Im going to keep this short and informative, may be an oxymoron. But overall solid first experience at thy "Pic-a-Lilli Inn", heard great things about the establishment for their wings. My coworkers and i went there one day for lunch and I was shocked to see they offer garlic paremesan wings, my favorite. They were delicious, came out hot and full of flavor. I would have given "the PIC" a 5 star rating but, they charge for blue cheese and celery? Like the great Hall of Famer Cris Carter would say, "C'Mon Man!" read more

I've been going to the Pic since high school for wings. On half days we would make the 45 minute trek out into the pine barrens to experience the best wings on earth. The Pic has the best wings around, hands-down. It's totally worth the drive from Philly or even up from the shore. I highly recommend ordering a dog bowl full of "spicy" wings, which are just the right amount of hotness mixed with a little sweetness as well. They also count 1 wing as being the drum and flapper, so 50 wings at Pic's is like 100 wings in most other bars and restaurants. The waitresses and bartenders are also extremely friendly and nice. It's pretty rare that I order anything here other than the wings because I love them so much, but any time I've ordered a sandwich, appetizer, or entrée it has also been great. Of course most meals are able to be soaked in their signature wing sauce. Well worth the drive! read more

Best wings!! Cocktails are always delicious! Best crab soup . Always a great time. Best Jeep stop there is in NJ! read more

See all

I consider myself fortunate to live close to to the Pic - but even if I had a long drive it'd still be worth it. The best wings (all their other food is excellent as well, it's just that wings are my favorite food of all time) - great service, awesome selection of beers and cocktails, and a great atmosphere to boot. I love sampling some of their special seasonal drinks - they make an awesome blueberry cocktail from fresh local blueberries when in season. All you can eat wing night is every Wednesday night - WINNING! You seriously can't go wrong here. read more

I am very sad that I ordered 50 wings and no blue cheese dressing or celery. I have been there multiple times and never had this problem. I have always given them a 4-5 stars. We were there on an off hour and maybe that's what the problem was? Next time we go there we will ask for blue cheese and celery. We live 35 minutes away so it is always special for us to go there and too far for what I believed to be included read more

I just love it here. Service is always friendly and the food is always good. My husband raves about the clams casino . he's enjoying them right now. The Tales (chicken breast buffalo style) are what keep us coming back. Tonight I'm trying the Cowboy burger. This is a down home good cooking place that is always full. Family's and friends are everywhere. read more

Awesome wings! My coworkers and I came here for Monday trivia night. There was also a BOGO wing special going. You definitely must try the wings here. I also got the pulled pork sandwich that came with sweet potato fries which was also really good. I will definitely come back here again when I'm in the area read more

Hands down the best wing sauce I've ever had. I always order the 'tails' (chicken tenders) but they also come in the wings (bone-in) and ears (cutlet) variety. Though by far my favorite is the buffalo scallops. Not something you would typically find, but definitely tasty! The crab soup and crab bread are OUTSTANDING, so I highly recommend sharing some of them with your table. Food is fresh and service is speedy. Their portion sizes are great for the price. I recommend getting a sampler or combo and sharing with the table. For me the spicy sauce (of the mild, spicy, hot and smokers) is plenty spicy for me, but I've ventured into the hot a time or two and can tolerate it. Full bar available with good variety. Atmosphere is a little daunting upon arrival, but you'll find both the staff and the locals very friendly. read more

My parents tell me that I've been coming here since I was born, so I'm excited to see that on my most recent visit (which doesn't happen enough) the quality of the food and service is still of upstanding reputation. They produce simply the best wings on Earth- and I also don't know how the rest of the country can't figure out how to make cheese sauce for cheese fries like they do at the Pic-A-Lilli (and throughout South Jersey.) This biker bar is 100% family friendly. Stop in, order an irresponsible amount of wings and fries, and make sure you wash it all down with some cold pitchers of something cheap. This is local classic that cannot be missed! read more

If you love cold beer and great wings make the drive down, you wont be dissapointed. I can't comment on the other food because I must get wings and cheese fries when im there. Staff is friendly and attentive, plenty of parking. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Salavating... - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

This is that place that should be allowed to get 10 stars. Hands down the best wings I have ever had. I drive here all the way from Langhorne, PA for the wings. I used to work in restaurants and would try my best to get my wings to taste like theirs and I never could. The waitresses are super nice but to be honest, they could make fun of me and throw the food at me and I'd still drive all the way there . I do not drink but my girlfriend was super impressed with how large the drink menu is. If you have never been here it is a MUST if you are ever in the area. read more

Wings are sooooo good , service team is friendly , family friendly , and good for a date too . Good pricing as well

Heard so much about this Inn and their food, in particular their wings. Stopped there one day for dinner and the Wings were out of this world. BUT Liked them so much we had a Super Bowl party; ordered 50 wings.... As good as they wore my first taste was as BAD as they were at our party. Friends and Relatives had a taste and ended up throwing the whole LOT out in the garbage. So, been there tried it twice.... NEVER AGAIN. read more

