I stopped in for a quick meal, before work. I asked how long would it be, and the gentleman behind the counter said maybe 20 mins!! He was right! My order came fast! I ordered chicken franchise with a side of spaghetti. It was excellent. They served warm bread and butter! Great service, read more

See all

I've been going to Pelham Pizza since 1978 when I got my drivers license. The pizza is superb. The staff enjoy working there and treat the customers very friendly. I've had everything on the menu and never had a bad experience. I lived in Pelham Manor most of my adult life. My wife and twin sons absolutely love Pelham Pizza. We moved to CT in 2020 and drive down to Pelham Pizza twice a month for dinner. Westchester County has several outstanding pizzerias. Lately I've been getting the sausage and pepper pizza roll with extra mozzarella cheese. Pelham makes it perfect. My wife and I are Italian and the majority of the staff is Italian. It's like eating with family. I'm 63 now and have been coming here since I was 18. read more

Real classic Italian old school pizzeria. Excellent service . Great selection. Love this place

The workers at the front touch any and everything besides the food and then go touch pizza. They never wash their hands. This is purely unsanitary. read more

A walk into Pelham Pizza is like a walk into a favorite pizza spot growing up in Brooklyn. Great guys behind the counter goes with some super slices with also great variety. The crust is crisp like it should be and not that limp soft slice you seem to get too often. Bravo! read more

Came here for NY style pizza. They didn't have a meat lovers(maybe that's not a NY thing?), but were very helpful and accommodating with what they did have. The pepperoni sausage was delicious. I like that it was large pieces of sausage. The sauce has a very unique taste. I get vibes of fresh tomato, a slight bitterness, garlic, and more. Also tried the spinach pizza. Lots of spinach, good flavor, a bit cheesy for me but overall well balanced. I liked it and would definitely come back. The place looks clean. Food was ready on time. read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Local pizzeria serving by the slice, delicious pizza and friendly people. Great place to eat during lunch and amazing vibes.

Good pizza with fast service. This is our go-to pizza place in Pelham. It's nothing fancy, but it certainly is quick (at least usually), and the food is good enough. Gotta say, I was happy to see that most people seemed to be wearing masks, at least out front, but one guy spent the whole time with his mask around his chin (and when needled about it by a customer, basically said that he thought that Covid was a conspiracy). These guys deal with food, so you'd hope that public health would be top of mind for them. I'm deducting one star for that. read more

Staff are a bunch of great people, amazing pizza, classic pizza place vibe. Been eating here my entire live - love this place.

The pizza is really good. The crust does not disappoint, nice and crunchy. Most of all this place reminds me of family. Everyone that walks in knows each other and know all the guys working. They are friendly and great. It's loud and very Italian. If you go on a Friday or the weekend, be prepared for a line. Totally worth it! read more

Food is ok! Service was excellent and the ambiance was cool!! I will go again but I like thin slices.

I don't normally eat pizza but today I decided to try this place out with my son and I was blown away by how delicious their pizzas are! I haven't had good, quality pizza like this in a very long time! After today, I will be coming back. This is now my go to spot for pizza! read more

Hands down, these guys are the GOLD STANDARD of pizza in South Westchester. Without a doubt! Regulars & Sicilians are delicious, specialty slices are unreal (eggplant & fra diavolo slices are my personal picks) rolls and heroes are STACKED & the kitchen food is equally tasty & plentiful. Take it from me: a guinny born & raised in Queens that worked at 8 different pizzerias in Qnz/BK doing everything you can think of from cook to delivery boy... these guys can hang with the big dogs in NY. Give'm a try. You'll be ecstatic you did. read more

It's ok decent pizza. Which is ok considering NY has a pizzeria every where you look. It's a neighborhood go to, the Pizza was ok, nothing to write home about. The place is cash only, super local loyal customers frequent the place, you go to the counter someone asks what you want, there could be someone next to you and you have to pretend like you know the protocol because you're new. There's an older lady who was working there kept giving me an evil eye lol. It was strange. But all in all ok pizza. read more

