Disclosure: did not dine in, ordered and carried out. The place was slow, nobody was dining in when I picked up around 6 pm. The place definitely had a "dive" feel to it, but not dingy by any means. I would take the family back and dine in. The pizzas: had two different pizzas, cheese for the kids (was free as a daily deal) and a BLT pizza. The cheese pizza was probably the best cheese pizza I've ever had. Granted I rarely ever eat cheese pizza (how boring). The crust was flakey, light and crunchy. The sauce was tasty and you definitely must like garlic. The BLT pizza was decent, nothing over the top. I'm honestly not a fan of BLT pizzas anyhow, my wife loves them. Unfortunately, the one BLT pizza my wife never stops talking about is at a place near Mt Vernon, OH which is the gold standard of BLT pizzas (to her). Luckily this BLT pizza is close to the gold standard for her. For me, I enjoyed the pizza without the extra toppings, just straight up bacon pizza, the way the good Lord intended. read more

Pizza Dive - BLT pizza before the toppings... - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

See all

My family really likes their pizza but I consistently recieve one complaint, they don't put enough sauce on their pizza and they charge for extra sauce, which no other pizza Ive encountered charges. Again, really good pizza, even if under sauced. read more

Beavercreek Pizza Dive leaves absolutely nothing to be desired! A few friends and I were looking all over town for a local, quaint pizza shop. We stumbled upon BPD, and were not disappointed. The pizza and calzones were out of this world, by all accounts. The ladies even hooked us up with free bread knots to hold us over while we waited for our food. They were delicious! The food was out in no time, and we all agreed it was fantastic. The place is spotlessly clean, has a cool vibe, and plays great music (a lot of 80s). The staff were friendly and polite. The service was excellent. I would come back for a second round for sure. Too bad we are only in town for a few more days! read more

Good pizza, and cheese sticks! Got my order as take-out. Restaurant looked clean and staff was friendly.

I am a New Yorker, grew up on Long Island and spent tons of time in Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens. I know good NY style pizza. Beavercreek Pizza Dive is the closest to authentic NY Pizza, in the Dayton area. Really enjoyed having dinner there with my family. I asked the young man behind the counter if they made Sicilian style Pizza. He had no idea what that was. It would be awesome if they did offer Sicilian Pizza. Can't wait to visit NY and Long Island and enjoy Sicilian style Pizza again. read more

Being from the East Coast and transplanting to Ohio it is very difficult to find good pizza that isn't cut in teeny tiny finger bite sizes so it was so awesome to find this place. I hate the pizza in Ohio like Marions and Milanos or any other one that destroys their pizza by cutting it tiny and tasteless. This place was absolutely delicious and brought back memories of good new York style slices. They have great lunch specials and night specials. We got a slice and a garden salad for $7 and to be honest i thought it would be a small side salad but it was enormous. Their pepperoni even curls like back home. We will definitely be back many many times. Loved it. Mmmmmm read more

See all

Very tasty NY style pizza! I recommend for families looking to not break the bank on delicious pizza.

Pizza was solid, a bit too greasy but overall decent pizza. The garlic bread knots were excellent and we also had pretzels which were excellent!!! Service was good! read more

Awesome job in every way. 1st off, this is the first time I've ever had pizza from this place and I'll be the first to tel you it's absolutely delicious. The crust, the sauce, the cheese. Amazing. In regards to the gentleman that said its no better than any other pizza chain he's been to, I'm not sure where he goes but it's no comparison to your typical franchise. 110% better. Secondly, I cannot say enough about their customer service. I ordered a pick up over the phone and when I arrived the pizza was not cooked with the toppings I requested due to miscommunication. Charles, said give me 8 minutes and cooked a new pizza for me with the proper toppings and gave me the pizza that was incorrect for free. It's not everyday that you find pizza like this, and it's not every other day you find customer service like this. Mom and Pop shop, 100% has my business. read more

My family and I have been frequenting Beavercreek Pizza Dive for well over a year now. Everything I wrote about the restaurant still stands. It's great pizza and great service! I love the way it brings people/businesses together via Facebook promotions. On the rare occasion I pick up pizza (I've been pregnant, so my H brings home the pizza ;) ), I've seen so many happy little faces exiting. Very sweet! Speaking of pregnancy, Beavercreek Pizza Dive has this promotion where you get a free meal (pizza, breadstick, soda, etc) when you newly give birth to a little squish. Well, my H and I missed the part where you're supposed to sign up on their website and prove your pregnancy, etc. Whoops. Pregnancy brain... ! After five minutes of speaking with a manager (not sure, which, sorry!), the pizza joint was able to "let" us redeem this perk at a later visit. For this reason alone (it's AWESOME customer service), I give it five stars. read more

Best pizza in Ohio that I've had! Always fresh, super friendly and overall delicious!!!

