Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pizza Grace

    4.4 (163 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Pizza Grace Photos

    PIZZA GRACE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Hipster
    Casual
    Trendy
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pizza Grace

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Outside sign
    Benjamin M.

    We came by here for a quick trip in between celebrating my birthday. The store is on Morris Street which still has the original road from the beginning of Birmingham. We really enjoyed our visit here and the food was so good! Something about enjoying pizza on sourdough just slaps right. The waitress we had was super kind and wished me happy birthday as well. Overall such a good experience.

    Meatballs
    Sawyer W.

    Best pizza ever!!! We started with the meatballs which we were very pleasantly surprised with, they were very yummy. The pizza is just out of this world.. the sourdough crust just hits different! Lastly, we had the pistachio tiramisu which might be the best dessert we have ever had. Super light with the perfect texture.

    Camille F.

    Wonderful service for Sunday lunch! This highlight here is totally the dough -- you can tell it's super fresh and has that great sour flavor. The 14" pizza is the perfect amount to split between two people. I love this location, and the gelato spot next door is the cherry on top. Parking on Morris Ave can be difficult some evenings, but well worth it. I love that you can see into the kitchen. The art on the walls is fabulous, I wish they would put the artists' names by them so I could look it up!

    Pepperoni Pizza and peach and prosciutto pizza
    Faye Y.

    Food first, thoughts after... This was my second time at pizza grace. The first time was before Michelin guide. Went with some friends and no surprise had to wait. They do not take reservations and are pretty popular. From the host to the server everyone was so friendly and down to earth. The apps were delicious. Pizza was overall okay. A little burnt but still good. The seasonal peach and prosciutto was so good! Got to try their hot honey and homemade ranch as well.

    Garlic Bread
    Angela M.

    I love Pizza Grace! This is my second time here and I had to get the garlic bread again. I'll probably get it every time and could just eat this as my meal. Highlyyyy recommend. We split the pepperoni and the Calabrian, which is on their summer menu and has chicken on it and is so flavorful. Their sourdough crust is really good and just a solid pizza overall. They do not do reservations so it's always good to get there early and put your name down. Luckily they have seating outside where you can drink a glass of wine or a really good gelato shop right next door to wait. Will be coming back!!

    Pepperoni pizza
    Michelle M.

    First time here and we enjoyed it very much. Waiter was a little aggressive but all in all it was good. Will come back

    Nardello pie
    Danielle B.

    We are here on a Sunday at 11 am. The restaurant is not too big but they do have outdoor seating. We had the Caesar salad and it was plenty for two to share. The fried capers and sourdough crisps were a nice touch. We ate the pepperoni pizza and got a pizza that was half the mushroom/olive and Nardello. The crust was sourdough perfection. The toppings were delicious and the pizzas were definitely covered in topping. We loved every bite. The service was speedy and the staff was friendly. A great place to grab a specialty pizza!

    Pepperoni pizza
    Elizabeth G.

    The wait wasn't bad. Service was good. We ordered appetizers and a pie. The food was good. Pepperoni galore on the pizza. We went basic. The meatballs were top shelf. Cute place with a nice vibe.

    Menu
    Thomas C.

    The staff were excellent!! A very welcoming and comfortable environment was also a nice feature. There is a full view of the kitchen which is an open concept. The pizza was good if you like a lot of dough. The toppings were good but sparse. It's not what I would consider a conventional pizza. It's also made with a sourdough crust which was good! It would be a good choice for a date or a family.

    01/30/26
    Gabe P.

    We came to Pizza Grace on a Friday, for an early dinner. Upon arrival, it wasn't busy(AT ALL) but we blinked and this places was full of pizza wanting patrons! This isn't the biggest restaurant. It's comfortable and you don't feel like you are sitting on top of anyone. The ambiance is relaxed and decorated nicely. My fav part is the exposed bricks. Table seating, a few bar seats and some high table top seats are available. We ordered the pepperoni pizza with mushrooms on 1/2. I also requested a side of hot honey. The pizza was quite tasty and I loved the sourdough crust. The ingredients were fresh & of great quality. Our server was really polite and kept our water glasses full. I also had a Good people IPA. They have a respectable wine list but had limited beer options. If you come here, parking on Morris Ave could be a challenge. Thankfully , it wasn't for us. This was my first time at Pizza Grace. The yummy food and good service were worth the visit!

    White Pie with Sausage
    Kelly L.

    Stopped by on a Tuesday evening. Restaurant was busy but luckily had 2 seats open at the bar. Service was great - our waitress was friendly and checked up on us throughout our meal. We ordered the Garlic Bread with a side of Marinara sauce as well as the White Pie with Sausage added. Everything tasted great and fresh. Didn't feel too heavy. Overall, I would highly recommend. Parking: Nearby street parking and paid parking lots nearby.