Going there for a quick slice of pizza is good and convenient, but when it comes to special orders they dont like it. I asked for a chicken parm hero on garlic bread and with vodka sauce instead of marinara and they wouldn't do it. I even offered to pay extra and he still said no. I was quite disappointed when he insisted to tell me you know because it wasn't like I was asking them to substitute it for free, other pizza places have no issues with doing the substitution. I will keep coming here for the pizza, but as for everything else I will go somewhere else. read more

I always visit Pelham Pizza when returning to NY. Great food and great staff. They have mastered the art of cooking eggplant, a veggie that many struggle with. Their eggplant rollatini is my gold standard for eggplant rollatini. Thinly sliced, light batter, cooked perfectly with a delicious creamy ricotta filling. Their tomato sauce is great. Pefectly seasoned and rich. Their egglplant pizza slice is also my gold standard. Big, not too thick, perfectly fried slices of eggplant cover almost the entire slice. An absolutley incredible slice. Other favorites include the spinach slice and the tomato slice. Both are great with good fresh veggies and a nice garlic flavor compliment. The chicken picata is also a favorite. Come summer time, don't forget to cap off the meal with an Italian Ice! read more

See all

I love Pelham Pizza!! The food is great and the people are great :) would definitely recommend

Omg.... simply the best tasting pizza in Westchester County. My #1 favorite is the chicken parm pizza. Just remember to bring cash with you. They do not accept credit cards. If you happen to be without cash, the shop has an ATM or you can go to the Chase Bank down the street. Give their pizza a taste. You will not be disappointed. read more

So good! Glad I stopped by here. The service was good and speedy. The place was packed but we were seated immediately and our food arrived within minutes. The soup and salad (and bread!) were all amazing - I ordered the house salad and chicken vegetable soup. I would definitely come back! read more

See all

Has the most solid pies in Westchester. They are consistently exceeded expectations. Getting the veggie pie, it's never soggy.

What a great little spot for a quick slice. The pizza was fresh and the staff were pleasing. Coming from North Carolina and being used to souther hospitality, I felt right at home. I enjoyed a slice of cheese and a slice of sausage. Seating was plentiful, parking was metered (0.25 cents per 20 minutes) and the adjacent businesses offer plenty of browsing to walk off the calories. Id definitely come back to enjoy some of their other menu options. Only suggestion I would make is to have a better system of collecting glass bottles instead of allowing them to collect on top of the trash can. While I was there, a guy knocked over the bottles and shattered a few on the ground while trying to dispose of his waste. Overall, AWESOME! read more

Every time we are in the area, not only do we make the effort to grab a slice? But we take multiple chicken rolls, throw them in a ziplock and bring them on the plane to pop in the freezer when we get home (or eat mid-flight). Absolutely delicious. I actually added it to my "Last Meal" list on Yelp, because it was truly the first thing that popped into my head. The staff is incredibly friendly and always make you feel like they remember the last time you were in (which in our case is impossible since we are only in once or twice a year). Perfect pizza. P.S. Want to eat outside? There's a nice little park across the street and up the block to sit and eat on a sunny day! read more

Great pizza, probably the best on that whole strip. They have a great showcase of pizza and everything seems tasty and fresh. The people that work there are very friendly. I have also sat down and ate dinner there on a few occasions. Sometimes it is hard to get a table. It's usually always busy in there unless you go once they first open, or right before they close. I've tried many of their different pizzas and all were great. They make a great regular slice, which is very important for a pizzeria, for obvious reasons. I hate going to a pizzeria and they can't make a decent regular slice. On the few occasions that I've sat down and had dinner I have enjoyed their Chicken Francese. On two separate occasions I tried their Chicken Sorrentino. Both times I've had it were disappointing. The first time i figured maybe my taste buds were off, but the second time i realized that it's not me, it's the dish. I do not recommend the Chicken Sorrentino. However, i do like that with their dinner entrees they give you nice hot bread, a salad and a side. You definitely get your money's worth. Two things I don't like: cash only! And no fountain machine. I hate bottled soda and canned soda. Moreover, this place is a bit outdated but that's ok .. they don't pretend to be a fancy pizza joint anyway, and for the most part they keep the place clean and well stocked. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed! read more

Best pizza around! The picture of the slice is taken when I sat in and dined and the pizza never disappoints! The other picture is from the first time I ordered grub hub. The portions are huge and the food is delicious! I will definitely be ordering again from the app. I have been a long time costumer and have enjoyed Pelham Pizza for a long time! They are constantly consistent and the pizza has been great for as long as I can remember! No wonder there are costumers that have been coming in for over 40 years. Would recommend to anyone who wants mouth watering food and family like service. read more