I went there for lunch today with my girlfriend and Mom We ordered the buffalo Mac and cheese. Not one of us liked it. It was bland and runny. I ordered the cheesesteak it was wet and no taste. My mom ordered the scallops she said it was fishy and rubbery. My girlfriend ordered a cheeseburger ordered well done the burger came out rare. The place was packed. I have no idea what people see in this place read more

I used to frequent the Pic quite a few years ago. I believe it changed hands, (i think maybe a family member took over) and began to go downhill. The wings used to be the best in size and sauce, but than they started to shrink and barely any meat on bones, which is why I had stopped going. Recently, I figured I would give them another try to see if anything has changed. Nothing has changed, the wings are so small, you would think they came off of baby chicks. read more

My word the buffalo ANYTHING here is great. Mild sauce is semi sweet and the wings are fully and meaty. Buffalo scallops............god my mouth is watering!!!! Service is great and friendly. Average priced. Full service bar. Menu is limited but anything you order you'll love. Try the seafood bisque. WOW. read more

See all

Our first time riding our bike to Picalilli. Nice night for a ride and some yummy food. There is an outdoor small bar/music area for those who want to have a drink and chill. Resturant was bustling and full of customers. We were seated promptly and all the wing sauce smells overwhelmed me. In a good way! Our server was nice and quick to supply drinks. Wife: cheese steak and onion rings Me: buffalo burger Food was hot and delicious. Wing sauce on my burger was on point. Will return! read more

Well pre ordered thinking that'd be better like lady said on phone. Ordered for 4 o clock. I get it super bowl sunday eagles in.. busy. U got there early 345 no wings... ok.. that's fine. 0445 ok where my wings I have guests at my house.. I left at 525 with my wings. When I got home.. order was wrong. Sorry but next year. Going to golden nugget. And I watched 10 other order get lost. read more

Came here for lunch on a Saturday after staying in AC for the night. The service was really good and everyone was really attentive and friendly. The food was also pretty good and the prices were reasonable. In my opinion, their "spicy medium sauce" wasn't really close to spicy so if you are a fan of spicy, get the hottest sauce possible. It always seems like this place is crowded when I pass it at night, so you might have to wait to get a table. read more

Good food served in a nice atmosphere. This place has been known for its wings as far back as I can remember. It's a good place to stop on your way from one place to another using 206. Lots of friendly bikers during riding season. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Buffalo chicken egg rolls. YUM!! - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Great spot to ride to from philly. Take about an hour. Great wings and they have a cool outdoor area with a bar and live music. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Awesome spot for live music and outside bar. - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

By far the best wings around! That's unanimous with my family of 6. A lot of people like the wings at the Golden Nugget, but I didn't like them. The wings here blow the Nugget out of the water! This place is worth the trip for my family. I like the fact that this place hasn't changed. It's a true piney experience. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Enjoying some wings at the pic - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Passed this place a gazillion times going down the shore and finally stopped in this past Sunday. The Pic Burger was great! (how could it not be when you add pork roll to it). It was a little chilly sitting outside (inside was at capacity), but looks to be a fun place to be in warmer weather. We will be back! read more

we have driven by this place a number of times going to a c and after reading about their wings we made the stop. it was well worth it! it was a monday so it's bogo. (by one get one). and if you think that wings can't fill you up you are sadly mistaken. the sauce is pretty much like everyone else's but the chicken has a different flavor. it actually HAS flavor! maybe because the chickens are kosher has something to do with it. met bonnie who is the fifth generation owner of the place and she could not have been any more welcoming! the atmosphere is warm and comfortable. inside is a fireplace and a fish tank and a pool table that only adds to the comfortable ambience this is a local place and most of the patrons the staff knew by name and habits. the tvs were on to local stations, sport chanel's, and news and business. the best part is that tap beers were served in a frosted glass. i had a modelo negro draft and my husband had yeunling draft of course we had to have two! i had the buffalo wing basket and my husband the 5 ears that came with 5 wings because of the bogo. plus the four beers and our total came to $31 not including tip there is an outside area with picnic tables and an outdoor bar which wasn't open on monday but looks like it would be a lot of fun when it's open. we won't be passing up this place again and will keep it on our party route to ac! read more

Probably thee worst bar food I ever had in my life. By the radio advertisements I would have thought they had the best wings in NJ. The wings were so small and so over cooked I could barely chew them, the cheese sauce horrible. The salad was so old we could not eat it. Never again, if you want good wings go to the jug handle, blows this place out of the water.... read more

