watch out there! Pricey. The overall vibe in the restaurant was a little depressing, and needs updating. The waiters were very nice, just ours was not super attentive. Street parking. Nice views. read more

See all

Best pizza place in Seatown! I keep forgetting about this place because I don't frequent West Seattle nowadays as before. Each time I come in, I would for sure go for the greek salad. It is the best salad I have ever had in my life. The pizza is delicious. I can't remember how pricey they are because I have not been back for a long time. If you sit inside, make sure you grab a seat right next the window to enjoy the amazing view outside the window! It is good for individuals and large groups. read more

Went here years ago when I lived at Alki. Loved the place!!! Great greek salad, feta bread & tasty pies. Went here a few months ago and everything was the same. Wonderful!!! Picked up a salad and pie to go recently. Got the greek salad, dressing on the side, no green peppers. Enough dressing on the side for 4 salads. :) Got a Toms special no green peppers. Meat-tastic!!! Almost too much pepperoni for me but everyone else was cool with it. Used their online order process & unfortunately when we arrived at the restaurant to pick our order up they only had our salad & not the pizza. :( They were very apologetic & quickly made our pie. Offered a glass of wine while waiting. Nice!! read more

See all

I really enjoy coming here, it always reminds me of first dates, summertime, and nice long walks on the beach. Also, good pizza and cold beer. Dh & I usually get the Hercules. Scoring a groupon here is striking gold, so many more options to choose from with the option of carry out or dine in. Thanks for always having enjoyable service! read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Just floating around town on this chilly overcast August day in Seattle. Surprise, surprise. Heard they had an unusual warm sunny weather for 65 days. Knew that would change when I got here. LOL We're at Alki Beach. Great pricey homes, as always where water is involved. A lot o eating places are open for dinner only. So this was the most appealing today. Can also find Subways, burgers and fish and chips Ordered lunch special 2 slices with 2 toppings and a side salad for $10.75. Of course we wanted Spinach salad so that was a $5 upgrade Salad was fresh and excellent. Pizza was very good. Not thin crust, but very good. Topping were generous. Would definitely recommend. Also service was quick and friendly. read more

See all

Pizza place seemed real popular in the area, there was a huge line. We were a party of 6 with a kid so our wait was around 40mins, which was expected. Service was good, staff was friendly, our server was great (sorry didn't catch his name), he deserves a mention. We ordered a pizza and shrimp pasta and lobster ravioli. Pizza was good, thick crust and decent amount of toppings, bread was fluffy and not soggy at all, which is great. Shrimp Fettuccine was good too, pasta was perfectly done, their pesto sauce was rich and creamy. There were pine nuts as garnish which I didn't enjoy as much. Lobster Ravioli, wouldn't recommend. Ravioli was too dry, pasta on the edges was hard. Filling was decent amount of lobster but the ravioli didn't taste very fresh and it was dry. So this place looses points on ravioli quite a bit. Over all a good experience and decent place. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pesto Shrimp Fettuccine - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Tough call for the rating, because the pizza isn't too good, but the service was excellent and I loved the view The waitress quickly resolved all the minor issues we had was super nice about it. The pizza was ok, too gooey and generic tasting. I would have like something more oven fired for the beach vibe Overall ... great happy hour specials ... make this a beach front stop, and grab a seat facing the water and slight views of the Seattle piers and Space Needle read more

See all

Even bad pizza is generally still edible. The "Pegasus Special" pizza and the cheese bread I ordered on the night of Sun 6/21 was not. The ingredients tasted stale and rancid. I tried to eat more than a small slice and couldn't. Even had to brush my teeth after. Another attempt an hour later ended in the same result. I HATE speaking in absolutes but it was definitely the worst pizza I've had in Seattle. And I've been to plenty of the low-end pizza joints. Hoping it was a *really* off night for y'all because otherwise you're f*cked. read more

FURIOUS~ Bought a salad to go here and the little kids waiting on me put half a bottle of dressing on it, threw it in a bag and handed it to me. No fork, knife, no NAPKIN and a soaked brown bag bearing the worst liquid salad I have ever eaten. OMG just a nightmare! read more

Pretty good pizzas with a breathtaking view, especially during sunset! We had their #19 and #28. Loved their #19 since it had that perfect crumbly beef texture with a lot of flavors. #28 was pretty ok actually - not as good as I had expected. read more

The food and atmosphere are amazing. Some of the best pizza you will ever find. Well decorated interior. Good music. A great vibe. Anyone leaving a poor review is one of those people.... read more

Wow, just wow. I have eaten here many times over the years and this time I can't say enough about how good the experience was. Normally I order the meatball sub sandwich with a salad. But this time I ordered the soup which was beef barley and was stellar. Then the meatball sub which was totally prepared differently than before and was even better than ever. Instead of a hard roll and large meatballs smothered in tomato sauce, it was a large soft bun and thinly sliced meatballs in melted cheese and sauce in a cup. So it was like a French dip only different. Man it was tasty! My water glass never was empty and the waiter took great care of me and the other folks in the restaurant promptly. Thanks ! read more

THE AGLIO E OLIO IS YUM! i got it a day before i left for college and it makes me happy! the garlic bread was soft and underwhelming however....! would go here again! read more