So, full disclosure here: after writing my initial (3-star) review of Beavercreek Pizza Dive, I was contacted by Theresa--one of the owners of BPD. She appreciated my honest feedback and offered a $25 credit, if I'd be willing to give them another run. Far be it from me to turn down some free pizza, so I accepted! This time around, I got our pies without the garlic/butter glaze--one cheese and one Hawaiian (and a BLT for Jules, but we're not counting that one). Much to my excitement, I was pleased to see some New York style pizza much closer to what I'd expect from some traditional thin crust. The proportions of cheese to sauce to crust were perfect, and the crust itself was perfect for folding. Minus the outside glaze, BPD's pies were exactly what I'd originally hoped for. One thing I hadn't gotten to try earlier was BPD's pretzels, which were an utter delight. Dense and delicious, the pretzels had just the right amount of salt and were a solid deal at 4 for $5. Definitely worth your money. As you can see above, I've gone ahead and increased my rating of BPD to 4-stars based on all this. While the glaze still isn't to my taste, the pizza is great without it and the pretzels were an added bonus. Plus, it's wonderful knowing that the owners really care what you think as a customer and value your happiness. read more

Amazing. We were in the area for softball tournaments and decided to stop and try this place. It was worth the stop for lunch. I highly recommend this place. read more

A lot of people think pizza is like sex, even if it's bad, it's still good. I think of it like sex too, if I'm paying money for it, you should at least put some effort into it. (Okay, I've never paid for it, but I'm sure if you wanted to try out that analogy, CraigsList would be a good start). Beavercreek Pizza Dive had great reviews on Yelp, so naturally, being a fan of pizza and having it in the vicinity of work I went to check it out. Now, I've never been to New York, and outside of the more famous NY pizza chains (think Michael Scott's favorite) I haven't had New York style. I saw that the Pizza Dive was offering a $5 for 2 slices deal I decided today would be the day. I was the only person dining in during my 20 minute window and wished it had more dine in business (they deserve it). Why do they deserve it? Because they came out with 2 HUGE slices as pizza as big as the tray they gave me. The crust was crunchy, the sauce, sweet and tangy, and the toppings were delicious. On top of everything, the folks working there were very nice and accommodating. I'm coming back soon Pizza Dive, and I'm bringing friends. read more

Stopped here for lunch one day when working in Dayton. I picked up their 2 slices for $5.00 special. Service was quick and friendly. I ordered a cheese slice and pepperoni slice. I guess I got there a little late because I got the last slice of each pie, not sure how long it had been sitting there, but figured what the heck. They heated it up, I took it back to my office and was not disappointed in the least bit. The slices were giant, think NYC style slice! They tasted pretty darn good too. One of my tests for Pizza is that it doesn't flop down when you try to pick it up to eat...and these slices passed the test. I could pick it up and eat it without having to hold it above my head and directing it to my mouth. It folded nicely too, just like NYC slices. The crust was thin with a light chewy texture. The cheese, plenty of it, was tasty and the sauce also had great flavors. I will definitely go back here again if I find myself in Dayton again. read more

If you want to bask in the glory of a perfect slice of Americana, if you want to eat some pizza that would make Italy cry, if you want to feel like you may need a bath after eating, if you want to indulge in some of the most deliciously heart-palp-inducing pizza in the area, if you want a prescription for Lipitor, if you think America is awesome, come here. Come and get the buffet. Get the nascar, the bomber, and even the MAC N CHEESE pizza. This place makes me proud to be an American where we can say "hold my beer" on any traditional cuisine and make it better. read more

I don't think I have ever left a review on Yelp before, but I had to. I grew up on the East Coast and have been on the hunt for good Philly/ NYC/ Jersey style pizza for ALMOST FOUR YEARS and finally found it. Fellow PA/ NY/ NJ transplants, this stuff tastes like home read more

