Went to Petsi's for the first time based on a recommendation from a co-worker and I enjoyed it! My husband and I ordered a medium spring chicken pot pie to go, frozen, to bake at home. It was a bit dry but still very delicious and flavorful. My only suggestion would be to include a bit more gravy, and more herbs; the lemon and dill didn't really come through. That being said, it was still really great and we were so excited to dig in to the leftovers the next day. Would absolutely recommend read more

Petsi Pies - Spring Chicken Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

Not sure how I've never stumbled across this gem before! As a Southern CA native, pie is no stranger to me. Growing up we would often get pie with my grandma at Marie Calendars or Cocos. Since moving to Boston, I hardly see pie on the menu....well today I found a new pie place!!! As soon as I walked in I was met with friendly faces. The pastry counter was filled with fresh baked goods and they even had samples out. This is strictly a pick-up and go, it's not setup like a cafe with tables. I bought the banana cream for a work event and a few minis to take home for me and my hubby. The banana cream was good-admittedly, it was more on the sweeter side than I expected. I really enjoyed the crust - it wasn't too buttery and cooked perfectly. It was def a hit. My hubby and I enjoyed sampling the blueberry, apple, and cherry crumble. Of the three, the apple was my favorite which actually surprised me. The blueberry was OK, not as sweet as I would have liked - opposite of the banana cream. And the cherry was perfectly tart-I really appreciated the crumble. All in all, I will def be back. Can't wait to follow their social media to see what the monthly specials are. Street parking is tough, I rec parking in star market if you're quick. You can also order ahead for a quicker pickup and they deliver within a 6-mile radius as long as you place the order by noon the day before. read more

See all

Fantastic pastries and pies!! Their chocolate mini pies (they call them "cutie pies") are my favorite. Their scones are tender on the inside and crunchy on the outside. All of their baked goods are so fresh and tasty. read more

Petsi Pies - Cutie Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

A friend brought me a little pecan pie recently (it had been years since I had a Petsi pie!), it was my first time trying the pecan and it was delicious. The small was a perfect size for someone like me with no self-control, anything larger would have been dangerous! Perfect crust and the pecan filling had lots of flavor! read more

Petsi Pies - Small pecan - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

I finally found a local pie company that's a family favorite! Petsi recently became my go to after bringing their pies to several events and receiving nothing but praise. The rotating menu paired with classics makes it easy to choose pies that will meet everyone's needs. My favorite pie is still the sugar pie, which is seasonal but delicious. I have yet to try the savory pies, but look forward to getting some during the colder months as an easy meal solution. Their service is always friendly, and their website is up to date, making it easy to plan around. I love that place has a local neighborhood vibe and truly feels like a hidden gem. read more

As an out of town guest, I found Petsi on Yelp as I was searching for a bakery with strawberry rhubarb pie. One of my dinner hosts apparently shared that his favorite was the fore mentioned pie. Little did I know, they were very familiar with your bakery. Each sublime bite brought a smile to their faces. Thanks for holding the pie for me until pickup at your cozy bakery. Success! read more

I got to try their vegan Apple pie during an event and it was delicious. The small 5" is about the same portion size as two standard slices and it was a good amount of sweet without being too sweet. I wish they sold their vegan flavors in store! read more

Petsi Pies were the highlight of our wedding! We ordered a dozen pies and they were delivered safely and on time. They were a hit with all of our guests. Our guests devoured everything from the blueberry pie to chocolate bourbon pecan pie. I was glad to be at the front of the line so I could get a slice of cherry crumb. Petsi also enjoys working with weddings and offers a complimentary sampling of 'cutie pies' for interested couples. They do not price gouge for weddings versus regular catering. I would highly recommend Petsi pies for any occasion whether big or small. read more

Tried pie here on PI day this year! Got the Mississippi mud pie and the apple crumble. Haven't had a nicer pie here in Boston! The apple crumble was packed with apples and the pastry was cooked to perfection! Mississippi mud pie was like a brownie in pie form! Loved it. read more

Petsi Pies - Mississippi mud pie and apple crumble - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

See all

Expensive local pie place, but I suppose expense is expected near Boston. I arrived an hour before closing and there were only a few pies on display. Fortunately, I was requested to get something in the apple genre and one such large pie remained (for 6 people - medium is not enough! we like dessert!). I can say that the taste was truly top notch - my mother's apple pies are my absolute favorite, nothing else compares, but this comes close enough that I found it tasty. That is not faint praise, I promise! But if you want a Petsi, do arrive early (or order ahead? I am not 100% certain how it works, not being a local) and do bring a lot of money. Because one pie was enough that I decided not to drop any more dough on... dough... so I only have the one pie to go by. read more

