What a happy accident lol. We took a wrong turn and found this place by accident. As soon as you walk in, it smells delicious! We ordered Pierogis to go. Will definitely be back read more

See all

Awesome place for pierogis. So many options, great service and most importantly, great pierogis. Nice space to get together with friends. Very warm and welcoming. We had a big group and the owner was very accommodating. It's not easy pleasing a large group of 55 year old women but they did! Forgot to take pictures but I'm sure you can see others posted. Solid, authentic pierogis. read more

Pierogi lovers, take note--this meal was pure comfort done right. To start, we split the the potato latkes and they were outstanding: perfectly crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and clearly made with perfection. I have had my fair share of latkes, and these were some of the best I have ever had. For an entree, I had 4 pan fried pierogis. The goat cheese and arugula pierogis were the surprise hit--creamy, tangy goat cheese balanced beautifully by the arugula, all wrapped in delicate, pierogi. I didn't think I would love these as much as I did, but they were great. My friend got the kielbasa and pierogi plate and it looked amazing. The classic potato pierogis delivered exactly what you want from a traditional favorite: rich, hearty, and deeply satisfying. Paired with the kielbasa potato pancake, the dish leaned fully into bold, savory flavors, with the kielbasa adding a smoky depth that elevated every bite. The sourcrout bright, tangy contrast to the richness of the meal and kept it from feeling too heavy. An additional plate we ordered was the Zbójnickie Pierogi Skillet and that has quickly become a favorite. It comes with jalapenos, sour cream, pierogis and kielbasa which all has a wonderful flavor in every single bite. For dessert, we both had cheese blintzes with raspberry sauce and it was crispy and delicious. Overall, this was a comforting, well-balanced spread that honors tradition while still offering thoughtful, flavorful twists. The service was quick and even though the place was packed, our server was very attentive and gave us great recommendations. Definitely a place worth returning to. read more

See all

Both food and service were excellent. It brought me back to my food roots. Place is conveniently located. Loved the wide variety of pierogies. read more

Outstanding pierogis! I was going to take my parents to Nan Xiang Soup Dumplings in Westbury, however they put pork in most of their soup dumplings. Shrimp... with pork. Crab... with pork. Enter Pierogibites, a much more vegetarian-friendly restaurant. The servers were attentive and the ambiance was casual. My Asian parents are kind of picky eaters, they're the type of people who travel to Paris then only eat Chinese food while they're there (Why on Earth would you go to one of the culinary capitals of the world and not eat French food?!?). Instead of Chinese dumplings, we opted to go the Eastern European route and my parents were very impressed with this restaurant. I ordered the 8 pierogis and ordered 7 different vegetarian pierogis (Potato Classic, Mac & Cheese, Sweet Cheese, Sweet Potato, Sauerkraut and Mushroom, Arugula Goat Cheese, and Blueberry). I doubled up on the Sauerkraut and Mushroom pierogi. I opted to have my pierogis boiled and they were all served to me on a single plate with caramelized onions on top and sour cream on the side. The restaurant's menu says they import flour from Poland, that's probably why their pierogis feel like a warm hug inside your mouth. Now the fun part, Ukranian Roulette with pierogis. Slice into each one and reveal the surprise filling. Here's my ranking of all 7 pierogis that I tried: 1) Sauerkraut and Mushroom - the pierogi that I doubled up on ended up being my favorite. Great balance of flavors. 2) Potato Classic - classic for a reason. No frills pierogi that was perfectly cooked. 3) Sweet Cheese - really rich and cream cheese filling. Delicious! 4) Sweet Potato - this one surprised me. They cooked the sweet potato filling with cinnamon and maybe nutmeg so it has a nice fall flavor. If I ever come back here in the fall, these would be my "go to" pierogis. 5) Arugula and Goat Cheese - a very solid pierogi 6) Blueberry - a sweet dessert pierogi, the pierogi that I saved to eat last. It's not a bad pierogi by any means, but I overall prefer the savory pierogis. 7) Mac & Cheese - my 9-year-old son's favorite pierogi was my least favorite pierogi. Something about biting through a pierogi, then finding another food made from dough (macaroni). Yummy, but definitely better pierogis on the menu. I would try it once, just like you would try the newest food item released at Taco Bell. Overall, I would absolutely dine here again. Best pierogis that I've ever had. read more

