The quality of pizza from this location has diminished significantly. Large pepperoni pizza--uneven and very light pepperoni, several pieces without cheese and/or sauce. The taste was not great and the price is high for the quality. Will not likely return again. read more

Pizza King - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

People raved to me about Pizza King and I was skeptical at first... now I'm a believer! If you go I recommend getting the Royal Feast. It's like a supreme pizza. I also recommend extra sauce! The only downside side about pizza king is it is a bit pricey for the sizes. But it is good pizza. read more

Great service unique pizza love the sausage and pepperoni ok crust decent sauce over all I would go back for the pizza but the service guarantees I will go back awesome staff read more

Almost rotten lettuce every time I order a chef salad! This was what I had to throw away. How do I get a fresh one??? read more

Pizza King - The lettuce I had to remove from my salad. - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

We have given this pizza king quite a few attempts as the one we used to go to in Greenwood was perfect. We have ordered there twice and never even received the pizza. Took almost a week to get a refund. Last time I was in there to pick up a fella took his pizza outside and came back in with it. It wasn't cut. I thought that surely couldn't be a pattern until last night. Had a pizza delivered and sure enough it wasn't cut. About 90 minutes after I ordered the pizza I called to see if there was an eta. Person on the phone was very rude. She said "yeah, we don't do that" and hung up on me. Terrible customer service and the pizza is mid. If I pay $45 plus a $10 tip to the driver, you couldn't least cut my pizza and not be rude. Last time there for us and I will spread the word. read more

Ordered from this location dozens of times for myself, kids, and events. Every time the order is accurate, timely, and exactly as advertised. The pizza and sandwiches are great, with our favorites being the Royal Feast. Highly recommend. read more

Placed an order through DoorDash thinking we were getting their traditional crust pizza and it was thick crust--disgusting! They hung up on us three times when we called in follow up on the $80 food order. I grew up on Pizza King and just threw away 2 pizzas as they were inedible. Will never order their food again. read more

Wow..... $80 gets you nothing here. The "chef" salads had very little lettuce, did not come with croutons (as advertised), the ham was only a few ounces' worth, and the dressing cups are half the size of your normal dressing cups - which they didn't even fill to the top. It was about one tablespoon. The "side" salad was literally 3 thin chops of lettuce with a slice of tomato on it. It's not even bad, this is now scam level. But the one star is mostly for the breadsticks. We got them and was like "you've got to be kidding me." What happened to the traditional, regular sized Pizza King bread sticks? These are half the length they used to be, as well as half the width. One of my breadsticks was literally the circumference of my pinky finger. This is not even 50 cents worth of bread and they're charging $7 for this. Pretty unbelievable. As far as the pizza, they didn't even take the toppings to the edges. And how hard would it have been to put on a normal amount of cheese? They gave us tons of sauce, it was swimming in it, and the cheese and meet were scarce. Come on. This is seriously bad business practice and so inconsiderate to customers. I grew up with the traditional Pizza King and they were never trying to take advantage of paying customers this bad. I don't know about other locations, but this Pendleton Pike Pizza King is a total scam. If we're paying almost $100 for one dinner, at least cut the breadsticks to the proper size. Don't come here. read more

Pizza King - Pizza King's "breadsticks" are not even as wide as my pinky finger. Don't forget the hefty price tag, either. - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

I ordered online from the Pizza King website, and I clicked the link to the Fortville location, which is a far better location. I didn't see it went to this location until the order went through, but it was the first time I had gotten food at this location & I will be sure to not get food here again. Pizza was chewy and not crisp, and poorly cut so we had to rip it apart. Breadsticks were stiff and incredibly thin. I also got cookies, two of which were specifically marked "soft and chewy" and a "buffalo chip" that I assumed was supposed to be a crunchier style - they all came crunchy and subpar flavor. They did take the tomatoes off my salad as I requested tho. There are just so many good PK locations in the area, do not go to this one. read more

Pizza King - Bread Stix (Add to cart 1 at a time) - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

Great pizza and service. Always good! Delivery is a good option also just make sure to tip the drivers well! They are delivering you your dinner remember read more

