I ate a slice here. It was fresh and cheesy and made well but was basic. The store was clean and they had other food to choose from. read more

Yummy! Ordered a take out personal size pizza for lunch, and was not disappointed. I added 3 toppings (pepperoni, bacon and green peppers) so it was about $7 for a 7 inch pizza. Big props for how much toppings they loaded onto my pizza! It was piled high and there were no bare spots, which I appreciate. The crust was yummy, more of a pan style thicker crust. Not overly cheesy or saucy, pretty much perfect. I felt like it was a quality pizza for the price, and was fresh and quick. Will definitely order again! read more

Pesaro's Pizza - Personal pizza (7 inch) with three toppings loaded on! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

On my way to the cemetary and wanted to pickup some grub along the way and went into this little pizza place. Been craving calzones ever since I watched parks & rec. Needless to say, get the dam calzone! I ordered the Italian in the medium size but i can probably live off this for two days if I wasn't so gluttonous. Pretty sure it's implied, but it is delicious. The crust/shell has a garlicy taste sprinkled with some parm cheese. It doesn't even need the filling to be honest. Back to eating this beast read more

Pretty average pizza for a really cheap price. I'm not a huge fan of their fried foods. The breading they use is not what I prefer for fried foods. Their pizza is consistent and good. My partner always gets their buffalo chicken sandwich. Good quick pick that doesn't break the bank. read more

The calzone & stromboli were good. However, our appetizers were not! I ordered fried mushrooms & my husband got the onion rings. The onion rings were burnt. When I called to complain, I wast old that they don't have a deep fryer. They cook them in the oven & if they cook them less, they get soggy. So, I guess the serve burnt appetizers. My "fried" mushrooms were the worst I've ever had. They were soggy & flavorless. I called & was given a credit for the onion rings (I didn't realize that my mushrooms were not good either & wasn't about to call them again.) Stick with anything other than the appetizers. Why even sell "fried" items if you have no way to fry things? We won't be ordering from this place again, even with the credit. read more

Worst pizza place in Pittsburgh. And I've had pizza all over the city. By far the worst! Service was also terrible.

I've never felt the need to write a review after years of using Yelp. But I feel I need to warn you. Unfortunately, this is the worst pizza place I've been to in Pittsburgh, and I've been to most. It also competes for the worst food I've had in Pittsburgh. Let me start off by telling you about the experience. First, online ordering is completely useless. I wasted about 20 minutes trying to enter my order into both Yelp and GrubHub and neither worked properly. I would try to clip the "free breadsticks when spending $25" coupon after adding $25 worth of food to my cart and instead of working it would just delete my pizza from my cart and say "Oops! Looks like you haven't spent $25 yet!" So I tried GrubHub. We decided to get the 'Family Feast' - Pizza, breadsticks, a sub, a drink for $25ish. When choosing the 1 topping pizza we noticed there's no option to make it only half pepperoni. Fine. We'll just make the whole thing pepperoni. But when you go to add 1 topping to your 1 topping pizza it charges you $1.75 for an 'extra topping'! I guess the one topping they give you for free is just the cheese. Fine. I'll pay $1.75 for pepperoni. Now to choose a sub - my wife wanted buffalo chicken. As you might expect, you can customize it a bit, but there is one section in particular where you can add extra toppings, like gyro meat or crab meat. We thought about it, then decided not to add crab meat...but it doesn't let you. It's a required field! You have to pay extra to add some extra topping or you can't add it. When I went back to check the pizza section I noticed it's the same thing - you are forced to pay extra for a topping - even the one that's included! And there is no way to just choose cheese pizza with no extra topping. So I called instead. That experience was great! I decided to add $5 cheese fries to our Family Feast. Food was done pretty quick and they gave us everything we ordered. Unfortunately. The most damning thing about Pesaro's is the taste of the food. The breadsticks are bland, the sub might have been edible but did they didn't put any buffalo sauce on the buffalo sub. The ranch is just packets. The pizza tastes like what I remember next-day Chuck E Cheese pizza tasting like. And that wasn't even the worst. Literally, what are those cheese fries? Why are they charging $5 for those? The fries are uncooked. The cheese is just a giant glob of some bland cheese that cements the raw fries to the foil. It was impossible to eat and if there is one thing I'm thankful for it's that. I threw them right away. To be fair, it wasn't all bad - the highlight of our meal was the 2 liter of Pepsi. It's often true that you can spend a small amount of money to get a lot of trash (Dominos), or spend more money to get a little gold (Spak). Pesaro's is like spending a lot of money on a little bit of trash. How does this place exist on Butler street? read more

