The grandpa pizza slice is very good. Crisp Sicilian dough, fresh mozzarella and topped with a thick tomato sauce. Satisfying. The decor is very nice for a pizza joint. Clean, modern and lots of natural light which radiates through the abundant windows. Two levels. Great other selections of creative pizza by the slice. Street parking. read more

Best pizza in all of Brooklyn. Love coming here for the food and company! The grilled chicken with garden salad, clam chowder soup, chicken parm, and fried calamari are my favorite from their kitchen. Definitely wish the location was closer to my home! read more

The worst customer service ever I have seen in my life! The person who takes the orders puts you on hold very rude and unprofessional! I'm not the first abs last person tells about worst attitude of person who takes order! If u need your business grow you new to respect and take phone calls with attitude! read more

I suggest getting the baked formaggio calzone. Tons of cheese and deliciousness. I was surprised they didn't add a small ramekin of sauce with it. So ask for it, where I'm from they give it to you and it makes all the difference! read more

After passing Pizza Daddy many times, decided to give them a try. The menu is loaded with Italian specialties and everything we ordered came hot and fresh. Mini vodka pie was good but could have used a little more sauce. Mini white pizza was great. Good flavor. But let's be real, it's all about the crust, and this was one of the best I've had. Grandma's pie had great taste with fresh basil aplenty. Cost was in line with all the rest, but we tried to order on line and was told they would not deliver to us as we were too far away. Called them and they said " no problem". I'm glad we called " Daddy". Pizza Daddy that is. read more

Pizza Daddy - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best calzones!!!! Love your food, wish you would open in my hood, but it's worth the drive.

They have the best cheese rice balls I have had in my entire life !!! Super amazing everyone should go here delicious food !!

After plowing snow all day, I got hungry, so I finally decided to try Pizza Daddy because it was close to my route. Let me tell you, what a great decision that was. In almost 30 years that I've been eating at different pizza joints in bensonhurst, I've never had a better meal. Their broccoli rabe and sausage roll is the best roll I ever had. It was made fresh, with just the right amount of sausage, rabe, and fresh mozzarella wrapped in the tastiest dough I had. I'm definitely going back to try everything else on the menu with my fellow sanitation workers from BK12. read more

This place lives up to the name. Love the simplicity of this place. Pizzas here are so delicious! Very thin and crispy. Great spot! Staff is really friendly. read more

Things have not changed after I gave them another chance. Still one star!! Much better pizza around the neighborhood than this dump

I don't see why Pizza Daddy would get as little as two stars. I came here a week ago to grab some pizza and it was pretty darn good! Better than Torres a few blocks down. I had the grandma slice and it was fresh hot out the oven. I haven't been here enough to review too much about this place but basing on my review of the grandma slice, this place is a solid 4 stars. We'll see if it'll change after I come here a little bit more. I do have to say though, the restaurant decor is beautiful. Most pizza restaurants are a little dingy and boring but Pizza Daddy took the time and effort to make this place look nice with an Italian ambiance to it. No complaints so far. read more

The bad reviews on here are hilarious. I normally don't write reviews but feel compelled to because I'm a customer who orders from here almost every week. I've never been met with an attitude, either on the phone, in person or with delivery. Yes, sometimes I'm on hold for a long time but obviously it's because they're busy and have other callers ahead of you. Which, by the way means that they're worth the wait. Food is great; love their soups especially the lentil soup- best I've ever had, even better than several restaurants I've been to. Pizza, rolls, calzones, pasta, sandwiches- tried them all and all are delicious. Definitely one of my favorites & top go-to spots read more

The worst pizza in Brooklyn , almost no chess , too much tomato souse , and it taste sour ( they don't know they need to add "pinch of sugar to the tomatoes to reduce the acidic " it's like caned from jetro or something in this style , The place looks good but pizza is really really bad !! Who ever saying this is good slice of pizza I think this person have no any taste buds . In this zoo ( pizza every corner) I will choose a different one next time . read more

SCROLL DOWN FOR UPDATED EDIT We've been ordering from here for years (at certain times we ordered once a week). My husband and I tried to order dinner two days ago and they hung up on us 3 times. I understand it was probably busy but we've called before and just been placed on hold. The person on the phones that day sounded annoyed and when we tried to pay with a credit card the person on the phone said they weren't accepting those and then told us to order online. Sounds like he just didn't want to bother processing the payment. That was the second time he hung up and we called back to get his name to complain to a manager and he hung up on us the third time. I've been ordering from here for years and have never had this happen. The food is delicious but this type of treatment is highly unacceptable and I'm not sure we'll be ordering from here again. Edit to reply to Joe: I'm not sure how to reply here but yes, I believe that's my husband's account. We order both online and over the phone and either way what difference does that make? The way we were spoken to and how many times we were hung up on is unacceptable. We've been placed on hold before (sometimes several minutes) and we're fine with that because we know the food is good and we know how busy it can get. This type of behavior is not something we will accept or support. LAST EDIT: the food here is hands down delicious. We had one rotten experience with ordering over the phone so that's our main problem. The service is usually pretty good so I am updating my review to 4 stars since this was the first ever really bad issue we've had but we'll probably not be ordering from here again, due to this incident. read more

