Something has happened to the crust over the past year or so. It used to be really light and with a sweet taste. My last three orders the crust is very doughy and looks and tastes like Bisquick. No more, long time customer not coming back. Price keeps going up, quality going down. I'm willing to pay for quality, but not for shortcuts to increase profits. Good by and good luck! read more

Amazing pizza, shit customer service. Original 5 star reviewer. Sorry. Screw me twice, shame on me.

I picked up a veggie pizza from Pizza Athena for dinner and it was so good! Lots of fresh veggies and plenty of cheese :) This was my first time going to Pizza Athena, I will definitely be back! Bonus: Hot pizza box in lap on chilly drive home = Awesome! read more

I got a good recommendation from a friend who is not easily impressed, so tonight I decide to be lazy and order a pizza. Oh My Gawd this place has the absolute best pizza in Palmer. I ordered the Mediterranean and it was everything I expected and more. Quality chicken, *real* full-leaf spinach, excellent cheese, just the right amount of sauce, and all the flavors melt together perfectly. Hand-made crust with just the right amount of bubbles at the edge. Cheese just starting to brown at the edge. Definitely will be ordering from these folks again and again.. read more

My wife and I ate here a few weeks ago and I neglected to review it. I submit to the fate the Yelp Universe seeks to mete out. Anyways. My wife and eaten here before when I was out of country and swore it's the best pizza in the valley. I was naturally skeptical. The building is pretty unassuming and just outside of Palmer. I didn't expect the food to be quite so good from such a small establishment. We ordered a classic pepperoni pizza and it was absolutely fantastic. I highly recommend this place if you are looking to pick up a pizza. I am looking forward to the next time we eat there. read more

Took 2 hours for one pizza and I live 20 mins away maybe not even 20 minutes I like their pizza but it was sort of pretty ridiculous

My family and I have had a lot of pizza around Alaska and we all agree Pizza Athena is the best tasting! The customer service does lack at times but the pizza is always worth it. read more

Pizza Athena is our families favorite place to order pizza from. We are never disappointed. Serving sizes are plentiful and usually provide 2 meals for a family of 4. I'd recommend the Dagwood sandwich, pizza & gyro. read more

We were on our way to Anchorage from Matanuska glacier and stopped here to get a veggie pizza to go. This is a small place with friendly staff and good food. Loved the pizza. The crust was thin and the sauce was delicious. They stayed open a bit past closing time for us which was nice of them. Would highly recommend. read more

I ordered ( and took out) Greek Fries (served with Tzatziki but no feta) And a Gyro Calzone. Fries were good, but could have used Feta. The crust on the calzone was good, so, I'll try a Pizza soon. If they keep it thin, I'll be a regular. read more

Pizza Atena has been in Palmer for a few years now. Having partaken in their offerings, I have to say that I am a fan. Their menu is very broad and they do it all well. The Dagwood sandwich is monstrous and enough for two. The Atena Special has a great blend of ingredients and you'll never go wrong with it. The Atena Meat Supreme is a carnivores dream. Oh, and the Feta Cheese bread is a great supplement to your order as well. Their delivery is quite good but we usually opt for pickup since we are so close. read more

Love their pizzas. This is my pizza place, I like to grab a Gladiator for home every now and then. I've never disappointed . Try them they're great read more

We were hungry on our way back from hatcher pass when we came across this pizzeria. Owner Gary was very nice and shared info about areas around anchorage .They make fresh doughs every day and pizza was fresh and delicious .It's a good option for vegetarians on their way to hatcher pass or Matanuska glacier . read more

My favorite place for Italian in the valley. They usually take about an hour so anticipate that. The meat sauce is so yummy! And the thin crust pizza is so good! read more

Wish Yelp had more than 5 star to give. This place is unique in flavours!! Tried there veggie pizza. Never ate such a wonderful crust with so much flavours. Ask them to brush it with Garlic spread. The owner was such a nice person gave us nice info to visit near by places. Dont't miss to try this place. A must go if you are in the area. read more

I have to say working in The Butte it can be rather difficult to find good food that is delivery. I want to thank Pizza Athena for delivering when closer pizza places would not. The crust on your pizza is spectacular.....hands down the best i have ever had. The sauce for me was a little on the heavy side as i prefer a light amount of sauce on my pizza. None the less this is the BEST pizza i have had in the valley and i will order it again. read more

Awesome pizza! I got their chicken garlic ranch supreme, and it was awesome! It's always very clean inside, and the food always comes out quickly :D Everything is very reasonably priced :) read more

I LOVE Pizza Athena!! I stuffed my face for the first time with their pizza, and I plan to come back for more!!