Omg-this place is AWFUL. Waited over an hour for wings-the table next to us ordered at the same time, ordered wings-but they know the owner so they got their food and ate and left before we even got our appetizers. Will NEVER come back. Do not waste your time -not prepared, not staffed. Rude. Awful service-even worse explanation. People next to us waited 45 minutes for a side salad. Go up the road to Applebee's-save yourself the aggravation. If I could give it ZERO stars, I would. Perfect example of a business that can't overcome the struggle of COVID. #AdmitDefeat #EpicFail The irony in this whole incident is that the owner (fifth generation) was eating under her mask and joking about it as she helped to bus tables and run food. Must be nice...maybe she should take the same care to feed her paying guests...yes, we still paid. The owner was 'gracious' enough to comp our drinks-but still charged us for the food that we were forced to take out after waiting almost 90 minutes. #customerservicesucks read more

waitresses are obviously unfriendly to non-white people!! She brought up our checks right after the meal came up. but at the same time, courteously asked the other couple the next table, whom already finished their meal.. may I bring up your check? What the..... read more

I live in Tabernacle so I get them often any parties that are happening around here always has pic wings great flavor!!!! Only bad thing I would say is wings need to be more meaty!!! which is easy to switch but price go up! But I would pay that for a better quality wing as in more meat on those bones read more

Don't give them your credit card information over the phone they steal it and purchase YETI items. I know because it was the only place I gave my credit card information over the phone for an order. Thief's shame on them. read more

The wing sauce is crave worthy. The chicken itself is very crisp and well cooked. Delicious.

Love this place BUT they hurry the food to turnover the tables. As a result, the awesome tasting wings can sometimes not b cooked crispy. My husband had the rv burger--it was grey (no char from grill or however they r cooking them) horrible tasting, bloody grease made the roll soggy. Very disappointing. Again, love the place but i would stick with the wings and ask for them crispy. Waitresses and bartenders were spot on. read more

Landmark - and - Best local place in the area for wings and a bite to eat. Perfect example of a local family-owned business that understands how to run a great business! They have a great friendly staff, fast service, the best wings bar-none and to top it off....they do it all with great prices. We always stop for wings "to-go" for trips to the shore, and they never fail to be the best wings. My daughters have grown up looking forward to a stop at Pic-A-Lilli's. They also have a private room for group gatherings. Love Russells Pic II as well. read more

This is a fantastic local spot. We each got the wings after reading the reviews and they were great. Each wing is a full wing (most places would say it's two wings because it's the wing and drumstick) so it's a good value for the price. The sauces all taste homemade. We tried the mild and the spicy, we preferred the spicy because it was more flavorful. We also ordered a side of the garlic Parmesan sauce which was packed with flavor. Another thing we especially enjoyed was the homemade blue cheese, if your order doesn't come with it, it's worth the extra 50 cents. We also each ordered a beer that was perfectly chilled on a hot summer day. We take off a star because we tried a small portion of the scallops and found them disappointing, definitely stay with the wings. And we wish they backed the sauce into the wings, instead of just pouring it on top, that would take it up to five stars. Overall, the place has wonderful food and atmosphere complete with local acoustic music. We would love to visit again. read more

Really fun restaurant bar now owned by the 5th generation Portion size of the food were generous and tasty with friendly waitress service. The atmosphere was fun and lively. A must read more

We went here on a Friday afternoon. The place was not full yet, so you would expect pretty attentive service, but we got the opposite. The waitress was quick to take our order, but did not check back very often. We had to ask the hostess to get our waitress a few times. She also did not tell us about the bogo special for wings even though we ordered a wing platter. If we had know about the wing bogo we would have just ordered them instead of the platter. A friend joined us and we told him about the special and he ordered it. He asked for mild and we got hot because the wait staff picked up the wrong order. The wings were good, but I have had just as good at other bars. Not overly impressed with this restaurant. read more

The best buffalo wings, tails, sea food in the area!!! Alabama slammers is my favorite drink there!

The Pic is always crowded, and at times, ridiculously crowded, which I can't understand because I've never had anything better than mediocre. read more

Love this place! It's always busy which tells you they are consistently good at what they do! Some interesting characters but always a good time. read more

The Pics wing sauce is worth a trip to South Jersey no matter where you live. I have lived in Philadelphia for a few years now, and I have not found a wing that could even relate to Pic's wings. The tavern is nothing to even mention. Hell, buy them from the little truck they bring to fairs. They will still be superior to any wings you can find in any "Gastropub". Be warned there is probably a stick of butter per ten wings in the sauce....but heart transplants are pretty common these days. So set your GPS and go to the sticks for some wings, I have a feeling it won't be your only trip. read more

Used to be good. Going down hill lately. Ordered ears, boneless breaded wings, they were so over cooked and greasy i couldn't eat them. For an extra charge you can have celery and blue cheese, had to send celery back it was brown and slimy. It was bogo so i got a free small, 6, order of wings. By small order i thought they meant amount not size of wing. They could have come from a pigeon. We sat at a high top in bar area and our server was one of the bar tenders. Not the friendliest person, the woman that brought our food out was much more accommodating and got our drink refills since we were sitting with empty glasses, she may have been the owner or manager. Won't stop again for awhile. read more