The pizza is delicious, crunchy thin crust, with just enough sauce and cheese, in true Italian style, like it's served in Palermo. Tonight we tried the kitchen menu, and it was delicious. Fish salad is to die for...tender fish! Everything was freshly prepared, very tasty, and a regular portion. Thank you Pizza Daddy for opening in our neighborhood. And to top it off, the prices are reasonable. read more

What used to be a delivery staple in my house has shifted to on the ban list after dealing with the surly young woman who handles orders over the phone. We had ordered a plain pie with a veal parm sandwich and was instead sent a veal cutlet sandwich - who orders veal with lettuce and tomato from a pizzeria?!- and when we called Pizza Daddy back instead of a "opps must have misheard" the woman argued that just a veal sandwich was ordered again why would I order a sandwich when we've been ordering the various parm heros since they've opened. Save yourself the aggravation and just drive over to L&B for a real Sicilian not Pizza Daddy's pathetic "Grandpa Pie". read more

Tried making an order for delivery, a guy put me on hold for 2 mins "which I didn't mind, I get it they are probably busy." So when the guy takes me off hold he seems to hear me perfectly fine when I said "I would like to make an order for delivery." I gave him my address as he requested which I proceed to hear a click so I kept asking if anyone is there, also I want you to note that he didn't ask if I was still there, which in my opinion would have indicated that maybe he couldn't hear me. I call back assuming that something went wrong with the phone line, when I speak to him he says "there was scratchyness on the line and you didn't say anything." So I ask him twice just to double check he can hear me because he was quite rude after this 2nd call and I wanted to double check he wouldn't hang up on me because "he didn't hear me" he then has the audacity to ask me if this is a prank call and honestly I was quite put off because this was the first time I was going to try out pizza daddy. After this I told him to "forget it" because now my worry is he's going to not only know my address but also potentially spit or mess with the food, so I hung up on him. I am not going to recommend pizza daddy nor will I ever try it because of the worst first impression I got. read more

Wow. The service, the professionalism, the respect, & the food is amazing. I recommend the vodka Grandma. Great place.

I live across the street and absolutely love the pizza. I see all these reviews about the lousy service. I personally have never experienced this from them. On top of that, I know its a pizza joint and don't have much expectations. I care that the food is good and that I get it timely. I religiously order the buffalo chicken slice (one of the best I've ever had) and my favorite pepperoni roll. I buy a pie once in a while and bring it to parties and people can't believe its that good. The scallions on it give it that rich flavor. MMMM getting one now. There was a time when they lost my order and the guy behind the counter apologized and gave me my pepperoni roll on the house. Maybe if some people didn't go in expecting them to bend over backwards for you, you would actually appreciate this place more. read more

My favorite pizza place in the whole entire neighborhood. Staff here are nice here never had problem. They accept all major credit cards which is a plus !! My favorite is their margarita pie . It's to die for ! YUMM. Their pizza crust isn't too thick like other places. I hate thick pizza crust. Their garlic knots are pretty big and they're pretty good just wish it had more garlic ! Calamari and fried Zucchini is of my go to as well. It's fresh and crispy ! They have an area for you to dine in and they offer delivery service which is pretty fast. read more

Creative slices that are all yummy and affordable! Perfect meal for whatever time of day. If the slice you want isn't on display they will make it for you fresh. It's just the best place ever. I love coming here. Friendly people work there and the upstairs seating is really nice. I'm so happy that this yummy establishment is near my house. read more

*Crunchy crust. *Tasty to the very last bite. *they do not skimp out on tomato sauce. *seating upstairs! read more

Buffalo chicken pizza is on point. Their lasagna, baked ravioli and stuffed shells are also pretty good for a pizzeria. Delivery time is also usually around 30 minutes which isn't too bad compared to other places around here. read more

I'd give less than 1 star if I could. The pizza was so burnt the bottom looked like mr popo.

Wanted italian so we decided on this place. What a great selection! We had ordered a plain cheese pizza, penne a la vodka with chicken added, baked ziti, chicken Parmesan with linguine and a veal penino (hot hero). The cheese pizza was really good and saucy. Baked ziti was pretty good and cheesy. Chx parm was good-sauce was great. Veal pinono was delicious. Chx a la vodka was delicious. The sauce was great. It was delectable. Chicken was kinda thrown on there but it was grilled and cut up but still good. Even had the char marks. The pasta dishes had a side of bread. If you like good mozzarella cheese, this is definitely the place. read more