Pelham Pizza - Sausage with Broccoli Rabe (side salad) Veal Amore (side pasta) Fried Zucchini - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

Ordered a pepperoni pie to go. There was traffic so I was worried that the pie would be soggy by the time I got home about 15-20 min later. Oh no. It was not soggy. It was great. I would marry this pizza, but we ate it all. read more

do not recommend, waiter Christina was extremely rude, she thought my child was cute and touch his knee. I thanked her and asked her to please not touch my child. State is literally under a state of emergency due to Monkeypox. She was bothered by the fact got extremely nasty and roller her eyes. when I went to go speak to the owner he literally cut me off midsentence to do something else. As I'm in the counter trying to speak the owner, Christina says I feel bad for her kids. When you come to New York you expect New York Pizza this is not the place. Pizza was mediocre, table was dirty I had to clean it myself with a wipe. read more

Great pizza. NY slice is good but Sicilian is the real winner here. Slices are on the smaller side. Lots of local regulars that are on a first name basis with the guys behind the counter so you know the food is good. Cash only as is with most good pizza joints. Definitely as good as the reviews but maybe not the best slice in the Bronx. read more

See all

They are the worst when I first went there they were good then where I go to the adult daycare I got them some business well they was very rude, they forgot some food, someone ordered shrimp scampi over linguine they never bought the pasta. Also I ordered it angel here with the vodka sauce and meatballs the meatballs tasted like wet sponge in the vodka sauce if it wasn't for salt I would've had to throw it in the garbage. Also we ordered again today they still forgot items so John I believe the manager of a family member told us his boss no longer wants to do business with us but he said with you people that is a racist comment and we paid good tips and we spent lots of money they're very races in Pelham Black people do not do business with them read more

This is my favorite neighborhood pizzeria and I have been coming here since before I could see over the counter. The sauce and quality of the cheese is phenomenal. They have great specialty slices and calzones BUT I like a plain pie with thin crust!! Since I've been more healthy they've been doing a great spinach with garlic sauteed in olive oil. read more

I have eaten here at Pelham pizzeria at least 6 times first time reviewing it but must say each and every time that I've come here ,I don't have one complaint about it first time I came I had a slice of pizza since I was hungry and had to go the second time I came I came with my wife and kids we had a small pie and a chicken parmesan for me and my son my wife had the grilled chicken salad and once again I must say everything was great I mean if you mess up on pizza then you really should be a restaurant a plus for this place read more

Pelham Pizza - Good old fashioned pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Fabulous spot....went with eggplant parm and spaghetti side and it was outstanding. Had some of my wife's pizza and it too was amazing. Could not go wrong here. Only thing I would suggest they lose are the paper cups. Very nice people and service was outstanding! Huge portions! read more

See all

On my constant quest to find great pizza here in Westchester I've tried many places more than once to find the best one and I've tried pelham pizza multiple times since I work so close to here this is the pizzeria that we always seem to order from due to some of my co workers swearing by it. I've had plain, spinach, margarita, chicken parm, slices and I'll be honest it's just average, the sauce is good but the slices are way too doughy, I've heard people say it and I agree, I can eat 2 slices here and I'm full but still not satisfied if you know what I mean. Because we order this at work I've had it a lot but most times I end up turning it down because if I'm going to use my calories on pizza I might as well get something I really like. We've also ordered some of their dishes which are better, penne ala vodka, chicken francese and chicken marsala were all good but the pizza is just ok. read more

Great pizza and friendly service at affordable prices. Place is no-frills but that just underscores the good experience. This is our go-to pizza place when we are in the area. read more

