Fun friendly place, perfectly located on-the-way to Catskill attractions, and serving very good pizza. Parking is ample and immediately adjacent to outdoor bench seating. Do yourself a favor and try their garlic knots. You do knot want to miss them. Get it? read more

The Calzone was a good size and it was delicious The Tiramisu and Apple Crump Cheesecake were to die for. Everyone in our group loved the food. read more

I live locally and have tried alllll the pizza places. This is our FAVORITE! The pizza is so good, the best wings, and even fresh salads. When my mom is in town this pizza is her number #1 must eat. read more

The food was excellent Service was great, very friendly people behind the counter. Ambiance was of a good old pizzeria. Excellent pizza selections. The toppings are creative as well as the names. We had the best wraps we've ever tasted. With the absence of bread, the wrap was loaded with wonderful ingredients. We live near by and will be going back soon. read more

Great locally owned family business. The calzone here is the biggest I've ever seen!! It was delicious! It also was enough to feed 3-4 people. Their specialty pizzas are amazing as are the sandwich and salads!! All good vibes here!! Thank you Phoenicia Pizza 28 read more

The best pizza around very friendly and next time you are around In the area the Hudson is definitely one of my favorite. Definitely 5 star!!!! read more

Our go to spot! Consistently the best pizza in town- great pizza, super nice people, excellent service. A true red sauce Italian spot. Sit down or take out- use Toast/Local App or online to order. Seriously excellent place to go. read more

Phoenicia Pizza 28 .. is very cozy front shop and indoor out door dining available .. nice chairs outside I used them to wait for my Pie .. pepperoni and sausage. This pie leaves you craving more. I had my first slice at a friend's house.. and immediately went looking for Phoenicia Pizza 28 . So good.. so fresh.. great crust.. just right cheese amount.. yum! I ordered my pie at the front and the staff were quick to take my order and recommend different toppings. Average pie prices.. topping extra.. as per usual in any shop.. give it a try!! read more

The best Pizza place around. The service was great and employees are super friendly. I go there pretty often and have ordered all sorts of different foods and they were all great. My personal favorite is the Mercy specialty pie. Its surrounded by other shops and even has a barber shop connected to it. I will continue going here regularly. Highly recommended read more

This is my favorite Pizza place in the Phoenicia area. The pizza is always fresh and delicious with a variety of choices and the staff is friendly. The crust is just the right thickness to be a little chewy yet crispy at the edges, and the toppings are great. read more

Phoenicia Pizza 28 - Half Phoenician and half double pepperoni and onion. - Pizza Near Me - Phoenicia, New York

Because everyone should care, BEWARE of Phoenicia Pizza 28 in New York State. LOW-QUALITY FOOD AT EXTREMELY HIGH PRICES. MISERABLE STAFF. Terrible Food: I was compelled to post after losing $15.09 on their over-priced meatball 'Parmesan Hot Hero'. It smelled and appeared unsafe to consume. Difficult to believe that anyone opined; "Fantastic food great prices...". Nonetheless, the staff member who prepared this item disregarded excessively-burnt black edges upon removal from their small speed-heating appliance, which over-heated the entire 'hero'. The bread also seemed as-if it were stale prior to preparation. This place has been in business for long-enough to become adept with their systems. Sadly, they are not. Traditional pizza restaurants heat their wedges and heroes in pizza ovens under regulated temperatures. The contents was even more unappetizing. The meatballs were very small and sparse, with large voids between them. There was barely any sauce, or cheese. The cheese was not a genuine parmesan, nor mozzarella. It had pooled below, indicative of cheap artificially processed white synthetic cheese akin to Velveeta. There was a strange non-Italian spice scent emanating from their gray quasi-meatballs. Splitting one of the small, overly-spiced balls in-half revealed at-least fifty-percent breading, with strange dark specks throughout. The unpleasant odor which permeated the entire crew-cab truck was extremely odd! I passed on tasting any part of it despite my hunger, and immediately discarded it in a trash-can at the next stop. Chedarella? I have never encountered inexpensive processed Chedarella Semisoft Cheese at any Italian restaurants before, nor since. A web review states; "I got this cheese and my kids don't like it. The taste is awful. I will not recommend this product.". Taking into account Phoenicia 28 Pizza's very high prices, it makes no sense that they would choose to use this processed product on anything at all. Unfortunately for customers, they use it extensively rather than traditional real cheeses, to increase revenue. Miserable Service: Upon entry, the atmosphere is frigid. Not the sort of warmth expected at a self-proclaimed 'Mom & Pop Pizza Shop' that's 'Family Owned & Operated'. The frowning girl at the counter appeared to be in her mid-twenties, and said absolutely nothing when I stood before her at the counter if front of the register where patrons presumably place orders. I had to excuse myself to gain acknowledgement, although I was not subsequently ask if she could help me. So, I asked if their meatballs were made in-house, to-which she said; "I don't know.". Naturally, I asked how long she'd worked there while kindly smiling, to which she replied; "5 months.". She took no initiative, so I asked her if anyone else may know. Her bewilderment remained, as she turned away without a word. She approached a nearby man who was operating a small speed-heating oven. I did not hear her ask him anything, so I repeat my question since he only took three steps from his work station in my direction, and said nothing. This man muttered a nearly inaudible; "Yes." before retreating. When the girl returned, I asked for their price on one meatball 'hero', which she did not know. I located the price in a 'to-go menu' from the counter, and said; "Your menus says $13.95.". She said; "Oh. Yeah.". So, I reluctantly ordered one 'Parmesan Hot Hero'. Big mistake, as we should always listen to our gut-instincts. My hunger got the best of me. Previous proprietor Danielle's Pizza Shop had a very friendly, enthusiastic environment with great prices for top-shelf products & very generous portions! They featured specialty and classic pizzas, including Sicilian, Detroit-style and Gluten Free, all made with the freshest ingredients, Grande cheese and Italian Caputo flour. It was truly devastating to the local community when they sold-out to the new owners. Masterful Chef David who had trained extensively under a renowned California Master Pizza Chef, and wife Danielle sadly did not return after his eye injury. I hope that he has fully recovered, and they are doing really well. They created massive calzones, tasty wings and hot subs using authentic parmesan, mozerella & ricotta, stocked ice-cold Boylan's cane-sugar sweetened sodas (not unhealthy high-fructose corn syrup swill), local Westkill and Woodstock brewery beverages, and authentically traditional tiramisu & cannoli, plus much more! Having learned my expensive lesson, I will never enter Phoenicia 28 Pizza again, and advise that others find one of many local alternatives. Many restaurateurs offer real cheeses, truly delicious pizzas, real parmesan wedges, authentic Italian dishes, healthy beverages, and tasty desserts at fair and competitive prices. None of us knows 'The Big Secret' as-to what comes next. Decent people genuinely care for each-other in the 'here and now'. Not so at 'PP28'. Best of journeys to those who truly care, and beware. read more