Lesson learned tonight: always check reviews when ordering from a new restaurant/location. After a long day of moving, we were happy to see a Pizza King in our neighborhood, as there wasn't one where we used to live. So, we placed an order a little after 9:00 pm. The order was accepted, we were charged, and, apparently, the pizza was started, as we received an "in the works" update around 9:45. The scheduled delivery time was 10:15, but it kept getting pushed back and back and back again until we were finally notified shortly before 11:00 pm that our order was not being fulfilled. So, now it is 11:00 pm on a Sunday and absolutely nowhere is open. As you can imagine, this left us in quite a spot. Looks like our only option is to run to Kroger, which may not be open this late due to Covid changes. I'm curious to know at what point they decided our business wasn't worth the effort. It looks like there is another Pizza King in the area. So, we will give them our business in the future. From the reviews, it doesn't appear this location cares too much about retaining customers. read more

I knew better! I should have trusted my thinking initially when I was hesitant to place an order for delivery due to the fact that I had done so before and it was the worst pizza I have had including store bought pizza's I literally have had better from Kroger freezer section! I thought it was dry and cold because of the delivery but let me just say I went against my better judgment and placed my order for carry out and wow!! Just when I thought the delivery they had done was the worst ever they manage to top that and make an even worse pie this time around plus it was 30 friggin bucks and when I questioned the bill she says that's with the coupon applied omg! NEVER AGAIN !! read more

Pizza King - Does that look like triple pepperoni? Does this look like a pizza worth 30 bucks ? I think not! - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

Being an Indiana staple since the late 50's Pizza King is your childhood microwave pizza all grown up and through the crisis of puberty lol. This is a great pizza close to tavern style crunch bottom fluffy top covered in a tangy yet smooth pizza sauce and topped with provolone cheese!! I love that they offer a million sizes of pizza lol and it's party cut so no 2 slices are the same shape or size :) aka Party cut lol the Pepperoni and sausage is a fine cube and crumble style which makes every bite that much bigger in flavor! Breadsticks are great but small and skinny so get two orders trust me! Love this classic and hope you will too! read more

I grew up in Muncie and have not had pizza king in many many years. The bf has never had pizza for some reason so it was time for him to finally try it. This pizza king did not have the phones at the tables. I was a little sad about that. We ordered the breadsticks half baked of course just like when we were kids and a pepperoni and sausage pizza. They use the crumbled sausage and pepperoni. It was just like I remembered. Delicious. He even liked it and he is a picky eater. He even said we will have to start picking up pizzas from pizza king. read more

Pizza King - Half baked breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

See all

I'm 1 mile away and out of their delivery range. There's a quarantine. People can't get out to eat in and you refuse to drive 1 mile. I said I'd make it worth your drive. You just lost a $120.00 order to Gramboli's. And a $25.00 tip. Nice work. read more

Total garbage establishment. Staff was sitting and not being professional and we waited over 45 minutes for our pizza that never came because they messed it up 3 times. Was asked multiple times what type of pizza we ordered and ended up leaving and didn't get a refund because of it. Horrible staff and an even worse experience. read more

Honestly I haven't had Pizza King since college at Ball State many years ago. Since we moved to McCordsvile, been wanting to give it a try. Well we did and that is all I'll really say about it. I've frozen pizza taste better. read more

Pizza King - two boxes of pizza sitting on top of a stove - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