Pierogibites & More - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

9.13.25. Goulash was bland and arrived cold. Odd because dining room was empty at the time. Meat was far from tender. Mashed potatoes were tasty. Our server said it was his second day but was nice. Not running back. read more

See all

My wife and I came here for an after work date. She is polish so has moments of wanting a full polish meal and this place did not disappoint. The food was absolutely delicious. We got the kopytka with mushroom sauce, pan fried pierogis (potato classic, sauerkraut & mushrooms, sweet cheese, and blueberry), and the chicken Kiev. The only thing my wife wasn't a huge fan of was the sauerkraut and mushrooms pierogis. We will definitely be back!! read more

See all

We loved this place. Pierogies were home cooked (yes, i know its a restaurant but they were just like as if they were made in your mom's kitchen), borscht soup was very good and we enjoyed the other staples with my only critique the stuffed cabbage. Still good just not too hot and seemed to be missing something so maybe i'm spoiled. Service was definitely friendly but scarce, and food took considerable time but if you can manage that, its a meal worth waiting for!!! Nice to have something different so close. I hope they stay the course and figure it all out as nothing within 20 minutes or more depending on time of day I can think of but i'm always open to suggestion! read more

Went here with a friend after getting a recommendation to try this place. We loved the dining space, modern but warm and inviting. The food was really good. Which each got a pierogi and kielbasa platter with different types of pierogis to try. The server was super nice and helpful. He explained a few different things on the menu that we had never heard of before. We both decided that we wanted to go back again to try other things. The only reason I gave it 4 stars, is because it was on the higher priced side. read more

The vibe is amazing! The service is really good for customers ,and food amazing overall great place read more

See all

I can't speak for authenticity, but these pierogis were delicious. Got an order of 8 and mixed and matched the classic potato with sauerkraut and mushrooms, goat cheese and arugula and sweet cheese. The pierogis are soft, chewy and pillowy. My favorite of the bunch being the goat cheese: it gave it that necessary tangy flavor with no sour cream needed. The sauerkraut and mushroom was also a surprise hit, it feels lighter than most pierogis and has such an earthy flavor; truly unique. My order was takeout but, if you walk inside, its clean, spacious and has plenty of seating. If it weren't so far from my hometown, I would definitely come back to try some more traditional Polish offerings! read more

Pierogibites & More - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Went on a Saturday night as a party of four. The restaurant looks modern and classy with some cute decorations. There aren't many tables so a reservation may be preferred. We were able to get a table without one at 6:00, but the place was full as we were leaving. The service was friendly and attentive. Now that we've got that out of the way, let's talk about what we're all interested in...the pierogis. They offer several varieties with your choice of boiled or pan-fried. Everyone in our party got a platter that allowed you to choose a variety and was accompanied with Kielbasa and other sides. The highlights were the classic potato and the meat. Personally, I enjoyed the buffalo chicken as well. The jalapeño and cheddar were a special the night we went and were also enjoyed by all. In general, there were no complaints about any of the pierogis. The Ukrainian Borscht was delicious as well. As far as beverages, you're mostly limited to beer and wine. I did enjoy the Zywiec (Polish beer) quite a bit. It's got a lager vibe. This was our first time here, but won't be our last. If you're in the mood for sausage and pierogis, you won't be let down. read more

So we tried again. And once again threw most of it out. Yeah, servings were big. Which often seems the basis of a lot of positive reviews of restaurants on LI. I thought one 4 star review here was revealing: they liked everything but the food. The food. Overcooked, too thick, doughy boring tasting pierogis, overcooked noodles in the chicken noodle soup, overcooked something else pasta based. The pierogis were also pan fried and...some were really, really, brown. I only know what the meat filling tasted like because I did not taste the others (and I didn't like it). Gee, you'd think that a restaurant that specializes in pasta dishes would know how long to cook their pasta. The soup stock and raspberry sauce were good. Nope, not trying again. read more

