The pizza is awesome and the selection of beer on tap is extensive. Definitely worth the trip!

Poor service, poor quality of food. Tried this establishment on several occasions, disaster each time. Simply put I drive past it now wondering how they keep the lights and and hoping they don't they give Fayetteville, WV a bad name. How can you be so good at one and so terrible at another. read more

Pies & Pints is one of my favorite pizza places. I first discovered Pies and Pints when rockclimbing at the New River Gorge in Fayetteville, WV, which is their first location. I've never been disappointed with their pizzas. They serve hand-tossed pizzas and the crusts has a garlic seasoning. So good! I usually prefer thick crust pizzas with tomato sauce, but their Mushroom & Garlic pizza and their Steak & Mushroom pizza is to die for! They use actual steak and it isn't overcooked or dry. Every time I go to Pies and Pints, I tell myself to try a new topping, but always end up getting one of the two. Can't help it. I am a mushroom lover! I've also tried the Thai pizza, which has shrimp and coconut curry. It was good, but I'm not crazy for sweet pizzas. If you get a large pizza, you can get half toppings. They also have a great selection of craft beer! The bartenders are also very knowledgeable with their beers. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

See all

Went to this place hours after the mask mandate. There was a 45 min wait bc everything in this town is closed on Mondays and everyone decided to go here with all of the Covid closures. We waited only 25 min, had some good beers while we waited. These employees were busting butt to make everything run smooth and they did a great job. We had chargrilled chicken wings with a Gorgonzola dipping sauce, 1 pizza 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 cheese for the kids and a white pizza with steak. This white pizza was awesome. Roasted garlic and delicious ricotta. Excellent! Highly recommend. read more

I love pies and pints! During normal lunchtimes (non-COVID) you can get a slice of pizza and a side salad for a relatively cheap lunch. Some of my favorites are the white pizza and antipasti salad. The salad has all kinds of goodies like salami, peppers, olives, cheese, etc. Their house vinaigrette is also delicious. Decent draft and drink menu as well! I enjoy sitting in the outdoor patio if open. read more

We've had good meals at Pies and Pints in Fayetteville and Charleston, but this restaurant does not live up to the reputation. Service was friendly but it was downhill from there; we were seated at a dirty table, my salad (wilted and sad looking) was served without dressing and my husband's cheesesteak sandwich had tough, almost inedible, meat. The final insult was watery iced tea. There are much better choices for dining in Morgantown. read more

Zero complaints! Our waitress was super attentive. Our food was really good and our glasses never went empty. The beer was great. I felt that the table and facility was clean and proper measurements were taken to ensure everyone was safe. It's a bit different to eat in a restaurant with takeout containers or plastic ware but that's just the new normal now. We're from out of town so returning often won't be easy but next time we pass through, we're definitely stopping back in! read more

See all

FOOD IS AMAZING. Ordered a CYO pizza and it was to die for. Alex our server was busy but he still did a good job. Great atmosphere and good bar! read more

Great place to eat! I love the chicken Gouda pizza. Mostly do take out. I need this to be 85 characters.

The music was too loud. The crotons were like rocks. The pizza was burned on the bottom. The manager did not charge us for the meal. We will try this place again. read more

See all

Came here for the first time in September when visiting the area. I have to say, this was unexpectedly the best pizza I've ever had. I ordered a mushroom pizza along with the grape & gorgonzola pizza. Now, I love mushrooms - foraging them, cooking them, eating them, learning about them! So I was surprised when the grape & gorgonzola pizza knocked it out of the park. I ate the grape pizza and my friend ate the mushroom! Wish they had a location in Maryland or closer to the DC area! read more

Solid pizza, interesting options as far as toppings, and the crust was excellent. Great service, even for a very busy time (move in weekend at WVU). Good place to get some pizza and drinks. read more

Great place. Great food. I suggest the Italian pizza. Cheap beer. Overall a good place to go.