**********UPDATE 11/06/18*************** Voting today worked up quite the appetite. I stood in line for over and hour while waiting to vote and got into a prolonged argument with a man about the definition of Liberty and how we no longer truly possess it. This country has been infested by pests who are rotting it from the inside out, just like the McCordsville Pizza King. As I pulled up this time, the store illuminated by the sun, I noticed how differently it looked in the light. Somewhere between dilapidated and condemned, the store sits just off of Brooksville Rd. Emblazoned on the south side of the building is the iconic Pizza King sign. Below their name is written "Muncie's Best," a quote I found comical seeing as though we were far from Muncie. I jokingly asked the woman behind the counter where they ranked in the pizza place hierarchy of McCordsville. With dead eyes and an unforgiving countenance, the woman behind the counter skipped acknowledging my joke and monotonously asked what I wanted to eat. I was willing to forgive her coldness in order to once again enter the cheesy gates of Nirvana. My pizza came out quick and was presented perfectly: gooey melted cheeses swimming in a deep red sauce adorned with obsidian black olives. The scent of the pizza rolled through the air and gently carressed my nostrils, sending me back to the moment I first tasted Pizza King's culinary artistry. The first bite was beyond anything I had every experienced before. I thought to myself, "When I die, lay a slice of Pizza King's 8" cheese pizza on my tongue so that I may die in peace." But as quickly as I rose into pizza pie paradise, I fell. I opened my eyes after swallowing that first bite. The first bite that would later be the last bite I will ever take. On the floor diagonally across from me scurried something with fervored pace. Imagine, if you can, knowing that the food you just ate, the food that covered your tongue, could have had a beetle the size of a half dollar walk across the room of the restaurant you're in. My food had been contaminated in ways I dare not think about. There was a news story about a young man in Australia who passed away recently. Years ago, he had eaten a slug on a dare his friends made. It was a gross out experience for sure but one that he took on without issue. Days later, pain overtook his body. He then slipped into a coma where he slept for over a year until his body could no longer fight. Beetles have six feet. A slug doesn't have any. My mother always said that the feet were the dirtiest part of one's body. If a slug can be dirty enough to carry a deadly disease without having feet, the filth that a beetle can carry with six must be horrifying. I could feel the death and disease seeping into my bloodstream. I had to move quickly. Faster than I have ever moved, I leapt from my booth and bolted to the bathroom. The door knob was slick and I was losing time. With the adrenaline coursing through my body, I attempted to turn the knob once more while driving my shoulder into the door. The force of my shoulder threw the door off the hinges and I tumbled into the bathroom. I was Born Again through Jesus Christ this night. My body sprawled across the floor and I scrambled as quickly as possible toward the soap dispenser. "Antibacterial," it read. "Thank you, Jesus," I wept. The first pump of soap into my mouth sent shockwaves through my body. I wretched and recoiled in horror as the bite of pizza made its return. Black olives and bile sprayed across the wall and floor. The panic in me grew even more. The bacteria once again had the opportunity to soak through the membranes in my mouth. I did what I had to, not what I wanted. With my eyes closed I pumped glob after glob of antibacterial soap into my mouth. I cried out to God, "LORD, LET ME SEE TOMORROW AND I SWEAR TO YOU MY LIFE IS YOURS! SEE ME THROUGH THIS TRIAL!" The manager came storming into the bathroom and found me on my back, appearing to be rabid from the soap dispenser I had emptied into my mouth. "I live," I whimpered. My rating for the store has been changed from five stars to three. Although I cannot ever eat their pizza again, I can't give a one star rating to the place I found God. read more

I was thinking diversity in Pizza and I have never tried Pizza King. I called and they were willing to deliver to my house. Taylor, the pizza angel, took my order and was very flexible in my wife's complicated order. She delivered it personally in about a half an hour. Well worth it! I am happy to help local franchisees. read more

really not good. there service was horrible, I was sitting there for over an hour, and when our food came it wasn't our food.

In the midst of the pandemic I was shocked at pizza king in Mccordsville tonight. We normally like this location, but today was a disaster. We called in our order and we were greeted on the phone by someone who didn't seem to have a clue how to take an order. She kept repeating everything as if she were questing us. After about ten minutes and placing an order for two subs the young lady told us it would be ready in 25 minutes. When I got there, there were quite a few people waiting. But, an older lady with long silver hair, went from sitting at a table, touching a note pad and pen to the kitchen.....she passed a sanitizing station and never even paused to use it! She went into the kitchen, touching things and food! I was.shocked. I saw her walk through the kitchen, carrying my subs. I have no idea where she took.them, but long story ending, it was 46 minutes before I walked out with two very sloppy, barely warm, but soggy subs. It will be awhile, if we ever return to this location. Watching the employee go from a table to the kitchen without sanitizing, was just gross. read more

The food is usually pretty good here but I can't say the same for the staff. Everyone acts like they hate their job and don't have much of a willingness to serve. Food is typically not ready when you're told it will be. Also, many of the items on their online menu are not carried at this location, which is a bummer. The inside seating area is small and could use some major updates. It's also not a very clean place (especially the bathroom). If you order delivery, they can't give you any wait time guesses. read more

Pizza and breadsticks tonight WORST EVER hardly any cheese toppings did not cover crust and bread sticks were half baked or less and cold this place is the worst!! read more

First time having Pizza King and it was delicious! We got our breadsticks 3/4 of the way baked. The staff was very nice and very helpful!

