I've eaten here a few times. The pizza is delicious. I decided to place an order for delivery. I put specific instructions to call or text when in the lobby because my bell doesn't work. Well the old guy called mumbling about how long he had to wait to get in. Ummm, if you had read the instructions, you would have known what to do. Don't send an old grumpy man to deliver food. Now, the food, my daughter enjoyed her Chicken Caesar salad. My chicken parmigiana wedge lacked flavor. Too much sauce and not enough cheese. In addition, the chicken was cut into thin strips. I've never had a chicken parm wedge with chicken strips. Will stick to the pizza! Oh and the chocolate moose wasn't good either!! read more

Despite the two latest reviews I still went with this place because I wasn't doing either of those. Got half pepperoni large and it was delicious. Nice, cheesy, hot, the right crisp, crust not too doughy. Timing was good, I got delivery. read more

Ordered my 16 inch well done and they cooked it perfect. Perfect crisp, no flop, good ingredients, good taste. Super hot out of the oven. It burned the roof of my mouth which is what I like. I prefer this place over gemelli's down the road. Nice employees, and I'm surprised more people don't know about this place. I'm new to the area, so I'm guessing this place is new (the building is very modern). Anyways, give them a shot! read more

Alfredo's Pizza Cafe - Half cheese, half white. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

pizza is always on point. sandwiches always hit right. the best thing is their customer service, it goes beyond.

Be careful when you're ordering through door dash since neither one of them is truthful about their prices. The manager argued with me on the phone until he became irate and made me looking like a jack ass. I'll never make the mistake of ordering from Alfredo's again. The Chicken Frances was flavorless made and was not even prepared properly. I deserve a comp but I just won't order from them again. read more

When you have a staff working hard to prepare to help with opening a new store location, the best reward is buy lunch. That's exactly what I tried to do when I ordered from "Alfredo's Pizza Cafe" in New Rochelle. The first issue I had was trying to order. I called and no one picked up. I started to look for another Pizzeria, when someone called my phone back. Now, I don't know how often this happens, but they called me back and asked was I trying to order pizza. It was a bit funny, put I proceeded with my order. It was great they took payment over the phone and even better they accept American Express (don't leave home without it). The price was better than in the city, so I was happy about that. They told me thirty minutes and they were on target. The pizza came hot and ready. Only problem was they didn't bring plates. The delivery guy left and came back with plates so we could eat. After he left, one of the employees mentioned they eat there a lot and they always give one free soda after a certain amount. I was well over that price so why didn't I get a soda? My employee left and spoke to them and came back with our free soda. So all was right....right? Well, for us who have never tried this pizza before, we weren't impressed. The meat on the pizza was a bit chewy and the crust was hard. It wasn't my favorite, however it wasn't my worst either. The staff that ate there regularly, loved it. We were fifty, fifty. I guess it's really a coin toss if you go or not. But take my advice, if you love Brooklyn, pizza maybe this place isn't for you. Don't say I didn't warn you. read more

See all

They have great customer service, food is fresh solid Italian fare and they will even tweek the menu for you.

They never have enough pizza out for purchase as slices. Seems like they only really do pies. Would be so much better if they more pies out on display. read more

Great food. Ordered shrimp fra diavolo. I hope I spelled it right. Amazing! Just the the right amount of spice. A healthy amount of shrimp. Although there were only a couple they staff served us, although with paper and plastic utensils...lol! The place is nothing's fancy but the food was great. The smallest most obscure places tend to have the greatest food. I came back the next day and got a couple slices of pizza. That was good as well. Check this spot out. A hidden treasure. read more

Always great food, always great customer service. A true and reliable neighborhod gem.

Sensational Sicilian that packs a serious punch of flavor with the phenomenal grande cheese and sauce, perfect crusts... Top 3 All Time and I have had many many many sicilians... caring, friendly management.. ordered many times over the years excellent food.. reliable and friendly delivery.. great business... the goto option for Pizza in New Rochelle! read more

Alfredo's Pizza Cafe - Sicilian light cheese. Perfect - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

First take out - Had to wait for order. Pizza okay - Stracciatella soup delicious - tossed salad really good - too much white lettuce, not enough green but otherwise really good. Good switch white onion for red. Baked Penne great. Tiramisu really good - Give it a try!! read more

Stopped by just before closing last night and had a plain cheese slice which was very good! Happy we've got a good pizza place nearby!