Been coming to this place since it opened for business. FINALLY a pizza shop just around the corner from where i live currently. Its not the best pizza i ever had but cant complain its good pizza. Decor: This is a nice looking modern pizza shop. when walking inside, on your right hand side is where the counter and brick oven and different slices of pizza on display. On the left hand side is about 5-7 red chairs to sit while waiting for your pizza and on the back and up a small flight of stairs is about 5-7 tables to dine in. Food & Staffs: The staff are very friendly and welcoming to everyone. The food is great and the different pasta at yummy. There is different slices and square pizza which are awesome. i recommend trying the buffalo chicken slice and the ceaser salad slice and also the Texas chill soup. Overall this place is great. since its around the corner i definitely would stop by more often. read more

Convenient location, located on the corner of 64th st and bayparkway. The interior looks and feels very modern and sleek. The seating area is satisfying, the big glass windows give a clear view of the outside when eating. Pizza is great too, a solid 7/10 for $3.25 topping slices. I definitely recommend trying the bruschetta slice (8/10). :) read more

Pizza Daddy - Favorite: bruschetta slice :) - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered delivery and it came on time. Food was amazing. Ordered the Margarita pizza and omg was so happy when the pizza came and it didn't become soggy it still held its shape kinda wish it was still nice and hot but can't really hope for that when ordering delivery. Also got the rice ball which was also good the cheese was amazing kinda wish that I knew that it didn't come with sauce if I did I would have ordered it for the rice ball besides needed some sauce and a little pepper it was great. Give it 4.5 stars. read more

The pizza is ok. I order the pie back walk 1 block home the crust is soft Not crispy. Not enough sauce and cheese. Not brick oven taste nor brick oven. read more

This is by far the WORST customer service I have ever experienced in my life. I called to order a half buffalo chicken half Caesar salad pie which I have never ordered from this place before ever. The person on the phone asked me "what kind of a question is that how am I supposed to put Caesar salad and buffalo chicken in the oven". He proceeded to say I always call them asking this question and then just end up ordering something else. I can't remember the last time I ordered from this place so that was ridiculous. It was disgusting response from a disgusting place of business. Would not order from here there are FAR BETTER pizza places in the neighborhood with better customer service. Get better customer service. As everyone can see from the owners responses to people's bad reviews he doesn't know anything about customer service or how to be a decent human being. It's embarrassing no other business owner would respond in such a manner. Sad. read more

I always judge a pizzeria based on a regular slice. Tried it out today after passing by hundreds of times. Loved it! Sauce was on point and the cheese was perfect. read more

I dine here quite often and the food is fabulous. Try everything. The pizza is awesome and if you want to try other Italian dishes they can make it for you. Its a nice clean place with the atmosphere just right. The workers are friendly and helpful. Just come in and enjoy the food. You will not be disappointed! read more

Read reviews and decided to try for myself. Decor was nice and clean, as well as modern. No line, but it was almost 9pm. Staff was nice. Had two kids with me and they seemed to enjoy having the kids watch them, even put on a little bit of a show, spinning the pizza dough out where the kids could see well. Still waiting for our pie to cook and will update review when I try the pie. read more

No long review needed.... good burgers & pizza that isnt greasy and has good flavor not cardboard!....perfect prices...cute little clean seating area upstairs with tv. Ill be back this weekend! read more

Great Pizza and Chicken Parm Heroes... Always consistent quality food! Great staff, always friendly.

Not only is Joe C from Pizza daddy miserable but he thinks he's a wanna be wise guy.. he tries to bully and intimidate his workers by yelling and Bossing them around ...on top of that ,he has the nerve to try to bully and intimidate me on yelp after I wrote a review about the horrible experience I had in his store it is ridiculous how a grown man who is successful with a great pizzeria that makes great food could act low class.. it makes you feel bad for him and I kind of wanna send him some flowers with a note telling him it's going to be OK...I could be offended on what he wrote which I am going to share with everyone but I choose to understand that this man is petty with a mind of a child so it doesn't make any sense to be offended by what he said I really do feel bad for him and hopes he could look himself in the mirror and wake up one day and just appreciate what he has going on around on top of that he has a wonderful son who helps them in the store and is a pleasure I would prefer that the sun with stay at the store and Joe C. Would just stay home read more

Pizza Daddy - This is his idea of an apology on how I was treated in his store - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

disgusting attitude and after being so wonderfully told to go F myself, the employee comes back to me to me with "you should be more understanding." i cant believe that after being a loyal customer for a long time i'm told to be understanding when told to F myself. ok food and a stank attitude made is a no go for me. In Brooklyn, you'll find other pizza spots, not dealing with them is better than trying their food. read more

Ordered a large pie for $14, the cheese and sauce were not spread evenly and it was very very salty. They have spice packets if you need them. They have nice seating if you want to eat in. read more

All you people are crazy giving this place a bad review. I know the owners two sons as I went to high school with them. The staff is respectful. I go in there so much that the guy at the register all ready knows what I want without me saying a word. Pizza Daddy owns Bensonhurst. read more

Ordered a Large pepperoni pie and delivery man was very rude snatched the money out of my hand and didn't give back the change . Overall great pizza read more