I have eight at every Pizza Keen in Muncie Indiana now I live on the north east side of Indianapolis this seems to be one of the closest ones to me I've been eaten them for over 30 years I even bought a house in Middletown Indiana based on the fact that it had Pizza King delivery read more

Pizza King - We came here to get a pizza I love them - Pizza Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

Their pizza is great. It is expensive but they use premium ingredients which is why it tastes so good. Also, try more than their pizza. I had the Big Sir Submarine sandwich tonight and it was delicious. I think their customer service has been upgraded. Tonight the person on the phone and the delivery driver were both great. I am only giving 4 stars for two reasons: 1. Price. Even though they use great ingredients it is still expensive in my opinion. 2. No option to order online. I frequently order from Papa John's because it is so easy to order online and they have a rewards program. Pizza King doesn't have a computer in the store at all. read more

Once again, Pizza King provides us with a great pizza. The Royal Feast is our favorite.

Pizza King is in my personal opinion the best pizza ever!! I love the small squares, the chopped pepperoni, I even love the sauce!! The breadsticks are just mediocre but the pizza is phenomenal!! Very happy with this location. I get pizza here about once a month!! read more

Poor service. My order was to be easy on the sauce. They put twice as much on as normal. Also, my 16 inch was missing a whole side row. Better Pizza King 2 min down the road in Fortville read more

If you're looking to wait 30 minutes on top of the 45 minute timeline they gave you, this is the place for you. I gave this place three different chances. All three times we ordered carry out, we waited about 20-40 minutes longer than the time they gave us. The pizza is decent but they have zero ability in time management or telling you an accurate time your order can expected to be ready. The pizza is also very overpriced and isn't even anything that special. Not worth your time and not worth your money. Do not order from this pizza king. If you're in the McCordsville area and wanting pizza, I recommend Greeks or Papa Johns located off of Fox Road instead. read more

Don't get me wrong, pizza is good - old style Pizza King BUT I'm done going here - they are RIDICULOUSLY over-priced. My husband just picked up 2 large sausage and pepperoni pizzas for about $50. The Pizza King Geist location on Fall Creek is just as good, same drive for us and much better prices read more

Pros: -Very good pizza. Not the best, but very good -Very consistent; never had a bad pizza or service Cons: -VERY overpriced It's too bad that a large pizza is about $25, but that is a little rediculous. I would get pizza from them a lot more if it was around $10 less. read more

The server here is extremely rude and it took about 30 min to even get our drinks, not to even mention our pizza. The waitress gave everyone in the entire restaurant attitude. When we first walked in, all of the tables were dirty and we had to clean them ourselves. Come here when this place gets tore down and becomes a better restaurant. read more

For the second time in a row, we had an absolutely fabulous Royal Feast pizza. Plenty of ingredients, baked to perfection. Let's just say that one person in our household has been a Pizza King devotee for 50 years or so, and he claims these were the best he's ever had. read more

Service was poor, our kids 8" cheese pizza only had 2 slices of pizza well covered with cheese, and our royal feast had a hair in it. Totally untypical of Pizza King. We love Pizza King pizza but we won't be visiting this location again. read more

$44 for 2 little pizzas and 5 tiny breadsticks. Now I remember why we order Gramboli's!

Fast delivery and friendly service each time. Best breadsticks / sauce in Indy. My favorite pizza joint around.

Great Pizza will pay whatever they ask because it's he best. You pay for what you get. You cray babies go pay 5 bucks at that one place. Pansies read more

Decent pizza, but service and respect for customer by management is horrendous. Waited last weekend for 90 minutes for a call in order. Told be ready in 30 mins on phone, showed up 40 minutes after and it was not even made yet or in the oven. 7 other customers wtg like I was. Manager showed no caring or concern for our waiting, acted like it was beyond her to care! what a joke. Never offered a discount or apology, when I asked for a discount, told me I would get 10% off then did not even know how to calculate that, ended up giving me 5% and having an attitude about it. Worth the extra 5 mins to got to Fortville location, better people there to help you and quality of pizza is better! Even people eating in were complaining as no one was servicing tables. read more

very very over priced. i have loved pizza king for years. just not willing to pay the high prices any longer