Amazing pizza restaurant hidden in New Rochelle. The pizza was delicious and the service was fast! They can seat up to 12 people as the place is small, but the menu is extensive! I believe they deliver and they accept cards on orders $10 and over! read more

Alfredo's Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

I've only tried the plain slice here and only tried it once, but it was so good, very memorable. Perfect cheese to sauce to dough ratio. I hadn't realized that the slices I've eaten recently were as bad as they were until I ate this. No more mediocre pizza for me! read more

Alfredo's Pizza Cafe - Wow this slice was . Was strongly considering getting another but I was too full. - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Alfredos has been my go to for years! The size of the portions for the money you pay is amazing!! Ordered chicken Francese with francese sauce on the linguini, and they followed notes perfect! The entree was absolutely delicious! Huge portion and absolutely tasty!! Garlic bread, not so great. Was kinda hard and tasted like it had the seasoning of baked clams on top. Also, mozzarella sticks had a really weird nude color and were hard and not too tasty. Will put em in the toaster later and hope they're a little better. Will continue ordering here! Great quality, delicious, hot food delivered fast!!!! read more

Great oven baked pizza, amazing hospitality. Anyone will love this. We stopped by with family, pizza and pasta was really great.

I enjoyed their pizza and service was very nice. Although I'm not in the area too often, I'll be sure to stop by next time I am. I only got their plain slices but they had the typical variety of other slices. I also got a beef patty that hit the spot. read more

Alfredo's was amazing! Friendly staff. Thin, cheesy NY-style pizza. Will definitely be back!

So I want to go to a gaming place which is near so we had to wait so we ate here and I have to say this is the best pizza I ever had crust well done cheese is good read more

As you may or may not know alfredos has moved from division to north avenue in new rochelle. I must say I am pretty glad they did. They are close by my job so I find myself in there at least twice a week. The simple cheese slice is soo yummy reminds me of my childhood when things were simple yet good. Their sauce to cheese ratios is just plain perfect. Definitely my new pizza spot. read more

The pizza here is delicious I order from here once a week,I use them for my daughter's class party the children ask for second the principal even asked where the pizza was from everyone enjoyed the pizza! read more

Been getting my pizza here for almost the past 10 years. Still a family-owned business in New Rochelle. I generally order pizza, but have ordered a few of the hot sandwiches too. Seating is limited, though I have brought a group of six here. read more

Alfredo's Pizza Cafe - large pie - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Actually not bad there pizza,when you go in and you look at the pies by slice,you say hmm,but when it comes to eating them now that is different. I found a pizza spot for slices read more

Been coming here for years. Yummy food and great hospitality. The owners are super nice and the food leaves you wanting more. I definitely recommend Alfredo's Pizza. read more

Pizza crust had no flavor and pie was super greasy (Bottom of pizza box was soaked). Cheap pasta entree was awful. Delivery down the street took over an hour also. read more

I have been eating both the pizza and dinners from here for over 12 years always fantastic. I recommend any entree, wedge or slice they are all great read more

I've been coming here for the past 8 years and the pizza never gets old. Their pizza to pastas are amazing. Their customer service is excellent - as soon as you step in they greet you and ask you, " how are you doing?" If you're in New Rochelle and want to grab a quick bite of pizza, then Alfredos is your spot! read more

Pizza is great and is always delivered Hot and Fresh. The new location is really nice. Great Entrees as well and the Cold Antipasto is one of the best. A hidden Gem in New Rochelle. read more

I love Alfredo's! The food is really terrific and the staff is friendly. The delivery is always on time and my order is always right. We've ordered at least once a week for the past 6 years. The pizza is the absolute best in New Rochelle. I highly recommend the penne and vodka sauce. The sauce is prepared fresh for your order and is the absolute best vodka sauce I've ever tasted. I also love the chicken scarpariello, chicken marsala and eggplant parm. read more

Great food!! Have never had a problem I've been eating here for about 6 years. The staff here is top notch. Definitely recommend.