    Eric C.

    Overall, really enjoyed my experience at Pizza Grace with no major complaints and would totally come back but personally doesn't stand out from other pizzerias. You are definitely paying for the atmosphere as it has a great ambiance with candle lighting on Morris Ave but doesn't take away from very solid pizza.

    "Peach & Prosciutto" 14 inch pizza ($32)
    Grace H.

    One of my absolute favorite restaurants in Birmingham!! I would eat here once a week if I could. It's a cute, unassuming spot off the charming cobblestone Morris Avenue. The pizzas and apps are always perfect. They also have the cutest rotating wine menu in collaboration with Golden Age Wine in MTB. The servers are also always so kind and not in a rush. If I could change anything, it would be to take some reservations. I have had to sadly pass up on doing several meals here due to not wanting to bring a group to a restaurant without reservations. Additionally, would love to see a slightly more enhanced outdoor seating area.

    half pepperoni and half chicken pesto

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ed W.
    0
    33
    0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 5 of 5

    Pizza Grace Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Pizza Grace

    Does Grace Pizza serve alcohol?

    Yes!

    Are dogs welcome?

    In the courtyard outside I'm sure.

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Wooden City - Fresh Burrata

    Wooden City

    4.7(142 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    Dude the food was amazing. The server was awesome; shes…read morefrom the bay like me! The ambiance was just a chill vibe. If I ever am in town again, I am coming back for more.

    First, know that there is parking behind the building. We didn't know and apparently for the number…read moreof cars trying to squeeze into nonexistent spaces, many others didn't either. We walked up the street with a half dozen other diners. Wooden City is definitely not in the best part of BHM. Walking to the restaurant was a little sketchy, no need for a detailed description. Although we had reservations, the hostess looked at us like we had three eyes. She found a small table for us in the far back of the restaurant. No problem, at least we were seated. Our server greeted us quickly and went over the menu. We ordered drinks, blistered Hungarian peppers and a sausage and mushroom pizza. We told him that we were going to a concert and were on a little bit of a tight schedule. By the time our server checked on our food, the second time, we went from a little bit tight to full "gotta get out of here" mode. I guess the delay in getting our food was to give the kitchen time to burn our pizza. Over half of the thick, chewy crust was inedible. The bottom of the pie didn't fare much better. The peppers, on the other hand, were amazing. (not so much so at 2 am but that's just me!) They are a do not miss. We were at least able to settle our bill quickly and made it to the concert with time to spare. Overall, would we go back? Only if in the area - those peppers were amazing. Still, I definitely would not make a special trip.

    Photos
    Wooden City
    Wooden City - Tavern Burger - american cheese, iceberg, grilled onion, dill pickle, bacon

    Tavern Burger - american cheese, iceberg, grilled onion, dill pickle, bacon

    Wooden City - Gimlet

    See all

    Gimlet

    Capella Pizzeria - Siena Pizza

    Capella Pizzeria

    4.8(194 reviews)
    8.8 mi
    $$

    Simply superb pizza. Capella's sources their ingredients from Italy and it shows in the freshness…read moreand taste. I have been a few times now and settled on the margherita pizza. It's what you might think of as a cheese pizza, the add garlic and fresh basil to the mix and it is a wonderful result. It's a hand tossed pizza with a fairly thin crust. The chew and the flavors are excellent. The staff are friendly, but don't wait on the tables, you order at the counter, they deliver you eat happily. They have TVs playing one soccer or F1 racing feed or another. It' is a European feel for sure. They have picnic tables indoors and a few small chairs outdoors with a bit of shade. Bring your dog for the outdoors maybe? My friends have done so. Capella has a large selection of bottled drinks, gelato and other Italian desserts. But the pizza is the headliner.

    Capella Pizzeria definitely deserves their high ratings…read more I came here with some others to pick up some pizzas for a family gathering. I was pleased that the had a large variety of options but even had gelato and desserts as well. Large pizzas run $21-$27 are thin crust. For pizzas, we got two of their Margheritas, Meat Buster and Palermo. They were all good and a hit at the family party. The meat Buster and Palermo had meat but honestly not a whole lot. They were good though. All the pizzas were lots of flavor and the sauce to cheese ratio was perfect. I loved that they had chili oil, extra dipping sauce, cheese, and peppers on the side for you to grab. While our time there we even had some gelato which was good and got some cheese cake to go. Our pizzas came out quick. The shop is very large with plenty of places to sit, even good for a large party. I loved that they even had plates on the table ready to go. This was a solid pizza spot and worth checking out if you prefer thinner crust.