Super fast and friendly service. Really good food. One of the only places in the valley where you can get proper service and food.

Fast delivery and pick up employees are really nice great pizza

So yea, this is my firest Yelp review, but I have always used Yelp to look for good places to eat. The reason I have never written a review is because honestly, I never really felt like spending the time to join.But after ordering a pizza from this place, I really, really felt like I needed to put my 2 cents into this. I just moved to the area, and was in the mood for a really good pizza. I spent about 40 minutes Googleing and Yelping, and reading about all the pizza joints in the Palmer,Alaska area. After reading all of the 4 and 5 star reviews on Yelp for this joint, I decided to order. A simple order, Large, pesto sauce, pepperoni, linguica, red onion, jalapenos. The girl taking the order at 6:35 pm says, $26.75 and will be here in 45 minutes. Ok, so I call at 7:35 pm to see where the pizza is. " It's on it's way". 10 minutes later, a truck pulls into the driveway. It took the guy 3 minutes to exit his truck and make the 10 second walk to my door. 2 screaming kids and $30 later, into the kitchen we go. So, I really wish I could post the picture I took of this (5 star pizza). Flat. Cold. No flavor to the crust. More toppings on a Digiorno. It really did look like a piece of cardboard with some cheese and afew chunks of 'stuff' on it. The only thing that was recognizable was the pepperoni, and jalapenos. Trash. Garbage. If this is what people are mistaking for 4 and 5 star food, well,... I promise, there is better out there. So in the end, I am forced to give atleast a 1 star rating. I honestly couldn't find a 1 star in this order. I can't, I will not order from this place again. read more

What a gem. Never had bad food from here. Always consistent and delicious. Their delivery drivers can't be beat, but they offer pickup too if you are so inclined. Give them a try! read more

Definitely best Pizza in Palmer. I think the Gyro pizza and their lasagna is fantastic!

I have never written a review but due to my last two experiences I just can't sit back and let it go.....I usually receive great food and good customer service.....however I have always disliked the sign outside the door that's states "Fast free delivery" because it's anything but fast as there is ALWAYS at least a 2 hour wait on your order. My previous order was for sandwiches but when the order arrived they had forgotten one of the sandwiches and had to go back and make another then re-deliver it, which took 2.5 hours, this time I ordered a simple pizza which we always order and after being told the delivery time would only be 45 minutes when I even stated it'd probably take 2 hours, I was duped into having it delivered. I ordered at 6:55 and when 8:35 rolled around I decided to call and check on my order. I was then told that they marked it for pick up instead of delivery. They then asked if I'd like it delivered (my original request) fearing it'd be midnight before I fed my family I opted to drive and get it. When I arrived I received no apology or "sorry for the inconvenience" or maybe a discount or SOMETHING to show good customer relations as I am a regular customer and always tip at least 4-5 $'s even if I pick it up. I was completely dissatisfied with how I was treated and being made to pay full price for a 2.5 hour old pizza, had it not been nine o'clock I'd have opted to tell them to cancel it and gone elsewhere. I am a loyal and repeat customer but after these two incidents I'll be taking my business elsewhere. It's too bad cuz until now I had really enjoyed the food, but there isn't a meal on earth worth that bullshit. My hats off to you if you have the patience to continue to deal with the long waits and cd full price food. If yelp allowed I'd give it negative stars but you have to at least pick one star or won't be able to post so the star I picked was merely cosmetic and absolutely in no way represents my true feelings of irritation and disgust for how we were treated. read more

One of my favorite places for pizza and calzones. We have never had a bad experience. However, tonight we ordered a meatball grinder and the sauce tasted like it had pumpkin pie seasoning in it. The general consensus was that it was altogether a bad flavor, so we called to complain. Despite previous customer service that had been wonderful, we received a "deal with it" attitude. Overall great place, just don't order the meatball grinder or call to complain. read more