Good pizza and awesome selection on beers good service that's really that place in a nut shell I recommend 100%

Best pizza in WV- chicken and gorgonzola cheese...yummy. Only wish we had one back home

I had the simple salad to start with both dressings because I couldn't decide on one. Great starter salad ... keep the Gorgonzola dressing to dip your pizza crust in! I also had a small pepperoni. Yes, I know it's basic. It's my go-to at all pizza places so that I have a baseline comparison. I thought the pepperoni was good quality but it couldn't have been cooked just a touch longer. I sat at the bar, and the bartender was great. Between my leaking glass and spilling oily dressing all over the place. Check it out, Morgantown! read more

Very tasty pizza with an above average specialty pizza selection on menu. 10" pizza is perfect individual size and 16" size is great for two to split. read more

The selection of pizza is great. The beer is trendy. The price is a little higher than average for the quality, but not ridiculous. There is not a lot of open seating inside, but there is outdoor seating as well. read more

They were open with no air conditioning in 85-degree weather. I felt badly for the staff. A waiter said it had been going on for days.

If there was a Pies & Pints in my town it would be my regular pizza joint. Great selection of pies and brews. The name says it all and a cool name it is. The staff is friendly and attentive without hovering over the table, great with selections and a smile. Kaylee was our server and if we lived here I would ask to sit in her section, like I said, friendly and helped with our pizza design. Hubby is the beer guy and he was in heaven trying to figure out a beer to try. read more

Pies & Pints - Beers and hydration - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

See all

10 stars on service alone!!! These pies are unreal. A light-pillowy crust with a good balance of cheese, sauce, and fresh ingredients. Packed full of flavor! We had margherita and chicken goulda specialty pies. The only thing that topped the food was the service! I wish I could remember our server's name, but she was phenomenal. The place was in the middle of a lunch rush on a nice day and our server still took her time to go over the menu and make recommendations. She never rushed us and even took it upon herself to bring us a sample of Gorgonzola sauce, just because she thought it paired nicely with our pizzas. Good general atmosphere with a nice outdoor patio. Hope to be back! read more

Best pizza! Its the crust that makes this place so good! If you like pizza & unique toppings, then this is the pizza for you! Also get the wings! Beer list is fantastic too! read more

Amazing food. Love the drafts and goat cheese app and Cuban pizza are delicious! Highly recommend

We love this place, great food, great beer on tap choices, and friendly staff. Always a terrific experience.

Great beer and pizza. I don't recommend the salad. The lettuce was nasty. The server acknowledged this, took the salad away, but did not remove the charge from our bill. read more

The best pizza and atmosphere combination ever! Love this place for family meals or beers with friends!

This place came highly recommended, so was my first stop on a recent business trip. I was able to get a table quickly (week night), and service was on point throughout the night, with regular check-ins and lots of great suggestions. Server was happy to let me try samples of a few beers to help me figure out what I wanted, and they had a nice and varied selection - definitely something for everyone. The pizza was the star here, and really delivered on flavor. I opted for a small (personal) pizza with pepperoni and olives, and it came completely covered in pepperoni - really nice. They have a wide selection of specialty pies as well, if you don't go the build your own route. The crust was crisp and flavorful - you definitely wanted to eat every piece - and the pie itself was perfectly done. Easy to see why this is a favorite in the Morgantown area. Would definitely be back! read more

Have only ever gotten Togo here but even that impresses. The creamy Gorgonzola dressing with their salad and wings is simply amazing (I always have to get an extra side of it). The wings have a great flavoring on them too. Most often we get the white pizza which is quite yummy. Want to try the cauli crust next time! read more

Fab time at P&P thanks to Erin. She helped us choose beverages and made sure our first time was amazing. Food was incredible, too, so thanks loads to those in the kitchen. Definitely recommend and if you go, try the Gorgonzola Dip!!! It is to die for. read more

We absolutely loved the "outdoor" seating option. It was just 3 of us and we had the entire patio to ourselves. They had the heat on, since it was cold outside, and it was great! The pizzas are ginormous, and so are the salads. You can even do a 1/2 & 1/2 on the pies and it works out great for everyone at the table! Also plenty to go home. Great place, great food an extensive beer list, and great friends to share it with! read more

