Lets be real for a few minutes you probably go here because they are your friends im speaking to the locals i myself have been going here since a kid but the reality is that they fell off big time and there pizza is border line garbage. They messed up my order served me pork when i asked for a chicken roll i call and the guy literally answers the phone like so what you want me to do about it. He didnt care whatsoever that they messed up they feel comfterable because they rely on there friendship instead of there quality of food thats why marcellos pizza is starting to take over they serve the best wood fire pizza i have ever tasted so either go to your friends and get crap pizza or go to marcellos and get the best pizza in your life dont take my word for it go see for yourself read more

Pizza crust was excellent, and a large is a good size, but sauce was under-seasoned and bland. It's also cash only, has limited street parking, uses paper plates and cups, had sticky laminate booths, was bothered by a couple of fruit flies, makes Caesar salad without Parmesan cheese with uninspired dressing, and had slightly burnt garlic bread. The strange music choice was also drowned out by the TV, and I didn't understand why both were on at the same volume. In terms of service, It was not great with only one teenage server whose heart was certainly not all that into his part-time career choice. People stood patiently unacknowledged for far too long at the counter for pick up orders and to be seated. It also seemed that cash was handled by the same people that served the food and made the pizzas out front. I went on a Sunday for lunch because of the good Yelp review but was disappointed. I'm not really all that picky, just observant of these fixable shortcomings. read more

The pizza was very good with reasonable pricing. Expected nothing less, I've heard nothing but positive reviews.

I ordered through grub hub. The pizza did not taste like it was from Pelham Pizza. I guess this is a dine-in only place. The Cesar sale I ordered had no cheese. Won't order delivery again. read more

My wife and I stop in and have a nice dinner. She orders shrimp francese and I order chicken parm with a side of linguine garlic and oil. We had this four times!!! Why? It's good!! The service is nice and friendly and you feel like family. If your looking for a nice meal without the glitz come enjoy a real meal here!!! The pizza is excellent as well!! read more

Didn't order from them but I called and wanted to get $200 worth of pizza delivered. They don't deliver, even though it says they do on here. I told the guy that on Yelp it says they deliver, more for just letting him know more than anything. He didn't say anything but he hung up on me right away. Fabulous. read more

Great pizza off Taconic parkway. Convenient location - delicious pizza - quaint village!

I actually kinda hate to review this place because I think if the secret ever got out about how good their pizza is it'll get swamped like a trendy new york nightclub. Aside from their Calzones I really only come here for either of two pizzas, the lasagna pizza or the eggplant pizza. Both are really entire meals in themselves with the lasagna thick and full of tasty sauce and ricotto and the eggplant pizza heaped thick with sliced of incredibly tasty fried eggplant. Trust me I've had pizza from every borough in NY from famous places like Lombardi's to little corner pizzerias in the middle of bensonhurst over the course of my 30 years on this Earth but I love Pelham's pizza the most. When I have friends visiting I always tell them that I'm gonna bring them to the best pizza in the world and they're always skeptical but after their first few bites there is no more doubt. read more

Pelham Pizza never disappoints. Whether you eat in, which of course we cannot at the moment or call in and pick up, the food is great and the staff is amazing. I ordered a pie today and the gentlemen I spoke to offered to bring it out to me. Way to keep us safe and well fed Pelham Pizza. read more

We have gone here for dinner three times since moving to town...last week. It's that delicious. I love the eggplant pizza. My dream come true! I wish they delivered. That's the only downside. Although I can picture driving over to pick up food during the winter. The reason I give them 4/5 stars is that the crust is so hard it's difficult to eat. You know, the top part where there's no sauce to soften it up. So that makes me sad but I enjoy the entire slice up to that point! read more

Probably the best Pizza in Pelham, but I wouldn't say it is the best pizza. However, they have a great grilled chicken ceasar salad and a strachiatelli (no idea how to spell it) soup. the grilled chicken is always so tasty, and the 'ceasar' dressing is more of a creamyish italian, but it is so good. the soup is a spinach egg drop with parm cheese. oh- and lets not forget, in the summer (i really think it should be all year long) the italian ices!!!!! great family place. read more

Curveball. I was up in Mamaroneck for March of Dimes and wanted to catch a quick slice on my way back to Astoria. Pelham Pizza got monster ratings on Yelp (4.5 stars), so it seemed like a no brain-er to hop off the Hutch and check this place out. If 1 star is the dollar slice at 2 Bros Pizza, then 5 stars should be kept for the likes of DiFara's, Lucali, Grimaldi's - the top dogs. To give a standard NY pizza parlor 4.5 stars is throwing a curve into this great system we have here. The pizza is solid. I had a regular slice and the eggplant parm slice. The ingredients were good - they use real cheese. Crust and dough were fine. Sauce is not too sweet. The guys working there seemed nice enough. Photos of local kids' soccer and baseball leagues adorn the walls. I'm sure that generates a lot of business, and it's nice that they're supporting the community. I would come back if I was on the block, but not worth a stop off the highway. read more