I've lived in Dayton for almost 7 years and this is the best pizza in town in my opinion. They have a buffet on Monday that is a killer deal because they fill it with their best gourmet pizzas vs. cheap crap. I've not had a pizza that I didn't like from this place. I reserve 5 stars for places that I think are good enough to take people who are visiting from out of town, and I can't imagine not taking someone here to try the bomber! Their prices are a little higher than chain places but in this case you get what you pay for. I also want to mention that this is a true mom and pop shop, which is something I love when it comes to eateries. I've met the owners several times, they are very nice. In fact, my girlfriend raved about one of the pizzas they were trying out on the buffet and they were nice enough to come to our table, without us asking for it, with some of it boxed to go simply out of appreciation for our liking of their new pizza. How is that for service! read more

NY style pizza is hard to find in Dayton, and this place has it. Big foldable slices at reasonable prices. They make their own sauce and it's a rich hearty sauce (not the watered down sweet stuff I'm used to finding around here), and they also make a garlic sauce that they put on the crust that gives the pizza that extra zing. Order a side of the garlic sauce to dip your crust in, yum! If you go at lunchtime, they have a pizza bar with 2 slices for $5. And, the slices are huge. Or you can get one slice and a salad for $5. It's really a great deal and perfect for a quick lunch. My favorite though, is the buffet on Mondays. It's $7 for adults and $2 for kids. It gives you a chance to try all the different types. They have specials every day of the week. One thing to note - they have canned and fresh mushrooms - make sure to ask for fresh mushrooms when you order if that's what you like. I certainly do. read more

I literally melt when I take my first bite of a Beavercreek Pizza Dive Pizza. I've never had a bad pie here. I lived in NYC for four years and it is so nice to have found a go-to NYC style pizza. The pizza sauce isn't too sweet which I love, but the crust is so it's as if dessert is included at the end of every slice. My husband and I love their weekly specials. We usually get cheese or pepperoni because they are simply delicious. However, we do go for the Bronx bomber when we have company SUPER filling SUPER delicious and SUPER impressive for guests. read more

Little pizza place located on the southwest corner of Grange Hall and Dayton Xenia Rd in Beavercreek. The staff is the best. Very friendly. The pizza is New York Style and is just amazing. They put a buttery garlic coating on the outside crust that adds a little sweet to the pizza. They also have sub sandwiches but the pizza is so good I have yet to try them. Seating is limited, there are about 7 or 8 tables in the dining area. They also have a BOMBER pizza that I believe is about 7 pounds of pizza. If 2 people can eat it in less than 30 minutes, it's free! My co worker and I took one of those back to work and we had 2 pieces left and it took us about 35 minutes to eat what we did!..LOL..definitely a challenge if you are up for it. I have always been a Marions pizza fan and still am, but this is definitely second on my list now! Better than Joes on Airway! So if you want some good pizza, great service, and maybe a food challenge, check this place out! read more

I think the pizza here is the best in the area for price and service is always great. The place is always clean, they staff always greats you with a smile and great place to bring the kids. Very kid friendly. read more

Locally owned/operated, quality food, and attentive staff. Food: Scratch made dough starts everyday. Style is reminiscent of classic New York City (think Joe's Pizza of Greenwich Village), with a thin yeast risen dough, midely sweet red sauce, and lots of delicious mozzarella. Crust is baked to perfection during a short ride on the conveyor oven, and is finished on the other side with a rub with a house made sweet garlic butter. The chef/owner has a number of novel pie's including the Bomber, Greek, and BLT just to name a few. The bomber is a a meatlovers dream; layers of all things meat (sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and ham) with a few sliced banana peppers, and copious amounts of mozzarella are sandwiched between two rounds of dough, and coated with glaze of sweet butter. Each slice is a meal in itself, and sure to resolve even the most extreme hunger pains. The Greek and BLT feature a standard pie, which is topped with greens and different sauces after it rolls through the oven. In addition to the pie's, plan on enjoying some of the pretzel bites or bread bites. These treats are a different take on the standard breadsticks found elsewhere. These dishes include a choice of dipping sauce. Id recommend opting for the spicy nacho cheese, it wont disappoint! Their menu also includes other treats, such as sandwiches and calzones the size of your head! One thing you can always be assured, is that your meal will be prepared fresh from scratch with quality products and care. Venue: The shop location and unassuming exterior might have you wondering it this is the right place. Rest assured, it is a hidden gem! The parking lot has space for around 15 vehicles. The restaurant features two primary dining areas, the front patio and inside. The patio offers picnic style dining with a few corn hole boards to pass the time while you pie is made fresh. Inside has about 10 tables, generally seating 4 people each. There are a few tables that seat 6 or 8. All of the tables are free standing, and could be moved to accommodate a large party. A promently featured hot bar makes possible a Monday special pizza buffet, which features almost every pie for patrons to sample. Staff: The restaurant generally is staffed with 5-8 employees. From the owner down to the cashier and everywhere between, are commited to providing the best possible customer experience. The staff also partners regularly with local schools and nonprofits to host fundraisers and give back to the local community. Through and through, Beavercreek Pizza Dive offers quality food, family atmosphere, and community value. Id highly recommend trying them out next time you and you family are craving quality NY style pie! read more