We have ordered take out/pick up many times from here and the last 3 times it has been horrible. However, to support locally owned, we keep trying. There were no toppings on any of the pizzas! I'm talking about pizzas and salads for 12 people. We ordered 2 hours ahead to be sure they were ready. They were. But the pizzas (6 different kinds) were each and every one lacking toppings. We ordered extra basil on all of them, and there might have been 3-4 little basil leaves? The Margharita pizza is a joke. Not edible even for hungry teenagers. There was nothing on it at all, it was thrown in the trash immediately. we would love to be able to order from here but this was our last time. and this is the only negative review I have ever taken the time to post but honestly, it was horrible. Just awful. So sorry you guys can't make decent any kind of pizzas. read more

Delicious food and great service! You won't be disappointed! My favorites are the wings, Greek salad and oh course the pizza!

Awesome pie. Very pronounced fennel in the house made sausage which I loved. They forgot one ingredient on the pizza and fell all over themselves to fix it. Great service Good selection of local beer and a very knowledgeable bartender. Sorry we were just passing through otherwise this place would be a regular. read more

The food is excellent! Service is great. The space is great for adults and kids, always happy with the food, great options, also healthy choices which is so hard to find in restaurants read more

Stopped here on our way to Cooper's Rock. Delicious wood fired pizza, outdoor patio seating and lots of beer options! Our waitress was friendly and helpful with the menu since we had never been there. Our food came out quickly and was hot and fresh. Great place to grab some pies and pints! Would definitely come back if we are in the area again! read more

Pies & Pints - Grape and Gorgonzola - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

First time here. Came in from Vegas. Wanted something my husband and I could both enjoy. He loves pizza. I love beer. Staff was very accommodating as the UFC fights were on and they changed some TVs for us. Very good view from the booths. Nice craft beer (and NOT craft beer) selection. The Simple Salad with gorgonzola dressing was excellent. The nachos were delicious, and huge!! The Classic pizza was excellent. We got the small and glad we did. The crust was thin and crispy but not burnt. We always ask for light sauce on pizza. It was so delicious. Our server was so patient and friendly. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

Love it here. A little loud, but we normally come here for a party of some sort. The waitresses we had were very kind and attentive. Our pizzas were excellent. Our wings were to die for. I just wish I hadn't gotten the flu bug the morning of our event. I don't drink beer, but if you do there were several crafts and drafts available. read more

"What're you doing here!?" That great feeling when you see a good friend, and you weren't expecting it. I pulled into Morgantown and saw a Pies and Pints by my hotel. I smiled, "What are you doing here!?" I adore this place. When I lived in gorgeous WV I frequented the Fayetteville location. The one in Morgantown has a different vibe...but same great freaking fantastic food. This one is more industrial modern, Fayetteville is more of a local cool hippy feel. Anyway- I had the Thai Pizza - curry, shrimp, cilantro...I just wanted to keep eating it. Can't stop. My dinner partner had the white garlic pizza. I stole a piece...I love that one too. Had a beer, great selection bottled and on tap. Our server was the bomb. Sigh. So content right now. What're you doing here??!! Go...get a pie and a pint. read more

See all

This place has all of the things I look for in a good restaurant: hip decor, extensive menu, friendly staff and knowledge of food allergies and preparation! They have tons of the usual options for pizza as well as some unique ones (hello, Grape pie?) They also serve flatbreads, great apps and salads. Also, almost every menu item can be made GLUTEN FREE! They have personal size gluten-free crusts which are incredible. The only other allergen on the label for the crusts is "may contain soy" due to being manufactured in the same factory. However, I always make sure to ask about other allergens just in case their type of crust changes. So far, I haven't gotten sick here! They have a pretty extensive beer menu with a ton of German, Belgian, and American options, including a gluten free lager called Omission (it's AMAZING). Give this place a try but if it's the weekend during the school year, be prepared to wait a few for a table. It gets busy! Definitely worth it! read more

Pies & Pints - Wings at a pizza place and they're pretty good! - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

Love the atmosphere and interesting choices for your pizza. Also like supporting a local business.