Petsi Pies - pies on request - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

Ordered pies for a work event, everyone enjoyed them. Only downside is they came cold, and am sure they'd taste even better warmed up. The cherry pie was delightful, not sweet and everything paired well with the crimson berry iced tea. Definitely will be ordering from them again. read more

Petsi Pies - Pumpkin, cherry, apple and quiche Lorraine. - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

See all

I got 2 pies Sunday. I didn't see the quality for the price. I think they were sitting around to long. Very expensive but Def not worth it!

Came here after seeing them on the best pies list. Came in with high expectation and left somewhat disappointed. They were good - just nothing special to me. Wouldn't go out of my way to go there again. Service was good though. read more

See all

Sweet pies and service! The crust is buttery and flaky that it compliments both savory and sweet. This cute little shop packs flavor with pie sizes that span to personal and shareable. Delicious and worth a try. read more

Best pie shop in greater Boston. Love the broad variety of fresh-baked sweet and savory flavors as well as the different size options they offer for most pies. I have gotten full size pies for Thanksgiving, birthdays, and other holidays though more commonly will go for their small (1-2 serving) and mini pies if I'm just buying for myself or a smaller group and want to try a few different flavors. Buttery/flaky crusts and a mix of classic fillings like apple, pecan, chocolate, and mixed berry in addition to a range of seasonal options like key lime, peach, strawberry rhubarb, etc. they also have a full range of coffee drinks as well as other pastries (cookies, biscuits, brownies) to supplement or for the less pie-inclined in your party! read more

Petsi Pies - Selection of pies - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

Delicious sweet and savory pies. Friendly and quick service. I live half an hour away, but it's worth the extra time it takes to get those pies. Lemon Chess is my favorite. read more

I am vegetarian no dairy! NO choices at all!! There are too many others that have many choices

$5 for a mini pie! steal! i should have warmed this up and had it with ice cream, my only regret. i will be back for more read more

Petsi Pies - mini pie - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

The cutest pie shop! I love passing this place and smelling their newest bakes of the day. I am a big fan of their pumpkin pie and chicken pot hand pie! The service is always so helpful and kind. read more

I love this place. Anything I've tried has been delicious. Savory pies and sweet pies. They're great to bring to someone's house or just have them at your own house. I love the little "cutie pies" - perfect for a treat. read more

Is "yum" good enough for a review? No? Okay, here's the full version. I've been coming here for quite a few years now. The bakery is outstanding. They have one of the best and largest selections I've seen! And the scent? It smells wonderful in here. There always seems to be something baking in one of their several ovens. I tried several of the delectable items and they've all been, well, delectable! Their magic bars are among the best I've eaten anywhere, and remind of the ones my mom used to make. They have two unavoidable drawbacks: parking and inside seating space. Thanks to the geniuses in Somerville, on street parking is all but non-existent in this neighborhood. Inside has seating for about 9-10 people, but a lot seem get things to go anyway. Coffee and other drinks are equally tasty! read more

LOVE that they have so many vegan pie flavors. I went to a pi day event and got to try the vegan apple, blueberry, mixed berry, and cherry pies. All of them were absolutely delicious, even when reheated a few days later. read more

Petsi Pies - vegan pies - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

See all

The best pies in Cambridge/Somerville imho! A Petsi pie is my go-to contribution whenever I'm needing to bring a dessert to an event or dinner party. A medium sized pie for 4 people has been a perfect ratio, giving the opportunity for a generous serving *and* seconds :) Each month, they have a different special pie that are, without fail, delicious and delightful. Their cherry pie is AMAZING, both the crumble-top version and the shell-top version - highly recommend if you or someone in your life loves cherries. And in addition to the incredible quality of the pies themselves, the people who work at Petsi Pie are amazing. A wonderful local business! read more

Popular pie place in Somerville. Large 10" $35 (6-8 pax), Medium 8" $18 (4-5 pax), Small 5" $9 (1-2 pax). Queues can be long at Thanksgiving and Christmas. Good: - chocolate bourbon pecan Ok: - mixed berries read more

Petsi Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

See all

This is a place where I could spin around, pick a pie, and it would still be one of the greatest things I've ever eaten. The crust is flaky and tender (no soggy bottoms!!) and the fillings are so flavorful without being too cloyingly sweet. Service is quick and the people are nice. It's so worth the prices-- I don't know what they put in their food, but DAMN is it good. read more