This was my first time eating in at Pierogi Bites in Bellmore. The first time I ordered from here was takeout, and that's when I realized I really only enjoy the potato pierogies -- I wasn't a fan of the other varieties. This visit, we went with a traditional Polish dinner: pierogies, kielbasa, and gołąbki (Polish-style stuffed cabbage with seasoned meat filling). The flavors were what you'd expect from a typical Polish restaurant -- somewhat plain and not heavily seasoned, but still comforting and satisfying overall. The gołąbki was actually the largest portion on the plate and probably the highlight of the meal. Where it fell short was the portion size, especially for the $30 price point. The kielbasa was about a 6-inch piece that had been sliced in half lengthwise. Unfortunately, cutting it that way really took away a lot of the juiciness and flavor -- it lost that snap and richness you expect from a good kielbasa. A full piece instead of one cut in half would have made a noticeable difference. The plate came with just three potato pierogies, and they were on the smaller side -- honestly about on par with Mrs. T's. And most Polish people will tell you Mrs. T's are actually better than a lot of homemade pierogies. For $30, five pierogies instead of three would have felt much more reasonable. Service was okay but clearly inexperienced -- it seemed like younger staff who need a bit more training. We were never asked if we wanted anything to drink besides water, weren't offered a dessert menu, and when the food first came out, the gołąbki had the wrong sauce on it and had to be corrected. Overall, the food was decent and satisfying, but between the small portions and the service issues, it felt underwhelming for the price. It was okay -- just not sure I'd go back again. read more

Great place to try polish food , food was good the zapiekanka was great , we celebrated my mom birthday she was very happy , service was great 2 boys did great job , very authentic place definitely will be back . read more

See all

I was really torn between 3&4 stars because there were definitely short comings in this experience but also successes. Let's start off with ambiance, it is very cozy spot on the corner next to the train station with a decent amount of seating. Two staff members manning the floor and counter together, very polite and pleasant. Now the juicy part. The food. Pelmeni - ordered them boiled. Was fairly disappointed. Filling was too firm and felt like it lacked seasoning. Portion size and size of the actual pelmeni was fair. Hungarian goulash- this was disappointing as well. Great large portion however lacking in flavor. Adding salt didn't really bring anything out in it Bigos - the combination of cabbage and sausage. This was successful. Large portion. Nicely flavored and a pleasure to eat Borscht - seemed like someone had an accident when making this and dumped way too much sugar in there. Typically this sort of soup isn't sweetened. This one was overly sweet. Aside from the sweetness the flavor was there and the vm beets, potatoes and meat really brought home that expectation of what the soup should be. Am I going back? Yes. Maybe the chef had a bad day. Yes I'll probably try completely different things next time and hopefully give this place a full 5 stars. I recommend trying this restaurant because they have the food that is nearly impossible to find anywhere else on this island read more

My partner in crime wanted stuffed cabbage for his birthday so his wish was my command!! We went on a Friday night and walked into an empty restaurant. Very clean and modern looking.. the waitress was very nice and seated us. I got potato pancakes and a cheese blintz Absolutely delicious, and portions were large. I took home 1/2 of my dinner to eat the next day. The waitress was very nice, answered all of our questions, didn't rush. There was us and another table with a large party but she kept checking in on us to see if we needed anything. The place is small so I think she was the only waitress but still gave us the attention we needed. Sorry for the choppy review, started it and forgot about it. All in all, I would definitely go back to try some of the other things on the menu. read more

Pierogibites & More - Table - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Amazing place. Great food. Amazing service and fun place to be. It was unexpectedly good!! The place was full and everyone seemed to be happy being there including staff. This s the type of place you want to be. I'm looking forward to my next visit read more

One of my favorite restaurants. You can tell this is family owned and the pierogies and borscht soup are delicious. There's really nowhere nearby like it read more

We love this place so much. We're part polish and I consider myself a tough critic when it comes to this cuisine but they knock it out of the park every single time. I've ordered at least 10 times and every time it's consistent, fresh, hot, and tasty. I always get the stuffed cabbage. It is perfection. Also for the price, the portion is large. The meat is tender and flavorful and the tomato sauce has the perfect amount of zip. The kopytka are just like jumbo gnocchi and the creamy mushroom sauce is addicting. And their pierogies are amazing. The only thing I don't like is how many bay leaves I come across while eating because they're unsafe to consume and should be removed before serving. read more

Pierogibites & More - Stuffed cabbage, pierogies (cheese and potato), kopytka with mushroom sauce, and matzah ball soup. - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Went there on a date with my wife. We drove over 40 minutes. We waited over 20 minutes for a table. After all that. They did not have white or Ukrainian Borscht soup. What a let down. It was only a little past 6pm. read more