The food is amazing, the old school feel of the whole store with the license plates and old juke box made for a great dining experience, and the employee by the name of "Zachariah" is an outstanding citizen so kind and polite and deserves a Nobel peace prize read more

Phoenicia Pizza 28 - Their garlic knots are out of this world - Pizza Near Me - Phoenicia, New York

Small pizza place big selection of pizza types sandwiches and desserts friendly service etc read more

Delicious grandma pizza! Also loved the spinach and artichoke. Was please surprised to find a beautifully decorated interior. Service was quick and efficient. read more

Great addition to the area and they're open every day! Amazing. The pizza selections are expansive and creative, and it's probably the best tasting pizza in the area. The staff is also very pleasant and efficient. Dine in or take out. Oh, and you can get a haircut in the tiny barbershop that's kinda built in to the pizza shop. Totally separate though (no hairs flying into pizzas). read more

My wife and I rented a place in Phoenicia with our 3 month old. Needless to say heading out to dinner is a thing of the past for the foreseeable future lol. So, we placed an online order for a large cheese and pep. Got the pizza home and dug in. WOW. You guys should be very proud. Awesome pizza. We're from Rochester, NY and I would say we do pretty well up here for pies (outside of NYC obviously). This place would be our go to if we had it closer to home. Bravo, guys! read more

Very kind and loving staff, food was phenomenal, my regular cheese slice was cooked to perfection. Will be going back for more!!

Really tasty food! We had the grandma pie with added olives, pepperoni and peppers plus the yaya salad. Both were delicious. Glad to have this local option in the neighborhood for a quick and tasty pizza pickup. read more

We were staying at a nearby resort and my kids were asking for a cheese and pepperoni pizza, so I ordered online. Their pizzas are delicious. Very tasty and fast, and the staff is super friendly. I highly recommend it! read more

Phoenicia Pizza 28 - The pizza was almost gone before I even got the chance to take a pic - Pizza Near Me - Phoenicia, New York

Forget to take a photo of the food because I was so hungry me and my family were up there for vacation and we stopped here for lunch. We were greeted by a young lady with awesome tattoos at the front told me what was good and even grabbed a box to show us how big their calzone was. And wow that thing was massive and so good me and my girlfriend split it and still didn't finish it. We had Pizzia and garlic knots as well. The service was amazing the cleanness was great and the atmosphere was amazing. If it wasn't more than 2 hours away I'd go here all the time. Family friendly everything was 5star read more

A real surprise! Great pizza and menu. Friendly service. Don't miss it! Cozy interior too.

Great addition to the area. Highest quality, excellent selection including vegetarian options. Clean, friendly, open many hours per week. Affiliated barbershop (which moved from Main St. Phoenicia) is also top notch. read more

Really good Pizza and friendly, accommodating staff. Great selection and variety as well. Heros are great as well. Really good every time!

the pizzas we ordered had a funky taste in the sauce and we both were sick with food poisoning. the pizzeria was a stop passing through to visit the famous Woodstock site. read more

Fantastic food great prices family owned stopped in on vacation staff was great food was unreal especially the cheesy garlic nots

My Wife, Daughter, and I have been staying in the Catskills for about a week and decided to do the rail explores tour. While riding down the tracks we spotted a pizzeria as we past and being from New Jersey we tend to gravitate towards pizza for some reason that I can't explain. With that being said we decided to place an order once we were done with the tour. We got a small plain for my daughter. The calzone and grandma pie were for the wife and I. The order was done quickly and the staff was very inviting and friendly. The plain pie was good, it had a nice crust and the sauce was good. The grandma was a little different than what we are used to back home but still tasty and I enjoyed the sauce on the pie, but the star of the evening was the cheese calzone. The dough was light airy and delicious, the ricotta and mozzarella were perfect. The calzone was honestly one of the best we have ever had and that's a lot of calzones in our lifetime especially being from the tri-state area. When we venture back to the Catskills we will definitely stop back in for some pizza and that perfect calzone! read more