Great place to grab a pie (or two, or three) - my only regret is we stopped in an hour before closing, and the selection was meager/the goods we got were a touch on the stale side. We got the one cutie pie (3") left, an apple pie. Next time, I'll toast it up in the oven before eating. It was heavy on the dough and light on the filling but I appreciated the care that went into forming a much smaller lattice top (in the shape of a star no less). Looking on their website, I'd definitely want to try their savory options, like the chicken pot pie and the chicken/leek/gruyere. Ordering ahead is recommended. Also tried their chocolate chip cookie and blueberry muffin. The cookie was just all right, on the smaller end for the price, not much chocolate chips, left an oily aftertaste. I loved the muffin - the texture and taste of the dough was more comparable to a scone, a little drier and less fluffy than the usual "wet" muffins. Really cozy inside, with one or two seats facing the windows. Parking: A bunch of street options and a Star's Market parking lot just one street over. read more

Let it be known that I've never formally been inside Petsi Pies. I had the pleasure of ordering delivery for a very special friend, and it is so exciting that this local place offers delivery to a six mile radius from the shop. I ordered online on Thursday morning for Saturday morning delivery. The website interface is perfect and easy to use. I ordered a small blueberry pie (pic below) and a handwritten letter from their local artist. I think it was all berry reasonably priced and looked beautiful online. Luckily, it tasted even better than it looked. My friend could not stop singing their praises and I'm glad this gift was able to bring so much joy to her day. I highly recommend surprising your friends with a Petsi Pie! read more

Petsi Pies - small blueberry pie! - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

Good pies! The small ones will fill up two normal people. I love the pecan pie. So fresh and nut-laden. The crust is buttery and on the thick side, and may sometimes seem a little dry, but I like that...it goes so well with coffee. Pick up a couple and take them home! read more

Oh my - possibly the best scones I've ever had. No hyperbole. I tried three different ones: currant, mixed berry, lemon. The right amount of crisp on the edges, right amount of butter, right amount of moisture. Petsi (pronounced peet-see) has got this all the way right. Six scones totaled $21. read more

Best biscuits around those are hard to find. I've actually never been disappointed. The pies are fantastic.

Great pie but pricy! Sometime wonder whether it is worth going out of my way to get it...

I was scrolling through my phone at a quarter to midnight and suddenly came across this post from Petsi Pies "last weekend for our seasonal strawberry rhubarb pie". I couldn't believe that the season was almost ending and I still hadn't had a bite of my very favorite pie! In less than a minute, a 'strawberry rhubarb pie with oat crumb' had been added to cart. I debated whether I should add another pie given their selections and I finally settled on the savory pie 'Heirloom Tomato w Gruyere, Dijon Mustard & Herbs de Provence'. Two pies and I was good to go! Picked them up on the weekend; and it was so convenient - placed on a table in-store at the time mentioned on my receipt. That strawberry rhubarb pie was exquisite. Sweet strawberries balanced with the tart flavor of rhubarb, wow. We savored every slice. The heirloom tomato pie was had for breakfast and I couldn't believe my luck that I added this to cart - wow again! Perfect mix of fluffy eggs, cheese, and tomato. It felt like such a fancy breakfast in the comfort of my home. I can't wait to try more flavors and next time, I won't wait until the end of the season! read more

See all

I've walked by this place several time's and have always seen a lineup. After an unsuccessful attempt last week (their business hours 9am - 3pm only..) I finally walked in on time. It's only one customer at a time but they have space outside for people to wait. Once inside, I was in it ally overwhelmed with the types of pies they had. After asking the staff about her favourite pies (oh my there are so many!) I went with two small standard apple pies ($8). The crust was so crumbly and the apple stuffing was sweet and tangy. The small pie can definitely be shared but we decided to each have our own (thank god for that since they were so good). I will definitely be back to try some of the other flavours. read more

Petsi Pies - Apple pie (small) - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

I just love Petsi Pies. Their pastries and pies are top notch and some of the best in the area. Their service is friendly and efficient. I typically try to go during "off" times as during the weekend it can get very busy with lines out the door. It's obvious as to why...they are fantastic! read more