It's a true testament to a restaurant's staying power when, despite almost always having long lines, not doing delivery AND being cash only, it is consistently packed. Such is the case with Pelham Pizza. The guys are great, each with a bigger personality than the last and making you feel like you'd known them forever. And then there's the food. I once purchased a gnocchi entree that was so big, it fed every person at our table (there were seven of us). I love the arugula salad (and arugula slice), both of which comes with mozzarella, arugula, tomatoes and balsamic glaze. They have delicious italian ices (I'm a fan of the almond) and really, you can't go wrong with any of the options on the menu. read more

Pelham Pizza is my favorite pizza place in the world. I've been coming here since I was a child when my grandparents/aunts/uncles/cousins lived right around the block. Even as a kid I knew that Pelham Pizza was special. Their pizza, pasta dishes, italian ices, stromboli...EVERYTHING is tasty and inexpensive. Even though I don't live in NY anymore, I visit whenever possible and find it comforting that the same people (or family members of the older generation that used to work there) are taking orders and engaging with the community. I always sit in the same booth with pictures of little league sports teams my uncle coached and my cousins played on. It is such a special place for me and my family. The pizza is second to none. Without a doubt, my favorite slice is the eggplant. Pelham Pizza's fried eggplant is second only to my grandmother's. This slice is heavy and one makes me extremely full. Year after year, their sauce and ingredients never change and you can always expect the highest quality food. Mango italian ice is my favorite, but the red white and blue one will always bring back many childhood memories. I live in Connecticut but go far out of my way to visit. I'll take any chance I can get to bring people there and will be going back for many years to come. Thank you for your consistently wonderful food and service! read more

Definitely not bad pizza for the area. Nice staff but not amazing pizza and nothing to write home about

Pizza was definitely better than the service, but when it comes down to the nitty gritty they both count in my rating. I absolutely hate when someone walks in after me is asked what do they want. Pizza was quick out of the oven but I felt rushed to pick my beverage as I returned to the counter. "Cash Only" would have been helpful knowing before the pizza came out. I only wound up ordering the white slice from seeing a previous review, and it honestly looked like the one for me when I laid my eyes on it. Very good btw. Had a spinach slice as well which wasn't too shabby, but about halfway down to the crust it exploded green juice all over my hand. Both crusts were overheated and little burnt for my liking. The older gentleman inside seemed like the guy who could have pulled an extra star out of me but not this visit I was helped by another guy. Might be back, and would try different slices. *Worth a stop, I have had plenty of bad pizza, and this wasn't one of those places. read more

Favorite pizza place all time... wish I lived closer ... if you live down that way great place

I've been going to Pelham Pizza for years - don't know what took me so long to write a review. First of all, the staff is super friendly - love them all! Second, the food is delicious! Aside from the pizza, there are SO many great tasting dishes on the menu - you can never go wrong here! Their spinach pizza is my all time favorite, but I really love everything. Their soups, pasta dishes, chicken dishes - everything is great. The chicken marsala rolls are awesome too. And another plus... their prices are so reasonable. FYI, cash only and no delivery. read more

From viewing the kitchen from the front desk, I observed no one wearing masks in the back kitchen. In the front only one person, that main person running the register was wearing a mask the whole time the correct way. The other two people in front were wearing masks around their chin and alternating between that and wearing it fully. Their mouths and noses were exposed however most of the time. Disappointing because their food is good and were helpful to the community during the pandemic, but not being safe by simply wearing a mask defeats the purpose in trying to not spread a virus that transmits through aerosols. read more

This restaurant is located on 5th in downtown Pelham and appears to have changed little in the more than 30 years it has operated. Parking was difficult but not impossible. The restaurant was completely full with no potential for an open seat or table but coming in mid-afternoon, I did not have to wait to order. The pizza here had several positive reviews and my experience was also very positive. The crust was tossed, thin and bubbly but slightly under-cooked. The cheese was excellent quality and the sauce was very good but I would have preferred that it was a bit spicier. Many of the reviewers mentioned their toppings which looked good but I have not had a chance to try yet. read more

I dream about this pizza on the weekly! I'm from California and have Family in Pelham. I don't know what it is maybe the cheese? Or the sause? i don't know but my mouth is watering as we speak. My husband likes four corners BUT my heart stays with Fifth ave pizza!! read more

Most of the food is great and with a great staff this is one of the best Italian restaurants in Pelham.