See all

I really like the Beavercreek Pizza dive. It is a very family friendly place which is important to me since I have 3 kids. Everyone is welcoming and helpful. It is locally owned so supporting them supports our local economy! I love the Monday buffet because it is affordable for the whole family with a ton of variety. I tend to like the less common pizza and I can get that here. my only complaint is that there are onions on almost all the pizza's at the buffet, and I hate onions, so I find myself picking them off. I would love if they would have some of their yummy varieties at the buffet sans onions, and then maybe my kids might try them too! This place also does a ton of community work and I absolutely love their charitable hearts. I got a free meal through the stork club after I had a baby. That was a major blessing. I follow the Facebook page for giveaways too, and I have won a few things! So overall, I really recommend this place! read more

Amazingly delicious pizza and staff. We recently moved to Beavercreek and wanted pizza. This place is literally two minutes from our house. Pizza dough is AWESOME, sauce is PERFECT, pizza is DELICIOUS!! Will definitely be back! read more

Ordered a couple of pizzas for take out. They were both tasty and the price was quite reasonable, especially with the Tuesday 2 for 1 deal. These are not the fancy hipster pizzas you get from Wheat Penny, but they are very nicely flavored with good ingredients and a nice crust. We also ordered a salad that was nothing special. Skip the salad. read more

Great place to stop for lunch. My coworkers and I have a rotation of places at which we meet for lunch on Thursdays. The lunch special is worth it as you can choose two HUGE slices of pizza and get a drink for under 10 bucks. The service is always fast and friendly and I always leave satisfied. Don't let the name fool you. While inside may be considered "divey," the pizza is really good. read more

No macaroni and cheese Pizza :( But the rest of the food was actually pretty delicious. The atmosphere is really easy going and it allowed my big group to talk very boisterously outside at the picnic tables. The staff is very attentive. And the servers had great attitudes. For the price it's definitely worth it. I ended up eating maybe a pizza and a half of different flavors and drink about 3 cups of soda. So it's definitely an enjoyable bargain. My group enjoyed it too so we are definitely coming back here. read more

This place honestly has decent pizza. The problem, however, is that they only make it right SOMETIMES. We like extra sauce on our pizza from here because their pizza tends to be made with a thin layer of sauce. I have ordered "extra sauce" 5 times from here and it has only actually been made with extra sauce once. It's not worth it to take your business here if they only make your order right 20% of the time. It is not the worst place I've ever been to but it is certainly not the best. It sucks because when they make it right, it's a damn good pizza. They just have a hard time getting it right. I wouldn't recommend it but I wouldn't say "stay away from here." Just know that you may be disappointed. read more

Great food, sandwiches are delicious and they make their own bread. Nice and friendly staff and owners. Get the soft pretzel and you will not be disappointed. read more

If you are in Beavercreek looking for pizza do yourself a favor and drive past Marion's and head straight to Pizza Dive.

