The best pizza in the northwest!!! Karl will take great care of you. Great happy hour with incredible views of the beach.

I completely understand mistakes, but 3 times now I've asked for no olives on my Greek salad, and every time it has olives. It's just annoying. Good food, but service is hit or miss. read more

Highly Recommend! Our favorite pizzeria in Seattle and the Greek style done right! The Manager Carl and wait staff are Amazing! On a robust and busy Saturday night, we received individual attention, excellent service and made us comfortable during a short wait. We will definitely be coming back to our favorite pizza place! Also, the food is amazing, fresh, hot, and with very hearty portions! read more

We came here tonight (9/23/18) for my sister's birthday dinner. Understandably because we were a big group there would be some hiccups. We'll it started with slow service. Then she forgets one of the kids ravioli dinners so my niece has to watch her cousins eat while hers still has to he made. The waitress already knew she was going to have trouble splitting the check up, so she has to ask again what everyone's order is, like she didn't write it down when we ordered or something. We'll she brings back the 4 checks and two are completely wrong. Mind you she had already asked us a second time our orders and wrote it down a second time. It's getting late, kids need to go to bed, she was supposedly trying to fix our check. She comes out thinking her "manager" had handled it but all he did was ask what the problem was and not try to fix anything. He did absolutely nothing to help this poor girl who is struggling big time. We're damn near out the door, our whole party is leaving at this point so we pay at the front cashier. The waitress whips up a new check just like that. So why did she have issues in the back? Well I pay even with the "gratuity" for a large group, attached to check. Mr Manager nowhere to be seen, no apology, nothing. Well I won't be back ever. I will not recommend anyone eat there neither. The foods good don't get me wrong. It's the service/management that stinks. I always give businesses a chance but they did not help their cause at all. read more

The service sucks, waited for 2 hours for one small pizza, because some waiter messed up my order.... gave me only a 10% discounts for the inconvenience, place sucks. And found a mushroom in my water read more

The pizza is great here plus a fantastic view the only draw back is that service is slow! Im not sure if they didn't have enough staff. One waiter was handling 5 tables. But you can't go wrong with their caesar salad and Tom's pizza! Yummy!! read more

Got a pizza to go today and it was great! My dad doesn't usually like pizza, and he loved it from this place. I really like the sunflower seeds, a unique addition to pizza and also very tasty. The price was a little on the high side, but good for the size and quality, I think. Although the large wasn't as big as it is in some places, it was very thick and packed with yummy ingredients that went well together. My whole family is really picky about food, but we all enjoyed it and felt good and full after finishing. read more

We went here after I'd heard one of my co-workers say this was the best pizza they've ever had. My reviews are usually pretty wordy but there's not terribly much to say here. We happened to go on a day when the sun was shining and we went on a whim so there was a wait. No problem, we just watched all the human oddities cruise by. The staff was friendly but not overly so which suited us just fine and they put us in the corner table outside which was great. We ordered the Greek. It came relatively quickly and it was a solid pizza. The sauce wasn't overly sweet or salty. The toppings meshed and the crust wasn't too doughy or too crisp. Still, nothing caught on fire for us. It was just good eats on a sunny Alki day after a long beautiful hike. Nothing stellar to mention but definitely no complaints. Solid! read more

Great views and good service. The pizza was awful. Probably the worst pizza I've ever had. We were really disappointed because the pizzas look so good when walking past. We got the Veggie pizza (one of the very few meatless pizzas) and it had absolutely no flavor. It was like they dumped a horrible salad onto a pizza. Barely any sauce or cheese on the whole thing. I don't think I'd ever come back for pizza, but maybe for a beer and to take in the views. read more

Decent pizza spot on Alki beach. Went with a large group on a Saturday night. It was not very crowded so they easily were able to accommodate a large group. They were really slow with the drinks and refills. Ordered an Alki special pizza which really hit the spot. Nothing fancy, but delicious. Friends ordered the Greek, which looked quite good as well. I would return. read more

Best pizza in the seattle area. or in the states cause the hercules has the perfect amount of meat and cheese. i come here every time i have a reason to celebrate. read more

Pegasus replied, fixed the issue, provided a gift certificate and worked on making this right. I'm pleased to see that the managers are thinking about front desk hospitality. read more

Great Alki location! We had the Canadian Bacon & Pineapple split with a Veggie pizza along with shrimp salad as an appetizer. Great food, good service....they even helped me retrieve my ball cap that I left behind! read more

Not the warmest of greetings. We weren't sure if we seated ourselves or not. No appetizers but the waitress was nice and explained different ways that things COULD be appetizers which i can appreciate. Happy hour was a BUST (1$ off beer/$2 off wine on a saturday at 5:00). I Didnt see anything else I wanted So we left before ordering. read more

The food was great. I had lobster ravioli which came with garlic bread and salad. The only reason why I don't give them 5 stars is because my waitress was very annoying and was rushing me and my friend to order. At some point I thought they were about to close (which was not the case) because every 3 minutes she came to our table to ask if we were ready to order. I'm definitely coming back just hoping for a different waitress. read more

I live in the neighborhood so I frequent the restaurants and shops on Alki all year long. Pegasus always has generous portions, tasty food, and decent service. Most of the time I'm picking up the Super Sub and Caesar salad to take home and it is delicious! read more

This is the best pizza I have had in years. Service was pleasant and fast. The crust was light with hat classic yeast flavor. Toppings were plentiful and good. We had sausage pepperoni and onions. Two of could barely finish a size small it was so big. Sat at outside table in front and watched the sun go down. read more

Have been here 3 times and will keep coming back. Great place, awesome pizza. Recommend to everyone! Best pizza I've had in Seattle.