    Photos
    Capella Pizzeria - Indoor seating

    Indoor seating

    Capella Pizzeria - My pizza was perfect

    My pizza was perfect

    Capella Pizzeria - Sausage and peppers on the left, mushrooms and chopped onions on the right

    See all

    Sausage and peppers on the left, mushrooms and chopped onions on the right

    Salvatore's Pizza and Pasta - Baked Ziti with Pepperoni

    Salvatore's Pizza and Pasta

    4.4(14 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    Only thing I've got to say is: "What took me so long to eat there". I bet I've been by this place…read morea thousand times, but never stopped. What a mistake! Wife and I ate there before going to the movie. She ordered spaghetti with meat sauce. Noddles were cooked perfectly. Meat sausage covered the noodles, not like some places that but a ladle in the middle and you end up with more noodles without sauce. I ordered the Salvatore's Special Calzone. Won't be the last time. Crust was crispy, filling were abundant and extremely tasty. My wife mentioned that unlike some calzones this one was not greasy. It was very flavorful. There place is rather small with less than a dozen tables inside, and an outdoor covered patio. Very comfortable, friendly staff, and obviously everything cooked to order. This may well become one of my new favorite places. Looking forward to my next visit, and sorry I've missed the opportunity to eat here over the last 40 years or so.

    Overview: I have lived in Birmingham, AL for well over 30 years. I used to live up 280 where the…read moreOriginal Salvatore's had a single Restaurant just of 119. It was then and now my favorite pizza place in Birmingham. I am from New York and the pizza reminded me of home. I only found out a few weeks ago that this "Downtown" location even existed. I would usually take the 25 minute drive up 280 for my pizza. I have no idea how I missed this. Food: The sauce is the key. Weiher on the pizza or on the pasta. We always order a Meatball Pizza and it has been very consistent. My son and I had a Medium Meatball pizza and Cheese Ravioli Parm which comes with Garlic Bread. Service: The service is simple. You order at the counter, and they bring it to your table. Just like every other Salvatore's location. The manager was OUTSTANDING. I asked for the crust to be a little more done, and it was PERFECT. Ambiance: Super Casual and perfect for the food they make. Lots of table and for the most part very clean. Pizza is a personal thing. What I like, other don't or have their own special place. Now that I know Salvatore's is so close to my home, actually walking distance, I will eat there more often. As a matter of fact, we are ordering for pick up tonight. I don't use delivery services unless I am desperate. Eat Well, Drink well and stay Healthy.

    Photos
    Salvatore's Pizza and Pasta - Baked Ziti with Pepperoni

    Baked Ziti with Pepperoni

    Salvatore's Pizza and Pasta - Baked Ziti with Pepperoni

    Baked Ziti with Pepperoni

    Salvatore's Pizza and Pasta - Baked Ziti with Pepperoni and garlic bread

    See all

    Baked Ziti with Pepperoni and garlic bread

    Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Smoked wings

    Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview

    4.0(425 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    I am truly blow away by the fresh ingredients and the flavor this one pizza puts out. My partner…read moreand I haven't left the parking lot without finishing half of our pie. We'll be back! Update: It's not even 24 hours later and I'm back. We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza with no white BBQ sauce. I love this place.

    I'm not the biggest pizza fan in the world so I would take my review with a grain of salt. I came…read morefor lunch on a Wednesday and it was extremely dead. We decided to sit outside which was nice because they were making good use of the ac inside. I was thinking about getting 2 slices, but by the time I did that it seemed like it would be a better deal to get a whole pizza. But I knew that would be way too much pizza for me. Our waitress informed us of the lunch special for a pizza and salad it's $13 or 2 slices for $18. She was great and super informative. The slice and salad intrigued me because you could get any salad on the menu. The slice options for the day were the white shadow, pepperoni, cheese, and maybe the wing & the prayer? I went with the white shadow & the spinach salad. I loved the salad with ranch, but it felt like it was missing a crunch maybe ? The balsamic vinaigrette really didn't add anything to the salad for me. The white shadow was pretty good but super greasy and maybe I'd add a protein next time. It was definitely cheese and grease overload but that's what I signed up for so I can't complain. I really wasn't wow'd by the pizza over any other place honestly. But the service and ambiance was great! If I had a taste for pizza and was in the area I would possibly stop by for the slice and salad deal again.

    Photos
    Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Bar area

    Bar area

    Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Spinach Salad

    Spinach Salad

    Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Loud door mentioned

    See all

    Loud door mentioned

    Pizza Grace - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...