Hidden gem of Beavercreek!! The pizza is cheap but tastes great and their garden salad is a great option for a family of 2-3. Good service and they also offer military discounts. Best pizza in town next to Malanoes read more

This place is amazing!!! Definitely a "dive" but the prices and staff were great. My husband and I split a 6 slice that was half Hawaiian half pepperoni. The sauce has a rich sweet taste but not overbearing. I don't usually like red sauce but this stuff was great! The only con was their soda fountain. Most of the flavors wee very watery and had a dirty taste. Not sure if it was the water or the machine. They have bottled options and I will get that next time. They also included complementary garlic bites with marinara! We will for sure be going back time and time again! read more

Pizza Dive - Half Hawaiian half Pepperoni. Complementary garlic bites and marinara! - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

Best pizza in the area. Period. Fresh dough, fresh ingredients, great people. I don't get pizza from anywhere else. read more

Wow, so many great things to say about this place! Of course the food is delicious! They also have good specials. The buffet is awesome! You get to try so many unique types of pizza. We fell in love with the mac and cheese pizza (which sounded terrible, but is absolutely amazing)! They are always packed because so many people love them. On a different note, the owners and employees are just amazing! Teresa is so incredibly kind and thoughtful. The way they give back and participate in community events is inspiring. They definitely make Beavercreek an even better city to live in! The cheesy games they play are so cute and fun. I've won at least twice! (And I enter contests all the time and never win.) The personal touch they provide to their customers is unheard of this day and age. On one of the cheesy games I mentioned something about my anniversary and Teresa sent me a private message on Facebook to wish me a happy anniversary, I was so incredibly touched! Last year they did Santa pizza deliveries. It was the cutest idea. They asked for personal details to share about the kids when they arrived and they remembered every last detail! Simply an amazing company, owners and staff! We are incredibly lucky to have them in Beavercreek. Thanks for all you do Beavercreek Pizza Dive! read more

Excellent pizza. I love their pepperoni, especially double pepperoni well done with a nice crisp on the edges. Overall the pizza is solid and a step above most of the pies served in Dayton. One point of improvement on the food would be the cheese as it is on the bland side however that is being picky; another improvement could be in the ranch which has a processed "Hidden Valley" resemblance. Their take home/make your own pizza option is a fun thing to have with small parties or just family where everybody can collaborate to make their own "best pizza." The take home kit has everything you need and was a nice introduction to pizza making (in general, cooking) for my little brother. Delivery times can be slow however I would highly recommend this place regardless if you want a solid pepperoni pizza. read more

This pizza was so freaking good - but only if you like a generous amount of grease on it (like yours truly). You know how pizza looks in the cartoons - triangles, thin, with cheese hanging off the sides as you pull a slice away from the whole pie (mouth watering yet?)? That's this pizza. Greasy, hot, and awesome. There's nothing special about the inside of the restaurant, but it's not necessary. The pizza bar is a cool idea, especially during the lunch hour (although I could easily eat a whole pizza to myself!). But alas, no free pretzels that I read about in other reviews. Maybe they stopped doing that? Not totally sure. Anyways, I don't really care - the pizza is good enough without anything else! Will be coming back for sure! read more

I had high hopes based on Yelp reviews (maybe too high??). The restaurant wasn't clean. We arrived 2 minutes before the pizza bar closed (mind you, we didn't know they even had one!) and they refused to let us get any pizza from that. The pizza was just okay. The atmosphere was filled with a couple of employees complaining about another one who hopefully wasn't actually there at the time. I may go back to hit up one of their daily specials, but won't make it a special trip. read more

Based on one lunch trip. It's a nice place near work, and offered NY style. First the good stuff. Staff are friendly, helpful. Free wireless. I had to ask for a password which was gladly shared. Good lunch specials. Got the slice of cheese, breadstick (both generously sliced) and salad.. Salad - fresh, crunchy - it's not common for me to come away this impressed by a house salad, but it hit the spot. Good! Sriracha and hot sauces available. They are also offer a gluten-less (bonus points for honesty, it's a pizza kitchen folks) pizza and sauce-free creations for variety. All excellent signs. The meh factor - the pizza and the breadstick. Which is sad, because this is the pizza dive. Please can I have it warmer and less greasy next time? It was just past noon, I was the sole dine-in customer. The pizza could be fresher than that, surely? The last time I had pizza like that it was a hair of the dog hangover special from the previous night.. And there's a garlic glaze on the breadstick I'm still remembering fragrantly. Maybe that could be a garlic breadstick and I could get a plain option? read more

Pizza is amazing! ! Great flavors and service. So many creative creations. Come out and try a slice of everything. Kid friendly!!! Indoor and out door seating. read more

Pizza Dive - Pizza and service it awesome. Great flavors and creative pizzas. Come out and try a little of everything worth it! - Pizza Near Me - Dayton, Ohio