Pesaro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

My favorite pizza, great crust, always arrives fresh and hot Only pizza I eat in Lawrenceville read more

I live about a mile from this place so its close when I want something delivered. It's a safe bet that this will be the last time that I order from them. I get the Family Fest - large one topping pizza, breadsticks, hoagie and two liter of soda. With tax it's a little over $25.00 and with the tip I am spending $29.00 for something that's borderline disgusting. I was craving a fish sandwich and ordered it with the rest of the offerings. What I got was a cut up piece of fish on a slightly toasted bun with rotten lettuce, slimy tomatoes and three small containers of tartar sauce. It's always been hit or miss with this place so consistency is an issue. I wish I could post photos of this pathetic excuse of a fish sandwich that they sent me, I'd be ashamed to even wrap it in aluminum foil let alone send it to a customer. I'd call and ask to speak to someone in charge but I doubt that it would change anything. They are located in the heart of Lawrenceville so people settle for "what's available" but honestly, that's no way to run a pizza shop. As it stands they are in the same ranks as Supreme Pizza which isn't saying a lot. read more

We're Quasi-Regulars delivery is timely, food is average. Pizza okay, Sandwiches, ingredients not so good.

We called around 1:45 am, and the guy picked up the phone to tell us, "hang up, we are closed"

So this is the first time I've reviewed ANYTHING that was local. My fiance and I just ordered Pizza and wings from Pesaro's and frankly we were too impressed NOT to write a review. This is the 3rd time we ordered from there. The Pizza is really good. Very Hot. The Extra Cheese is generous and the crust is Crispy. Made to order and on time. What more do you want? Pizza Hut delivery is AWFUL. Dominos, Meh. and I doubt one can get Baklava on Butler, but Pesaro's has it and it's good. :smile read more

Went to a few places around a few surrounding neighborhoods and came across this place out of the blue. Wow... from pizzas to subs, or hoagies as Pittsburghers say, it is allllll good. Not too much or too sweet of red sauce of this pizza and the crust is always tasty. read more

This place is always reasonable and one of my favorite places to order from. I cannot comment on most of their as competently as I can their hoagies. From Itailian to Steak to Chicken, they are always fresh and delicious! We have had their Cheesy fries also and they are very good. I would also like to comment that their delivery is timely and efficient. Most of all and one of the many reasons that we continue to patronize them is because of their customer service. I appreciate being a valued cusomer and not just someone who gives them money. Thank you! read more

We've been ordering from here for at least five years. The most recent deliveries have taken an excessive amount of time. Tonight we placed the order at 10:25pm. The driver called us at 11:03 saying he was on the 62nd street bridge and asking where we lived in Shaler. The only problem is we live in Lawrenceville... Off of Stanton. It's now 11:37 and still no order. We should have picked it up, I'd be in bed by now. The pizza better be hot, but I have a feeling it won't be. read more

The mozzarella cheese sticks were not cooked and taste horrible. The honey bar b que bites were burnt, soft textured and no flavor. The buffalo chicken was completely gross and the chicken was cold as ice. The pizza lacked flavor, cheese was cheap with opened canned tomato sauce. WILL NEVER EAT FROM THEM AGAIN. A COMPLETE DISASTER AND WASTE OF MONEY read more

First time ordering from the Lawrenceville store. Yuck. This place better re-evaluate their ingredients and taste standards because it was just blah. The Sicilian pizza crust was terrible and there was hardly any sauce on the pizza. There are so many better places in the area, especially Bloomfield. Try Frank's also in Millvale. Amazing. read more