I have been on Alki since 2016. As a "Chicago Guy" I know great pizza (if anyone from NYC wants to debate that - whatever). I am here to say, I am here almost weekly - just making it official! read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - They need to name this one, "Alki Johnny" It is a DANDY! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Pegasus Pizza is an Alki Beach staple! SO many reasons to love them: Amazing catering options, delicious pizza and pasta, plus they are a wonderful West Seattle family owned business who are alway active in the community. We love Pegasus Pizza! read more

I ate at this restaurant with friends who used to frequent it before they moved away. The pizza was awesome! It reminded me of pizza I enjoyed growing up in the province of Saskatchewan in Canada. I call them "hearty pies" with a solid crust, lots of topping and then cheese backed on top to hold everything together. It's not your typical Italian or NYC type pie. Different but so delicious . I'm definitely coming back even though it's a bit of a drive from where I live. read more

Pizza is really heavy on the cheese. Practically no sauce on it at all. A little dissatisfied based on the pictures I saw. Definitely needs to be dipped in some sauce. read more

The pizza was great the crust is amazing. Are always heard of Pegasus pizza, and I want to try it. I called them they delivered and it was fantastic! read more

Follow Pegasus On Instagram and their posts and stories always look SO Delicious, very disappointed. Came here on a Saturday night and got a seat right away in the bar. There was also many tables available in the non bar area. We got waters right away and were asked if we wanted drinks. after getting drinks we ordered our appetizers, cheese bread, with a side of marinara for $3.99, Mediterranean salad, and chicken wings. Sadly our chicken wings never came. We ordered the chicken chipotle pizza for dinner and the chicken pesto ravioli. The pizza tasted more like mushrooms than chipotle but loved the crust and the different cheese. The ravioli was amazing but both pizza and pasta weren't really hot? Overall their pictures look better than the actual food. Especially for a $70 dinner for 2 we expected something way better. Won't be back sadly. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - 28. Chipotle Pesto Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The signs and website say open at 11, it's a sunny Sunday not raining, and they have outdoor seating a plenty. However when we came in at 11:30 we were told we could not be seated outside. The inside and outside were both completely empty, no customers at all, possibly because they are not seating customers outside during a pandemic. read more

I will drive all the way to Alki from Kirkland for their pizza !!!! Food is always hot and fresh and great service.

OK Colin and Beatrice gave us excellent service this evening. We had to get my little boy a to go dinner and they provided us with a awesome kids meal. It really ended our a fantastic day in a fantastic way! read more

Placed my pre-order, it was accepted, then cancelled due to being unusually busy and cant fulfill the order. WTH. buh-bye

During our visit to Alki we ordered a couple gourmet pizzas to go. The service was amazing. The pizza was delicious. I highly recommend this authentic pizza restaurant. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Great wait staff. Greeted warmly when we arrived. A really nice setting - several TVs to view sports/news. Clean and relaxing dining experience. The Greek salad (half portion) easily fed 3 people. The medium Pegasus Pizza was plenty for 3 also. Enjoyed the view of Alki Ave. read more

See all

So, we stopped by because it looked like this place had great reviews and it would have been a perfect place to get in and out. We started with a round of drinks and my mimosa was flat and the tanginess of the orange juice was really upsetting. We decided not to order the food and checked out. When we walked past this place an hour or so later, it was packed, so obviously it's a good place... just not for me. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Super disappointing mimosa. It was flat and sour! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Would be nice if their phone staff was a little better informed. Call Alki location to ask about ordering from the SODO location. Was told they're open today and to just call them directly. Called "Fave Kitchen" spot, where Pegasus SODO is apparently operating out of, and was told Pegasus moved from there some time ago. Oh well. Interesting times indeed. read more

Staff was kinda weird, stand offish. Place was dirty, trash and food on floor, knife wasn't clean. Wasn't provided a menu by hostess and was told to scan code, which is fine, but the menu I saw online and the one from the code were different. I really wanted the veggie sub, but it wasn't even listed. The server finally showed up at our table and then provided us a paper menu, but I had already placed the order. Ended up getting a cheese pizza which imo wasn't very good- WAY too much cheese and it was so stringy it was hard to get it off the tray. Also ordered the artichoke spinach dip, needed a little something more for better flavor- kinda bland and strange crackers to eat it with. Some veggies- baby carrots, tomatoes? would have been a nice addition. Threw all of the leftovers away because we were traveling, would not eat here again. Music was cool- 80s rock mix. read more

When searching for vegan food on yelp. This location pops up. It's only a couple of blocks from my house so I wanted to give them a try. I understand most pizza dough is VEGAN. I always like to ask Incase there's egg or butter added (believe it or not. This is a thing). When I called I told the gentleman yelp suggested this place had vegan options, and I just wanted to make sure. He replies "We don't have vegan cheese that for sure". No problem there. I've ordered cheese less pizza in the past, and was ready to do it again based off the reviews of this place. So I ask the gentleman "what about your crust"? Instead of placing me on a brief hold to ask. He simply replied "That I don't know". So I wait for about 5 seconds to give him a second opportunity to ask. He didn't. So I had no choice but to tell him have a good day. This is not what I expected from a place with so many good reviews. read more