Happened to find this little gem late night through yelp. Just wanting to grab something quick. I yelp "pizza" I'm 8 minutes away from Pelham Pizza, so I give it a shot. The pizza is thin NY style, loved it, and the crust was amazing. I really wanted a spinach slice, but the guy before me had just ordered the last one..just my luck! I ordered a regular slice and a Sicilian. I get in the car and while I'm driving I can just smell that amazing aroma, I can't wait. I open the box and the pizza looks dismal, my heartbreaks, but low and behold...I bite in and, it's spectacular. I wish I would have seasoned it with a little oregano, garlic, and red pepper flakes before I left the restaurant. This pizza is top notch. The only reason it isn't five star is because when I bit into my regular slice I could taste all of the garlic from what was probably a "garlic slice" also when I bit into my crust I could taste pepperoni...I know this often happens in NY pizza shops still doesn't make it right. Also, they take card, but I never received a receipt. I didn't want a receipt to be petty I actually wanted it so I could tip (I didn't have a cash). I will definitely return, looking forward to trying new things here! read more

I have been coming to this Pizza joint since I was 5 years old. I have never had a better slice in my life. Now, I consider myself an objective man of taste. I remember the first time I had sushi at 9 years old and loved it, only to realize it was trash 20 years later when I got fresh Sashimi in Tokyo's fish market. I realize now how greasy and horrible my favorite Chinese Take-Out was and how getting it every week in my teenage years was a HUGE mistake. But I've had pizza from every joint in Pelham, in the heart of Manhattan, up and down the East & West coast of our great nation, and even across the Atlantic Ocean in both Florence & Rome. My friends, I have never had a better slice. They make a good cheese slice. You know the kind. The one that gets the balance of cheese, sauce, and dough perfectly. The kind with those fresh ingredients cooked on a slice that's just thick enough. It's baked in an oven hot enough to keep the sauce moist but also have that satisfying crunch when you bite into the crust from underneath. But their slices with the toppings though. That's where things get crazy. The fresh ingredients used for the toppings are heaped on in helpings big enough to fill your belly but shop short of being gratuitous. You will NOT leave this establishment hungry. But you'll also not leave this place feeling like you just finished up some gratuitous, greasy burger challenge (there's chains for that in the next town over). And the toppings they use are top notch. Italian Sausage, tomato with extra mozzarella slices, chicken parm, spinach Alfredo... there's just so many that offer those authentic Italian flavors. My favorite pizza is the Eggplant parm, but that's just me. They're all fantastic. If they're serving dinner you can ask for a menu and sit down for table service. You can order wine with other more intimate, knife and fork oriented dishes. I've done this with my family many times but (to be honest) I couldn't tell you how any of the other dishes are. The fam always said everything they ever ate was delicious but I've never ordered anything else here other than the pizza. ...Oh wait that's not true. I just remembered that I got the escarole and beans here once 7 years ago and it was amazing. Never mind. Anyway, do yourself a favor. Don't settle for Villaggio on the other end of main street, with it's over-sized restaurant side that segregates the pizza from the wine / dinner dishes. Don't do delivery from one of the greasy corner shops in town just because they'll bring it to your doorstep. And for goodness sake, DON'T do Digiorno! You owe it to yourself to drive downtown and get the real deal. You owe it to yourself to have the greatest slice you'll ever have in your life. read more

Best pizza in the Pelham/New Rochelle area! Staff is friendly and loves to joke around. Feels like family every time I walk in. Pizza so good you might need to wait for a table and the lines go out the door. When they have it, I love their version of the salad pizza. read more

I love there meatball wedges. Reminds me of the subs back in the day.There white pizza slice is delicious

We called and ordered three pizzas one white Pizza ( half Spinach), 1 pizza ( half with vegetables), and 1pizza ( half sausages and pepperoni) l. I went over the order with the take-out person before hanging up. The Pizzas we're ready in time for pick up. However, they added an extra plain pizza and charged us for it. The pizzas were delicious, but we were annoyed that they said a pizza. Of course, we could have refused the pizza, so the fault is ours. I suggest that you take extra care in ordering from them! read more

Normally I love pelham pizza, practically grew up there.But today I was a bit disappointed. Not only was one of the dinners not in the bag, and theres no delivery, so we had to run back. There was a little friend to great me in my dinner.... Facial hair is a no go in a kitchen... read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

Pelham Pizza has been a life long home for me, literally, I have been eating here for more than 30 years and I am barley older than that. You will always get friendly service and great food here. The pizza is classic New York style, and their menu is really great for a pizzeria, I recommend all of the soups especially the minestrone and the pastas are all very good. Please visit this place and support a classic Pelham institution! read more