Normally I have no issue Pesaro's but after my last order I'm done with them. I ordered the family feast when the driver came I paid him $23.53 right after the driver left I noticed I did not get the breadsticks or 2lt of tea & my hoagie was wrong. I called was giving the run around about that's not what I ordered and I would have to pay $3.50 more if I wanted those missing items. After complaining about how often I order from them I was told the $3.50 would be waved even thou I had paid it with my original delivered order. When the 2nd drive came with the corrected hoagie & missing items I was told once again I had to pay $3.50 I was told it was put into the system wrong. I don't see how that is my problem when I paid the 1st time, if I didn't have hungry boys I would had returned my whole order. I paid the difference and vowed to never go back there they didn't care they were loosing a long time customer. The only thing they cared about was $3.50 and would not believe I had paid the 1 driver who I suspect kept the difference and also his mouth shut when asked what I paid him. Mistakes happen and would over look this is the I wasn't treated so rudely. read more

Won't be ordering from here again. The delivery man was rude because they transposed my address. I, very nicely, assured the man that I gave the correct address and again he shoved the receipt in my face wanting an apology. I know this looks like a scorned review - but the pizza actually earned 2 stars on it's own. WAY too greasy and just okay tasting. I was really hopeful I'd have a better experience since this place is in the neighborhood. Oh well, you live and learn. read more

Pizza is good...don't order any of the appetizers. ..they were terrible...so was the fish sandwich...if you're going to order anything...make it pizza and nothing else read more

The steak hoagies are amazing, generous portion of seasoned steak and the perfect amount of cheese. I get it well done and it's delicious.

Got a meatball sub and fries for take out. Not the best sub I've ever had, but not the worst. The fries were awful and soggy even though I picked it up right as it was finished being made. I'm not sure about their pizza, but I'm not too confident it's better than the places I currently order from. read more

Sucked, ordered a BBQ Chicken Sicilian pizza and they gave me a regular. There was no BBQ sauce in it. The seafood calzone had more bread and grease then actual meat. And the service was shit. No more from me. read more

Ordered the pepperoni calzone and added mushrooms. It was delicious and ginormous. Think they made me a large one when I ordered a personal. I'll take the mistake! read more

This spot is located right in the heart of Lower Lawrenceville. Pretty basic pizza place and their prices are reasonable. One of the better pizza places I've had when it comes to casual, delivery/take-out pizza. They have a large menu, so you can definitely find something you like. Hoagies, salads, wedges, wraps, and lots of options for sides. read more

This place is right down the street from me. I've been curious to try their pizza. Just got a large Sicilian. The dough tasted like soggy cardboard. Now I know. And knowing is half the battle. I won't be returning. read more

Fries is so undercooked it's practically white. "Garlic" bread is basically butter on bread with garlic powder - it's so salty and greasy it the stuff of heart attacks. The lettuce on the wedgie is anything but fresh, its color is a mixture of light green and shades of brown. This food is not edible. read more

Pesaro's Pizza - I kid you not, the pictures make the food look better. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

It seems that others have had problems with deliveries, however I have only picked up orders here before. Pizzas have been quickly made and ready by the time I arrived. The quality and pizza prices are right-down-the-road average in my opinion. I would recommend trying it sometime. read more

I ordered Pesaro's last week and it was great. I know a lot of other people have had bad experiences, but I really loved it. We got a large pizza with black olives and extra cheese. It was cooked perfectly, delicious and it got here in a reasonable amount of time with no problems. I'll try it again soon and hope that my opinion doesn't change!! read more

First try last night, very good service. They delivered the pizza right at midnight! Great way to start the new year. Fast delivery even for a busy bsy night. I got an extra large pizza, it was pretty good. Price was okay. Very good dough snd cheese. Check it out read more

Staff was friendly. I was advised about what to try. I went with a calzone. It was massive although I ordered the personal size. It was average in taste but was very filling. read more

I just received my order from Pesaro's after waiting over 90 minutes! It wasn't even a busy time of day to order - 1:15 in the afternoon. The person who delivered it did not apologize or seem to care. Furthermore, I open the food and it looks GROSS. The broccoli bites were undercooked, soggy, and grey looking. The pizza was some of the greasiest pizza I have ever seen! The box was completely soaked through and yet the pizza was ALSO undercooked. The pepperoni was not cooked even close to well enough so I took off the pizza thinking it would probably make me sick. There are so many better pizza deliveries in the area like Mia Pizza. I would rather order from Dominos than ever order from this restaurant again - the food is even worse than the service! read more

I get the Hawaiian usually- very tasty simple pizza! I have done delivery and pick up. Both experiences were there quick.