You can't go wrong with this place. Stopped for lunch and what a wonderful experience. The was fabulous. The service was amazing & the place (although small) you will enjoy the experience. So much favor & large portions. I highly recommend you try the pierogi's. read more

Food was delicious and with large serving sizes. The mushroom pierogi were my favorite. Mac and cheese pierogi were popular with the big kids. Kielbasa pieces were like the "old fashion" long sausages from the Brooklyn Polish meat markets. The stuffed cabbage was humoungus, probably 6" long. I wasn't sure if the filling had rice or mash potatoes but it was light and "fluffy" for its size. No raisins in it. The staff were friendly and helpful. The ambiance was modern and beautifully designed. Would definitely make the trip instead of purchasing the frozen ones at the Polish markets. read more

Pierogibites & More - POLISH PLATTER DINNER - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Ordered from the apps last night as they don't have a direct delivery. I called and asked. May have gone in to eat, but really not feeling too well. So pierogi seemed like something I could stomach - perfect comfort food. Ordered a dozen fried, four boiled, 'grilled' kielbasa, chicken noodle soup, and four potato pancakes (three and one) so we could each have one - with app delivery came to $92 that's a lot of money for peasant Polish food - beware, the delivery app price is higher and that doesn't even count the fees assessed from the apps. The same order adds up to $62 from their menu online - https://www.pierogibites.com/menu. The kielbasa was pictured with delicious grill marks and looked nice and crispy. Instead what showed up was a scored sausage that didn't taste grilled at all. The fried pierogi and potato pancakes arrived in air tight containers which steamed the food to an unappetizing soggy state. They had to be touched up in the air fryer, no problem. The potato pancakes are humongous, easily splittable for a person or three. So we over ordered those. The food is definitely handmade with love, and I would probably go dine-in in the future for a better experience. While I was able to stomach the food, I couldn't stomach the delivery price. read more

See all

This place was amazing! So cute inside and food was so authentic and delicious. Our waitress was so sweet and the food came out really quick. Left feeling so full but not heavy like after a big meal at most places. I can't wait to go again and try more things on the menu. read more

Pierogibites & More - Kielbasa & Pierogi Plate - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Tasteless food . Not right temperature. Very bland . There's was nothing there that appeled to us at all

Really good!! We had pork and potato. Fun ambiance too. Take some home to enjoy later. 9/9/25. read more

Where to begin? Let's start with the obvious, pierogi. Their pierogi are almost as good as moms. The farmers cheese crepes, nalisniki are to die for. Can't tell mom, but they are lighter and fluffier than moms. The service is fantastic, waitstaff attentive but not annoying and very funny. Decor is nice and clean, crisp aesthetic. It's worth the drive! EDIT: took my 91 year old mom who usually hates all food she didn't make herself and she actually loved it! She said the Pyzi was different than hers but very light and tasty. For a woman who has always made everything from scratch this is a tremendous compliment. She even said she's looking forward to going back soon.... This is a first! lol read more

Delicious food, great atmosphere. Great service. Pickle soup rocks! Will definitely be back! read more

The service and food were amazing. So many options on the menu. Food is authentic and great quality!

Just moved from Lido Beach. Walked in and ordered with the waiter/host. Place is small but nicely furnished. Got 2 orders of pierogis with sour cream and onions. Should have gotten three!! Really good. Just like grandma. Also got the kielbasa plate and a Hungarian goulash which came with homemade polish gnocchi. This place will be on the rotation read more

I went for a birthday dinner since I requested stuffed cabbage. Cozy spot in downtown Bellmore, (parking can be tricky) very hip, big order desk with easy to read menu selections on the wall. spartan dining area comfortable and immaculately clean, not fancy. We knew we were in a legit place as there were several tables of families speaking Polish. I ordered the Polish platter, kielbasa, 3 pirogies, and the stuffed cabbage I needed to comp,etc my Birthday. Was very happy with stuffed cabbage and my pirogies and cabbage, their house red cabbage and horseradish side is fantastic ! They have 6 or more pirogies to choose from, I really enjoyed the meat one I ordered. On my rotation now of go to places to eat ! read more

The restaurant was cold the evening we went because there are two doors in two spots of the restaurant. I suggest keeping the side door shut. read more

The culinary skill on display here is remarkable. I was pleased with my time here. The quality here is remarkable. Employees here showed warmth toward every customer. The spot maintains good service. read more