Unlike most reviews from customers coming in for the pies, I came for the Cinnamon Rolls. Unfortunately, they did not have any Cinnamon Rolls the day that I visited, but I did get a Cinnamon Roll Bread Pudding that was tasty. I also got a savory Artichoke Stuffed Brioche and a savory Cheddar, Bacon, & Chive Scone. The Cinnamon Roll Bread Pudding was my favorite item of the purchase. The savory items were good, but the scone was a little more "bready" than what I'm used to when I think of scones, so I think I expected it to be a little more like a biscuit in texture, and when it was chewy like bread, it threw me off. It had good flavor, but the texture just wasn't there for me. The brioche had good flavor and texture, though. I'd probably order any of their brioches some other time. I think I messed up in not getting a Mississippi Mud Pie, so I will have to come back for that. Street parking can be a little tough during peak hours, but luckily, there's a grocery store next door that's easy enough to park at and run over to Petsi Pies really quickly. The staff was super friendly and patient with me, especially considering that it was my first visit, and I wanted to stare at everything. It's a take-out only kind of place, so it's super easy to be in and out within minutes. Also, I hear that it has been in this neighborhood for quite some time, so I think it's worth the stop. read more

The chocolate bourbon pie is absolutely delicious! It's the perfectly flavored and not super sweet at all, but just the right amount. Will definitely return and try other menu items from here. read more

Got a couple pies for my boyfriend's birthday and it was a hit! Bought 4 small pies and 1 medium to try some of the different flavors. Keep in mind that if you order online for pickup they ask you to order at least a day ahead. I ordered from the website 2 days ahead and had no problem getting the flavors I wanted. Pickup was very smooth and all pies were ready by the scheduled time. We ordered: Salted Caramel Apple Pie 7/10 - very good pie, not used to the salt on the top but the flavor profile was still great. Expected a little more taste of the caramel. Mixed Berry Pie 7.5/10 - amazing berry pie. One of my friend's favorite. Pumpkin Pie 9.5/10 - AMAZING & A MUST GET! My personal favorite (and also my first time trying pumpkin pie!!!) and I definitely regret not making this one the bigger size. I would have gotten a large of this one if I knew how good it was! Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie - I can't speak to the flavor of this one because I'm allergic to nuts, but this one was my boyfriends favorite. I'm gonna say this one is a must try just because of how many good reviews I read on this pie alone and now seeing how much my friends enjoyed it. Mississippi Mud Pie 7.5/10 - less of a pie and more of a brownie, but who doesn't love brownies?!! This specific pie had a pretty hard crust, but the other pies didn't turn out like that, and the goodness on top more than made up for it. Bacon Cheddar Scallion Biscuit 8.5/10 - I love love biscuits, and this was no exception. Had it for breakfast and it tasted like a scallion pancake in biscuit form (no complaints for sure from me). Overall amazing experience! I'd come again just to get a large pumpkin pie & try some other flavors. read more

See all

Went to Petsi Pies this morning to pick up a birthday pie for a coworker. 1 customer at a time these days. Sadly, key lime was out of season. Ended up getting three small $8 pies- chocolate bourbon pecan (my fav), sweet potato pecan (another coworker's fav), and pumpkin. They are super friendly and helpful inside! Also got a cold brew that kept me going the whole day (I usually have at least 2 cups of coffee). read more

Petsi Pies - Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Somerville, Massachusetts

See all

Delicious pies, great pastries and warm and friendly customer service! Short distance from Boston and a hidden gem!

My husband used to live down the street from this place during a summer internship, and our longstanding joke was that Petsi Pies didn't actually exist because it was NEVER open whenever we would stop by. Fast forward 10 years, and I was delighted to find while randomly walking past that Petsi Pies was open! I immediately walked in and ordered a chocolate bourbon pecan pie to have later at dinner with friends. The people inside were very sweet and seemed to know their regulars well (a guy walked in and the lady instantly knew what pie he wanted). Honestly it was tempting to buy multiple pies, but I knew we could only get one. The chocolate bourbon pecan pie ended up being AMAZING. Like seriously one of my top 3 pie experiences of my life, and this coming from someone whose mother-in-law makes incredible pies on the regular. If you've ever thought that pecan pie was too gloopy or one-note in flavor, you need to try this. The slight bitterness/acidity of the chocolate perfectly cuts through the sweet pecan filling, and makes each bite irresistible. The bourbon is very subtle (I could hardly taste it), which was perfect for me because I don't actually like alcohol in my desserts. The pie as a whole was very rich, but so delicious that my friends and I each had two slices. I was tempted to eat the whole pie on my own, that's how good it was. The price was pretty reasonable considering the fact that there are pecans in it, and it was boxed up well for transport. I will absolutely be stopping by again to get another one of these pies, along with the lemon lavender chess pie! read more