Delivery time was great. Food had great flavor. Food tasted good. I would recommend. Quality for the right price. I would order from here again. Portions were terrific. read more

I absolutely love the cheese calzone. I get the personal one and it's huge. More than enough for one person.

The food was THE BEST! Ordered Steak, Pepperoni & Italian Clazones....Just thinking about the food make me hungry.

We got wings here. They were decent, i didn't have a problem with them at all. But the service was horrible. We ordered ahead of time and showed up at the time we were told (about 20 min). We were told it would be five more minutes because the wings needed to be "sauced". We then saw the wings being put into the oven. They had not even been started. It was not busy in there. There were FOUR people "working", but three of them were standing around talking while one did everything. We had also used a coupon, which we had told them over the phone as requested, but we were rung up without the coupon. When the coupon was mentioned, they very quickly deducted the amount without question, which made it seem like they knew very well about it, but were just trying to see if they could get it past us. I may be reading too much into that, it could have been an honest mistake, but that was my impression. Maybe I was just irritated after waiting for my whole order to be made after calling it in ahead of time when they clearly were not busy (and had plenty of people working that were not doing anything. I would definitely not order from here without a coupon, the prices were a bit high for standard takeout wings. read more

I am not sure how to rate Pesaro's. It is not the best pizza in the neighborhood, Graziano's is, so I should give Pesaro's 1 star because if you want pizza, Graziano's is the place. Unfortunately, Graziano's does not deliver and I am not always motivated to get off my butt, so I give Pesaro's 5 stars because they are the best delivered pizza in the 'hood. They also have a larger menu selection than Graziano's, which is good. The pizza is solid, just not as good as Graziano's. read more

This place is great for late night pizza. The employees are friendly, it's open til 1:45am, and you can get a 'takeout special' Large 1 topping Pizza for exactly $10.69. It's big enough to sober you up before bed and still have tasty leftovers the next day. What more can you ask for? read more

IF YOU ORDERED FROM THIS STORE THROUGH GRUB HUB, PLEASE CALL AND COMPLAIN!!! 1-877-585-1085. GRUB HUB GAVE ME A CREDIT, AND SAID MORE PEOPLE SHOULD TAKE THE TIME TO CALL THEM, TOO. We have ordered from this terrible place more than once. Every time, I ask myself "Why the hell did I do that again???" Don't order any of their fried apps: broccoli bites, mozzarella sticks, poppers, etc. I seriously think they dip them in some kind of leftover pizza dough and try to bake it. That's EXACTLY the taste and consistency. Mushy and tasteless, covered in tasteless doughy stuff. Gross! For some reason, my boyfriend decided to order from them tonight. We checked their grubhub menu, and ordered a personal calzone and mozzarella sticks. Added 3 toppings to the calzone (pepperoni, mushrooms, broccoli). We received the order, gross cheese sticks, then I cut into the calzone. NO TOPPINGS!!! Literally just sauce and cheese. I am not usually the one to complain. I know that pizza places have their moments. I can deal with bacon instead of pepperoni, onions instead of mushrooms, etc. I really don't mind. I called Pesaro's. I just had to. I really felt like I had wasted $25. We always tip them $5, and they are literally 3 blocks away. The man on the phone was so completely RUDE! He said since I had already paid (through grubhub), there was nothing they could do. I had paid, and I had only paid for a plain freaking calzone??????? I asked him why they didn't call me???? I could've paid the extra $3 - $5 cash! They didn't even ask! They didn't call Grub Hub, who also could've called me. He just said "Too Bad" and kept talking over me. I was FURIOUS!!!!! DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY OR TIME!!!!!!!!!!! They just delivered the worst meal when we are freaking starving!!! I called Grub Hub, as I felt they needed to know who they are advertising on their site. She said she was calling them and they gave us a $10 credit. Yay Grub Hub!!! Boo this garbage pizza place! Lawrenceville needs more respectable businesses, not these half-ass businesses moving in trying to take our money!!! read more