OK pizza sauce and food. Nice location for summer. Prices too high for what you get. $13 for a small pizza. No thin crust pizza, just thick. Probably won't go back. read more

They have a really nice gourmet pizza lineup. Try the hurcules if your a meat pizza lover like me. The crust is wonderful as well. I've always got it to go and its usually ready in 15 read more

Great Ravioli, just near the beach, great service and guess what?? Prime card - great discount - good bill :)

The best pizza in town. The crust is always perfect, and they are never shy with the meat toppings. Pizza always takes a while to make it to the table, but the staff here always makes sure that you are well stocked with beverages which makes the wait much better. The only downside is the plethora of children tearing around this place. It seems like parents think that it's a day care or play ground where they can tune out and let their kids run wild. Shame on the parents. The pizza's worth the irritation, though. We just drink enough beer and wine which helps us tune out the kids much like their parents do. read more

The delicious smell wafting through the air is what drew us in. The marinara sauce in the meatballs appetizer was perfect. The slightly spicy meatballs were pretty awesome too. Then, the pizza...(sigh) WAS ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. Therefore, SUPERB is the only word to describe it. :-) read more

Took my dad here last October when he was visiting from out of town, he couldn't get over how great the pizza was--and he's picky about his pizza! Thanks for making a great impression read more

Pleasantly surprised at the excellent service. Our server was completely professional, attentive, laughed at our stupid jokes, accommodated our requests for extra plates, napkins, red sauce, split this, put that on the side, get more beers, box it to go ... All of that. It was also really nice to be offered drinks while we waited for our table and I appreciated how swiftly our orders came out. read more

AWESOME pizza!! Better than Zeeks but I'm sorry, not up to Via Tribunali status. The location is prime. Nothing beats a beautiful day on Alki. They have awesome outside seating where I have enjoyed a cold drink and some great pizza here. I'd recommend it to all friends and family. read more

The Pizza was great and the service was phenomenal. I am an idiot and started a 30 day vegan diet recently but they were so friendly and accommodating at Pegasus. I ordered my pizza sans cheese, blasphemy- I know, but it was still delicious with their sweet and balanced marinara sauce and fluffy chewy crust. A topping of freshly topped spinach was the perfect mask to hide my diet woes. My friend's meaty pizza looked pretty amazing and the bacon was seriously super thick and perfectly crisped. We also both had great salads and delicious cocktails. All while enjoying the beautiful Seattle sunset in the outdoor seating area. Our server was a young gentleman and was very friendly and attentive. Always there when we needed something and never there hovering over our table. I really like that the location is closer to the end of the Alki strip since it meant less noise during the peak summer hours and still enjoy all of the great people watching in that part of town. read more

Excellent service and pizza. I think Pegasus is one of the best pizza places in Seattle.

I love this place!!! Everyone here is amazing! I grew up in west Seattle and this place is close to my heart. Tonight I had an fantastic time, my server was wonderful, met the GM and she was unbelievably great! Come down to the shore and enjoy some great pizza! I did! read more

Good pizza, salad and good local beers! The location is all the way inland of Alki but the beach is right across the street. Service can be slow during busy hours. They do take reservations and can accommodate couple larger groups. Small groups sitting by the window is best. read more

Love the beautiful new bar, definitely a welcome addition to the Alki neighborhood!! Not only do they have a great wine and cheese selection but the new cocktail menu is amazing as well. Looking forward to working my way threw the wine list this fall!! read more

Fantastic new bar! We ordered the Italian salami and pepperoni pizza and it was amazing. Great place for drinks and food. Super cocktails and a very nice selection of beers on tap! read more

The new bar is amazing, service was impeccable, truly a West Seattle gem! I live in Alki and must say it's hard to go to other places

The amazing irish bartender Karl. Is absolutely amazing. Make awesome cocktails and hands down the best service on Alki beach. We will be back.. read more

I went there with friends and it was good experience but not exceptional. Average service. Even though, in particular our table server was very nice and commited. Good localization, just near to the beach. Outdoor seating available, excellent for summer. read more

I have to say, I'm not a huge Pegasus fan. I feel like its too pricey for Pizza Hut quality pizza. I do like the view, and the service has almost always been fast, but I was disappointed for the quality. read more

Nice place, nice view, great food, fair price

I always liked coming here but now I probably won't even go back because 1) they told us 5-10 minutes wait but turned out to be 45 minutes 2) when I went to asked nicely how long more of a wait the waitress basically cut me off and was rude and told me "he's taking you now!!!"...it sounded more rude in person. Food is also over rated.... read more

I took my brother and his wife there today. I couldn't believe how bad it was! I felt totally ripped off and embarrassed. The pizza was one half mushroom,half pepperoni. It was practically flavorless. The best part was the crust. The pizzas are small. I really can't understand what all the great reviews are about. A good pizza should be able to stand up even if it's plain cheese. I would never recommend this place. It is nice being on Alki though. read more

If I get put on Death Row for whatever reason and I have a request for a last meal, the pizza and drinks from this place might actually be in my top 10! My friend and I have been here a few times now, and every single time has been an exceptional experience! The Wait: When it's happy hour and the place isn't packed or when it's really busy on beautiful sunny days, we still get a seat in less than 5 minutes. On top of that, the wait staff get you everything you need and want very quickly. The Food: The pizza is SO good, I feel like I have to smoke a cigarette afterward or something. I like the different options and variety of different pizzas. My friend and I always get a half pepperoni and half chipotle chicken pizza. And I must not forget about their Alki Hurricane. It's the perfect drink when you're chillin on the beach after a brutal day at work. The People: Every time we're here, the wait staff has always been super friendly. I think her name is Kate or Katie or something like that... well anyway, she served us our first time here and she was very sweet, joking around with us like she was part of the crew! We loved her, and I think she deserves a raise... *hint hint, wink wink* read more