I have been trying to get to this restaurant and finally made the time to go this afternoon for lunch with my husband. I am so glad we did!!! It is a small place very nicely decorated and super clean!! The waitress was so sweet and attentive. Try the cherry nectar drink, was so tasty. The pan fried Arugula & Goat Cheese was great! Smooth and creamy with a nice crunch! The Ukrainian Borscht was delicious. My husband used super picky and loved it! After we left, we are still talking about this restaurant! read more

See all

The food offers taste perfection alongside service perfection. My taste buds thank me for this experience. They succeed in all areas from dishes to surroundings. Staff demonstrates expertise alongside warm service. This spot brings visitors to the neighborhood. read more

I ordered Almost every type of the pierogie on the menu. Delicious. There are so many entree choices that I adore and I will return to try them all as well. Staff is phenomenal. Decor is airy, lovely and inviting. I highly recommend if this place is on your list as it was on mine. Glad I took the time to stop by. read more

Pierogibites & More - Cozy alcove - Polish Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Listen, Pierogibites...I wanted to love you. I wanted to really like you. I wanted to at least feel like I could return to you, and yet, months after initially visiting you, I just don't think I shall be returning. Yep, despite everything that sounds so great about this Polish Bellmore storefront, I just don't think it lived up to any hype. The hype for me came from a combo of a coworker telling me about the place and from good ol' Yelp reviews rounding things out to a legit 4.7 stars with 63 reviews. It was enough for my wife and I, with slightly hungry stomachs, to meander into 'bites after visiting a few stores nearby. Honestly, we probably should've/would've taken our grub to go if we lived a little closer, but instead we sat down...well after it was a little confusing in the setup of how things worked. The girls behind the counter took us to a table and gave us menus, but after doing this and sitting for a few minutes then told us we have to order at the counter. I'm fine with that, but I was a little thrown for their process. Plus, on this warm late June day, the place definitely didn't have any air conditioning (or it was super weak). The interior wasn't stifling, but it was warm enough to make us a little uncomfortable while we ate. What did we eat? Well the menu specializes in Polish-Ukrainian cuisine so there are plenty of food choices that fall into that realm of edible options. For us, we decided to order the grilled polish kielbasa, an 8 piece order of pierogis, and the potato pancakes. Before going any further, another small gripe I had was that the potato pancakes were legit huge (albeit pretty tasty), but when we ordered, we were trying to decide between getting the side order potato pancake (just one) or the full order (which turned out to be three). It would've been nice, as we stood at the counter and asked the girls that worked there, if they had mentioned how massive these suckers were, because then perhaps we would've ordered the single one. It helps to be informative when you work at a food establishment...just sayin'. Though like I mentioned, the pancakes were quite enjoyable so having to take them home and reheat them the next day wasn't a horrible task. What was more of a letdown were a majority of the pierogis and the kielbasa. I'll give Pierogibites props for allowing us to mix and match from their pierogi flavors, but most of what we ate (potato, meat, sauerkraut/mushroom) weren't anything special. The arugula and goat cheese choice was probably the best, but one flavor can't save you. And the kielbasa, despite the beautiful presentation, just didn't have much flavor. I've had store bought kielbasa that is much more tasty than this one. Sigh. Overall, maybe I'm crazy. I don't like to be the black sheep reviewer who goes against the excitement of others as well as the positive Yelp scores this spot holds, but Pierogibites just felt like it missed the mark. It had all the makings of a place that could've and should've been better, but the warm space, confusing staff, and hit or miss food just makes it something that I can't warrant a return trip to. Sorry. read more

See all

Wow! After MONTHS of wanting to try this place i finally got to with my friend today and it did not disappoint! It was so chic and beautiful inside. Not what I expected at all. Carolina, the waitress, was so friendly. And then there's the food. I got the seasonal squash soup which was so tasty and seasoned perfectly and for pierogi, i did pan fried: classic potato, sweet potato, bacon/egg/cheese, & blueberry and the standout was def the sweet potato. I would order 100 more. Will absolutely be back! read more

See all

I heard so much about this place and it did not disappoint. The food is fresh and delicious, the service was fantastic and it's very cute and comfortable. We went with our one year old granddaughter and they gave us some children's books to occupy her. The pierogis were light and delicious, the potato pancakes and the cheese blintzes with raspberry sauce were the best I ever had. Go with an empty stomach, you'll leave full. I cannot wait to go back. read more

See all