Pelham has an odd overabundance of pizza places. This one is very good, and is our family's go-to pizza place. Eggplant pizza is excellent. Always busy, so plan ahead. Recommended read more

Would have glady given 5 starts for experience and food; however, pelham pizza lacks in convenience as they do not deliver and only accept cash. Yes, they have an atm on site, but now my 5.00 bill is a 7.50 bill. Nevertheless, food is amazing and staff is great read more

My favorite pizzeria in town.. Everyone is so nice and friendly. It's a very good crowd/environment for kids. It's cheap, makes great pizza and pasta, and everyone is so nice. The only downside is that it's usually packed.. but other than that definitely my favorite! read more

They are still using their bare hands to take pizza slices out of the oven. Didn't want to make a scene, so I just threw it out.

This place right here? PRETTY FRICKEN GOOD! One of my favorite places in Pelham! Super great service and super friendly environment. What's that? It's nice out side? OUT. DOOR. SEATING. Highly recommend to let the person at the counter pick out your slices. Go on an adventure to flavor town! read more

Friendly welcome right off the bat. Individual at the counter was very patient and helpful while we decided. They have a full menu of standard favorites as well as a good variety of ready-made individual slices. We chose a booth (there are about ten plus a few tables) and they brought out paper mats and silverware - a counter service restaurant will full service treatment. We chose the lasagna pizza and fettuccini with Alfredo - both excellent. The lasagna pizza was messy to eat because they're generous with the topping. Plenty of Alfredo sauce on the fettuccini, too. Place is relaxing and clean with a big TV at one end. Parallel parking with coin-pay meters available. Found a spot at 5pm easily on a Thursday. A+ will definitely return. read more

Love this place. Traveled from Louisiana to visit family (and have an NY Slice, of course). This place is incredible. Pizza was perfect. We ordered a garlic cheese bread too also very good. The service was great. If I lived in Pelham or anywhere close I'd be a regular. read more

Been coming here for a few decades now. The food is great! Just took my daughter for the first time and it turned out to be great for toddlers too. read more

Best pizza. Been coming here for over 15 years. Some of the same guys still work here and they're all hilarious and friendly. Really good Italian ice, especially the chocolate flavor. You can't go wrong with their pizza. Never tried any pasta dishes because I like their pizza so much. read more

This place is always busy, and for good reason. Pizza was great, and the like all good Italian food, it's all about the sauce. My anchovie slice was on-point, although the crust was a little bit burnt. Despite constantly being busy, (and I mean with a line nearing the door) service is excellent and all staff passing our table made sure we were good to go. read more

Pelham Pizza - House Salad with Anchovie Slice. Perfect combination. - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

This is a great place. Their regular pies are so GOOD, and that's the best of all. People sit down for proper dinner. Feels very...neighborhoody. read more

Sicilian! Sicilian! Sicilian! Didn't mention Sal and the boys at Pelham Pizza make excellent Sicilian Slices? This place has been around for a while and I can not believe it's taken me his long to come around. The ambiance is casual, the crowd is awesome and the staff Love's what they do and you can feel it the moment you walk in the door. On this visit to Pelham Pizza I got a Chix Parm and a Sicilian. But judging from the clients and their choice of dishes of the Menu. This "Pizza Spot" seems to me more like a casual Italian Restaurant. I'll be back for the Chicken Scarpiello! Buon Appetito read more

The fried zucchini was crispy and melt in your mouth delicious. We ordered the choose your own 6 topping pizza pie and it was everything I love about New York Pizza. I miss my 3 Boys From Italy on Burke Avenue, but this place has may give them a run for their money if they ever open again. read more

Pelham Pizza - Delicious choose your own topping pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

A great place to eat great food a loaded menu from pasta to seafood to veal and chicken dishes I love there homemade soups and salads when in Pelham another great place to eat read more

Luv the food so yummy at great prices nice people definitely recommend and so coming back also the people are so nice and great service

Great find thanks to Yelping on the road (I wasn't driving!). Don't miss the lasagna pizza...and bring cash or pay the ATM fee. read more

Pelham Pizza - My husband with a slice of sausage & a slice of white. - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

I frequent this local pizza place in between my appointments. Always busy, very clean, friendly and a great spot for delicious pizza. I just had the Reverse Slice - cheese in the bottom and gourmet sauce on top (light and delicious) - it's like a Margarita slice. A must try!!!! read more

The service is always great! My family has been coming here for at least the past 10 years! I usually just get cheese pizza or the "white" pizza. But I've heard great things about their other dishes as well. read more